- il y a 1 heure
Watch Murder on Trial, Season 2 Episode 4 on Dailymotion (2026).
Catégorie
📺
TVTranscription
00:32Marcy's firefighter husband
00:34and the other first responders
00:35could not save her
00:37They do an autopsy that's standard
00:40with a person who's relatively young
00:42who passes without a real good
00:44explanation. A growing mystery
00:46as detectives investigate a
00:47respected fire captain
00:50It's been the worst two weeks
00:52you can all imagine
00:53and a loyal daughter torn by
00:56doubts. I was just thinking
00:58there's no way my dad could have done this
01:28Fire Department
01:29Fire Department
01:36She's coming to see you right now
01:38She's never had one
01:40I have her on the floor right now
01:42on her side
01:44She's not breathing right now
01:47Upstairs the wife of a battalion fire chief
01:50was barely clinging to life
01:58The paramedics take over from the battalion chief
02:01in the white t-shirt
02:02and hook up his wife to an
02:04automated chest compression machine
02:06They said they did not get any kind of
02:08electrical activity from her heart
02:10even from the beginning
02:12so it appeared that she had already
02:14passed before they started
02:17their efforts
02:18Battalion fire chief Kevin West
02:20and his wife Marcy
02:21had been married for 22 years
02:24with a son Ted
02:25and a daughter Megan
02:26Happy couple
02:28My mom was a unit coordinator
02:30for the peace health hospital
02:32in the ER
02:37She was
02:39you know the funnest person
02:40I knew
02:41She
02:42she was my best friend
02:44She was my favorite person
02:45in the world
02:47He was the fire captain
02:49and was promoted to fire chief
02:50I would
02:51tell all my friends about him
02:54I'm like oh yeah
02:54my dad's a firefighter
02:55like he saves people
02:56he's a hero
02:57you know
02:59I was very proud of him
03:02The paramedics at the scene
03:04all knew Kevin
03:05from his years
03:06in the fire department
03:07and they comforted him
03:08as he cried over
03:09his wife's body
03:11He's described
03:12by everybody
03:13as distraught
03:14just beside himself
03:22Kevin was also well known
03:24by the local police officers
03:26assigned to do the
03:27follow-up investigation
03:29He's on a first name basis
03:31with them
03:33and his narrative of events
03:34is what medical personnel
03:36and law enforcement
03:37are going to initially rely on
03:39as far as trying to piece together
03:40what happened
03:41And the sudden death
03:43of an otherwise healthy
03:4448-year-old woman
03:45was indeed a mystery
03:47Can you just kind of
03:48run me through last night
03:49and give me rough estimates
03:51of time frames
03:52of when can I say
03:52she got some ibuprofen
03:54or something along the way
03:55Yeah, so
03:58we had dinner
03:59I think
04:05she had a headache
04:06about 10.30
04:07roughly
04:0910.30, 11
04:12She doesn't take any prescriptions
04:14No prescriptions?
04:15Did you say no?
04:16No alcohol?
04:17No
04:17She doesn't drink alcohol
04:18And then
04:20when the call came out
04:22is that about
04:22when you noticed
04:23something was wrong
04:23or was there
04:24about what time
04:25do you think
04:26something was off?
04:27I don't
04:27I have no idea
04:28what time it was
04:29it was just
04:30as a paramedic
04:31for 18 years
04:32she was still actively seizing
04:33and then
04:36I could tell
04:36she wasn't breathing
04:37Okay
04:38All right
04:39I think that's all
04:40I should need
04:41for now
04:41If I need anything
04:42I'll let you know
04:43if you have any questions
04:45The initial investigation
04:47involved interviewing him
04:49taking all around
04:50photos of the inside
04:51of the house
04:54Kevin and Marcy's
04:55daughter Megan
04:55was at school
04:56at the University
04:57of Washington
04:58when her father
04:59showed up that day
05:00in her dorm room
05:02He sat me down
05:03on my chair
05:04and he's like
05:04your mom passed away
05:06this morning
05:07and I obviously
05:09began uncontrollably
05:11sobbing
05:12screaming
05:12asking why this happened
05:14and he just told me
05:16to be quiet
05:16he's like
05:17we don't want anyone
05:18to know that
05:19there's something wrong
05:20I'm like
05:20well there is something wrong
05:21my mom's dead
05:22They do an autopsy
05:24that's standard
05:25with a person
05:25who's relatively young
05:27who passes
05:27without a real good explanation
05:31and they
05:31you know
05:32the early reports
05:33were that there were
05:34bilateral injury
05:36to her throat
05:37and there was some
05:38bruising to the back
05:39of her neck
05:39But not enough
05:40to suggest foul play
05:42injuries that could
05:43be consistent
05:44with aggressive
05:45CPR techniques
05:46There's an awful lot
05:47of activity
05:48going on around her
05:49a lot of people
05:50with their hands on her
05:51working very hard
05:51and very fast
05:53The local police
05:54turned over the case
05:55to the Clark County
05:56Sheriff's Office
05:57and Detective
05:58Dean Tellison
06:00They were worried
06:00about any perception
06:01of conflict of interest
06:03should they move forward
06:05with the investigation
06:05so they had reached out
06:06to us
06:07to take over
06:08the death investigation
06:11The detective's first step
06:12was to review
06:13the body cam footage
06:14from the scene
06:179-1-1
06:18and the 9-1-1 call
06:20that Kevin made
06:21And what's your first
06:22and last name?
06:23Kevin West
06:25There's a lot of information
06:26that can be gleaned
06:27from the 9-1-1 audio
06:29Typically in 9-1-1 calls
06:31people are frantic
06:32and there didn't seem
06:34to be that rush
06:36on the initial front end
06:37Tell me exactly
06:39what happened
06:40She woke me up in bed
06:43I have her on the floor
06:45right now
06:45on her side
06:47This was very
06:48matter of fact
06:49casually relaying
06:50the information
06:51I also know
06:52from personal experience
06:53even though
06:54I'm a cop
06:55when I call
06:57or have had to call
06:589-1-1 for medical emergencies
06:59for family members
07:01it is different
07:01when it's
07:02it's your own family member
07:03experiencing the emergency
07:05Are you with her now?
