Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 2 days ago
Transcript
00:12Every year in the spring, a country born from the ashes of annihilation remembers a loss
00:19for which there are no words.
00:40To be continued...
01:09To be continued...
01:42To be continued...
02:11To be continued...
02:20To be continued...
02:30To be continued...
03:15To be continued...
03:34To be continued...
03:46To be continued...
05:04To be continued...
06:25To be continued...
12:11To be continued...
12:44To be continued...
13:16To be continued...
13:51To be continued...
14:25To be continued...
14:57To be continued...
15:10To be continued...
15:36To be continued...
16:04To be continued...
16:10To be continued...
17:04To be continued...
17:32To be continued...
17:39To be continued...
18:07To be continued...
18:21To be continued...
18:37To be continued...
18:41To be continued...
18:50To be continued...
18:52To be continued...
19:29To be continued...
19:34To be continued...
19:55To be continued...
20:18To be continued...
20:22To be continued...
20:42To be continued...
20:52To be continued...
20:57To be continued...
21:06To be continued...
21:14To be continued...
21:29To be continued...
21:33To be continued...
21:46To be continued...
22:00To be continued...
22:02To be continued...
22:03To be continued...
22:03To be continued...
22:03To be continued...
22:04To be continued...
22:04To be continued...
22:05To be continued...
22:07To be continued...
22:09To be continued...
22:10To be continued...
22:13To be continued...
22:17To be continued...
22:17To be continued...
22:18To be continued...
22:18To be continued...
22:20To be continued...
22:22To be continued...
22:24To be continued...
22:25of spiritual and cultural ideals,
22:28and a rebuttal of crude power politics and petty nationalism.
22:42The most thoughtfully tortured of the idealists
22:45was the philosopher Martin Buber.
22:47Buber had known Weizmann and Jabotinsky
22:50when they were all young Zionists,
22:52but unlike them, he didn't think Zionism had to be mostly about matters of power.
22:58On the contrary, if Zionism ended up merely reproducing the power plays of the rest of the world,
23:04all of its achievements would be merely self-defeating.
23:08For Buber, a true Jewish national revival had to be based on Judaism,
23:14and the principle of Judaism that mattered most to him was simple.
23:18Do not do unto others what is hateful to you.
23:24Now, the acid test of that fundamental Jewish principle for Buber
23:29was how Jews treated the Arabs of Palestine.
23:33Four decades afterwards, whatever happened,
23:37Buber would insist on the importance of that.
23:47Chaim Weizmann was the diplomat-statesman.
23:50Jabotinsky was the ideologue.
23:52Martin Buber, a moral philosopher.
23:54What was missing if Zionism was really going to work as a concrete, successful movement?
24:01The answer is organizational politics.
24:04And no one was as good at that as David Ben-Gurion.
24:09Ben-Gurion was the vital force of hard-headed politics.
24:17He came from Plonsk in Russia, but he always said he never really suffered very much
24:21from anti-Semitism directed at him personally.
24:25So it gave his vision, which he certainly had, a Bible-saturated vision,
24:30a kind of flinty optimism, a sort of element of rejoicing in it,
24:35as well as a fierce sense of political calculation.
24:39And it was this kind of complex moral decency inside this human machine
24:46of political cunning that won David Ben-Gurion respect,
24:49both before and after Israel's independence.
24:55But the decades that lay between the Balfour Declaration
24:59and the Declaration of Independence proved to be bloody ones.
25:05Despite the high hopes expressed in Prince Faisal's letter,
25:09opposition to a Jewish national home among the Arabs of Palestine
25:14had quickly turned violent.
25:19Arab attacks on settlements and towns were met with swift Jewish counter-attacks.
25:27Hunkered down in pillboxes and fortified barracks,
25:31the British had brutally suppressed Arab revolts.
25:35But at the same time they were slamming the door on Jewish immigration to Palestine
25:40in the hope of appeasing Arab opinion,
25:44provoking mass protests from the Jews already there.
25:52And, at the same time, all over the rest of the world
25:56other escape routes were being closed,
25:59condemning to death the Jews trapped in Nazi Europe.
26:04The Protestant cemetery in Jerusalem bears testimony
26:08to the human cost of Britain,
26:10of the adventure begun by Balfour and his colleagues,
26:14soldiers and policemen who died on active service,
26:18some of them victims of Jewish terrorism.
26:21By the time the last man died,
26:24Britain had handed responsibility for Palestine over to the United Nations.
