- 2 days ago
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:02In the summer of 1476, in La Coruña, Spain, the scribe Moses Ibn Zabara and the
00:11illuminator Joseph Ibn Chaim put the last touches to a masterpiece, one of the most
00:18exquisitely beautiful books ever made. It's a Hebrew Bible, but not the austere
00:28black-and-white kind I grew up with. This is a kingdom of glowing colour, lapis lazuli
00:36blue, gold, rose, carnation and vermilion. A book so enticing you want to live inside
00:46its pages. And you wouldn't be short of company.
00:53There's Jonah and his whale, King David on his throne. There are musical monkeys, fire-breathing
01:06dragons, battling cats. And on the last page, a contortion of naked figures which make up
01:18the Hebrew characters are the illuminator's name. It's a Bible overflowing with life.
01:29But just 16 years after the Coruña Bible was finished, the Jewish world that had made it
01:35the Jewish world that was brutally snuffed out by royal decree. In 1492, all Jews were expelled
01:44from Christian Spain. Isaac de Braga, the Bible's owner, and hundreds of thousands like him were
01:52sent packing from a country where they'd lived for over a thousand years, reduced at a royal
02:01hand clap to destitute wanderers.
02:07Perhaps, in his wanderings, Don Isaac turned to this page. For in times of trouble, Jews recite
02:14the affirmation of God's uniqueness, the Shema. Shema Yisrael, Adonai Eloheinu, Adonai Echad.
02:25Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one.
02:33It was the Jews who'd first given the idea of one God to a pagan world that believed in
02:39many. The idea was taken up by others. First Christians, and then Muslims. New religions
02:53that saw Judaism as an unwanted grandpa religion, too old, too obstinate in its ways to accept
03:01a new messiah or a new prophet. And while the followers of Christ and Muhammad would have
03:09the force of military empires behind them, it was the fate of the Jews to be exiles in
03:16the lands of the cross and the crescent, struggling to find a foothold on the narrowing ground between
03:23grudging toleration and murderous hostility.
03:28It's a familiar Jewish story, but it's not the only one. Look at this Bible again. Some
03:35of its most beautiful pages come spontaneously from Muslim patterning from the human drama of
03:42Christianity, even from the mythic bestiary of the ancient pagan world. Like Jewish experience itself,
03:51it's a weave of different threads. What this Bible says to me is that even amidst torture and grief,
04:00even on the eve of destruction, Jews took to heart what's on this page, a verse from the book of
04:07Deuteronomy. I have set before you life and death, blessing and a curse, therefore choose life.
04:16This is the story of how Jews lived amidst Muslims and Christians and how they tried to stay Jewish by
04:24opting for life.
04:26Amen.
05:14Every year, on the fast day of Tish B'Av,
05:18Jews around the world dim the lights like candles
05:21and mourn the loss of their high temple with prayers.
05:26Tears and Lamentations.
05:372,000 years ago, Roman soldiers destroyed the temple in Jerusalem,
05:43the heart of Jewish worship, teaching and life.
05:52In the wake of the calamity, the Jews were banned from Jerusalem and displaced from Judea,
05:59severing the link between a people and their ancient sacred capital.
06:07A Judaism stripped of its temple should have withered away and perished.
06:14But Judaism survived. How?
06:19By setting down rules for living that would allow Jews to keep their identity intact
06:24in the often hostile world beyond Jerusalem.
06:40This is Sepphoris in the heart of Galilee, one of the places where the bold reinvention
06:47of an ancient people took place.
06:53It might look Roman, but in fact, this was a Jewish town.
07:01And around every corner, you would have come across buildings that were giving Judaism
07:06its new lease of life in the post-temple world.
07:11The synagogue.
07:17And this is what that new Judaism looked like in those early centuries.
07:25The temple is still here, but it's a poignant memory depicted in mosaic tiles,
07:33surrounded by the objects of temple worship.
07:37The menorah ready to be lit.
07:40The bull waiting for sacrifice.
07:43The basket of fruit about to be offered to God.
07:48The Jews would never let go of these memories.
07:52But this was far more than a place of longing and regret.
07:57Just look at the zodiac that dominates the centre of the floor with its frankly pagan imagery.
08:06Beautifully dressed calendar girls representing the seasons.
08:10Wintry Tevet.
08:12Blooming, fertile Nisan for spring.
08:16Clearly, the Jews of Sepphoris chose to live life in the here and now.
08:24But if you're thinking, well, this must have been a pretty relaxed place
08:28where liberal, laid-back rabbis would wink at a picture or two,
08:32you'd be absolutely wrong.