07:08I would have expected
07:09a little more urgency
07:11I guess
07:11behind the 9-1-1 request
07:13Firefighters spent
07:14a lot of time together
07:16and some of Kevin's colleagues
07:17knew he had
07:18a rocky marriage
07:19A couple
07:20two, three days
07:21of
07:22the
07:24Marcy's death
07:24we started receiving
07:25reports that
07:26Kevin
07:28might have had
07:29an affair
07:29and then
07:30some additional information
07:32that
07:32Kevin and Marcy's
07:34relationship
07:34wasn't the best
07:36as far as
07:37what had been going on
07:39prior to her death
07:39And those reports
07:41raised enough questions
07:42for detectives
07:43to ask for a
07:44second autopsy
07:45by the medical examiner
07:46They actually called
07:48the person
07:48who was transporting
07:49Marcy's body
07:51to the funeral home
07:51and had her
07:53had him turn around
07:54and bring the body
07:54right back
07:55Now
07:56the medical examiner
07:57discovered injuries
07:58that were missed
07:59the first time around
08:00She had bruising
08:02beneath both earlobes
08:04and then she had
08:05a large
08:07contusion
08:07or bruise
08:08under the skin
08:10hematoma
08:10on the back
08:11of her head
08:12as well
08:12And some small
08:14pinpoint bruising
08:15or contusions
08:16called petechia
08:17around the eyes
08:18They're commonly
08:20associated with
08:20strangulation events
08:21so just started
08:22kind of turning
08:23the gears
08:23as far as
08:24maybe there's
08:25more into this
08:26and we should be
08:27taking a closer look
08:28at it
08:35Sorry guys
08:37No worries
08:37My name is Dean Tellison
08:39I'm with the
08:39Clark County Sheriff's Office
08:41This is my partner
08:42Lawrence Zapata
08:43Do you have a few minutes
08:45to chat with us?
08:46Yeah for sure
08:46Come on in
08:47Thank you
08:48How's it going?
08:49Good
08:50A very soft approach
08:52as far as letting him
08:54kind of lead
08:55and tell us the story
08:56of the relationship
08:58their history
08:59So
09:01it's nice to meet you
09:02I'm sorry
09:03it's under these
09:03circumstances
09:05We've been asked
09:06by the medical examiner
09:07to just come out
09:08follow up with you
09:09a routine interview
09:11and make sure
09:11that we're not
09:12missing anything
09:14Our understanding
09:15is Marcy was
09:16in her 40s
09:17or late 40s
09:19So obviously
09:20a younger
09:21kind of unexpected
09:22death at this point
09:24just wanted to come out
09:26and chat with you
09:26hopefully get a little
09:27more background information
09:28on Marcy
09:29if that's okay
09:30That'd be just fine
09:32It was the beginning
09:33of what would become
09:34a months long investigation
09:36as detectives
09:37tried to answer
09:38the question
09:38of whether
09:39Kevin West
09:40had tried to save
09:41his wife
09:41or had strangled her
09:43His daughter
09:44was certain
09:44she knew the answer
09:46I'm like
09:46oh
09:47it's all lies
09:48don't even look
09:50into it
09:50he's innocent
09:51I was just thinking
09:52there's no way
09:53my dad could have
09:54done this
10:04It was just
10:06two weeks
10:06after Marcy West's
10:08death
10:08and Kevin West
10:09told detectives
10:10the family
10:11was still struggling
10:12with their grief
10:13It's been
10:14the worst two weeks
10:15You can only imagine
10:17How are the kids
10:18doing with everything?
10:20They're
10:24they're very strong
10:28they're
10:31they're
10:31it's hard to hear
10:34when they say
10:35I want to hear
10:35I want my mom
10:36you know
10:38My first instinct
10:40is
10:40you know
10:41trust my father
10:42he's the one
10:43who raised me
10:43it's my instinct
10:44to trust him
10:45why should I
10:46think differently
10:47But his daughter
10:48Megan was surprised
10:49to learn from her father
10:50that her mother
10:51died after having
10:52a seizure
10:53and cardiac arrest
10:55I was shocked
10:56because
10:57my mom had never
10:58had a seizure
10:59before that I knew of
11:00My mom and I
11:01shared a lot of
11:02things together
11:02I feel like
11:03she would have
11:04told me
11:05and she just didn't
11:06It was just
11:07very confusing
11:08and upsetting
11:10and adding to
11:11Megan's questions
11:12was a woman
11:13named Cynthia
11:14who showed up
11:15at her father's
11:16birthday party
11:16just 10 days
11:18after her mother
11:19died
11:19My dad had had
11:21a few drinks
11:21everyone was drinking
11:22he would put his
11:24arm around her
11:25call her sweetie
11:26or honey
11:27and that just
11:27it made my skin
11:29crawl
11:30I was
11:31I was honestly
11:32disgusted
11:32I knew
11:33you know
11:34there was
11:34something more
11:35to this
11:36because
11:36I'm not stupid
11:39Detectives also
11:40knew about Cynthia
11:42and they wanted
11:43to see if Kevin
11:44would tell them
11:44about her
11:45without first
11:46being asked
11:47Are you able
11:48to talk to us
11:48about like
11:49your relationship
11:50more recently
11:52like just in general
11:55So
11:55our relationship
11:58for
11:59I mean
12:02the better part
12:03of our
12:04lives together
12:05has just been
12:09busy
12:11crossing paths
12:12He had brought up
12:14some previous issues
12:15or bumps
12:17I believe
12:17was the term
12:18he used
12:18Like any marriage
12:20we had our bumps
12:22in 2015
12:23we had a bump
12:23But no mention
12:25of Cynthia
12:25So nothing recent
12:27didn't give any indication
12:28of
12:31ongoing issues
12:32or ongoing affairs
12:33Just
12:34kind of
12:35an important omission
12:37You know
12:38just because
12:38we don't
12:39explicitly ask
12:40doesn't mean
12:41you can't
12:42bring it up
12:42on your own volition
12:44And only later
12:45would detectives
12:46learn that
12:47while they were
12:47questioning Kevin
12:48in the living room
12:49Cynthia
12:50was in the garage
12:53Your new mistress
12:54is in the garage
12:54and you're not
12:55telling us about that
12:56or being forthcoming
12:57about that
12:58And Megan says
12:59that bump
13:00in 2015
13:01was very serious
13:03My mom had found
13:05a pink shirt
13:07blouse
13:08in my dad's truck
13:09that was not hers
13:11and she did
13:12kick my dad out
13:13I was 10
13:159 or 10 years old
13:16and even I knew
13:17what was going on
13:18I was disappointed
13:21because even I knew
13:22it was wrong
13:28Eight days later
13:29detectives were back
13:31at Kevin West's home
13:32this time
13:33with a search warrant
13:34and more pointed questions
13:36Do you happen to know
13:37Cynthia?