26:32In November 1947, the UN recommended partition.
26:40A viable, independent Jewish state,
26:44covering 56% of Palestine had been voted into existence
26:48by the international community.
26:53On the 14th of May 1948,
26:56at a hastily arranged ceremony at the Tel Aviv Museum,
27:00David Ben-Gurion turned the United Nations vote
27:03into an historic reality.
27:09The land of Israel was the birthplace of the Jewish people.
27:13Here, their spiritual, religious and national identity was formed.
27:21Exiled from their land,
27:23the Jewish people remained faithful to it
27:26in all the countries of their dispersion,
27:28never ceasing to pray and hope for their return
27:32and for the restoration in it of their national freedom.
27:50But national freedom had to be fought for.
27:54The Arabs rejected the UN partition plan,
27:57as they had rejected every previous attempt to divide Palestine.
28:01The bitter civil war between Jews and Arabs in Palestine
28:05now became a war between Jewish and Arab states in 1948,
28:10when armies from Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon and Iraq
28:14simultaneously attacked Israel.
28:21One of the crucial battlegrounds was here,
28:24at the kibbutz of Yad Mordechai,
28:26where a small group of Jews,
28:28inspired by comrades who had fallen in the Warsaw Ghetto uprising,
28:32held out against Egyptian tank divisions for a critical six days.
28:37For Yad Mordechai, the heroic deaths in Warsaw
28:41had made their own battle to survive in Palestine a sacred obligation.
28:50After the war, an armistice agreement allowed Israel to expand its boundaries,
28:56redrawing them along the so-called Green Line
28:58and putting Israel in control of nearly 80% of Mandate Palestine,
29:04including West Jerusalem.
29:07The biblical heartland of Judea and Samaria
29:10and the old city of Jerusalem,
29:12site of the Western Wall, were not part of this new Israel.
29:15But for secular Zionists,
29:17this was an emotional symbolic issue,
29:20rather than a practical one.
29:24The centre of gravity of the new Jewish state
29:27was not Jerusalem, burdened with the aura of its history,
29:31but Tel Aviv,
29:32which by the 1940s had grown into a modern, secular, breezy metropolis by the sea,
29:37a cafe-happy cultural powerhouse of creativity,
29:41boasting the latest in modernist architecture and modernist thinking.
29:48A new home for new Jews in their new old land.
30:04For the Arabs of Palestine,
30:07Israel's war of independence had meant Nakba, catastrophe.
30:11The displacement, sometimes violently,
30:14of hundreds of thousands of Palestinians
30:16from towns and villages like Lifta,
30:19on the outskirts of Jerusalem.
30:26By the time of the 1949 armistice,
30:30around 700,000 Palestinians had left,
30:34some fleeing in fear,
30:36some obeying the orders of village elders or Arab guerrillas,
30:40some driven out by force and terror.
30:47Their towns and villages became part of Israel,
30:51and they have never been able to return to their homes,
30:54except occasionally, as visitors.
30:58How stalkies are the icons of their loss,
31:01and their hope of an eventual return.
31:06It killed us.
31:09But this life outside Lifta shaped our mentality.
31:16They lost everything.
31:19Only the hope to come back.
31:22So, always I bring my son to come to Lifta.
31:28I tell them, here is my father's house.
31:32Here is your father's house.
31:34Here, here, here, here.
31:37So, they will never forget.
31:43But there are other memories,
31:46and other catastrophes dating to these same fateful years.
31:51Hundreds of thousands of Jews,
31:52living in Muslim countries for centuries,
31:55discovered suddenly their home was no longer their home.
32:03This is the Eliyahu Hanavi,
32:06Elijah the Prophet, synagogue in Alexandria.
32:09In its day, it could swallow a thousand worshippers without blinking.
32:15This was a deeply rooted community with clans of families,
32:20inevitably some richer, some poorer,
32:22the older of them sitting in their family pews.
32:26You showed up on Shabbat,
32:27and you knew exactly where the shamans would be sitting.
32:33But all of that became suddenly irrelevant,
32:37following the establishment of Israel in 1948,
32:40and the war that followed.
32:45It hadn't always been easy to live as a Jew in a Muslim country,
32:49and long before Israel was created,
32:52it was getting harder to avoid charges of Zionism
32:55in countries like Egypt and Iraq.
32:57But after 1947, the gloves came off.
