00:00The Mets enter this offseason knowing they need more starting pitching.
00:03The rotation finished 23rd in the majors in ERA, 22nd in innings pitch.
00:07So, naturally, much of the conversation is centered around the biggest name available, Tarek Skubal.
00:13But while David Stern searches for another front-line starter, there's another question the Mets have to answer.
00:19What if the ace they're already looking for is actually already here?
00:34So, Nolan McClain gave the Mets a glimpse of what he could become in 2025.
00:38Eight starts with a 2.06 ERA, 57 strikeouts, and 48 innings.
00:43But a great eight-game introduction is one thing.
00:46Doing it over a full Major League season is something else.
00:49In 2026, McClain made 31 starts, threw 179 in two-thirds innings, struck out 194 batters,
00:56and finished with a 3.16 ERA and 1.17 whip.
01:01He led the Mets in both innings and strikeouts.
01:04And that workload is something to note, because McClain is still young in the game when it comes to doing
01:09this full-time.
01:10At Oklahoma State, he was a two-way player where he earned the nickname Cowboy Otani.
01:15He didn't become a full-time pitcher until his second professional season.
01:19Yet, by the end of 2026, he was the most dependable starter in the Mets rotation.
01:24Part of what makes McClain so intriguing isn't one dominant pitch, it's how many different ways he can attack you.
01:31Baseball savant tracks seven different pitches from McClain in 2026.
01:35A sinker around 95 miles per hour, a four-seam fastball around 96 to go along with a curveball,
01:41cutter, change-up, sweeper, and a slider.
01:44And that depth creates different problems for a hitter every time through the order.
01:48But, to understand why those pitches work together, I wanted to talk to someone who studies pitching for a living.
01:55Nick Pollock is the founder of PitcherList, one of the most respected voices in pitching analysis.
02:00Nick, gotta ask you this.
02:01When you look at Nolan McClain's arsenal, what makes him so difficult for hitters to solve,
02:05and how much of that comes from the way his pitches play off of each other?
02:09Yeah, so Nolan McClain's a very interesting one.
02:11His right-handed approach is varied.
02:14He has sinkers, four-seamers, curveballs, sweepers, cutters, change-ups.
02:18He even has a slider in there, which is actually different than the other ones as well.
02:21And he has a ton of movement.
02:23That is the real skill of Nolan McClain.
02:27It's just all of his things just go in opposite directions.
02:30Now, the command of it is a little in question, but he's so good at jamming his sinker inside to
02:35right-handers.
02:36He has this huge, hard sweeper that he throws away to right-handers as well.
02:40And then against lefties, I love the fact that he added a cutter.
02:43I really leaned into that a bit more this year.
02:46So he's really hard to hit.
02:47But here's part of McClain's season that may tell us even more about his future.
02:52One of the pitches most associated with him stopped working the way that he had wanted.
02:56His sweeper had been his signature breaking ball.
02:59But as the 2026 season progressed, McClain said he wasn't getting the same shape.
03:04After the All-Star break, he began throwing it far less frequently.
03:08So he made some adjustments.
03:09In June, McClain introduced a harder slider.
03:13A different shape, less horizontal movement, and more velocity than his sweeper.
03:17And his season, it didn't fall apart as a new pitch worked out pretty well for him.
03:22After the All-Star break, McClain posted a 2.61 ERA across 12 starts.
03:27That may be more important than any one pitch because great stuff can get you to the major leagues.
03:33But the ability to adjust when that stuff isn't behaving the way you expect can help keep you there.
03:38So, Nick, McClain had to adjust during the season when his sweeper wasn't giving him the same results.
03:44What did you see in the way that he adapted?
03:47And does that give you more confidence that what he did as a rookie is sustainable?
03:52Sure.
03:53So, Noel McClain, his sweeper is so interesting because it should be getting all the whiffs that you see from
04:00any other major sweeper like this.
04:03But he doesn't locate it as well as others.
04:06He doesn't get it totally away from batters.
04:08He does get a fair number of called strikes.
04:09A lot of front hip with that.
04:11And what it really meant was that Noel McClain had to lean on his bread and butter, which is really
04:15just sinker, sinker, sinker.
04:16He did throw a fair number of four-seamers as well.
04:19But I'm not actually a big fan of that four-seamer.
04:22His lower arm angle means that he gets a ton of horizontal break on that sinker.
04:28While the four-seamer rise that makes it look like it's a rising fastball missing above the bat, it's not
04:33very good on this pitch.
04:35It's actually below average.
04:36So, the best way that Noel McClain gets his outs is when he's mixing these two effectively so that instead
04:41of missing the bat, he's getting pop-ups instead.
04:44McClain's rookie season was good enough to put his name into a much different conversation.
04:48He became the first rookie pitcher in Major League history to win a gold glove.
04:52But there's a difference between being a very good front-of-the-rotation starter and being an ace.
04:59McClain's 3.16 ERA was impressive, no doubt.
05:02His 3.59 fielding independent pitching and 3.63 expected ERA also suggests there may still be another level for
05:11him to reach.
05:12And that's really the question.
05:14When you project McClain going forward, do you see the arsenal of a good Major League starter?
05:19Or does he have the stuff in command to eventually pitch at the front of a rotation?
05:25Absolutely. It's interesting. He's in this little middle ground, right?
05:29A little bit of purgatory where he can get innings and the Mets are going to rely on him a
05:34ton for them because he does get outs on that sinker and four-seamer.
05:38However, to take the next step, to really be that front-of-the-line starter that is consistent throughout the
05:44year, you have to overwhelm.
05:46You cannot allow 9%, 10% walks. Those are the marks of young arms.
05:54The aces, you know, think of Zach Wheeler, for example. 5% walk rate, 6% walk rate at most.
05:59And that means that you are limiting guys on base with free passes and with no McClain already so hard
06:04to hit.
06:06Then you add in the lower walk rate. All of a sudden, there are even fewer men on base.
06:10That means more opportunities for strikeouts. And then he becomes that true ace.
06:14Now, none of this means the Mets should stop looking for front-line pitching because they shouldn't.
06:20The rotation still needs help. And if they can add a pitcher like Tyra Scoble, McClain's emergence only makes that
06:26possibility more interesting.
06:28But a year ago, the question was whether Nolan McClain could turn an exciting 8-start debut into something sustainable.
06:35Then he answered that question as he gave the Mets 31 starts, nearly 180 innings, and almost 200 strikeouts.
06:41When his signature pitch stopped working the same way, he found another way to get batters out.
06:47So, maybe the Mets' biggest question this winter isn't simply, where do we find an ace?
06:52It's how much they can count on the one they may already be developing.
06:56Because Nolan McClain has proven that he can be a good Major League starter.
07:00Now, 2027 may tell us whether he can become something more.
07:06We'll see you next time.
07:06Bye.
07:06Bye.
07:14Bye.
07:16Bye.
07:16Bye.
Comments