13:39And how do you know her?
13:41I guess
13:41what's your relationship?
13:43So
13:46I had an affair
13:48Okay
13:49Cynthia
13:51and
13:53I'm
13:58struggling with
14:00my
14:00choice
14:02of doing that
14:03Gotcha
14:05And as far as
14:06timeline of
14:07the affair
14:08when was that
14:09happening?
14:10Right now
14:10Right now?
14:11Okay
14:12Again
14:12we're not here to judge
14:15It's hard for me
14:17because
14:17I'd be
14:20honest with you
14:20having that affair
14:22I feel a lot of guilt
14:29for that
14:31Have you guys
14:32talked about
14:32the future
14:33or what the plan
14:34is now?
14:36You know
14:38there is no plan
14:40simply
14:41we're having
14:42the affair
14:43we're having sex
14:44I mean
14:46and
14:49I
14:51shouldn't have
14:52but I did
14:55There are ever any
14:56talks of if
14:56if something were to
14:57happen to Marcy
14:58that you'd move forward
15:00with Cynthia?
15:02No
15:05Detectives would later
15:06run that Kevin and
15:07Cynthia had begun
15:08planning to buy
15:09some land together
15:10even before
15:11Marcy died
15:12I think that
15:14their plan was to
15:15eventually
15:16build a home there
15:18And Megan says
15:19that her father
15:20had in fact
15:21been thinking
15:21of getting a divorce
15:23He was
15:24upset that she
15:26was gaining weight
15:27that
15:28he thought
15:29she wasn't
15:30putting in a ton
15:30of effort
15:31and he confided
15:33in me that he
15:33was thinking
15:34about divorce
15:35because he said
15:35he just couldn't
15:36do it anymore
15:37Now detectives
15:39began to turn
15:40up the heat
15:40aside kind of
15:41the elephant
15:42in the room
15:45As far as
15:46the autopsy
15:47and stuff go
15:48would it
15:49surprise you
15:49if I told you
15:51that there were
15:52some injuries
15:52uncovered?
15:54Yeah
15:55Okay
15:57Is
15:57but again
15:58there's
15:59is there anything
15:59that you can
16:00think of that
16:01could explain
16:02why she
16:03had any injuries?
16:05No
16:07there was
16:07there was
16:08absolutely nothing
16:09you know
16:10the
16:13we had a good
16:14night
16:16we made love
16:20she went through
16:21what she went
16:22through
16:25I woke up
16:26to the event
16:27my indiscretion
16:28with Cynthia
16:29has nothing
16:30to do
16:31with the other
16:32at that point
16:33West cut off
16:34the questioning
16:34and went looking
16:35for a lawyer
16:36I have nothing
16:37to do
16:39but detectives
16:40had their
16:41court ordered
16:42search warrant
16:42and they began
16:43to look for
16:44what they hoped
16:44would be
16:45a missing clue
16:52the search
16:53of Kevin West
16:54home
16:54began
16:55as soon
16:55as Kevin
16:56said
16:56he was
16:57through
16:57answering
16:58questions
17:01and detectives
17:02thought
17:02they hit
17:02pay dirt
17:03with a discovery
17:04hidden
17:04in a wooden
17:05chest
17:06in the garage
17:13one of my
17:14partners found
17:15Christmas cards
17:16that had been
17:17written by
17:18Kevin
17:18to Cynthia Ward
17:20sometime before
17:21Marcy's death
17:22in early January
17:24we'll be together
17:25every day
17:26celebrating
17:26adding 2024
17:28will be our year
17:29I love you
17:30Cynthia
17:31love forever
17:32and always
17:33Kevin
17:33the Christmas
17:34card seemed
17:35to very
17:35plainly
17:36indicate
17:38plans of
17:38moving forward
17:39with Cynthia
17:39and intent
17:40to be with
17:40her next year
17:44in the
17:44cell phone
17:45extraction
17:46from Kevin's
17:47cell phone
17:48there were
17:49numerous messages
17:50with Cynthia's
17:52mother
17:52moving out
17:54on the 8th
17:55meeting with
17:56the divorce
17:56attorney that
17:57week
17:58we're gonna
17:59have reason
17:59to celebrate
18:00here soon
18:02and was it
18:03a coincidence
18:04that that was
18:05just happened
18:05to line up
18:06the same day
18:06that Marcy
18:07died
18:08so very
18:09set in stone
18:10plans it seemed
18:11like to move
18:12forward with
18:13Cynthia and
18:14kind of begin
18:14a new chapter
18:15of life with
18:16Cynthia
18:18Cynthia moved in
18:19with Kevin
18:19and he would
18:20later propose
18:21marriage to her
18:22it's almost like
18:23he just expected
18:24us to accept
18:26her like this
18:27is your new
18:28family
18:29which was very
18:31hard
18:33at one point
18:35neighbors called
18:36police to report
18:37a possible
18:37domestic dispute
18:39between the two
18:40which they both
18:41denied
18:42was anything
18:43physical between
18:43the two of you
18:44not even a little
18:45bit
18:45would you be
18:46willing to chat
18:46with me for a
18:47second
18:47how come
18:49because I'm just
18:50upset about
18:51stuff
18:51okay
18:52okay
18:53that's fine
18:54are you injured
18:54in any way
18:55me
18:56yeah I'm gonna
18:57come
18:57is it okay
18:57if I come
18:57your neighbors
18:58are outside
18:58I don't want
18:59to embarrass you
19:00no I appreciate
19:02that
19:02anything physical
19:03never
19:03okay
19:04for Kevin's
19:05daughter
19:06the doubts
