- 2 days ago
Category
📚
LearningTranscript
00:10This is a Jew, and so is this, this is a Jew, and this, and this, and so am I.
00:28So what, if anything, do we have in common?
00:33Not the colour of our skin, not the languages we speak, the tunes we sing, the food we eat.
00:47Not our opinions, we're a fiercely argumentative lot.
00:53Not even the way we pray, assuming we do.
00:59What ties us together is a story, the story kept in our heads and hearts, a story of suffering
01:07and resilience, endurance and creativity.
01:15It's the story that made me want to be an historian in the first place.
01:19For I understood when I was quite small that there were two special things about the Jews that we'd endured
01:26for over 3,000 years despite everything that had been thrown at us, and that we had an extraordinarily dramatic
01:35story to tell, and somehow that these two things were connected.
01:40That we told our story to survive, we are our story.
01:46And the last one, we are our story.
01:47Let's pray.
01:48Let's pray.
01:50Let's pray.
01:53Let's pray.
02:03Let's pray.
02:05Let's pray.
02:34In the summer of 1938
02:36an eminent elderly Jew
02:38recently arrived in London from Vienna
02:40was interviewed by the BBC.
02:44I discovered some important new facts
02:50about the unconscious and psychic life.
02:57People did not believe in my facts
03:01and thought my theories
03:05and savouries.
03:09My name?
03:11Siegmund Freud.
03:14Dying of a cancer that had eaten away
03:17half his jaw.
03:18Driven from Vienna by the Nazis
03:20at the age of 82.
03:22His daughter Anna
03:24interrogated by the Gestapo
03:26his life's work
03:27demonised as Jewish science.
03:32But Siegmund Freud was now safe in England
03:36lovely, free, magnanimous England
03:39as he called it
03:40and he could return to the questions
03:42that had haunted him for years.
03:45Where did the distinct identity
03:48of the Jews come from
03:49and how, in spite of everything,
03:52had it managed to survive?
03:56Among Freud's collection
03:58of ancient figurines and sculptures
04:00from religions and cultures long dead
04:03was an artefact that told
04:05a different story
04:07about endurance and survival.
04:12An ancient Hanukkah lamp
04:15a commemoration of the temple light
04:17that tradition said
04:19kept burning.
04:27It mattered supremely to Freud
04:30this little object
04:31with its Hebrew inscription
04:33Ki ne'a ha mitzvah v'hatorah ha'or
04:36for the commandment is the lamp
04:38and the teaching the light.
04:40The menorah is the most ancient
04:42and enduring symbol
04:44of Jewish identity
04:45even for someone
04:46who called himself
04:48a godless Jew.
04:52Godless he may have been
04:54but Freud never gave up
04:55on his Jewishness
04:57and as the dark stain
04:59of Nazi anti-Semitism
05:00began to spread
05:01he proclaimed it
05:03publicly and loudly.
05:06He was also driven
05:07to begin his own exploration
05:09of the roots of the Jewish story
05:11work that would dominate
05:13the final years of his life
05:14first in Vienna
05:15and then in London.
05:21Psychoanalysis
05:22Freud's great discovery
05:23was driven by the belief
05:25that in our origins
05:26lay the explanation
05:28of everything that followed.
05:30Dismayed by the dark hatreds
05:32unleashed by the Nazis
05:34Freud applied his theory
05:36to the Jews.
05:38At the heart of their story
05:40was an old obsession
05:41of Freud's
05:42Moses
05:43the domineering father figure
05:45who'd led the Jews
05:46out of slavery in Egypt
05:48and had placed on their shoulders
05:50the gift
05:51and the burden
05:52of the Ten Commandments.
05:56As the Nazi horror
05:58closed in
05:59Freud came back to Moses
06:00in earnest
06:02and to ask the question
06:04why, how, and when
06:05the peculiar destiny
06:07of the Jews
06:08got started
06:09and how was it
06:11that the rest of the world
06:12so often
06:13had decided
06:14to make them pay
06:15dearly for it.
06:20Freud's theory
06:21was outrageous.
06:24The ancient Israelites
06:26had rebelled against Moses
06:28and murdered him
06:31but then
06:32consumed by guilt
06:34and remorse
06:34had adopted
06:35the laws
06:36he'd carried down
06:36from Mount Sinai
06:37with an obsessive devotion
06:40that had endured
06:41despite millennia
06:42of suffering
06:43exile
06:44and persecution.
06:46When it was finally published
06:48it caused a scandal
06:49which cast a shadow
06:50over Freud's
06:51last few months of life.
06:55Something supremely important
06:57had been lost
06:58in all the yelling
07:00and shouting
07:00and that was Freud's
07:02passionate conviction
07:03that by preserving
07:04their religion
07:05whether consciously
07:07or unconsciously
07:08the Jews
07:09had given themselves
07:10an extraordinary possibility
07:12of enduring
07:13not just as a faith
07:15but as a people
07:16when everything else
07:17had been lost
07:18land, kingdom
07:20and power.
07:22That was the meaning
07:23of the travelling menorah
07:24and why Freud
07:25had kept it.
07:26the idea
07:27of sustaining
07:28an identity
07:29around things
07:30intellectual,
07:32cultural
07:32and spiritual.
07:48like Freud,
07:49every Jew
07:50godless, devout
07:52or anywhere in between
07:53must find
07:54their own Moses
07:55and their own place
07:56in the Jewish story
07:58and that the annual
07:59feast of Pesach
08:00or Passover
08:01surrounded by family
08:02and friends
08:03that's what happens.
08:07Welcome everybody
08:08I don't know about you
08:09but of all the occasions
08:11in the Jewish year
08:11always since I was
08:12a little boy
08:13and started to figure out
08:14I was stuck with being a Jew
08:16and very happy about it
08:17I was too.
08:18Pesach and Seder
08:19was the one thing
08:20I always look forward to
08:22more than anything else
08:23so I'm very happy you're here
08:27it's entirely a moment
08:29of celebration.
08:32And at the heart
08:33of the celebration
08:34is the liberation
08:35of the ancient Israelites
08:36from slavery in Egypt
08:38the story of stories
08:40replayed around the Seder table
08:42with the help
08:43of the Seder plate
08:45and its symbolic foods
08:48and a ritual book
08:49called the Haggadah.
08:51This is the bread of affliction
08:53which our ancestors
08:54ate in the land of Egypt
08:55all who are hungry
08:56let them come and eat
08:57all who are needy
08:58but this is about
08:59more than just retelling
09:00an ancient story
09:06it's about reliving it.
09:08What do we think
09:09everybody
09:11so what are for tears
09:12or Red Sea?