08:34Because Sepphoris was a place of intense devotion and study,
08:38where every religious discussion came back to the critical issue
08:43of how to be Jewish and how to stay Jewish.
08:50Leading the discussion were the rabbis.
08:53The teachers with one eye on the past,
08:55with its pious veneration of the laws contained within the Hebrew Bible.
09:02And one eye on the present day,
09:05where those laws had somehow to be honoured
09:07without the institution that once supported them.
09:12When the vast and magnificent temple in Jerusalem went,
09:16it was replaced by an equally vast edifice of words.
09:21In a breathtaking decision,
09:23the rabbis decided that the words of the Torah, the Bible law,
09:27were not enough to fill the void
09:28and that they needed supplementing with the oral tradition,
09:33which would henceforth have the status of law.
09:36This work was called the Mishnah, and it was begun here at Sepphoris.
09:43The Mishnah attempted to catalogue systematically
09:46the commandments that are scattered throughout the Torah,
09:50and to record the many oral interpretations
09:53that had clustered around them.
09:56The authors of the Mishnah aim to cover everything in Jewish life,
10:01from circumcision to funerals.
10:03And unlike the Torah,
10:04their work was helpfully arranged in subjects.
10:08If you wanted to know about divorce,
10:10you went to the book called Women, Nashim.
10:12If you wanted to know which crops to sow and harvest,
10:16you went to Zerayim, Seeds.
10:18And if you wanted to know what not to do on the Sabbath,
10:21they offered 39 varieties of prohibition in the chapter on the Sabbath.
10:28Thinking of tearing something? Don't do it.
10:30Thinking of curing a hide? Absolutely don't do it.
10:33Thinking of lighting a fire? Don't even think about that.
10:40And the Mishnah was just the start of what, over the next four centuries,
10:45would expand into the Talmud.
10:49That endless hypertext made up of the voices of hundreds of rabbis,
10:55all circling obsessively around the central dilemma of post-Temple Judaism.
11:03How to stay Jewish in a non-Jewish world?
11:09Ever wonder why Jews are so argumentative?
11:13Because it is, in fact, part of our religion.
11:18This is my old friend Leon Wieseltier,
11:21someone with whom I've had my fair share of arguments over the years,
11:24but we both agree that the Talmud would become the foundation stone
11:30for the rebuilding of Jewish life in exile.
11:35The fact is that this became the durable, stable, tenacious tradition
11:41of people who lived in many places and were often on the moon.
11:44It's suitcase-ready. That's right. It's suitcase-ready.
11:46You see rabbis sometimes who don't even share the same century arguing among themselves.
11:51Absolutely right. Here you have the commentaries that surround the text
11:54of the Mishnah and the Talmud, 11th century France,
11:5712th and 13th century France, 11th century Tunisia.
12:01The interpretation never ends.
12:04Nothing ever gets fixed. I mean, that's, you know...
12:07And it never gets frozen. Remember, this civilization,
12:10civilization that was based on the law that was established in the Talmud
12:13would have disappeared long ago if it had not learned to adapt.
12:16Right. So it has a kind of organic quality.
12:20It is deeply organic. Enduring, adapting.
12:22But it adapted in ways that would not damage its own integrity.
12:26It was written for an endless future.
12:29It was created for an endless future.
12:34One of the places where that future unfolded was in ancient Rome,
12:39the capital city of the empire that had torn the heart out of Jewish life.
12:47But like the Jews of Sepphoris, the Jews of Rome chose life.
12:57How do we know?
13:00Well, to answer that question, you have to come to a place of death.
13:09This is an underground cemetery, dating from around the 3rd century AD.
13:18When it was discovered, it was assumed that these were early Christian catacombs.
13:25Until this was found.
13:28Ah!
13:29A Jewish menorah.
13:33And that is a powerful, eternal symbol.
13:36A symbol.
13:36An unmistakable, very simple.
13:39With my guide, Elsa Lorenzi, I explored this maze of tunnel tombs
13:44where all kinds of Jews were buried.
13:47Rich, poor, young and old.
13:50Multi-coloured, striped.
13:52That's beautiful, like, representations of the Jews.
13:54The deeper we went, the further from the daylight, the more startling the catacombs became.
14:04We found date palms, a Jewish symbol of resurrection.
14:10Peacocks, symbols of creation.
14:13Flying horses.
14:14And what looked, to me, very much like Cupid's.
14:20There's an old tradition in Judaism of describing the afterlife as a Gan Eden,
14:26a garden of Eden, a paradise garden.
14:29And this place teems with nature.
14:32My mother used to say, I'm going to the paradise garden one day.
14:36And so the Jews in this subterranean world dwelt in that paradise garden.
