- 4 minutes ago
Jeremy White and Joe DiBiase spend some time discussing whether Josh Allen’s interceptions actually hurt the Bills ability to win games that badly. They cite some interesting numbers from Chris Trapasso who did some digging and found that Allen’s picks don’t necessarily hurt the team that badly in the situations they’ve been thrown in. Then they guys extrapolate from there and discuss why they have NO concerns about Allen’s interceptions moving forward.
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00We did some interceptions stats from Chris Trapasso that he's posted a piece of Buffalo Rumblings.
00:04He tagged me because I think he knew I would love what I'm reading here about Josh Allen interceptions.
00:09Good morning, Jeremy and Joe, Owen Parker, and Colin Ritchie both here as well, hanging out.
00:15We've got a watch party tonight at 1812 Tavern for Sabres and Caps, so come out.
00:20Come on out.
00:22Great spot to watch a game.
00:23Yeah.
00:23By the way, the Bills, we've maybe referenced it even a couple times this week,
00:26because the Bills had been the number one offense in football by EPA per play and other stuff.
00:31They are no longer number one, but they're number three.
00:34You know the two that are above them?
00:36I would say it's Cincinnati.
00:37Yep.
00:39And San Francisco?
00:40Yep.
00:41Okay.
00:41Those are the two.
00:42The top five are all pretty close together.
00:44It's Niners, Bengals, Bills, Jags, and Chiefs.
00:49Defense wins championships?
00:51Is Minnesota out here as, I guess, Jacksonville maybe too?
00:56Who's carrying the flag for defense wins championships in the 2026 National Football League?
01:00Wow, it's the Vikings.
01:01Anybody else?
01:02The Jags win it.
01:03Seattle did it last year, but they're the offensive player of the year on the team.
01:08You know?
01:09That is true.
01:10It's worth mentioning.
01:12This year, it looks like it is a fireworks show to the finish, but Minnesota's there.
01:18They are, you know, really back-to-back Super Bowl champions will get a lot of credit for
01:24winning it with defense, even though their offenses, especially near the end, were fantastic.
01:32Like, Jalen Hurts in the Super Bowl against Kansas City was unstoppable.
01:36They were just chucking bombs to Brown and Smith, weren't they?
01:40In that Super Bowl.
01:41So, like, yeah, their defense played well too, but...
01:44They had a pick six.
01:45These are not the 2000 Ravens that have been winning it, or the 2015 Broncos.
01:49Like, there's a difference, I think, between you have a great defense, and you won the Super
01:55Bowl because of it, and, well, you had a great defense, you were not good on offense, and
01:59you won the Super Bowl.
02:00Because that has not been Philadelphia, or that was not Seattle either.
02:03And I would say that's not Jacksonville.
02:06Jacksonville, let's see how they do it.
02:07If they win a Super Bowl 10-3, then maybe we'll make the story about, oh, defense wins championships,
02:13look at the Jags, they traded for Jordan Phillips, or, uh, not Jordan Phillips, Jordan Davis,
02:18and they won it.
02:20But, isn't it more likely the Jags would win the Super Bowl scoring like 31 points?
02:24Oh, for sure.
02:25Yeah.
02:26I mean, the Jags, they have a loss this year to the Texans, and it was a shootout back
02:30and forth, right?
02:31This is an international game.
02:32Right.
02:32So, I mean, it's tough to play defense in today's NFL.
02:35You've got a lot of great offenses.
02:38But if the Vikings won the Super Bowl, I would further, I would more believe they won it scoring
02:42like 17.
02:44But even so, right now, they went out and needed a quarterback change because they felt
02:47they had a fully built offense that wasn't being maximized because the quarterback play
02:52was so bad.
02:53Correct.
02:53So, if the Vikings go ahead and win the Super Bowl, I would imagine the stats would say,
02:57since acquiring Cousins, they have the ninth best offense in football.
03:00Yeah.