09:14what do we think
09:16tears
09:17is Red Sea
09:18an alternate
09:19and the Haggadah
09:21provokes questions
09:22that belong as much
09:23to the here and now
09:25as to the long ago.
09:28In every generation
09:29there are those
09:30who rise up against us
09:31and seek to destroy us
09:32but the Holy One
09:34blessed be He
09:34saves us
09:35from their hands.
09:37This is a tough passage
09:39really
09:40I mean
09:40this says
09:41that we can predict
09:43really
09:44that in every generation
09:45there will be
09:47exterminators
09:48just around the corner.
09:49I mean
09:50is Jewish culture
09:51always expecting
09:52the worst?
09:53Oh Lily
09:54yes darling
09:55yeah
09:55is that?
09:56I just thought
09:57it was realistic.
09:58Yeah.
09:59The Jewish imagination
10:00is paranoia
10:02confirmed by history.
10:16when it comes to history
10:19the Jews have certainly
10:20had their fair share
10:21and that history
10:22is rooted
10:23in a very particular place
10:25a sacred landscape
10:27known by many
10:29resonant names
10:30the land
10:31of milk and honey
10:33the land of Israel
10:34the holy land
10:36the promised land.
10:40This is the view
10:41from Mount Nebo
10:42in Jordan.
10:43According to the Bible
10:44this is where
10:45Moses died
10:46after leading
10:47the Israelites
10:47for 40 years
10:49through the wilderness
10:50on the very
10:51threshold
10:52of the God
10:53promised land
10:54he was never actually
10:55allowed to set foot in.
10:59You don't have to
11:00accept the Bible
11:01as literal truth
11:02to believe that
11:03three and a half
11:04thousand years ago
11:05something extraordinary
11:06and fateful
11:07in world history
11:08did happen
11:09over there
11:09on the other side
11:10of the Jordan Valley.
11:13Trying to understand
11:14what remains as urgent
11:16and necessary for me
11:17as it once was
11:19for Sigmund Freud.
11:22But the first people
11:24in the modern era
11:25to actually go there
11:26and explore the history
11:27of the Jews
11:28from the ground up
11:29weren't Jewish at all.
11:37They were Evangelical Christians
11:40Victorian scientists
11:42surveyors
11:43clerics
11:44and military engineers
11:45funded by bishops
11:47and philanthropists.
11:52150 years ago
11:54the Palestine Exploration Fund
11:57dispatched a series
11:58of expeditions
11:59to the place
12:00its supporters
12:01called
12:02the Holy Land.
12:04They wanted to prove
12:06the truth
12:06of their Christian faith
12:08by discovering
12:09the Jewish foundation stones
12:11on which that faith stood.
12:15Equipped
12:16with the latest
12:16in technology
12:17that Victorian science
12:19could provide
12:19they sought nothing less
12:21than the precise
12:22grid references
12:23for the places
12:24where the miraculous events
12:26described in the book
12:27of Exodus
12:27actually took place.
12:31That's a lovely one
12:32isn't it?
12:33Felicity Cobbing
12:34curator of the PEF
12:36collection
12:37showed me
12:38the fruits
12:38of their labours.
12:40Yeah, and here's
12:40an ordnance survey
12:42and we're used to
12:43thinking about
12:43ordnance survey maps
12:44and hills in Wiltshire
12:47and here
12:491867-68
12:51the same
12:52painstaking
12:54passion
12:55for measuring
12:56and producing
12:57this glorious
12:59map
13:00of the Sinai Peninsula
13:01you know
13:02the place
13:02where the law
13:03was given
13:04to Moses
13:06but for all
13:07their painstaking
13:08precision
13:09they couldn't
13:10resist
13:10the romantic
13:11appeal
13:11of the land
13:12they were
13:13documenting.
13:14You can see
13:15the spell
13:16being cast
13:17in the crowd
13:18pleasing photographs
13:19that accompanied
13:20the maps
13:21and surveys
13:21focusing
13:23on the awesome
13:24peaks
13:24of the Sinai Peninsula
13:26all objectivity
13:27was swept away.
13:30Science
13:30may have supplied
13:32the technology
13:32but the Bible
13:33provided the place
13:35names.
13:36They've gone for it
13:38it says Mount Sinai
13:39in the south end of the base
13:40but it is
13:43just a mountain
13:48and there's the wonderful picture
13:51of the place
13:53of assembly
13:53thought to be
13:54of the Israelites
13:55gathered
13:56to witness
13:57Moses coming down
13:58from Sinai
13:59with the Ten Commandments
14:01hot off the press
14:02as it were.
14:05What they're looking for
14:06is a kind of
14:07theatre
14:08or arena
14:09like space
14:10because they say
14:11well the Bible
14:12says there are
14:12600,000 Israelites
14:14they all need
14:15to see Moses
14:16they've got to see
14:18him coming down
14:19looking angry
14:20with the tablets
14:21of the law.
14:21It's not a bad
14:22contender
14:22this one is it?
14:23No it's fantastic
14:24look there it is
14:25actually
14:26great
14:26you know
14:27the biblical rock
14:28concept.
14:29Cecil B. DeMille
14:29would be proud.