14:43They had no sense at all that there was any danger any time soon
14:48that they were going to be kicked out of a common paradise.
14:56Above ground, Rome was changing.
15:02A pagan empire with its belief in many gods was transformed into a Christian one.
15:15With the conversion of an emperor, Constantine, in the 4th century AD.
15:25For the Jews under Roman rule, life was about to change.
15:33This is one of the oldest Christian churches in Rome.
15:38It was built as a mausoleum for Constantine's daughter, Constantina.
15:43Santa Costanza, she became.
15:49Its massive splendour is the measure of how far Christianity had come between Constantine's conversion
15:56and Constantina's death.
16:01From tolerated sect on the periphery of empire to state religion at its very heart.
16:14The 4th century mosaics revel in the power of that transformation.
16:19Christ appears as a youthful god emperor with lustrous golden tresses and silken robes.
16:30But to his right is the man who, for the Jewish story at least, really matters.
16:37Saint Paul.
16:40Born a Jew like his saviour, it was Paul who, within a few years of Jesus' death,
16:45began the process of liberating Christianity from the chains of Jewish ritual.
16:53Christianity was either universal or it was nothing.
16:57So, Paul aggressively de-Judaizes the Christian message.
17:03And there was no surer way of doing that than insisting on the divinity of Jesus.
17:10That violated the first supreme principle of Judaism,
17:14which was the indivisible oneness of God, achad.
17:20Two?
17:21Father and son had Jews scratching their beards.
17:24Three?
17:25The Holy Spirit.
17:26Why not five?
17:31And it was Paul who repeated the sinister notes sounded in the early Christian gospels.
17:38The Jews as Christ killers, crying out before Jesus' crucifixion,
17:44his blood be on us and on our children.
17:51And where Paul went, cruder, fiercer church fathers followed.
17:57Like the Syrian bishop of Antioch, John Chrysostom,
18:02a.k.a. Golden Mouth.
18:06Chrysostom was bent on making it impossible for Jews and Christians to live together.
18:12So, in his sermons, the Jews became people who consorted with devils,
18:17demons dancing in the synagogue,
18:19and they themselves were inhuman monsters
18:23who, in his words, sacrificed their sons and daughters to devils,
18:29outraging nature worse than wild beasts.
18:34There was a reason for Chrysostom's hostility.
18:37His flock was in the infuriating habit of visiting synagogues to be enthralled by Jewish sermons,
18:44seeking out Jews to cure their ills and bless their crops.
18:51Obviously, coexistence with this Christ-killing, child-killing devil people was out of the question.
18:57For Chrysostom, only one conclusion was possible.
19:02Physically avoid these people as you would a leper.
19:07Shun them like a walking sickness.
19:13Within a generation of Golden Mouth's death,
19:16his fulminations had become official imperial policy.
19:22Jews were excluded from all public employment.
19:27It became illegal to build new synagogues,
19:30and they were ultimately forbidden from assembling in public at all.
19:34The Mishnah even became a banned book.
19:39The Christian Empire was pushing the Jews into the shadows.
19:51But there were places in the medieval world where Jews could live in the light.
20:00In our own age of bitter hatreds, it's not so easy to believe,
20:04but over a thousand years ago,
20:06Cairo was home to one of the most thriving Jewish communities in the world.
20:14And that story was repeated across the Eastern Mediterranean,
20:18and in Arabia itself.
20:22The birthplace of a powerful new monotheistic faith.
20:28Islam.
20:34With no accusation of Christ-killing to contend with,
20:38Jews under Islam were spared the demonisation they suffered in Christendom.
20:45According to later Islamic sources,
20:48there seems to have been an early moment when Jews and Muslims
20:52might have been part of a common community of believers.
20:57In the document of the Ummah,
20:59it was said that Jews have their religious law
21:02and Muslims have their religious law.
21:05and many of the practices of the new religion drew on those of the old.
21:12In one of the first mosques ever built in the city of Medina,
21:17the direction of prayer indicated by the Qibla, or the prayer niche,
21:22was towards the holy city of Jerusalem.
21:29The Jews have been in Medina for centuries before the arrival of Islam.
21:34They ran the city's main market as they did in many Arabian towns.
21:40They spoke Arabic and appear to have used the Arabic name for God, Allah.
21:48But the Jews of Medina simply could not accept Muhammad as a new prophet of God.
21:55Their religion insisted that the age of prophets was over,
21:58that God no longer spoke directly to man.
22:06The Jews turned bitterly and publicly critical and were accused of treason.
22:14Two Jewish tribes were exiled from Medina
22:18and hundreds of Jewish men massacred, their women and children enslaved.