33:03Assaults, riots, murders, arrests, show trials,
33:09public hangings, expropriations, expulsions.
33:16Did you have any sense that there might be trouble?
33:21I knew nothing. I was only ten years old.
33:25So, all of a sudden, at midnight, ten Egyptian officers in our house,
33:32searching everywhere.
33:34I don't know what they were searching after.
33:37They opened closets, drawers, they cut mattresses.
33:41I didn't know what they wanted, and they left.
33:45They found nothing. They left.
33:46They did the same to my uncle upstairs.
33:49But they took him to prison.
33:52For me, it was a trauma, a shock,
33:55because prison for a child ten years old is a criminal.
34:00My uncle was a criminal?
34:02I asked my mother if that's true.
34:05Is he a criminal?
34:06She explained to me that he went to prison because we are Jews.
34:14The same story was repeated all over the Muslim world,
34:18not just in Egypt, but in Iraq, Yemen, Syria and Lebanon,
34:23Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia and Libya.
34:26At least 700,000 Jews left or were expelled.
34:31Many reduced to destitution, taking with them only what they could carry.
34:37Some went to America, others in the North African world to France,
34:41Iraqis to Britain, but many came to Israel,
34:45most of them Zionists by necessity rather than choice.
34:53The exodus of Jewish communities from Muslim lands
34:56almost doubled the population of Israel in just a few years,
35:01the first but not the last demographic tidal wave
35:04to engulf this tiny country.
35:09In the decades that followed, millions more would come when they could,
35:13from places as far apart as India, East Africa, the Caucasus and Russia.
35:21This was a country for Jews,
35:23but it also became one of the most diverse in the whole world.
35:30The state did all it could to forge a common identity for these new arrivals.
35:36Hebrew was the armature around which a Jewish-Israeli identity would be built.
35:43The ancient language of the Bible adapting itself to the demands of a modern state.
35:52Israel exploded the stereotype of Jews as weak, rootless victims.
35:57Here, the Jews were enterprising, muscular and vigorous.
36:03Those born here were nicknamed Sabra, prickly pears,
36:07tough and uncompromising on the outside, soft and sweet on the inside,
36:12and the rest of the world would just have to get used to dealing with them.
36:27And this is when I played my own modest part in the miracle.
36:31In 1963, I worked for two months on a kibbutz called Betta Emek.
36:38Returning, nearly 50 years later brought it all back.
36:42Freddie Kahana, Betta Emek's resident architect and planner,
36:46who's been on the kibbutz for more than 60 years, showed me round.
36:52These are the original houses of Betta Emek.
36:54You probably remember them.
36:56I do remember them.
36:56I remember the lawns very well and I remember the olive trees.
36:59Just the trees have grown up and a bit of the landscape has changed.
37:03Yeah.
37:03But these are the original houses of Betta Emek.
37:06Some of these trees are 200 years old, 300 years old.
37:10They're very beautiful.
37:13It looks like a comfortable enough kind of place,
37:16but in its day, Betta Emek and the other 270 kibbutzes of Israel
37:21were once the scene of a radical new departure in the Jewish story.
37:30The kibbutz blended the Zionist dream of building a new Jewish country
37:35with a secular, socialist vision of building a better world.
37:40For a Jewish teenager like me, it was an irresistible blend
37:45of romance, social idealism, adventure and sunshine.
37:54The reason I came to Betta Emek was I was a member of a Zionist youth group in London,
38:00Habodin, being drawn to the ideals of communalist and socialist Zionism,
38:07pretty much as an alternative to a religious life.
38:10I wanted a different kind of Jewish from the Judaism that the synagogue offered.
38:16The kibbutz movement, when it came, they were secular.
38:21They weren't religious. They didn't pray, but they were Jewish.
38:25And this raises the question, what is then Judaism under those circumstances?
38:29And the kibbutz movement, in effect, at some stage decided that they were the new Judaism
38:37and started to redefine Judaism in its own image.
38:42And all this created in Israel a new way of being Jewish.
38:48And it's a secular way.
38:49And if there's a secular community in Israel today,
38:54it owes a great deal to the foundations of the meaning of it,
38:58which was created in the kibbutzim.
38:59Mm-hmm.
39:03Kibbutzniks were never more than a tiny percentage of the population,
39:07but their influence was enormous.
39:10They were the elite of the new social-democratic Israel,
39:14a progressive bloc who for decades would dominate the country's political, social and cultural heights.