14:38but the archaeologists
14:39who've followed
14:40in a century
14:41and a half since
14:42have had to tell
14:43a more sober story
14:47despite a lot
14:48of digging
14:48no hard evidence
14:50has yet come to light
14:51to make the exodus
14:52or the wandering
14:53in the wilderness
14:53an historical reality
14:57not a stone
14:58not a clay fragment
15:00not a scrap
15:01of papyrus
15:02or parchment
15:08to find
15:09some of the first
15:10solid
15:11archaeological evidence
15:12for the Jewish story
15:13you have to
15:14fast forward
15:15a couple of centuries
15:16from the traditional
15:17date of the Moses epic
15:18and come here
15:20to the Valley of Elah
15:21in present day Israel
15:24according to the Bible
15:26this was where
15:27a giant called Goliath
15:29was brought low
15:30by a shepherd boy
15:31called David
15:31armed only
15:32with a slingshot
15:38the valley lies
15:39on what was once
15:41an unquiet frontier
15:42between the coastal people
15:44whom the Bible calls
15:45Philistines
15:46and the hill people
15:47the Judeans
15:48the Iron Age ancestors
15:50of the Jews
15:50with their capital
15:51in Jerusalem
15:52a day's march
15:53northeast from here
15:55and commanding the valley
15:56was the fortress
15:58of Elah
16:01it was excavated
16:03by the Israeli
16:04archaeologist
16:05Yossi Garfinkel
16:06here for the first time
16:07you have a heavily
16:08fortified city
16:09some stones
16:10are up to 8 tons
16:10it's just one layer
16:12it was suddenly destroyed
16:13so it's a biblical
16:14Pompeii
16:17Yossi concluded
16:18early on
16:19that this stronghold
16:20must have belonged
16:21to the Judean hill people
16:23not to the pig-eating
16:25Philistines
16:26from the coastal plain
16:29so you found bones
16:30of goats
16:31thousands and thousands
16:33of animal bones
16:33were found in the site
16:34all together
16:35thousands
16:35thousands yes
16:36it's very common
16:37and we have
16:39sheep, goat and cattle
16:40but we have no pigs
16:41at all
16:41so the people here
16:42didn't consume pork
16:45things got more intriguing
16:47when the site
16:49was carbon dated
16:50to around 3,000 years ago
16:51a period
16:52traditionally associated
16:54with the reign
16:55of King David
16:55that shepherd boy
16:57with the deadly aim
17:02for many archaeologists
17:04today
17:04the bible
17:05is a distraction
17:06with nothing useful
17:08to say about
17:08what actually happened
17:10and when
17:13but Yossi Garfinkel
17:15takes a more nuanced view
17:17so it's not really important
17:19if David and Goliath
17:20are historical figures
17:21but they're representing
17:23a process
17:24200 years
17:25of struggling
17:26over the border
17:27this is I think
17:28the biblical tradition
17:29trying to tell us
17:30and not people taking
17:32you know
17:32the story literary
17:33you have metaphors here
17:34and about much longer
17:36and much more stronger
17:37historical processes
17:39that's the way I understand it
17:41yes
17:41the bible has an echo
17:43of some sort of reality
17:44it's a wonderful way
17:45to put it
17:48but the most intriguing
17:50finds at the fortress
17:51of Elah
17:52give us our first glimpse
17:54of a figure
17:55who looms
17:56is very large
17:57in our story
17:58the Jewish God
18:00this is really
18:02the earliest example
18:02that we have
18:03of a purification
18:04read before you enter
18:05a holy place
18:06in cult rooms
18:08complete
18:08with their own
18:09purification basins
18:11and sacred vessels
18:12Garfinkel's team
18:13discovered
18:14a little altar
18:16for sacred offerings
18:17and two model shrines
18:21or arcs
18:29tantalizingly
18:30they are empty
18:31prefiguring
18:33the empty holy of holies
18:35in the high temple
18:35the chosen dwelling place
18:37on earth
18:38for that
18:38extraordinary religious innovation
18:40the faceless
18:41formless God
18:43of Jewish monotheism
18:52that singular God
18:54was slow to emerge
18:55from the crowd
18:55of rival gods
18:57adored in the rest
18:58of the ancient world
18:59and from the abundance
19:01of fertility deities
19:03cupping their breasts
19:04found at many sites
19:06it's clear
19:06that it took centuries
19:08for the ancestors
19:09of the Jews
19:09to accept
19:10their God
19:11as the one
19:12and only God
19:13when he did emerge
19:16he would have
19:17neither face
19:18nor form
19:19but many names
19:24he was Elohim
19:26God
19:27El
19:30the Mighty One
19:32El Shaddai
19:35the Almighty
19:38Adonai
19:39Lord
19:41Elyon
19:43the Highest
19:46Avinu
19:46our Father
19:50Tsevaot
19:51God of Hosts
19:54Echye
19:55Asher Echye
19:56I am
19:57what I am
20:02These are the names
20:03of power
20:04to be uttered
20:05only in sacred places
20:06in the profane world
20:08he is known simply as
20:10Hashem
20:11the Name
20:20With no divine images
20:22or sacred statues
20:23to channel their faith
20:25the Jews of the ancient world
20:26expressed their allegiance
20:28to God
20:28with animal sacrifices
20:30before an empty
20:32holy of holies
20:33the smoke
20:34rising from the temple
20:35to the heavens
20:36with nothing
20:37in between
20:46but there would also be
20:47another channel of devotion
20:49open to the Jews
20:52the Hebrew Bible
20:54the Hebrew Bible
20:58Sefer Torah
21:00the sacred scrolls
21:02containing the first five books
21:03of the Hebrew Bible
21:04are central to Jewish worship
21:06objects of respect
21:08veneration
21:10even love
21:14a high point
21:15in any synagogue service
21:17comes when a scroll
21:18is taken from the ark
21:19to be read
21:23but before the reading
21:24takes place
21:25there is a ceremony
21:26designed to bring people
21:28and their sacred book
21:29together
21:36now there is much
21:38in this service
21:39in the reform tradition
21:40that more orthodox
21:42congregations
21:42would find
21:43well
21:44unorthodox
21:45women and men
21:47together
21:47female rabbis
21:49and readers
21:50the choir
21:51and the organ
21:52and then
21:54there is that
21:55peculiarly English touch
21:57top hats
21:58but whatever your tradition
22:01the respect
22:02paid to the Sefer Torah
22:03is common to all
22:05and every reading
22:07is preceded
22:09by a moment
22:09of pure
22:10sacred theater
22:28this is the moment
22:30when Jews
22:30I think
22:31feel
22:31most Jewish
22:32the ark opens
22:34you stand up
22:36the Torah
22:37the scrolls of the law
22:38are held up
22:39and you smile
22:40at least I always
22:41smile
22:41at the pure
22:43beauty
22:43of it all
22:44and it is an absolutely
22:46extraordinary thing
22:47this
22:48the definition
22:49of worship
22:50through the sanctification
22:52of words
22:54and it is
22:55and was those words
22:56read
22:57remembered
22:58perpetuated
22:59that would ensure
23:01the survival
23:02of Jews
23:03and Judaism
23:04through the generations
23:10the squirrels
23:11are so sacred
23:12that when you read them
23:14you must avoid
23:15touching the words
23:16directly
23:17with the finger