22:29But the breathtaking success of the Arab conquest in the decades following the death of Muhammad,
22:35transformed the antagonism of a rival into the lofty stance of a victor.
22:41The dominion of the faithful would soon spread all the way from Spain to Afghanistan.
22:49Secure within the borders of their empire,
22:52Muslims treated Jews and Christians as dhimis, tolerated inferiors.
23:01Jews and Christians couldn't build synagogues or churches higher than mosques.
23:06They couldn't ride horses, very important matter of dignity in the Middle Ages.
23:11They could ride donkeys, but only sidesaddle like women.
23:15And it was under Islam that distinctions of religion were defined by dress.
23:21The yellow badge, the yellow hat, the yellow coat first happened under Islam.
23:27And given the kind of conditions in the Middle Ages,
23:30most dangerously of all, they were not allowed to carry any sort of weapons,
23:35which meant that Jews and Christians were open and vulnerable to harassment and assault.
23:42All the same, this was a whole lot better for the Jews than being treated as a demon in human
23:48guise,
23:49a kind of walking infection by Christendom.
23:52Which is why, during the Islamic Middle Ages,
23:55over 90% of all Jews lived and often flourished and prospered in the Islamic world.
24:05We might never have known the truth about the lives of Jews under medieval Islam,
24:10had it not been for Scottish twins, Agnes Lewis and Margaret Gibson,
24:15who were swept up in the Victorian craze for the Middle East.
24:21Nosing around the markets of Cairo one day, these amateur historians came across some decrepit-looking documents,
24:29which aroused their curiosity.
24:32Their friend, the Cambridge scholar Solomon Schechter,
24:35identified one of their finds as a fragment of the Hebrew Book of Ecclesiasticus.
24:46Hearing that the source of those documents was the Ben Ezra Synagogue in Cairo,
24:51Schechter came here eager for more.
24:56And he got far more than he bargained for.
25:01Over 300,000 documents found in the synagogue's Geniza, or storeroom,
25:07which revealed in rich detail the story of everyday Jewish life at the heart of medieval Islam.
25:16This is the place, more than any other I know,
25:19that testifies to the Jewish compulsion to preserve the word.
25:24By Jewish law and tradition, any document bearing the name of God could not be shredded or burnt or destroyed
25:32in any way.
25:33It had to be allowed to decompose slowly, so up there in the Geniza it went.
25:40But the Jews of Cairo were even more compulsive than that,
25:44because they seemed to feel the need to save anything that was written in Hebrew characters.
25:50Up in the Geniza are first drafts of philosophical essays, items of private correspondence,
25:58shopping lists, recipes, anything that Jews did was set down, recorded and stored in the Geniza.
26:06Which makes it the single most complete archive of a society anywhere in the whole medieval world.
26:19Whatever the official rules had to say about their inferior status,
26:24the Geniza makes clear that the Jews of Cairo lived and worked and traded with Muslims,
26:30if not as equals, then certainly as neighbours.
26:36The documents reveal more than 450 different ways for Jews to make a living,
26:43from cheese maker to carp pickler, from policeman to spice merchant.
26:50And with cousins around the world, the Jews turn their far-flung connections to commercial advantage,
26:57becoming the shippers, importers and suppliers to a world hungry for new things,
27:05from North Africa, from Sicily, Spain and the coast of India.
27:13And they pioneered some of the financial instruments we all still need for doing global business.
27:21As Ben Althwaite of the Geniza research unit explained.
27:26This particular merchant, Abouziki Cohen, he trades with India,
27:29so he might be in India or he might be back in Egypt,
27:32and he will have to exchange goods for money, but he can't carry...
27:36All that cash?
27:37He's not allowed to carry gold across borders on pain of death.
27:40That's an Islamic restriction.
27:42Yes. So they have to use paper currency.
27:44So it's a 12th century cheque.
27:47Some of the most touching documents in the Geniza are also the most sweetly mundane,
27:53including exercise books of children learning the alphabet.
27:57I was doing this at Geda, not as well, you know, at five and six,
28:02really practicing my vav and my he and my chet.
28:05And here, what I wasn't doing, because I was much too scared,
28:09are pictures, actually, little animal doodles.
28:12How cute is that?
28:14And there's a little menorah there as well, there's a candlestick.
28:17Yeah.
28:19But interaction between Jews and Muslims wasn't confined to the business of daily life.
28:28In certain places at certain times, the Judeo-Muslim rhythm
28:33broke into a kind of joyous cultural music.
28:38This is the place the Arabs called El Andalus, and we now know as Andalusia.
28:45The deep south of Spain, the country the Jews called Safarad.
28:53At its heart is the city of Cordoba.
28:59From the eighth century, this was the capital of the Islamic Umayyad dynasty.