03:01Like, Seattle last year in the playoffs, their three-point totals in their three playoff games
03:05were 41-31-29.
03:10So, how well did they need their defense to really play?
03:13I mean, you only have to win three games.
03:15How about that?
03:15Like, that's what Bills fans should be focusing on, right?
03:18Get the one seed and win three games.
03:20Right.
03:21Three games.
03:22Which they have not done yet.
03:23No, that's right.
03:24So, Chris Trapasso, Buffalo Rumblings, he posted this on his Twitter account and at
03:29Buffalo Rumblings, about Josh Allen's interceptions.
03:32How damaging have Allen's interceptions been?
03:35And it's not lost on me, Joe, that right after, or sorry, right before I saw this from
03:40Chris, I had just watched somebody else break down why Josh Allen's rushing value is higher
03:46than people think it is.
03:47It's more than just the one-yard touchdowns.
03:49It feels like the NFL is constantly arguing about Allen and whether or not he's propped up
03:55by bogus one-yard touchdown vulturing, you know, he's stealing touchdowns and that's
04:00elevating his numbers, blah, blah, blah.
04:03And Allen doesn't get the passing numbers of the top quarterbacks.
04:06And that's true for multiple years, right?
04:09Sure.
04:10There's less time he was at the top of the league in passing or near the top in passing
04:14or passing touchdowns.
04:17He's not.
04:17You want me to check, like, where he's ranked each year?
04:19I wonder if he's even been in the top 10 recently.
04:23In MVP season, he had 26 passing touchdowns.
04:26So there's going to be a traditional argument about quarterbacks and value.
04:31And here Burrow's about to throw for 50, right?
04:33He's on pace for 50.
04:34And if he gets to 50 touchdowns and Allen finishes the year with 28, but 20 rushing touchdowns,
04:41I feel like there is a segment of football fandom that wants the quarterback that didn't
04:47just shark one-yard touchdowns to win the MVP.
04:51Now, that said, Burrow leads the league in touchdown passes of less than five yards.
04:55Right.
04:56And Stafford last year, I think, had eight one-yard touchdown passes.
05:01So if you want to pick it apart, you can.
05:03Anyway, to get to this interception point, his rushing value is underestimated, even though
05:10the one-yard touchdown thing is used against him.
05:12And what Chris Trapasso did on the interceptions, he found that since 2020, Josh Allen's lost
05:19an average of 3.7 expected points added on interceptions.
05:25EPA.
05:25Like, how much is an interception costing you on EPA per play?
05:28And what he found is that Allen's number there was the third lowest, right, to just Bo
05:35Nix and Caleb Williams.
05:36But then this one is the one I like from this season, that Allen has lost, again, the third
05:43lowest on EPA per play on interceptions this year, too.
05:46And what he dug into was that in the last six seasons, Allen throwing interceptions, 41%
05:53of his interceptions since the start of 2020 are either third and 10 or more, fourth down,
06:02or throws of 20 yards or more down the field, nearly half of his interceptions meet those
06:09criteria.
06:10Yeah.
06:10And that makes total sense, right?
06:12Like, and I mean, if you wanted to dig further in, what percentage would also be batted off
06:17a receiver's hand where you're not even mad at him?
06:19Sure.
06:20But like the Brandon Cooks interception in the playoffs in Denver, that's an interception.
06:24That's obviously not on him.
06:26There have been a couple this year that go off a hand.
06:30And as we've watched this team get better and better, and the Joe Brady version of them
06:34and what they want to be, there's, I think, been a good segment of the fan base, I'm very
06:39much in this camp, that has wanted them to kind of break offensive football.
06:44And one of the ways to do that is to realize that your quarterback's interceptions are not
06:48that damaging, and they really never have been.
06:50And if you watch the Bills, you just know that.
06:54Right?
06:54All the numbers, oh, he leads the league in interceptions.
06:56Like, yeah, but it doesn't really even matter.