23:18of flesh and blood
23:19instead
23:20they are read
23:21with a silver
23:22or ivory
23:22yad
23:23as if the writing
23:24finger of God
23:25were moving
23:27through the text
23:31and these words
23:32are not meant
23:33to be read
23:34silently
23:35but publicly
23:36out loud
23:39the Hebrew word
23:40to read
23:41Kriah
23:41means as it sounds
23:43to cry out
23:45and so
23:46whatever your tradition
23:48the words
23:48of your Torah
23:49will sound
23:50out
23:51in your synagogue
23:52for all to hear
24:08the Bible
24:09started to be written down
24:11around
24:122,700 years ago
24:15what a moment
24:17in literature
24:17that was
24:18what stories
24:19were delivered
24:20to the world
24:21Adam and Eve
24:22Cain murdering
24:24his brother Abel
24:25Noah and his Ark
24:26Abraham called
24:28to sacrifice
24:29his son
24:29Jacob
24:30wrestling with the angel
24:32Joseph and his coat
24:33of many colours
24:35and that's
24:35just volume 1
24:37before Moses
24:38even makes an appearance
24:40in his basket
24:41of bulrushes
24:46and these stories
24:48from the sacred scrolls
24:50are not the museum pieces
24:51of some carefully preserved
24:53folk tradition
24:54they still matter
24:56to people
24:56in the here
24:57and now
24:58the arrival
24:59of a new scroll
25:00from the scribe
25:01is a cause
25:02for celebration
25:08embroidery artist
25:09Aviva Rahamim
25:10is a Jew
25:11living in the Israeli
25:12city of Lod
25:13but originally
25:14she's from an ancient
25:16Jewish community
25:17in Ethiopia
25:18known as
25:19Beta Israel
25:22but life for the Jews
25:23there became perilous
25:24when Ethiopia
25:25was plunged
25:27into civil war
25:28and terrible famine
25:33in 1982
25:34aged just 14
25:36Aviva
25:37and a small group
25:38of companions
25:38set out
25:39on a perilous journey
25:41on foot
25:41to the promised land
25:43of Israel
25:46her embroidery
25:48designs
25:48which draw
25:49on the imagery
25:50of the Bible
25:51also reflect
25:52her own
25:52personal
25:53exodus story
25:56call it
25:56call it
25:57the book of Aviva
26:01when I left
26:02for the road
26:02it was very difficult
26:04there were predatory animals
26:07there were robbers
26:08bad people
26:09and there wasn't anything
26:11to eat
26:11and there wasn't anything
26:12to drink
26:13it was very hot
26:18on the road
26:20on the road
26:21when people died
26:22they covered them
26:23with dirt
26:23and they covered them
26:25with leaves
26:26and cried
26:28it's painful
26:29difficult
26:30very grave
26:32when leaves behind
26:34young men
26:35children who have died
26:38and then
26:39we continued
26:40with the tears
26:41with the pain
26:43continued to walk on
26:46for me
26:47Jerusalem
26:48to the end
26:52on Shabbat
26:54we did not walk
26:55we would wait
26:56when Shabbat
26:57was out
26:57we walked
26:58at Passover
27:00we ground flour
27:01on the spot
27:02cooked it
27:02and ate
27:03we observed
27:04kosher completely
27:05if we were to make mistakes
27:07we will not reach
27:08Jerusalem
27:08land of Israel
27:13God almighty
27:14help me
27:15in spite of all
27:16the bedlam
27:17that had affected me
27:18thanks to him
27:19to God
27:20I reached Israel
27:21we kissed the ground
27:23we prayed
27:28on Pesach
27:30you have your own
27:31Haggadah
27:32really
27:32you have your own
27:33you have your own
27:34Haggadah
27:34when I read
27:37the Passover
27:37Haggadah
27:38I feel
27:39our Aliyah
27:39is the same
27:40as the journey
27:41of our ancestors
27:42who came up
27:44with Moses
27:52but for all
27:54the inspiring
27:55stories of liberation
27:56and survival
27:57against the odds
27:58as a chronicle
27:59of a people's history
28:00the Bible
28:01can often make
28:02for tragic reading
28:03God
28:04may have chosen
28:05this people
28:06but his book
28:07never soft peddles
28:08the harsh fate
28:09of puny
28:10Jewish kingdoms
28:11crushed between
28:13imperial superpowers
28:15Egypt
28:16Assyria
28:17and Babylon
28:21when it was
28:22when it was the
28:22Babylonians turn
28:23to give the Jews
28:24the latest lesson
28:26in history
28:27it came in the form
28:28of destroying Jerusalem
28:30after a year long
28:31siege
28:34the high temple
28:35said to have been built
28:36by King Solomon
28:37was torn down
28:39and the city's elite
28:41deported to Babylon
28:43the first great exile
28:45in the story
28:46of the Jews
28:55but Jewish identity
28:57did not disappear
28:58in this alien land
29:00beneath the shadow
29:01of the Ishtar gate
29:03Jewish scribes
29:04continued the collective
29:06endeavor of Bible writing
29:08and Bible editing
29:10making God's laws
29:12clearer
29:13tougher
29:14fiercer
29:18and so
29:20when the Persians
29:21defeated the Babylonians
29:23and released
29:24the captive Jews
29:25the exiles
29:26returned to Jerusalem
29:28with the Bible
29:29that bound Jews
29:30ever more closely
29:32to its rules
29:32and its commands
29:38the Jerusalem
29:40they came back to
29:41was a pathetic
29:43heap of ruins
29:44the temple
29:46was hurriedly rebuilt
29:47but it wasn't really
29:48a patch on the original
29:51and it was
29:5280 years
29:53before the city walls
29:55were finally repaired
29:56by a returned exile
29:58called Nehemiah
30:01but repairing
30:02the city fabric
30:03was just the start
30:13next
30:14those
30:15who'd been left
30:16behind in Jerusalem
30:18had to be reminded
30:19just who
30:21they were
30:21and what it was
30:22that made them Jews
30:25Torah
30:26law
30:30on the first day
30:31of the seventh month
30:32so the book of Nehemiah
30:33tells us
30:34Ezra
30:35the spiritual leader
30:37who returned from Babylon
30:38a dozen years before
30:39did something absolutely
30:41extraordinary
30:42at one of the city gates
30:44the repaired walls
30:45behind him
30:46he assembled
30:47all the Jews
30:48of Jerusalem
30:49women
30:49as well as men
30:51the Bible makes a special point
30:52of saying that
30:53as well as
30:54all those
30:55who could understand
30:56which almost certainly
30:57means slaves
30:58and servants too
30:59and there
31:00he read to them
31:01from the Torah
31:02the law
31:03which had been brought
31:04from Babylonia
31:05where it had been edited
31:06for five generations
31:08its monotheistic edge
31:10refined
31:11to a new sharpness
31:16and then
31:17with the full authority
31:19of the book
31:20behind him
31:20Ezra
31:21demanded
31:22that the Jerusalemites
31:23hold themselves
31:24aloof
31:25from their non-Jewish neighbours
31:27and put away
31:29their foreign wives
31:31and their half-foreign children
31:34too
31:37this is brutal
31:40a hardline purge
31:41that elevates
31:42religious
31:43and ethnic purity
31:45at the expense
31:45of social reality
31:47and although Ezra says
31:49this is the way
31:50it's always been
31:51for us Jews
31:52it's him
31:53who's actually
31:54gone out on a limb
31:55not the Jerusalemites
31:57for their spontaneous
31:58coexistence
31:59with local clans
32:01how do we know this?