29:05But also, under their protection, one of the great centres of Sephardic Jewish life in Muslim Spain.
29:17Cordoba was a city of gardens, fountains, canals, and posts delivered by carrier pigeon.
29:35The Mesquita, the great mosque built by the Umayyad, stands as the architectural consummation of the land.
29:46But in the shadow of the mosques were the synagogues, and they too wove worldliness with holiness to create patterns
29:55of intoxicating beauty.
29:58An impulse that endured for centuries.
30:03And inspired by Arabic models, that same note was sounded in the poetry of the Sephardim.
30:11A literature which gave the Hebrew language a startling new life.
30:17Just listen to this.
30:20Last night, a gazelle of a girl showed me the sun of her cheek,
30:25and the veil of her auburn hair was like a ruby falling over a dampened crystal brow.
30:32She was like the fires of dawn's rising, reddening the clouds with its flames.
30:39You don't find words like that coming out of the ultra-orthodox of either Judaism or Islam today,
30:45but they were the words of Yehuda HaLevi, a poet of sensual love, but also a deeply devout Jew,
30:53for whom there was no distinction at all between the physical and the spiritual.
30:58His notion of the nefesh, the traditional Jewish idea of soul, was indivisibly part of the physical as well of
31:07the spiritual world,
31:08so that when he came to write poems addressed to God, they sound startlingly as though he was talking to
31:15a lover.
31:15This one is called Lord Adonai.
31:19All my desire is here before you, whether I speak it or not.
31:25I'd seek your favor for an instant and then die.
31:30If only you would grant my wish, I would place my soul in your hands and then sleep,
31:37and in that sleep, find such sweetness.
31:45HaLevi's poetry lives and breathes the atmosphere of Judeo-Islamic culture.
31:52But at its heart is the aching void of exile and a yearning for a return to Zion.
32:03He'd once written that the peculiar glory of Judaism was that it was a religion of deeds, of action,
32:10not faith like Christianity or obedience like Islam.
32:13You thought about it every day because you had to live it every day.
32:18So at some point, Zion stopped being simply a poetic metaphor and became an obligation, a destination.
32:28My heart is in the East, but I am on the edge of the West.
32:34How can I taste my food? How can it please me?
32:38How can I keep my promise? How can I fulfill my vow?
32:43I will gladly leave behind me all the treasures of Spain to see the dust and ruin of your shrine.
32:55Halevi was as good as his word.
32:58At the age of 65, he turned his back on all of Spain's treasures and embarked on a perilous journey
33:04to Jerusalem.
33:07We'll never know whether this passionate pilgrim made it.
33:11The last we hear of him is riding the storm-wracked Mediterranean.
33:16As the sea rages, he writes, my soul is jubilant for my ship draws near to the sanctuary of her
33:24god.
33:26But man-made storms were about to sweep away the world Halevi had left behind.
33:33The reconquest of Spain by Christian kings gathered pace from the north.
33:39While from the south, fundamentalist Islamic warrior tribes from Morocco supplanted the worldly Islamic rulers of El Andalus.
33:50Caught between militant cross and fundamentalist crescent, the Jews suffered from the intolerance of both.
34:02In the 13th century, Muslim rule in Andalusia collapsed.
34:09The mezquita in Cordoba was turned from mosque to cathedral.
34:16The future for the Jews of Europe now lay under the shadow of the cross.
34:33For lessons in how to survive in Christendom, the Sephardim would have been well advised to consult their cousins, the
34:40Ashkenazi Jews of Northern Europe.
34:47The Jews of medieval Christendom could have told them that while living among people who believed you to be devils
34:55was never going to be easy, it was possible.
35:01This is Lincoln, home to one of the most thriving Jewish communities in medieval England.
35:11The Jews had been first invited to England by William the Conqueror in 1066, and some had made a pretty
35:19successful life for themselves.
35:24This is where one of the wealthiest money men lived, Aaron of Lincoln.
35:33Aaron was rich, and the proof of that can be found in the most unlikely of places, Lincoln Cathedral.
35:45A long tradition has it that construction of this spectacular church was underwritten by loans made by Aaron.
35:55The facts of his life are few and far between.
36:00What we do know for sure is that Aaron's dizzy rise to fortune began with a loan to King Henry
36:07II,
36:08that his money built 16 abbeys, and that the Bishop of Lincoln here, Robert Chesney,
36:15built his fancy palace just down the road with an Aaron mortgage, secured with a cathedral treasury.
36:22Naughty, naughty bishop.
36:23For the mitred, the robed and the crown, Aaron's was the bank that liked to say yes.
36:32Yes to bankrolling new cathedrals, yes to abbeys, yes to palaces.