19:07were growing
19:08I had received
19:09a call from my
19:10dad
19:10they're opening
19:10investigation
19:11they think
19:12I killed
19:12your mom
19:13I had read
19:14news articles
19:16I had watched
19:17the news
19:18and
19:19it just
19:21things just
19:21started
19:22connecting
19:22he would give
19:24me calls
19:24and
19:27he'd be like
19:28hey
19:28like I saw
19:29someone posted
19:29this thing
19:30about me
19:30I would like
19:31you to go
19:31and you know
19:32comment on the
19:33via or contact
19:34them and like
19:35tell him the
19:35truth for me
19:36defend him
19:37online
19:37defend him
19:38publicly
19:38he's like
19:39these people
19:39need to know
19:40you have my
19:41back
19:41if my kids
19:41have my
19:42back
19:42they know
19:43there's no
19:43way I could
19:44have done
19:44this
19:46detectives
19:46began to
19:47build a
19:47picture of
19:48the couple's
19:48finances
19:49and found
19:50a heavy
19:50load of
19:51consumer
19:52debt
19:52and determined
19:53that it
19:53wasn't a
19:54sustainable
19:56spending
19:57pattern
19:58and their
19:59theory was
19:59Kevin really
20:00could not
20:00afford
20:01a divorce
20:02it's like
20:03any first
20:03responders
20:04nightmare
20:05where you
20:06work two
20:07or three
20:07decades
20:07have a
20:08pension
20:08and then
20:09if you
20:10divorce
20:11in Washington
20:12your spouse
20:13is likely
20:14going to
20:15get some
20:16of that
20:16pension
20:16so despite
20:18having a
20:19large income
20:19source
20:20they also
20:21had a lot
20:22of spending
20:23on the
20:23back end
20:24weeks went
20:25by and
20:26still
20:26no arrests
20:27they don't
20:28have the
20:28final autopsy
20:29report
20:29I think
20:30they're just
20:31reviewing
20:32more
20:32materials
20:33you know
20:33they don't
20:34have access
20:34to him
20:34anymore
20:35because I'm
20:35on the
20:36scene
20:37and so
20:38it's just
20:38kind of a
20:39waiting game
20:39and he just
20:40you know
20:41goes about
20:41his life
20:42as well
20:43as he can
20:44Kevin went
20:45back to work
20:45at the
20:46fire department
20:46I think
20:47it put
20:48the members
20:49of the
20:49Camas
20:50Washougo
20:50fire department
20:50in an
20:51impossible
20:52situation
20:52it's somebody
20:53that they
20:54respected
20:54that they
20:55looked up
20:55to
20:55I think
20:56a lot
20:57of them
20:57initially
20:58wanted to
20:58give Kevin
20:58the benefit
20:59of the doubt
20:59and felt
21:00that Kevin
21:02the Kevin
21:02that they
21:03knew
21:03it wasn't
21:04possible
21:04that he
21:05could have
21:05done this
21:08on March
21:0920th
21:10the detectives
21:10finally got
21:11what they
21:12were waiting
21:12for
21:12to make
21:13an arrest
21:14the medical
21:14examiner
21:15declared
21:16an official
21:16cause of
21:17death
21:17homicide
21:18caused
21:19by asphyxia
21:20due to
21:21blunt neck
21:22trauma
21:24we began
21:25in this
21:25hour
21:25with a
21:26case
21:26where
21:26investigators
21:27claim
21:27a husband's
21:28double
21:28life
21:29ended
21:29in
21:29murder
21:30West
21:30was
21:31arrested
21:31without
21:31incident
21:32and then
21:32quickly
21:33released
21:33on bail
21:34a few
21:34weeks
21:35later
21:35I asked
21:35him
21:36like
21:36look
21:36I'm
21:36having
21:37a lot
21:37of
21:37doubts
21:37like
21:38did
21:39you
21:39do
21:39it
21:39I was
21:39like
21:40I need
21:40you
21:40to
21:40be
21:40honest
21:41with
21:41me
21:41did
21:41you
21:41do
21:41it
21:42and
21:42he
21:42got
21:42very
21:42angry
21:43just
21:44yelling
21:44at
21:44me
21:45asking
21:45like
21:45how
21:45I
21:46think
21:46you
21:47know
21:47he
21:47would
21:55Ted
21:55quickly
21:55came
21:56to
21:56his
21:56father's
21:57defense
21:57so
21:58whenever
21:58you're
21:58ready
21:58please
21:59Ted
22:00a
22:00self
22:01trained
22:01masseuse
22:02put on
22:02a
22:02demonstration
22:03for
22:03detectives
22:04at
22:04the
22:04office
22:04of
22:05his
22:05father's
22:05lawyer
22:06showing
22:06the
22:07massage
22:07he
22:07gave
22:08his
22:08mother
22:08the
22:08day
22:09before
22:09her
22:09death
22:10I
22:11would
22:11kind
22:12of
22:12press
22:12and
22:13go
22:13in
22:13circular
22:13motion
22:14on
22:15the
22:15back
22:15trying
22:16to
22:16find
22:16those
22:16knots
22:17suggesting
22:17he
22:18might
22:18have
22:18inadvertently
22:19caused
22:20his
22:20mother's
22:21neck
22:21injuries
22:22it
22:22sounds
22:22like
22:23kind
22:23of
22:23like
22:23a
22:23throw
22:24away
22:24theory
22:24but
22:24at
22:25the
22:25same
22:25time
22:25he
22:26really
22:26did
22:27give
22:27these
22:28really
22:28deep
22:29intense
22:29massages
22:30and
22:30he
22:32just
22:32demonstrated
22:33how he
22:33had
22:34pressed
22:35on her
22:35her
22:36shoulders
22:36and
22:37the
22:37lower
22:37part
22:38of
22:38her
22:38neck
22:38and
22:38he
22:38actually
22:39did
22:39that
22:39the
22:39day
22:40before
22:40she
22:40passed
22:41and
22:42Ted
22:42this
22:42is
22:42what
22:43you
22:43recall
22:43generally