32:03well
32:04one answer
32:05lies
32:05900 miles south
32:08in a Jewish world
32:10startlingly different
32:11from the monolithic
32:13purism
32:13of Ezra
32:28and Nehemiah
32:29at precisely
32:30the same time
32:31that Jerusalem
32:32was being purified
32:33by the Babylonian exiles
32:35here in the very
32:37Gentile world
32:38of Upper Egypt
32:39exiles
32:41were living
32:41a Jewish life
32:42of a very different kind
32:45this is Aswan
32:47where the Nile
32:48once plunged
32:49over the first cataract
32:51here
32:51on an island
32:52called Elephantini
32:54stood a fortress town
32:55guarding the frontier
32:57between Egypt
32:58and Nubia
32:59to the south
33:01since the 7th century BC
33:03it had been manned
33:04by Judean mercenaries
33:06who lived on the island
33:07along with their families
33:11a century later
33:12when the Babylonians
33:14destroyed Jerusalem
33:15and carried its elite
33:16into exile
33:17some of the ordinary people
33:19finding themselves abandoned
33:20made their way south
33:22and Exodus
33:23in reverse
33:28there was one
33:30great formative moment
33:31when the Israelites
33:32became Jews
33:33and that of course
33:34was the Exodus
33:36from Egypt
33:37and the Nile
33:38ran through that story
33:39like a silver thread
33:41that destiny
33:43had begun
33:43when Pharaoh's daughter
33:45had found the baby Moses
33:47in the river
33:48and taken him back
33:48to be brought up
33:49as a prince of Egypt
33:51at court
33:52when that prince
33:53had turned liberator
33:54his god
33:55had turned the Nile
33:56to blood
33:57in an effort
33:58to persuade Pharaoh
33:59to let
34:00the Israelites go
34:01so
34:02to return
34:03to the Nile
34:04was to repudiate
34:06that history
34:06to take away
34:07that covenant
34:08to undo themselves
34:10yet
34:11to the disgust
34:13and dismay
34:14of the prophets
34:15back
34:16they went
34:16all the same
34:22even today
34:23it's easy
34:23to imagine
34:24what life
34:25must have been like
34:26in the
34:26narrow streets
34:28and close packed
34:29mud brick houses
34:30of Elephantini
34:31where Judeans
34:33mixed with
34:34other races
34:34and creeds
34:35we know in detail
34:37about their lives
34:38thanks to
34:39a rich trove
34:41of papyrus documents
34:42found on the site
34:43at the end
34:44of the 19th century
34:46mostly
34:47their legal documents
34:49marriages
34:50divorces
34:51property disputes
34:52wills
34:53but between the lines
34:54we find out
34:55about the kind
34:56of Jews
34:57who lived here
35:02we know
35:03they honoured
35:04Moses' law
35:05or as much
35:05of it
35:06as they knew
35:07they prayed
35:08to the Jewish
35:09god
35:09but they also
35:10invoked his
35:11consort
35:12the queen
35:12of heaven
35:13some took
35:15Egyptian wives
35:16and husbands
35:16who converted
35:18to their religion
35:18and changed
35:19their names
35:20now just ask
35:22Jews
35:22in Los Angeles
35:23or St. John's
35:25Wood today
35:25if any of this
35:26sounds familiar
35:29the people
35:30who feature
35:31in the Elephantini
35:32papyri
35:32are not
35:33the grandiose
35:34patriarchs
35:35and prophets
35:36of the Bible
35:36they're ordinary
35:38everyday Judeans
35:40the documents
35:40really are
35:41the first
35:41complete portrait
35:43we have
35:43of an entire
35:44community
35:45of Jews
35:48but the Elephantini
35:50Jews did more
35:51than just build
35:52houses and lives
35:53here
35:53they also built
35:54themselves
35:55a temple
36:01according to
36:02the strip rules
36:03laid down
36:03in the Bible
36:04the high temple
36:05in Jerusalem
36:06was the only place
36:07where it was
36:08permitted to make
36:09animal sacrifices
36:10to God
36:10an essential part
36:12of the Jewish
36:13religious ritual
36:14of ancient times
36:15especially on
36:16high days
36:16and holy days
36:17like Passover
36:20Passover
36:20perhaps the Elephantini
36:22Jews didn't know
36:23about the rule
36:23or perhaps
36:24distance from
36:25Jerusalem
36:26made them
36:26indifferent to it
36:28because
36:28they built
36:29their own temple
36:30here
36:31in the heart
36:32of this alien land
36:36they boasted
36:37about its
36:39antiquity
36:39how it was
36:40older
36:40than the
36:41rebuilt
36:42Jerusalem temple
36:43with five
36:44monumental
36:45gateways
36:45a holy
36:46of holies
36:47inside
36:47with bronze
36:49hinges
36:49to the doors
36:50a cedar roof
36:51and gold
36:52and silver
36:53vessels
36:54more outrageously
36:57animals
36:58were indeed
36:59sacrificed
36:59to Elephantini
37:00along with
37:01offerings
37:01of grain
37:02and fruit
37:03there was
37:04much curling
37:05of smoke
37:06and sprinkling
37:07of blood
37:10but circumstances
37:12were about
37:13to deal
37:13the proud
37:14Elephantini Jews
37:15a cruel blow
37:16their temple
37:18stood right
37:19next to the
37:20Egyptian temple
37:20of Khnum
37:21the rams
37:22headed god
37:23who presided
37:24over the annual
37:25life-giving flood
37:27of the Nile
37:32the Egyptians
37:34held
37:35rams
37:35sacred
37:36but the Jews
37:37sacrificed
37:38them to a god
37:39they proclaimed
37:39as the one
37:40and only
37:41not
37:42tactful
37:45the priests
37:47of Khnum
37:47bribed
37:48the commander
37:49of the local
37:49Persian garrison
37:50to attack
37:51and destroy
37:53the Jewish
37:53temple
37:56a catastrophe
37:57for the Jews
37:58of Elephantini
38:02but for the temple
38:03authorities
38:04in Jerusalem
38:05it was an opportunity
38:07when they were asked
38:08to support a petition
38:09to rebuild the temple
38:14there was a lot
38:15of stonewalling
38:16at first
38:16but eventually
38:16permission
38:17was granted
38:18but
38:19on the strict
38:20condition
38:21that only
38:22cereal
38:23and fruit
38:24offerings
38:24were going
38:24to be made
38:25at Elephantini
38:26in the future
38:27no more animal
38:29sacrifices
38:30no more blood
38:31no more smoke
38:32the Elephantini Jews
38:34had been put
38:35firmly in their place
38:37they couldn't really
38:38describe their place