36:39And the reason Aaron said yes was because Christian theology said no, no to usury, the sin of lending money
36:49at interest.
36:53Which is why the Jews were so convenient.
36:56They were willing to dispense the cash and take the sin on themselves.
37:01A theological sweetheart deal.
37:06That's how Aaron got started.
37:08By the time he finished, in terms of liquid assets, which is to say, hard cash.
37:14He was the richest man in England.
37:16And as you bankers out there know, a source of fortune can also be a source of great misfortune because
37:23it makes you a big fat target.
37:29Especially so when religion straps on its armour to wage holy war.
37:34The coronation of England's crusader king, Richard the Lionheart in 1189, was the perfect pretext for mobs to carry out
37:44their own murderous crusade against Jewish communities all over England.
37:52And if the paper weren't recording the debts that everyone owed to these demon moneybags went up in smoke, well,
37:59all the more reason to join in the carnage.
38:07Some Jews were offered the choice of conversion or death.
38:13Horrifyingly, many chose suicide and the death of their own children, rather than submitting to the mob.
38:22The authorities, church and crown, were supposed to protect the Jews, but that rarely prevented the poisonous spread of popular
38:30anti-Jewish hatred.
38:35In Lincoln Cathedral, you can still see today the remnants of that medieval anti-Jewish folklore.
38:43A stained glass window shows a Jew, identifiable by his red pointed hat, putting his own son in an oven
38:52for taking Christian communion.
38:57And around the corner are the chilling remains of a 13th century shrine, dedicated to Hugh, an eight-year-old
39:05Christian boy who in 1255 was, according to popular report, obscenely tortured and murdered by Lincoln's Jews in a black
39:16reenactment of the crucifixion.
39:26The chronicler Matthew Paris is still considered one of our best sources for the history of medieval England.
39:32And he gives some of the poisonous flavour of the fictions that fed into this gruesome tale, playing with devilish
39:41virtuosity on the suspicions generated by Jewish separateness from the rest of Christian society.
39:51A great number of Jews assembled in Lincoln, and with the concurrence of all, the boy was subjected to various
39:59tortures.
40:01They scourged him until the blood flowed.
40:04They crowned him with thorns.
40:06Each of them also pierced him with a knife, calling him Jesus, the false prophet.
40:12And after tormenting him in divers ways, they crucified him and pierced him to the heart with a spear.
40:24This libel received royal endorsement when King Henry III visited Lincoln and personally ordered the execution of the supposed ringleader.
40:34Ninety-one of Lincoln's Jews were sent to the tower.
40:39Eighteen were hanged.
40:44Though never officially canonised, Hugh became known as Little Saint Hugh,
40:49and his elaborate shrine in the cathedral, a place of popular pilgrimage.
40:58It wasn't until 2009 that the shrine was rededicated,
41:05and it was explicitly stated that the story was a shameful libel and a fiction.
41:12An evil corner had been turned.
41:15Not only were the Jews held hostage to the demonology that portrayed them as Christ-killers,
41:21but the institutions that should have protected them from harm and which profited from their presence.
41:27The church and the crown now endorsed the libel when it suited their purpose.
41:37On 18 July 1290, King Edward I expelled the Jews from England,
41:44relieving everyone of the inconvenience of paying back their debts.
41:53It took 700 years for the Jewish community to return to Lincoln.
42:01Today, they worship in what is believed to have been the medieval synagogue.
42:09Still reading from the same books,
42:12perhaps singing the same songs as their medieval counterparts,
42:15whose presence was no longer welcome in Christian society.
42:31It was a story that was soon to spread across Europe.
42:48To be in Seville during Semana Santa, the Holy Week before Easter,
42:53is to enter the world of medieval Christendom.
43:00Hooded figures move through clouds of incense.
43:07And thousands of penitents, some barefoot, others carrying heavy crosses, walk through the night,
43:15in emulation of the suffering of Christ.
43:19This procession dates back to the time when the medieval church became increasingly concerned
43:25with conformity of belief and ritual.
43:32It's easy to imagine how uncomfortable this changing mood must have been for the Jews of medieval Christian Spain.
43:43As the pursuit of Christian Orthodoxy gathered pace,
43:47Jews were seen as a malevolent fifth column inside Christian society.
43:53Their obstinacy was standing in the way of the Second Coming
43:57and the universal victory of Christ.
44:01In the eyes of the church, that longed-for moment could only happen with the mass conversion of the Jews.
44:13But rather than forcing the Jews to convert at sword point, the church engaged in a theological battle
44:21designed to show the truth of Christianity and the folly of the Jews.