22:44doing
22:44that
22:44day
22:44but
22:45it's
22:45not
22:45exactly
22:46a
22:46complete
22:47reenactment
22:48of what
22:48you
22:48did
22:48is
22:50A few
22:51weeks
22:52before
22:52the
22:52trial
22:52Megan
22:53got
22:53an
22:53even
22:54more
22:54troubling
22:54phone
22:55call
22:55from
22:55her
22:56father
22:56and
22:57he
22:57is
22:58just
22:59sobbing
23:00hysterical
23:01crying
23:01and
23:02just
23:02repeating
23:03over
23:03and
23:03over
23:04and
23:04over
23:04again
23:04like
23:05I'm
23:05sorry
23:05I'm
23:06sorry
23:06please
23:07you
23:07have
23:07to
23:07forgive
23:07me
23:08I'm
23:08sorry
23:08I
23:08didn't
23:09mean
23:09to
23:09do
23:09it
23:09I
23:10could
23:10tell
23:10that
23:11he
23:11was
23:11obviously
23:12drunk
23:12he
23:12just
23:13wanted
23:13attention
23:14and
23:14sympathy
23:14wheels
23:15are
23:16turning
23:16in
23:16my
23:16head
23:17I'm
23:17like
23:18okay
23:20is
23:20he
23:21guilty
23:21you
23:22know
23:22is
23:22this
23:22the
23:23moment
23:23he
23:23confesses
23:25now
23:26Megan
23:26had
23:26to
23:26decide
23:27what
23:27she
23:27would
23:28say
23:28when
23:28she
23:28was
23:29called
23:29to
23:29testify
23:30at
23:30her
23:30father's
23:31trial
23:47was
23:47was
23:47it
23:47seizure
23:48or
23:48strangulation
23:49that's
23:49the
23:49question
23:50a
23:50jury
23:50in
23:51Washington
23:51faces
23:51in
23:52the
23:52trial
23:52against
23:52a
23:53former
23:53fire
23:53battalion
23:54chief
23:54former
23:55fire
23:55chief
23:55Kevin
23:55West
23:56is
23:56charged
23:56with
23:57murdering
23:57his
23:57wife
23:58Marcy
23:58it
23:59was a
24:00huge
24:00story
24:00everyone
24:01in the
24:01community
24:01was
24:01talking
24:02about
24:02it
24:02everybody
24:03is
24:03still
24:03talking
24:04about
24:04it
24:04now
24:05I
24:05was
24:05just
24:05watching
24:06everything
24:06unfold
24:07and
24:07kind
24:07of
24:07just
24:08in
24:08shock
24:08it's
24:09terrible
24:09because
24:09of
24:10the
24:10kids
24:11it's
24:12got
24:12a
24:12sensational
24:12tagline
24:14right
24:14you know
24:14respected
24:15accomplished
24:16battalion
24:17chief
24:17charged
24:18with
24:18the
24:18murder
24:18of
24:19his
24:19wife
24:19and
24:19he's
24:19having
24:20affairs
24:20prosecutor
24:21Melinda
24:21McMahon
24:22did
24:22the
24:22opening
24:23at
24:244 27
24:25a.m.
24:27about
24:27two years
24:27ago
24:28to the
24:28day
24:28today
24:29the
24:30defendant
24:30Kevin
24:31West
24:32called
24:33911
24:33the
24:35first
24:35responders
24:35trusted
24:36what
24:37they were
24:37told
24:39because
24:39it
24:40wasn't
24:40an unknown
24:40caller
24:42it was
24:43a battalion
24:43trained
24:45someone
24:46that was
24:46a friend
24:46someone
24:47that they
24:47trusted
24:48and most
24:49importantly
24:50someone
24:50who's
24:50trained
24:51in
24:51life
24:52saving
24:52measures
24:52the
24:53evidence
24:54will
24:54show
24:54that
24:54the
24:54defendant's
24:55story
24:56of what
24:56happens
24:57does
24:57not
24:58hold
24:58up
24:58to
24:58investigative
24:59scrutiny
25:00it
25:01does
25:01not
25:01hold
25:02up
25:02to
25:03medical
25:03testimony
25:05members
25:05of the
25:05jury
25:06when you
25:06evaluate
25:07the
25:08phone
25:08data
25:08the
25:09testimony
25:09witnesses
25:10the
25:10medical
25:11testimony
25:11the
25:12photographs
25:13everything
25:13in conjunction
25:14my colleague
25:16Jessica Smith
25:17will ask
25:17that you find
25:18the defendant
25:18guilty
25:19of murder
25:20in first degree
25:21thank you
25:23and it's
25:26my understanding
25:27defense wishes
25:28to make
25:28opening at
25:29this time
25:29is that correct
25:30it is correct
25:31thank you
25:33Kevin West
25:34lawyer
25:35Brian Walker
25:36Kevin West
25:37did not
25:39kill
25:39Kevin West
25:42on
25:43early
25:45morning
25:45of
25:45January
25:468th
25:472004
25:48tried to
25:49save her
25:49he used
25:50his
25:50skills
25:52of 25
25:52years
25:53of being
25:53a paramedic
25:54his training
25:54his passion
25:56to try to save her
25:56but Kevin West's
25:58lawyer knew
25:59he had to deal
25:59up front
26:00with some
26:01bad facts
26:02the bad facts
26:03are pretty obvious
26:04the affair
26:04is a bad fact
26:05for us
26:06but it was not
26:07a perfect
26:07you will find
26:08it was not
26:09it was a
26:10injury
26:11it was one
26:11that had been
26:13promulg for years
26:14and over the years
26:16Kevin's not
26:16getting that
26:17attention
26:17that he wants
26:18that kind of
26:18love that he wants
26:19he reaches out
26:20to Cynthia
26:20finds it on
26:21Facebook
26:22this is a
26:23relationship
26:24that Kevin
26:25is keeping
26:26secret for us
26:30holding out
26:30the hope
26:30of perhaps
26:31someday
26:31that relationship
26:33couldn't have
26:34be repaired
26:35perhaps
26:36you can love
26:39a new person
26:39and still
26:40love the
26:40mother of your
26:42children
26:42and this is not
26:44the kind of thing
26:44that he would do
26:45it does not
26:52add up to proof