38:39as a temple
38:40anymore
38:40it was merely
38:42a sanctuary
38:43hard Jerusalem
38:45rules
38:45had definitely
38:46won
38:51by then
38:52a new power
38:53was emerging
38:54in the region
38:55the Greeks
38:56and the Jews
38:57were faced
38:58with a new
38:58kind of threat
38:59annihilation
39:01through
39:02assimilation
39:06in the 4th century BC
39:08led by a warrior king
39:10called Alexander
39:11the Greeks
39:12took over
39:13the ancient world
39:14in the wake
39:15of the warriors
39:16came the philosophers
39:18poets
39:19architects
39:20and artists
39:21who made their own
39:22cultural conquests
39:24the hard military power
39:27of Assyria
39:27or Babylon
39:28had sought to
39:29destroy Jewish identity
39:31through invasion
39:32and deportation
39:33the soft power
39:36of Hellenism
39:37threatened to
39:38submerge it
39:39beneath its
39:40welcoming waters
39:52I was brought up
39:54to believe
39:55that Hellenism
39:56and Judaism
39:57was one of the
39:58great dividing paths
39:59in the history
40:00of culture
40:01you couldn't be
40:02Jewish
40:03and
40:04Greekish
40:07which was it
40:08going to be
40:09philosophy
40:10or the Psalms
40:11the nude
40:12or the word
40:13God
40:13as a formless
40:14invisible being
40:15or God
40:16as the ideal
40:17vision
40:18of the human body
40:19beauty
40:20or law
40:21so what do we
40:22make of this
40:26palace
40:26this spectacular palace
40:2840 miles east
40:29of Jerusalem
40:30was built
40:30in the 2nd century BC
40:32for a rich
40:33Jewish family
40:34the Tobias
40:35who made a pile
40:37collecting taxes
40:38for the Greek government
40:39in Egypt
40:40but it was still
40:41kosher enough
40:42to marry into the family
40:43of the high priest
40:46their cash
40:47bought them
40:48an authentic
40:50Jewish
40:50classical
40:51masterpiece
40:52a combination
40:53of grace
40:54and power
41:01like the Tobias
41:03many Jews
41:03were seduced
41:04by Hellenism
41:05some
41:06even went through
41:07the painful
41:08operation
41:09of reverse
41:10circumcision
41:11an eye-watering
41:12procedure
41:13involving weights
41:14and pulleys
41:15so that they
41:16could appear
41:16without embarrassment
41:18alongside the body
41:19worshipping Greeks
41:20in the gymnasium
41:24more significantly
41:25the Hebrew Bible
41:27was translated
41:28into Greek
41:29an important bridge
41:30that connected
41:31Judaism
41:31to the wider world
41:36but although
41:37individual Jews
41:39could cross that bridge
41:40and many did
41:41Jewish identity
41:42itself
41:43could not
41:44if it was to
41:45remain distinctly
41:46Jewish
41:49you could build
41:50yourself an elegant
41:51palace
41:51in the latest
41:52Greek fashion
41:53you could speak
41:54Greek
41:54you could dress
41:55like a Greek
41:56you could read
41:57the Bible
41:57translated into
41:58Greek
41:59you could even
41:59tell yourself
42:00that Plato
42:01and the Greek
42:02philosophers
42:02must have read
42:04Moses the law
42:05giver
42:05but in the end
42:07an absolute
42:08fusion of the
42:09two cultures
42:09was actually
42:10impossible
42:11Zeus was not
42:13a beefier version
42:14of the Jewish
42:15God
42:15and the favourite
42:16residence of that
42:18God was not
42:19a limestone palace
42:21but a house of words
42:27it was loyalty to this
42:29god of words
42:31that in the end
42:32prevented Jewish
42:33identity from being
42:34swallowed whole
42:35by cosmopolitan
42:37Greekness
42:38like the orthodox
42:39faithful of today
42:41the lure of
42:42assimilation
42:42provoked
42:43stubborn resistance
42:47and when a Greek
42:49ruler desecrated
42:50the high temple
42:51itself
42:51and banned
42:52circumcision
42:53resistance
42:54turned into
42:55open rebellion
42:58the Jews
42:59the Jews
42:59led by the
43:00Maccabees
43:00rose in revolt
43:01and established
43:03an independent
43:04Jewish state
43:05ruled by
43:05priest kings
43:06that lasted
43:07for almost a
43:08century
43:11the Hasmoneans
43:12were succeeded
43:13by the decidedly
43:15unpriestly
43:16Herod the Great
43:17he owed his throne
43:18to the Romans
43:19who'd taken over
43:20from the Greeks
43:21as regional superpower
43:22and he built big
43:24and lavishly
43:26in the Roman style
43:27ports
43:28palaces
43:29and aqueducts
43:30but he didn't
43:32neglect the high
43:33temple either
43:34massively extending
43:36its lofty perch
43:38it was this
43:40immense pile
43:41with its conveyor belt
43:42of continual sacrifice
43:44that in the
43:45final century BC
43:47appeared to express
43:48most clearly
43:49what Judaism
43:50was all about
43:51not however
43:53for everyone
44:05for some
44:06pious Jews
44:07the smoke
44:08of temple sacrifice
44:10was in danger
44:11of obscuring
44:12the words
44:12of Moses' law
44:14and so they
44:15sought out places
44:16where they could
44:17bury themselves
44:17in sacred texts
44:19and await
44:20the coming
44:21of the Messiah
44:22and what better
44:23place to wait
44:24than here
44:24on an inhospitable
44:26fringe of land
44:27on the shores
44:28of the Dead Sea
44:29far from the
44:30swaggering aristocracy
44:32of the temple
44:39this is Qumran
44:40where that
44:42astounding
44:42collection of documents
44:43the Dead Sea Scrolls
44:45was found
44:46around the same time
44:48as the birth
44:48and death
44:49of a Jew
44:49known as
44:50Jesus of Nazareth
44:51this was the place
44:52where the sacred texts
44:54of the Jews
44:55were poured over
44:56by a group
44:57of pious mystics
44:58known as
44:59the Yachad
45:02the community
45:03of together
45:08what a place
45:09for a sacred library
45:11an extraordinary
45:12collection of 850
45:14separate manuscripts
45:15not just the Bible
45:17there were the wild
45:18and wacky
45:19mystical books
45:21around its fringe
45:22so-called wisdom books
45:24books which revisited
45:25the creation
45:26in startlingly
45:28unorthodox ways
45:29which really
45:30explode the idea
45:31of what being Jewish
45:32what the Jewish
45:33sacred texts were
45:34because these