44:30In towns like Girona in northern Spain, home to one of the most learned Jewish communities in medieval Christendom,
44:38New Orders of Friars, the Dominicans and Franciscans, launched an attack on the Jews
44:44and on the sacred books that had preserved their identity for a thousand years.
44:53The church had always had a problem when it came to dealing with the Jews.
44:57It couldn't attack their Old Testament because the scripture contained prophecies of Christ's coming.
45:04You couldn't have a New Testament without an Old Testament.
45:09So the Jews had to be protected and preserved as witnesses to the miracle.
45:14They were too blind, fanatical or stubborn to admit one day perhaps they would.
45:20But now, as far as the heresy hunters were concerned, things have changed.
45:27These were no longer Bible Jews, they were Talmud Jews.
45:33And what was this Talmud, this oral law anyway, but a load of endless arguments.
45:40By their own standards, the Jews had betrayed their own scripture.
45:45And with that betrayal, their protection had gone right out of the window.
45:55In 1263, the church organised a public showdown between Christians and Jews.
46:05Leading the Christian church was Pablo Christiani, a Dominican friar and convert from Judaism.
46:15While the man with the task of defending Judaism was Moses Ben Nachman, known as Nachmanides.
46:23A deeply learned rabbi from the Jewish quarter here in Girona.
46:32Christiani, the convert, set out to use passages about the coming of the Messiah in the Torah and the Talmud,
46:38to prove that the Jews had in their own sacred texts predicted the coming of Jesus Christ, the Messiah, all
46:46along.
46:48The theological show trial, known as the Barcelona Disputation, began on the 20th of July, 1263.
46:59In front of a packed Christian audience, including the king and the leading clergy of the land.
47:06Most dramatic.
47:08Leon Wieseltier sees the debate as one of the most moving events in the history of medieval Judaism.
47:16It's pretty clear that Nachmanides was an unbelievably courageous man in those three days, those three summer days in 1263.
47:25Here was a man who stood up alone.
47:27He had no force of any kind to count on except his own spiritual and intellectual force.
47:34He was helpless, quite literally helpless, before the power of the church and before the secular power of the king.
47:42He tells the king of Spain that you think that the Messiah is the center of Judaism?
47:47You're wrong. He isn't.
47:48You are a king and he is a king.
47:50You are a king of flesh and blood and he is a king of flesh and blood.
47:54He condescends to them.
47:55He is your version of Messiah, then two things should have happened.
48:00One, all my predecessors would have converted a long time ago.
48:04And secondly, the reign of peace would have broken out.
48:07Forgive me, but I don't actually notice that much peace.
48:09Well look, this goes to the heart of the difference between the Jewish messianic temperament and the Christian messianic temperament.
48:15Think of it this way. The problem for Jews is that we wait and wait and wait and wait and
48:20he doesn't come.
48:21The problem for the Christians is that he came and the world did not change.
48:26The Jews will always so arrange matters that they will never wake up on the morning after the Messiah arrives.
48:32Because the risk is much too great.
48:35Because the world will still be the world.
48:37And if you've been aspiring to a transformation and it comes and things are not transformed, then you are bereft.
48:45And when Nachmanides says to the Christians, he couldn't have been the Messiah because look at the world.
48:51There are wars. There is suffering. Look at the world.
48:56For the Christian establishment, the presence in their midst of people with such obstinately different beliefs became unbearable.
49:06With increasing ferocity, they asked themselves, what place did the Jews have in Christian Spain?
49:14And the answer came back, none.
49:18Either they must convert or suffer the consequences.
49:24Here in Seville, those consequences were spelt out in brutal fashion.
49:30With a massacre of 4,000 Jews on a single day in 1391.
49:38An act that triggered horrifying violence against Jews all across Spain.
49:45After that, a third of Sephardic Jews did convert, but even that didn't solve the Jewish problem.
49:53Could the sincerity of the converts be trusted now?
49:57Who knew what they really thought and believed?
50:03This is the Iglesia de la Maddalena in Seville.
50:06The first headquarters of the Spanish Inquisition, designed to root out the pretenders from the true believers.
50:19But the torture and burning of thousands did nothing to ease the paranoia.
50:27Converts could never be trusted while there were still Jews in Spain to lure them back to the old faith.
50:36So, the Jews had to go.
50:40The date on this parchment bound volume is 1492.
50:44These are the records of the small town of Girona in Catalonia, Nachmanides' town.
50:51And like all local council proceedings, most of the stuff recorded here is very much small potatoes,
50:58property disputes, how to resolve quarrels between landlords and peasants.
51:03And then in the middle of it is something which is not small at all, the record of an immense
51:09tragedy.