26:53and at the end
26:55of this season
26:56I'll be asking
26:57you
26:59to render
26:59the prosecution
27:05called a series
27:06of Kevin's
27:07former
27:07fire department
27:08colleagues
27:09including some
27:10who came to
27:11learn of his
27:11affair with
27:12Cynthia
27:12he said he had
27:14been seeing
27:14her
27:15and that
27:17she had told
27:18him that she
27:19was willing to
27:19wait for him
27:20for however long
27:21it took
27:21and then one
27:23of his best
27:23friends
27:24Terry Slocum
27:25and on the day
27:27of Marcy's
27:28passing
27:28when you were
27:29with him
27:30at the residence
27:31was there a point
27:32that just you
27:34and Kevin West
27:35were alone
27:35together
27:36yes
27:37what did he say
27:39and he was relieved
27:40and that a burden
27:41had been
27:42lifted off
27:42his shoulders
27:45no good
27:45questions
27:50and then
27:51one of the
27:51state's
27:52most important
27:53witnesses
27:53the forensic
27:54pathologist
27:55Dr. Martha
27:56Burt
27:56who determined
27:57Marcy's death
27:58was not from
27:59natural causes
28:00but a homicide
28:01did you observe
28:02any injuries
28:03to Marcy's
28:04head or neck
28:05externally
28:08yes
28:08is the constellation
28:10of injuries
28:10you observed
28:11on Marcy
28:12in the totality
28:13of your findings
28:13consistent with her
28:14having had
28:16a seizure
28:17turned cardiac
28:18breast
28:19and died
28:20from that
28:21no
28:23why not
28:27a primary seizure
28:29resulting in
28:30cardiac arrest
28:31should not
28:32have
28:33these
28:34associated
28:34injuries
28:38I have a question
28:40for you
28:41good afternoon
28:41doctor
28:42now you said
28:43that
28:44you were unable
28:45to think of
28:45any
28:46external
28:47forces
28:48or external
28:48causes
28:49that would
28:49have caused
28:50death
28:50so you deemed
28:51it a strangulation
28:52and homicide
28:53correct
28:53in general
28:54I agree
28:55with that
28:55statement
28:55what if
28:56the person
28:57was
28:58was nauseous
28:59felt ill
29:00had a massive
29:01headache
29:01fell down
29:02and hit
29:02her head
29:02on the
29:03floor
29:03would that
29:03point explain
29:04the contusion
29:05objection
29:09that is
29:10one scenario
29:11to explain
29:12the contusion
29:12on her head
29:13thank you
29:17the prosecution
29:18was that Kevin
29:20killed his wife
29:21so he could
29:22be with
29:22Cynthia
29:23so what was
29:24the plan
29:24with Kevin
29:25and his
29:25relationship
29:29I don't know
29:31I wouldn't
29:32I don't know
29:33there was no
29:34discussion of
29:35what he was
29:35going to do
29:36in his
29:36relationship
29:36well eventually
29:37he was
29:38going to
29:39leave
29:39Marcy
29:40at some
29:41point
29:42I don't
29:42know when
29:42that would
29:43have been
29:43exactly
29:45so you
29:46and Kevin
29:46had discussions
29:47about him
29:47leaving
29:47Marcy
29:48yes
29:50and what
29:51is the
29:51current
29:52state
29:52of your
29:52relationship
29:54we're
29:55engaged
29:56as the
29:57defense
29:57prepared
29:58its case
29:58West
29:59lawyer
29:59planned
30:00to call
30:00his daughter
30:01Megan
30:01to testify
30:02still not
30:03fully sure
30:04what she
30:05might say
30:15for his
30:16defense
30:16Kevin West
30:17was counting
30:17on his
30:18family
30:18they had
30:19everyone in
30:19his life
30:20take the
30:20stand
30:21his mom
30:22his dad
30:25friends
30:26family members
30:26it was
30:27very important
30:28from the
30:29defense's
30:30point of
30:31view
30:31to characterize
30:32him as
30:33someone who
30:34was good
30:35but made
30:36a mistake
30:43his son
30:45Ted
30:45strongly
30:46defended
30:46his father
30:47and demonstrated
30:48the massage
30:49he gave to
30:49his mother
30:50the day
30:50before her
30:51death
30:53the defense
30:54wanted the jury
30:55to think
30:55that's what
30:56caused
30:56Marcy's neck
30:57injuries
31:05prosecutor's
31:06question
31:06why he
31:07never told
31:07police
31:08about the
31:08massage
31:09until after
31:10the autopsy
31:11results came
31:11back
31:12you did not
31:13talk about
31:13the massage
31:14that you
31:15gave your
31:15mother
31:15until after
31:17the autopsy
31:18results
31:18is that
31:18correct
31:19with law
31:20enforcement
31:20I can't
31:21remember the
31:21timeline
31:24detective
31:25the final
31:41family witness
31:42was Kevin's
31:43daughter
31:43Megan
31:44it was probably
31:45the scariest
31:46thing I would
31:47ever have to
31:48do
31:48I was shaking
31:49I was sweating
31:50my eyes are
31:51bugged out of
31:52my head just
31:53because of how
31:53terrified I was
31:54Megan said it
31:56seemed her
31:56father's lawyer
31:57was pushing her
31:58to disparage
31:59her mother
32:00she didn't
32:05always choose
32:05the healthiest
32:06food options
32:07she drank soda
32:09a lot instead
32:10of water
32:13a lot of
32:14processed foods
32:16she occasionally
32:17did try
32:18keto diet
32:19but it never
32:21really stuck
32:22he wanted me