45:35were incredibly
45:36imaginative
45:38angels and demons
45:39a demon wrestling
45:41with the creation
45:42of God
45:42stalked through
45:44the scrolls
45:45among the book
45:46of Jubilees
45:47the book of Enoch
45:48and you know
45:49I always think
45:50when I stand here
45:51it's not just
45:52the rocks
45:52of the caves
45:53not just the Dead Sea
45:55but this immense
45:56dome of the sky
45:58seen by day
45:59and night
46:00they were great
46:01sky watchers
46:02astronomers
46:04astrologers
46:05obsessed with
46:06the run
46:06of time
46:07it was in
46:08this huge vault
46:09hung with stars
46:10or this enormous
46:11blue expanse
46:12that they saw
46:13their visions
46:14they could see
46:15the demons
46:16and the angels
46:17walk through it
46:17they could see
46:18the battles
46:18between the sons
46:19of darkness
46:20and the sons
46:21of light
46:21they could see
46:22the grey upheavals
46:24of the cosmic
46:24acts of creation
46:26and destruction
46:27this was as close
46:29as you could get
46:30to the rough
46:31hand of God
46:40in the cool laboratories
46:42of the Dead Sea Squirrels project
46:44in Jerusalem
46:45it's possible
46:46to come face to face
46:48with the holy books
46:49that so grip the Yachad
46:50thanks to the work
46:51of a team
46:52of specialists
46:53who preserve
46:53record and publish
46:55these extraordinary documents
47:03yes so what you see
47:05in front of you
47:06is a plate
47:07one of 1260
47:10in this case
47:11it's of parchment
47:1280% of the
47:14of the scrolls
47:16are written on parchment
47:1620% are written on papyrus
47:18and this is a sample
47:20of one of the copies
47:22of the community rule
47:25and the portion
47:27in the copy
47:27that talks about
47:28the prohibition
47:29of doing
47:30any kind of work
47:31on the Sabbath
47:32except of course
47:34what is allowed
47:34or what is demanded
47:35of one
47:36okay
47:37and you see
47:38we're saving
47:38every little
47:40scrap
47:41every little scrap
47:42of parchment
47:44is saved
47:44it's so striking
47:46how clear
47:47I mean
47:47the Hebrew there
47:49is the Hebrew
47:49I learned
47:50from my
47:50Bar Mitzvah
47:51and El Cheda
47:52it's so extraordinary
47:54to actually be able
47:56to read
47:56well this is what
47:57always excites us
47:58that we're talking
47:59about 2000 years old
48:00scrolls
48:01and any 6th grader
48:03that learns to read
48:05can come and read this
48:07and I think
48:08there's nothing more
48:08moving than being
48:09able to read
48:10your Bible
48:11from 2000 years old
48:13scrolls
48:16among the hundreds
48:17of manuscripts
48:18one in particular
48:19captures the
48:20apocalyptic expectations
48:22that gripped
48:23the pious Jews
48:24of Qumran
48:25it's known
48:26as the war scroll
48:29the war scroll
48:30is an extraordinary
48:31high pitched
48:34slightly
48:34kind of
48:36feverishly
48:37poetic document
48:38which is about
48:40this impending
48:41battle
48:41between the
48:42sons of light
48:43and the sons
48:43of darkness
48:44it wouldn't be
48:45any good
48:46as a military manual
48:47because a lot
48:48of the war scroll
48:48is actually
48:49about writing
48:50which is inscribed
48:51on the weapons
48:52and God
48:54will fight
48:55because of the
48:56covenant
48:56of course
48:56on behalf
48:57of the sons
48:58of light
48:58yeah
48:59they saw themselves
49:00as the sons
49:01of light
49:02in a world
49:03where battle
49:04was going on
49:05and maybe
49:05there was a very
49:06very big battle
49:07about to happen
49:12the big battle
49:13anticipated
49:15with such
49:16poetic excitement
49:17in the war scroll
49:18became grim
49:19bloody reality
49:21in 66 AD
49:22an immense
49:25rebellion
49:26against Roman rule
49:27broke out
49:27in Galilee
49:28Samaria
49:29and Judea
49:30a maelstrom
49:32of violence
49:32that required
49:33the weight
49:33of three legions
49:35under the command
49:36of the general
49:37Vespasian
49:37and his son
49:38Titus
49:39to crush it
49:42our only written
49:43source
49:44for what then
49:45unfolded
49:45comes from the
49:47hand of someone
49:47whose life
49:48was torn
49:49between the
49:50classical
49:50and the Jewish
49:51world
49:52he even had
49:54two names
49:54born into a
49:56priestly family
49:57as Yosef
49:58Barmatityahu
49:59he would die
50:00in Rome
50:00as Flavius
50:02Josephus
50:03the in-house
50:04historian
50:04of the Emperor
50:05Vespasian
50:06as a boy
50:16I was taught
50:17to look down
50:18on Josephus
50:18as turncoat
50:19and traitor
50:20having taken up
50:22arms against Rome
50:23at the siege
50:24of Iotapata
50:25he chose to
50:26surrender
50:26rather than
50:27to kill himself
50:28as his comrades
50:29did
50:31worse still
50:32he then
50:33joined
50:34Vespasian's
50:35entourage
50:35as local
50:37advisor
50:37cheerleader
50:38and pet Jew
50:41but
50:42Josephus'
50:43history
50:43the Jewish
50:44war
50:44is all
50:45we have to
50:46go on
50:46for an account
50:47of what
50:47happened
50:48when the
50:48Roman
50:49legions
50:49moved
50:50on to
50:50Jerusalem
50:51to administer
50:52the coup
50:53de grace
50:53Josephus'
50:55was there
50:55outside the
50:56city walls
50:57while inside
50:58fanatical
50:59zealots
51:00instigated
51:01a reign
51:01of terror
51:02to deter
51:03any talk
51:04of surrender
51:04and while
51:05the population
51:06who included
51:07Josephus'
51:08own mother
51:09very slowly
51:10and very
51:11painfully
51:12starved
51:13to death
51:15Josephus'
51:16says
51:16that
51:16ever
51:17since
51:17the
51:18siege
51:18at
51:18Yotapata
51:19and ever
51:19since
51:19he
51:19came
51:20to
51:20Jerusalem
51:21with the
51:21Roman
51:21army
51:22his
51:22only
51:23concern
51:24was to
51:24spare
51:25his
51:25own
51:25people
51:25unnecessary
51:26cruelty
51:27suffering
51:28and death
51:29he'd long
51:30ago
51:30come to
51:31the
51:31conclusion
51:32he says
51:32that
51:33God
51:33had
51:33chosen
51:34the
51:34Romans
51:34as
51:35his
51:35instrument
51:36for
51:36punishment