39:23But even these irreproachably liberal, right-minded, left-leaning Jews
39:28had to struggle to come to terms with the historical reality
39:31on which their bright new future was being built.
39:36In the case of Beta Emek, an Arab village called Kuekat.
39:42I must admit, I was not happy about the fact that this was sitting on an Arab village.
39:48I didn't feel good about it, but I accepted it.
39:51It wasn't there.
39:51The problem was simply not there.
39:54And over the years, we expanded the kibbutz, we took down the Arab houses,
39:58we expanded the kibbutz on top of the Arab village.
40:01And looking back now, we can say,
40:03okay, we didn't think about it, maybe we should have thought about it.
40:06But that's not the point.
40:09It's important to remember where we are,
40:12and also why we're here.
40:14I have no regrets, personally.
40:17But it's not an easy subject.
40:26The dream of a Jewish state was always going to be rather different from the reality.
40:32In Israel, ideals and aspirations are challenged every day by the complexities of survival,
40:39in a world that mostly remains hostile.
40:44Photographer Micha Ba'am has been recording the struggle between aspiration and reality for more than 50 years.
40:53It's a kind of a witnessing, observing and trying to leave your little scratch by the way you look at
41:03things.
41:07This is one of the first settlements in the Negev, which is the southern part, the desert part of Israel.
41:16What is this?
41:17That is trenches.
41:19Oh, they're trenches!
41:20They are trenches, and you can see them in many settlements.
41:24This makes it even more fantastic.
41:26So you have this really rather innocent image of the Halutz, the pioneering house.
41:32Very, you know, kind of honest, virtuous sets of home and hard work.
41:37And then you have the military reality around it.
41:41It's something like a rift.
41:44Like a rift dividing, even now, the Israeli society.
41:53In June 1967, Israel was once again fighting for its existence, with Egyptian, Syrian and Jordanian armies massing on its
42:03borders.
42:03But with a series of bold preemptive strikes and swift forward actions, a war fought initially for survival became, just
42:13six dramatic days later, a military triumph for Israel that few had foreseen.
42:24Israeli forces pushed over the Green Line, south into Sinai, north into the Golan Heights and east of the banks
42:32of the Jordan, occupying cities and territory steeped in biblical history.
42:39But it was the capture of the old city of Jerusalem, the religious heart of Judaism, that caused even the
42:47most secular-minded Jew to be swept away by a sense of the miraculous.
42:54Micah Ba'am was there when Israeli paratroopers arrived at the Western Wall, the last remnant of the High Temple
43:01destroyed 1900 years before by the Roman legions, the start of centuries of exile from Jerusalem.
43:15This is a crash of bullets.
43:18Yeah, exactly.
43:19That was the day the Western Wall in Jerusalem was liberated by the paratroopers.
43:28It was such a moving moment for everyone.
43:33You didn't have to be a religious Jew, but it's a historic moment when the messianic spirit and the military
43:43power have merged and brought upon us what is now the spirit of Israeli society.
43:54They changed Israel. That's the simplest way to say it, don't you think?
43:58And all of a sudden you could visit biblical scenes that were part of the history of the Jews from
44:06the River Jordan, from Joshua crossing into Hebron, Nablus, Sikkim.
44:16You know, all of a sudden the feeling of people was that maybe it is right to go back to
44:24all those historic sites.
44:29But going back was just the beginning.
44:32For some, the victories of the Six-Day War were a clear divine summons to reclaim not just biblical historical
44:40acreage, but what they now thought had been the true Zionist ideal all along.
44:46Eretz Israel, the land of Israel, for them, was a place of messianic redemption.
44:54This was the start of the so-called settler movement, a hybrid of religious and nationalist zeal flourishing under the
45:01umbrella of Israeli military power and taking its authority from the Bible rather than its permission from the UN.
45:13The international community regards these settlements, some now the size of cities, as illegal.
45:20To the Palestinians, they are part of a Trojan horse annexation policy orchestrated by the government and the military.
45:27To many Israelis, they become simply a source of affordable housing.
45:39But Zvi Cooper, like many Israelis who choose to live in the settlements, is still driven by the ideals of
45:47the founders of the settler movement.
45:52This is Tekaua, halfway between Jerusalem and the Dead Sea.
45:57It's a relaxed kind of place where everyone knows each other's names and looks out for each other's kids.
46:08This is the very heart of what the world calls the West Bank.