32:24to paint
32:24a picture of
32:26my mom
32:26that she was
32:27this fat
32:27lazy person
32:29and that
32:29you know
32:31contributed
32:31to some
32:32health issues
32:32which broke
32:33my heart
32:35she said
32:36that I was
32:37trying to get
32:37her to say
32:38things
32:38and I
32:40you know
32:40that to me
32:41that's
32:41that's an
32:42insult
32:42ethically
32:43we can't
32:44do that
32:44ethically
32:44I don't
32:45do that
32:45that's a
32:46matter of
32:46integrity
32:46I thought
32:47that I
32:48thought her
32:48testimony
32:49was very
32:49helpful
32:53there was
32:54no cross
32:55examination
32:55by prosecutors
32:56and no
32:57opening for
32:58Megan to
32:58testify
32:59about her
33:00father's
33:00phone call
33:02as she
33:02left the
33:03courtroom
33:03she did
33:04not look
33:04at him
33:20I don't care
33:21what anybody
33:22says
33:22juries want
33:23to hear
33:24the defendant
33:25testify
33:25period
33:26they just
33:26want to know
33:27what he has
33:27to say
33:28Wes began
33:29by demonstrating
33:30for the jury
33:31what he did
33:32that night
33:32when he says
33:33Marcy began
33:34her seizures
33:47it came across
33:48like somebody
33:49who knew
33:51how best
33:52to handle
33:52a body
33:53in the worst
33:54kind of way
33:56would you
33:57would you describe
33:57your behavior
33:59as violent
34:00or aggressive
34:02or deliberate
34:03how would you
34:04describe it
34:04no deliberate
34:05and concerned
34:07no
34:07and
34:08were you
34:09trying not to
34:10hurt her
34:10were you
34:14working in the
34:14dark
34:15yes
34:15how long
34:17did you stay
34:17up there
34:18after she
34:18passed
34:20after she
34:21passed
34:22I wasn't
34:23up there
34:23for very
34:23long
34:24at all
34:27efforts
34:27had stopped
34:29I prayed
34:30for her
34:30I said
34:31goodbye
34:34I went
34:34downstairs
34:36and
34:37I had
34:39people
34:40surrounding
34:40me
34:43describe
34:44how you
34:44felt
34:45like if
34:45you were
34:45having a
34:46bad
34:46moment
34:47nothing
34:48how did
34:48you
34:49experience
34:49of
34:50extreme
34:50sadness
34:51seeing my
34:52kids
34:52sadness
34:52was
34:52so
34:53incredible
34:54so
34:54difficult
34:55so
34:55incredibly
34:56difficult
34:56my
34:58emotions
34:58went back
34:59and forth
34:59because
35:00we had
35:01so many
35:01problems
35:01that were
35:02unresolved
35:02that
35:02I was
35:03sad
35:03I was
35:04frustrated
35:05I was
35:05angry
35:05about
35:06that
35:07but
35:08it was
35:09also
35:09what I
35:09loved
35:09for
35:12a lot
35:13of years
35:16sorry
35:17Kevin
35:18did you
35:18put
35:18your
35:19wife
35:19in a
35:20weird
35:21naked
35:21chokehold
35:21and
35:22strangled
35:22her
35:22to death
35:23no
35:25did you
35:26do
35:26anything
35:26to cause
35:27the
35:28contusion
35:28on the
35:29matter
35:29for him
35:29no
35:30I did
35:30not
35:34did you
35:35do
35:35anything
35:35to cause
35:36Marcy's
35:36death
35:36no
35:37I did
35:38not
35:41you
35:46were
35:46asked
35:47directly
35:47and
35:47you
35:48have
35:48no
35:48explanation
35:49for
35:49her
35:50injuries
35:50I
35:51have
35:52no
35:52explanation
35:53for
35:53her
35:53injuries
35:54you
35:54told
35:54your
35:54best
35:55friend
35:55that
35:56a
35:56burden
35:56had
35:57been
35:57lifted
35:57did
35:58you
35:58not
35:59if
36:00I
36:00said
36:00that
36:01that
36:01was
36:01completely
36:01taken
36:02out of
36:02context
36:02and
36:02was
36:03meant
36:03for
36:03some
36:03other
36:04reason
36:04I
36:05am
36:05not
36:05a
36:05cold
36:06person
36:06thank
36:06you
36:07no
36:08I
36:09was
36:09very
36:09surprised
36:09how
36:10short
36:10the
36:10cross
36:10examination
36:11was
36:11it
36:12kind
36:12of
36:12started
36:12and
36:12then
36:12just
36:13sort
36:13of
36:13stopped
36:14I
36:15don't
36:16I
36:16frankly
36:17don't
36:17think
36:19they
36:19damaged
36:20his
36:21testimony
36:21at all
36:22during
36:23cross
36:34prosecutor
36:34jessica
36:35jessica
36:36smith
36:36handled
36:36the
36:36closing
36:37in
36:38the
36:38beginning
36:38this
36:39appeared
36:39to be
36:39a
36:39tragedy
36:40a
36:4148
36:42year
36:42old
36:42mother
36:42dying
36:43unexpectedly
36:44her
36:45husband
36:45fired
36:46to
36:46fire
36:46performing
36:47a
36:47presentation
36:47a
36:48hero
36:49turned
36:49grieving
36:50but this
36:51is not
36:51a case
36:52decided on
36:53first impressions
36:54this is a case
36:55decided on
36:56evidence
36:58and when you
36:58look closely
36:59when you look
37:00beneath the
37:01surface
37:02the story
37:03the defendant
37:04told falls
37:04apart
37:06and when you put it
37:07all together
37:07there really is only
37:08one conclusion
37:09that fits
37:10with every piece
37:11of the evidence
37:12which is
37:13Marcy was killed
37:14by a vascular
37:15strangulation
37:16at the hands
37:17of the only person
37:18that was there
37:19which is her
37:19husband
37:26Kevin
37:33did not
37:34kill
37:34Marcy
37:38they did not
37:39prove that
37:40here
37:40what did Dr.