06:58It's never really mattered.
07:00Sure, oh, wow, he threw four in a game to the Jets, and they won by a point.
07:03Or there were a couple against the Chargers, I don't know, the five turnover game against
07:06the Chargers.
07:07Even the Denver game.
07:08The Denver game, he had four turnovers himself.
07:10And if you watch the Denver game, you'd say, yeah, there's a couple weird plays in there,
07:14but still, he played pretty well.
07:16He did fine.
07:18He's the reason they're in it.
07:20So, I find it interesting.
07:22You can boil it down in numbers if you want to.
07:24Sure, you don't want to throw interceptions, but here your quarterback is, when he's throwing
07:29them, hurting you almost as little as possible.
07:33They are not a damaging play.
07:35Right.
07:35And we're about to get to December and January, and if we're playing playoff games, if the
07:41Bills are playing playoff games in December, and it's against Jacksonville or Kansas City
07:46or Cincinnati, I'm thinking about punts as interceptions.
07:51You can't afford to punt.
07:52You're going to need 38 points.
07:54You're probably going to need to break offensive football.
07:56You need a healthy Kincaid.
07:57You need a healthy DJ Moore.
07:59And you need your head coach to not worry about interceptions, which I think he's pretty
08:04good with.
08:05I think Brady does have the mindset of leaning fully into Josh.
08:09Josh is going to be Josh, and you're going to be fine.
08:12Which was why it was a little weird to me that he kind of took up against arm punts
08:16this week.
08:18Now, I don't know if he'll act on that, because Allen's still throwing them, right?
08:22As he should.
08:24Yeah, third and 20.
08:25Chuck it down the field.
08:26I don't care.
08:27In fact, I want that.
08:28The one that was third and 23 would have been against Minnesota.
08:32And that one was a little different.
08:33Field goal range, whatever.
08:34That one's different.
08:35Third and 20 from the 30 is different than third and 20 from your own 20.
08:39True, but the reality is that got returned to the 50 almost all the way back, so that
08:43ends up looking like a worse one.
08:45Right.
08:46But even so, over the course of a season, it's just not going to, it's probably not
08:52going to hurt you.
08:53No.
08:53Because if you unleash him into his fullest potential.
08:56And most returns are not that much, right?
08:58Like, same as a punt.
08:59Sometimes you get a 40-yard punt return against you.
09:02Whatever.
09:02Is that the punter's fault?
09:04And these arm punts, most of them are not being returned for 50 yards.
09:07It's, like, field position-wise, if you care about that, it actually is pretty beneficial.
09:12It's about the same result as you're going to get on the very next play when Tommy Doman
09:16comes out and he punts it 50 yards into the air.
09:19But I'm giving my receiver some chance to make a big play and turn it.
09:23So, I want him to continue to do that.
09:26I think everybody should.
09:27And the no-pick-six streak he's got going on right now, I think, is another example of
09:34where his picks come.
09:35They're down the field.
09:36That should always be a thought that that's totally fine.
09:39In the playoffs, all this is about the playoffs, right?
09:44He doesn't do it in the playoffs.
09:46No.
09:46Like, the Cooks interception, which is not his fault in any way, shape, or form, that
09:51is, some you might even think is still a catch, and if you don't think it's a catch, then it's
09:56obviously Brandon Cooks' fault that it's an interception.
10:00When is the playoff game that he has really lost them because of picks?
10:05When has that really been their detriment?
10:08The reason they haven't made it to a Super Bowl?
10:10Well, he didn't even have multi-turnover games in the playoffs until Denver.
10:16And, yes, the fumble at the end of the first half.
10:20Pretty bad.
10:20Mind-numbing.
10:21Pretty bad.
10:21That was bad.
10:23Is that the only turnover he's ever had in his playoff career where you go, that cost you?
10:30That cost you.
10:31You can point at that and say that's why you didn't win.
10:34I mean, Houston, he tried, right?