51:37just
51:37as
51:37he'd
51:38chosen
51:38the
51:39Babylonians
51:39generations
51:40before
51:41and
51:42now
51:43the
51:43Jews
51:43were
51:43facing
51:44impossible
51:44odds
51:45hopelessly
51:46outnumbered
51:46facing
51:47the
51:47strongest
51:48imperial
51:49army
51:49in the
51:49world
51:50and
51:50they
51:51had
51:51turned
51:52on
51:52each
51:52other
51:52like
51:53wild
51:53beasts
51:54what
51:54was
51:55the
51:55point
51:55of
51:56going
51:56on
51:56and
51:58you
51:58think
51:58oh
51:59sure
51:59you're
52:00just
52:00trying
52:01to
52:01save
52:01your
52:01skin
52:02and
52:02save
52:03your
52:03reputation
52:04for
52:04posterity
52:05from
52:05your
52:05cushy
52:06billet
52:06in
52:07the
52:07emperor
52:07Vespasian's
52:08apartments
52:13the
52:14spirit
52:14of
52:15the
52:15defenders
52:15finally
52:16crumbled
52:17the
52:18city
52:18walls
52:18were
52:19breached
52:19and
52:19Josephus
52:20was
52:20there
52:20to
52:21witness
52:21the
52:22greatest
52:23disaster
52:23to
52:24befall
52:24the
52:24Jewish
52:24people
52:25since
52:26the
52:26Babylonian
52:27invasion
52:27more
52:27than
52:28650
52:28years
52:29before
52:32the
52:33temple
52:33established
52:34as
52:35the
52:35exclusive
52:36focus
52:36of
52:36Jewish
52:37prayer
52:37and
52:37piety
52:38went
52:38up
52:38in
52:39smoke
52:39and
52:40flames
52:40the
52:42Roman
52:42legionnaires
52:43prized
52:44the
52:44massive
52:45masonry
52:45blocks
52:45from
52:46the
52:46top
52:46of
52:46the
52:46temple
52:47mount
52:47and
52:48sent
52:48them
52:48crashing
52:49onto
52:49the
52:50fine
52:50limestone
52:51pavement
52:52below
53:05the
53:06destruction
53:07of
53:07Jerusalem
53:07was
53:08the
53:08making
53:09of
53:10Vespasian's
53:10family
53:11the
53:11Flavians
53:13Vespasian
53:14was declared
53:14emperor
53:15and Jewish
53:16loot
53:16and Jewish
53:17slaves
53:18provided the
53:19cash and the
53:19muscle for the
53:20building of the
53:21Colosseum
53:22a massive bribe
53:24to buy the
53:25allegiance of
53:25Rome's
53:26bread and circus
53:27mob
53:32on the
53:33arch
53:33dedicated to
53:35Vespasian's son
53:36and co-general
53:37Titus
53:38you can see
53:39the triumphant
53:40Romans making off
53:41with the loot
53:42from the temple
53:42including
53:43the giant
53:44menorah
53:48and among the loot
53:49was Josephus
53:51himself
53:51carried to Rome
53:53and installed
53:54in the Flavian
53:55family compound
53:58and
53:59but no one
53:59in Rome
53:59thanked him
54:00for doing
54:01the right
54:02thing
54:02the kind
54:03of people
54:04you'd expect
54:05him to hang
54:05out with
54:06historians
54:07philosophers
54:08playwrights
54:09and politicians
54:10all
54:10despise
54:12the Jews
54:12they
54:13didn't mind
54:14saying so
54:17at some point
54:19Josephus
54:19had had enough
54:20of all his
54:21ignorance
54:21and gloating
54:22about 20 years
54:24after he wrote
54:25the Jewish Wars
54:26he took up
54:26his pen again
54:27this time
54:28to explain
54:29with patient
54:30dignity
54:31and a note
54:31of firm defiance
54:33and over
54:33considerable length
54:35just what
54:35Judaism was
54:37and what it did
54:38it's the first
54:39serious attempt
54:40by a Jew
54:41to make
54:42a skeptical
54:43non-Jewish world
54:45understand that
54:46Judaism
54:46is not
54:47as the Romans
54:48like to sneer
54:49a mere
54:50superstitio
54:52a superstition
54:53but a true
54:54religio
54:55an authentic
54:56religion
55:02and so
55:03Josephus
55:04like Sigmund Freud
55:06many centuries
55:07later
55:07turned to the
55:08lawgiver
55:09Moses
55:10to be Jewish
55:11he explains
55:12is simply
55:13to observe
55:14the laws
55:14that Moses
55:15brought down
55:16from Sinai
55:16laws that
55:17teach
55:18not impiety
55:20but enemies
55:20to injustice
55:22and have a care
55:24of righteousness
55:28these laws
55:30require
55:30honour
55:31to parents
55:32they abhor
55:33killing
55:34they require
55:35charity
55:36and succour
55:37for the sick
55:37and old
55:40at last
55:42this compromised
55:43sycophantic
55:45creepily
55:46self-exonerating
55:47historian
55:48stands tall
55:49brimful
55:51with pride
55:51in his Judaism
55:52and says
55:54in a phrase
55:54I find genuinely
55:55moving
55:55we have become
55:57the teachers
55:58of men
55:59in the greatest
56:00of things
56:07given the hammer blows
56:09of the Roman legions
56:10and coming as they did
56:12after century upon century
56:14of blows
56:14from Egyptians
56:15Syrians
56:16and Babylonians
56:17there would have been
56:18scant reason
56:19to suppose
56:20that the Jews
56:21would survive
56:22alive as a people
56:23and yet
56:24two thousand years later
56:26the Jews
56:27are still here
56:28how?
56:32well
56:33one answer
56:34can be found
56:35back at the arch
56:36of Titus
56:37not something
56:38that's here
56:39but something
56:40that's not
56:43when Josephus describes
56:45the procession
56:46of loot
56:47and prisoners
56:48paraded through
56:49the streets
56:50of Rome
56:50he says
56:51and last
56:52of all
56:53of the spoils
56:54was carried
56:54the laws
56:55of the Jews
56:56but
56:57where are the laws
56:59where are
57:00the Torah scrolls
57:03conspicuously
57:04tellingly
57:05they are
57:06absent
57:10what were
57:11scrolls of law
57:12anyway
57:12just so many
57:13words
57:13on parchment
57:14not really worth
57:15the time
57:16of a sculptor
57:17or the cost
57:18of the marble
57:18but words
57:20copied
57:21memorised
57:22internalised
57:23made unforgettable
57:24will beat
57:25swords
57:25any time
57:26you can't
57:27hold
57:28words
57:29captive
57:29the Roman Empire
57:31has come
57:32and gone
57:33but go into
57:34a synagogue
57:34any Saturday
57:36and you'll still
57:37hear those
57:38words
57:52in September
57:531913
57:54Dr. Siegmund Freud
57:57the godless Jew
57:58was in Rome
57:59and he sent
58:00a postcard
58:01of the arch
58:01of Titus
58:02to a friend
58:03on it
58:05he wrote
58:06der Juder
58:07überstetzt
58:08the Jew
58:11survives it
58:12and he
58:42You