37:41Hurt say
37:42every question
37:43that was
37:44answered with
37:45could be
37:46potential
37:47she must have
37:48said that
37:4950 times
37:50could be
37:51potentially
37:51could be
37:52potentially
37:52that is not
37:53proof beyond
37:54reasonable
37:54doubt
37:55and
37:57I ask
37:58that you
37:58find Kevin
37:59not guilty
38:00of murder
38:01in first degree
38:02not guilty
38:02of murder
38:03in second
38:04after a long
38:09weekend
38:09the jury
38:10needed only
38:11a little more
38:11than two
38:12hours to
38:12reach a
38:13verdict
38:23West held
38:25hands
38:25with his
38:25sister
38:26Amy
38:46he was very
38:47disappointed
38:48I'll put it
38:48that way
38:49and his
38:50daughter
38:51Megan
38:51told him
38:51she believed
38:52the jury
38:53got it right
38:54and I told
38:55him I was
38:55like for
38:56now I
38:57don't want
38:57to talk
38:58to you
38:58anymore
38:58please do
38:59not call
38:59me again
39:03and at
39:04his sentencing
39:04Megan told
39:05the world
39:06what she
39:07thought
39:10my name
39:11is Megan
39:12and I'm
39:13here to
39:13speak as
39:14my mother's
39:14child
39:16my mom
39:16was an
39:17incredible
39:17woman
39:18you killed
39:19the person
39:19who loved
39:20me
39:20who raised
39:22me and
39:22who was
39:22my home
39:24you tried
39:25manipulating
39:26me against
39:26my own
39:27mother
39:27because of
39:28what you
39:28and your
39:28attorney
39:29pushed me
39:30to say
39:30during the
39:31trial
39:31you didn't
39:32just destroy
39:33your family
39:33you tried
39:34to use us
39:34as collateral
39:35in your
39:35wreckage
39:37it hurt
39:38him a lot
39:39it was very
39:40very hurtful
39:42and I will
39:42carry her
39:43with me
39:43for the rest
39:44of my life
39:45and I will
39:46continue to
39:46speak her
39:47truth
39:48because she
39:49deserves
39:49that
39:51because love
39:52does not
39:53stay silent
39:54thank you
39:56well said
40:06well the impact
40:07on the audience
40:08was obvious
40:09because they
40:09applauded her
40:11which is
40:12extremely
40:12inappropriate
40:13in a courtroom
40:14setting like
40:15this
40:16her brother
40:17Ted
40:18asked the
40:19judge
40:19to show
40:19their father
40:20leniency
40:21painting a
40:22different picture
40:22of Kevin West
40:23than Megan
40:24had
40:25I love and
40:26respect my
40:27father deeply
40:27I respectfully
40:29ask that
40:30you take
40:30his character
40:31and the
40:32positive impact
40:33he has had
40:34on those
40:35around him
40:35Ted was in
40:36severe denial
40:37and he still
40:38is
40:38he's very
40:39angry with me
40:43your honor
40:44ladies and
40:44gentlemen
40:44thank you
40:45for taking
40:45time for
40:46your day
40:46to be
40:46here
40:46I made
40:47every effort
40:48to save
40:48her life
40:49but was
40:49unable to
40:50I am truly
40:51sorry
40:51for having
40:52an affair
40:53I know
40:54that it was
40:54wrong
40:54and I
40:55should have
40:56waited
40:56for the
40:57divorce
40:57to be
40:57final
40:58for that
40:59I am
41:00deeply
41:00sorry
41:01however
41:01that was
41:02my only
41:03wrongdoing
41:04in conclusion
41:06a mockery
41:07has been made
41:07of my wife's
41:08passing
41:08please in
41:10your time
41:10take a
41:11moment of
41:11silence
41:12even if
41:12you didn't
41:13over
41:13and allow
41:13Marcy
41:14rest in
41:14peace
41:16but the
41:17jury has
41:17found
41:18and I
41:18concur
41:19with their
41:19finding
41:20that in
41:21this case
41:22your
41:23explanations
41:24don't make
41:25any sense
41:26the only
41:26thing that
41:27makes sense
41:27is that
41:28you deliberately
41:30killed the
41:31victim in
41:31this case
41:32and
41:33ripped your
41:34family apart
41:35the sentence
41:36300 months
41:37or 25
41:38years
41:38in prison
41:40really
41:41showed me
41:41that my
41:42mom's
41:42life was
41:43only worth
41:4325 years
41:44when he
41:45honestly he
41:46should have
41:46gotten life
41:47in prison
41:49Megan has
41:50signed what's
41:51known as a
41:51no contact
41:52order
41:53that her
41:54father can
41:54never again
41:55contact her
41:56it's honestly
41:57terrifying
41:58because
42:00I know
42:01there's gonna
42:02be a day
42:04when I'm
42:05you know
42:0640 years
42:07old
42:0745 years
42:08old
42:09and
42:10my dad
42:11is gonna
42:11be out
42:12and he's
42:12gonna be
42:13able to
42:13find me
42:15Megan says
42:16she's
42:16comforted by
42:16a note
42:17she wrote
42:17to her
42:17mother
42:18that she
42:18found in
42:19her mother's
42:19purse
42:20but what I
42:21didn't know
42:22was that
42:23she had
42:24put it in
42:24her purse
42:25and carried
42:26it with her
42:27every day
42:27and the fact
42:29that she felt
42:30it was special
42:31enough
42:31to put it
42:32in her purse
42:33and carry it
42:33with her
42:34every day
42:34means everything
42:35to me
42:36and it feels
42:37like a piece
42:38of her
42:38is still
42:38with me
42:39all of the
42:40memories
42:41and everything
42:42she left
42:43in here
42:43is a little
42:43piece of
42:44her
42:46happy birthday
42:47to you
42:50happy birthday
42:51dear mommy
42:55happy birthday
42:56to you
42:57happy birthday