46:12But to Zvi and thousands like him, this is Judea and Samaria, the biblical home of the Jews thousands of
46:20years ago and now their home once more.
46:26One of my beliefs is that there's not going to be peace if Jews can't live anywhere, especially in their
46:33homeland.
46:34A Jew can live in Berlin, a Jew can live in Cairo even.
46:37But many people believe that Jews can't live in the ancient biblical homeland, which includes Tekaua, my home.
46:45Tell me what, you're suddenly Zvi to power, and you had a map, what would that map look like?
46:52I mean, how would you redraw the Green Line?
46:56The Green Line would, in my opinion, doesn't really exist today.
46:59OK.
47:00A dream would be a return to the larger borders, or at least the ability...
47:05Where do the larger borders end?
47:08You know, Solomon's kingdom or David's kingdom.
47:12And today, I wouldn't necessarily imagine that we would ever return to those borders, but it would be nice that
47:17a Jewish family could move in and build a homestead in some of those villages.
47:23There are amazingly rich archaeological sites that are evidence to the contribution that Jews made to this world in this
47:33area.
47:33The ancient Jewish settlements in Jordan, there are ancient Jewish settlements in Syria, up to the river Prat, the Euphrates.
47:42And I think it's a lie to humanity for us not to be able to inhabit this land and these
47:48places.
47:49And it would be a disaster.
47:53Meeting Zvi was not easy for me.
47:56I recognised the sincerity of his views, but profoundly disagree with them.
48:03A sense of territorial entitlement prescribed by the Bible is not a development of the Zionism of necessity, but a
48:11threat to it.
48:12For the Bible is many things but a blueprint for peace in this land.
48:17It is surely not.
48:21If, in fact, settlements have to be part of the Jewish state, you're going to be a minority presiding and
48:29ruling over, you know, an unemancipated majority.
48:35You know, you will genuinely be in the imperial situation which Zionism has never wanted to be.
48:42I think that the history is unfolding and people like me and others are making that history.
48:47And it's up to us to bravely look at where we live and understand that there is no dividing up
48:55this country.
48:56There is no dividing of Jerusalem.
48:57There's no handing over of the biblical homeland to Koa and other villages like that.
49:01We're going to have to find a different model, a model that may not exist in Europe anyway.
49:06So, the conventional logic that's applicable to the entire world may need some adjustment for the Holy Land.
49:13It always has.
49:15All the rather beautiful things you speak eloquently about may indeed be felt, if not with a biblical text, by
49:23the Palestinians as well.
49:24So, I don't know what to say. It seems to me like, yeah, we're arguing roots, whose roots are deeper.
49:32I'd just like to say my roots are here too.
49:40There's been a dramatic shift in Israel over the past decades.
49:44The secular, outward-looking Israel I remember from my days in Beta Emek has been eclipsed by one that insists,
49:54in the name of religion, nationalism or security, on separation and difference.
50:02The Israeli novelist David Grossman has tackled these issues throughout his life as a writer.
50:08He believes they stem from the very roots of Jewish experience.
50:12The Euphrates to the sea.
50:13I mean, we talked to a settler from Dakar the other day, who got a kind of dreamy look in
50:19his eye when he said,
50:21of course, you know where the tribe of Gad was one day and so on.
50:25And those borders are kind of set out very extravagantly in Genesis.
50:31But they're not the borders of a defensible home.
50:35Do you think that's part of the problem?
50:38These are borders of a dream.
50:40Yeah.
50:40Of deep religious belief.
50:42In the years that Israel exists, in 65 almost years of our sovereignty, our borders have moved and shifted.
50:53We invaded others.
50:55There were all the time this ambiguity of where the border is.
51:02I wonder, I ask myself why it is like that.
51:05Probably it has to do something with our attraction as a people to the abstract.
51:10You know, we have invented the abstract God.
51:13But it's not only that.
51:14For 2,000 years, you know, Jews lived in Spain and Morocco and Egypt and Yemen.
51:20And they had their concrete everyday life there.
51:24But at the same time, the essence of their life, the essence of the meaning of their being was in
51:30a totally different remote place.
51:33In the end of the East there in Jerusalem, in Zion.
51:36And in the Torah.
51:37In the Torah, in the Talmud, they created an enormous body of existence that was all imaginary, all in the
51:46mind.
51:46And I think part of our tragedy is that when we already came here, to this place, to our home,
51:53we still flirt with this abstraction.