51:11About four lines down is recorded the decision of the king to expel the Jews, their expellendos, from his kingdom.
51:23It's the death sentence of a culture which has lived in Girona for half a millennium and in the rest
51:30of Spain for even longer.
51:31It's the death sentence on the possibility of Jews having a coexistence with Christians.
51:38It's an appalling tragedy.
51:41And however good the intentions, something recorded in the Edith makes it, if anything, even worse.
51:47Because the king, further down the page, orders his subjects not to harass or disturb the Jews in the process
51:56of packing up and selling off synagogues and lands and possessions.
52:01Get them out of here in peace as quickly as possible, to which you want to say how very considerate.
52:18The Jews were given just four months to liquidate what it had taken centuries to build.
52:28So, Jews did what Jews do. They packed.
52:34And you all know there's pictures of long lines of pathetic bedraggled figures toting bags along dusty roads.
52:43That began here in 1492 in Spain.
52:50And one of the most glorious, rich, sophisticated, poetically beautiful cultures there's ever been in Europe came to an end.
53:01But there were some things that could not be taken from the Jews.
53:05Their language, their music, their poetry, their richly spiced, gorgeous cooking.
53:13I could keep myself a long way away from Spain.
53:17And above all, of course, inside their heads, inside their hearts, inside their little books, inside all the things designed
53:24for portability and endurance.
53:26Their religion.
53:28So, when those ships were loaded with Jews and their things in the harbours of Iberia, you might well have
53:38heard the Shemar drifting over the water.
53:43Here, O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one.
53:54So, where did they go? Almost everywhere.
53:57Morocco, Italy, Egypt.
54:00And above all, the Ottoman Empire, where the Turkish Sultan actively encouraged the Sephardim to resettle.
54:07Taunting the Spanish king that the expulsion would impoverish Spain and enrich his empire.
54:18Commerce also motivated the rulers of the Republic of Venice to offer a welcome of sorts to the Jews.
54:33With family connections in the Islamic world, the Jews would be priceless to a Christian city that lived on trade.
54:42But this didn't mean there was going to be some sort of happy mingling on the shores of the Adriatic.
54:51The lords of the lagoon came up with a new way of isolating the Jews.
54:59From 1516, Venice's Jews were forced to live in a small district of just a few residential blocks at the
55:09northern perimeter of the city.
55:14The gates were locked at night.
55:19And a new word was born.
55:21And a new word was born.
55:29Today, the word ghetto is synonymous with poverty, racism, families under stress.
55:40All the above were true of here, the world's first ghetto.
55:48And yet, there are places where you can feel the sigh of relief that was Jewish Venice.
55:56A place for all its condescension and humiliations where you could actually make a Jewish life.
56:07Nowhere more so than the Shrula Spaniola.
56:11The Spanish-Portuguese synagogue where the birds in flight from Spain came to rest.
56:20When it came to redesigning the synagogue, the Sephardim thought big and beautiful.
56:28By now, the Jews were old hands at living under the sufferance of Christians and Muslims.
56:37And under pressure, they went back, as always, to the core of their religion.
56:45They followed the mitzvot, the commandments.
56:48They sung the songs.
56:50They read the books.
56:51They built the synagogue.
56:56I have the strangest sense of having been here before hundreds of years ago.
57:02This is a delusion, I know.
57:04But Jews are tied together by irrational bonds of memory very often.
57:10There's a sort of odd air of spice and old Jews, of which I'm one now.
57:16This place is so beautiful.
57:18It speaks for me of the deep pathos of Jewish longing for beauty, for grandeur.
57:25Jews never really think it's an obligation to build gorgeous ornaments, gorgeous buildings.
57:31Because you always know you're going to have to leave them behind.
57:35You're going to have to reach for the suitcase sooner or later.
57:38And yet, you want to believe that in the place you've just come to, where God has allowed you to
57:45prosper, and for a few generations at least be safe,
57:48honour your religion, by doing this, by making something stunningly beautiful.
57:55So this whole place feels as though it reconciles the idea of refuge with beauty.
58:02And if you can bring that off just for a little moment in the hard lives of Jewish history, you
58:10have performed a mitzvah, just as surely as you've looked after the poor, the sick, and the dying.
58:17That's what it says. That's what Venice says.
58:21And if anyone has cliches about the ghetto, you bring them here to see how beauty can also be a
58:30mitzvah.
58:32That's what I feel.
58:44A remarkable secret about Oliver Cromwell's statue outside the Houses of Parliament, QIXL follows next on BBC Two.
58:52And when his beloved wife passes away, a man asks his best friend to help him say goodbye.
58:57A moving film premiere, Silent Souls, is on BBC Four in 15 minutes.