10:36But he wasn't a superstar yet, and he actually didn't even turn it over.
10:40He lateraled to Dawson Knox, and it actually wasn't a turnover.
10:43It went out of bounds.
10:44He tried to throw a jump ball to Pat DeMarco, but it actually wasn't picked.
10:47It fell to the ground.
10:48So, he might have got lucky there, but then he became great, and every time he's played
10:53in a playoff game since, turnovers, picks, have never really been their downfall.
10:59Ever.
11:00At the end of seasons.
11:03Sack avoidance is another thing.
11:04You're not seeing much in the MVP debate, but that's the stat that should be in there.
11:09Sack avoidance?
11:09Sack avoidance.
11:10He just consistently avoids sacks and extends plays and negative plays.
11:15There's all these fancy stats, right?
11:18Havoc rate or toxic plays and all these different ways to measure if your offense or defense is good.
11:24And here's Allen just eliminating havoc rate because he gets away from people.
11:29Well, you know what?
11:30Maybe you can appreciate this.
11:31One of the things that we're not doing in the MVP race this year, I guess, is we are
11:36not only caring about the quarterback doing the most with the least because that's Jordan
11:43Love, and he's nowhere near the MVP conversation right now.
11:45He leads the NFL in passing yards with the most dropped footballs in the league, no run
11:50game, one of the worst lines in football, a defense that's only decent, and they're in
11:56a playoff spot, and he leads the league in passing.
11:58And is he anywhere near winning MVP?
11:59No.
12:00It feels like it's going to be Burrow.
12:01If it keeps going the way that it's going, it feels like it will be Burrow.
12:05It's Burrow, Josh, and Purdy are really the top three.
12:08But Burrow is exactly minus 110.
12:13It's basically a coin flip by the odds to whether Burrow would win it.
12:16He also has not won it yet, which should it matter in these?
12:22Shouldn't.
12:23John Cooper?
12:23John Cooper-ish.
12:25It feels like this guy should have an MVP by now.
12:27A guy that hasn't won before, I think we'll get bonus points.
12:30He'll get a couple extra votes because this guy hasn't won it yet.
12:33Feels like he should have won one.
12:35Is that Stafford last year?
12:37I mean, Stafford against May.
12:38May had a good case, but Stafford was a little bit of, hey, he should be rewarded for this.
12:44I mean, the year that Josh won it, would Burrow have won it if he had just simply made
12:48the playoffs.
12:49He went 9-8, had 4,900 yards and 43 touchdowns with nine picks.
12:54Why did he not win?
12:55Because they missed the playoffs?
12:56Maybe.
12:56Yeah, maybe.
12:58The one-seed race is on.
13:01This week, though, not expected.
13:03A lot of movement in that department.
13:05Thanksgiving week, week 12, that's a big one.
13:08They're, yeah, next week for the Bills and Chiefs game, obviously.
13:12At some point, though, there have to be upsets.
13:15Like, I know I've heard this with some survivor pool discussion the last couple weeks, how
13:18like nobody's getting eliminated because all the favorites in the NFL have been winning.
13:22So, I hope the Bills continue that.
13:24But one reason there has been a lot of movement is nobody's really losing a game they shouldn't.
13:30Cincinnati came really close.
13:33Right?
13:33Tennessee.
13:34Tennessee in overtime.
13:35Otherwise, you haven't really had a result like that.
13:38Like, what's the biggest upset among those top four teams in the AFC?
13:41I don't know that any of them have lost a really bad game.
13:44The Bills haven't lost a really bad game.
13:45I mean, is New England a bad game?
13:47No, it's a competitive team at the time.
13:49Now they're going to go way, way down.
13:50It's going to look worse and worse.
13:51Right.
13:52But at the time, May was healthy.
13:53May was healthy.
13:54They had been struggling out of the gate, but I feel like they were still a team that
13:57was bound to turn it around if they got healthy.