51:56We still, we are here, but it's always possible for us to be out of here.
52:03You know, it's always possible for us to exist in the sphere of the imagination, of spirituality.
52:12Peace can root our being, can make it more solid.
52:24Today in Israel, the distance between dream and reality can be measured in hundreds of miles of barbed wire and
52:32concrete.
52:36The separation barrier was a response to a devastating wave of suicide bombings, unleashed a decade ago in which more
52:45than 500 Israelis died.
52:47Today, it cuts Israel off from the West Bank, except where it snakes deep into the occupied territories to protect
52:55some of the larger settlements.
52:58Shredding Palestinian territory and making life for the Palestinians a daily ordeal.
53:09I don't know why, but walls are big in Jewish history, aren't they? Walls of lamentation. Walls of the temple,
53:17ghetto walls, this.
53:20Steve Jabotinsky, the militant nationalist Jewish Zionist leader in the 20s and 30s, talked about the necessity for an iron
53:29wall,
53:29as a condition of there being any realistic chance of a Jewish state surviving.
53:36Well, he got it in this, didn't he?
53:40I want to say that nobody, including me, ultimately has the moral right to say that shouldn't have happened.
53:49The wall shouldn't have happened.
53:51Before the wall happened, hundreds of people were dying every year from terrorist attacks.
53:57After the wall happened, very, very few.
54:01In some senses, if you don't live in Israel, I don't live in Israel, you're morally obliged to be nearly
54:09silent, nearly silent, all the same.
54:12I also want to add to that huge moral caveat this.
54:16The Bible is full of encounters between men and God, between men and other men, between even enemy brothers.
54:26It's very difficult for me to sort of stand here and say that that kind of Judaism, the Judaism of
54:33openness, of encounter, has a chance of a true life here.
54:39This is a Judaism, a Jewishness that looks, scurries beneath the shadows of these towers for safety.
54:46It's not ultimately a Judaism of bravery.
54:50It's not ultimately a Judaism of life.
54:59But there are gaps in the wall where a little light gets in.
55:08At the hand-in-hand school in Jerusalem, Jewish and Arab students are taught in Hebrew and Arabic by Arab
55:16and Jewish teachers.
55:19The kids here are no starry-eyed utopians.
55:23Bitter divisions, long inherited and deeply felt, crowd in on their teenage lives.
55:29It's not true, it's true.
55:32It's a reason for me to be able to sleep in the night.
55:35It's an atmosphere there, and the time when people come there, people come there, people will be able to do
55:44it more.
55:45Yes, I feel like I'm going to come here and I'm going to come here and start to...
55:49I'm not going to listen to the Arab, but the name of the people I'm going to be able to
55:52be a place or something like that.
55:57But growing up together must do something to immunize them against the habits of hatred.
56:03Where others see enemies, they see friends.
56:33The duel between raw power and ethical idealism has been at the heart of the Jewish story for thousands of
56:41years.
56:43It's what the historian Josephus meant when he said that Jews have become the teachers of men in the greatest
56:50of things.
56:50It's what flowered in medieval Spain when Jews and Muslims shared the same space and culture.
56:58It's what enabled Moses Mendelssohn to use thought and language to build a bridge between the Jewish and non-Jewish
57:05world.
57:09It's what made the songwriters plant a conscience into the hard-bitten money makers of Timpan Alley.
57:20It's done, brother, in paradise.
57:30Ultimately, it's about the victory of humanity over force.
57:35A victory enshrined in this copy of the Talmud, that bottomless treasure house of all things Jewish.
57:42It was printed in Heidelberg in 1947 on German presses, under the authority of the liberating American army, to whom
57:52it's movingly dedicated.
57:55But it was produced and published by Jews, who, having survived the death camps, wanted to proclaim, like us, our
58:04culture has survived destruction too.
58:06Which is why it's known as the survivors Talmud.
58:14This is a vision of the eternal dialogue of the Jewish story.
58:19The dialogue between lament and rejoicing.
58:23Between history and hope.
58:25Between the earthly world and a visionary possibility.
58:28It's an argument as well as a dialogue.
58:30An argument which no one is supposed to win.
58:33Because if we know one thing for sure about the Jewish tradition,
58:38it's that the chapter is written, but the book is not finished.
58:43In 1st.
58:45In 1st.
59:07In 1st.
59:09In 1st.
59:10In 1st.
59:12In 2st.
59:13In 1st.

Recommended