- il y a 1 heure
Watch Murder on Trial, Season 2 Episode 2 on Dailymotion (2026).
Catégorie
📺
TVTranscription
00:28Sous-titrage Société Radio-Canada
00:32With these types of investigations, it is definitely good to look at who are close, who they're having issues with.
00:41The search went on for weeks for the missing mother.
00:44If you hear from her or if she shows up, would you let us know?
00:47And then police surveillance reveals a grisly secret.
00:52It looks like he might be putting something in the water.
00:55Using a bucket in the water and dumping whatever was in the bucket into the water.
01:01He's definitely rinsing something off right now.
01:04Could police get there in time to stop it?
01:27Day one of the case began at the Indian Harbor, Florida, police headquarters.
01:32Todd Howery had come in to file a missing persons report on his ex-wife, Nancy Howery.
01:39They just walked in the front door, Todd and her two children, and reported her missing.
01:50Nancy Howery was a vivacious 44-year-old mother of two who had lived in the Florida area for the
01:56last five years.
01:58She was originally from Brazil.
02:00She liked to have fun and hang out, and she cared very deeply for her children.
02:04Okay, so her name is Nancy Howery. She's your ex-wife?
02:08She is my ex-wife. We've been divorced for just a bit more than two years.
02:12Todd said their marriage had ended badly.
02:14Yeah, we have a very hostile relationship, okay?
02:18Our relationship is through text messaging, and it's not pleasant at all.
02:26His statement was a little off. He was very, I guess, an angry person at Nancy.
02:35He made it very clear that he avoids her at all costs.
02:38The ex-husband said he became concerned after Nancy failed to pick up their children at their school for two
02:44days in a row.
02:45So when a parent doesn't pick them up, and then that happens two consecutive days in a row, it was
02:51just extremely unusual.
02:53Now, she has done that in the past. Let's say in the last two years, in the last two years,
03:02she may have done that six-ish times, okay?
03:07So is that something totally out of the norm for her not to pick up the kids?
03:10Two days in a row is out of the norm. This has never happened, that she's disappeared like this.
03:16Okay.
03:17Okay?
03:17There's a couple questions about the action. Does she take any medication?
03:20I'm trying to determine if she's in any danger as far as her possibly not taking any medication.
03:26Maybe that's causing her to act this way.
03:28I don't know of any medications that she takes.
03:31I've never seen somebody drink as hard as what she does. She drinks until she passes out, and then she
03:37wakes up, and then she continues drinking.
03:38Okay.
03:39Well, I'm trying to get it. Is she under the care of any, like, doctor at the moment?
03:42I have no idea.
03:43No idea.
03:44Have you ever been suicidal or anything to the best of your knowledge?
03:47No, no.
03:47No?
03:48No.
03:49With these types of investigations, it is definitely good to look at who are close, who they're having issues with.
03:55Some of the red flags were there.
03:58Right now, we're going to treat her as a missing person.
04:00Mm-hmm.
04:00Okay? So we're going to exhaust all our leads. We're going to try to make contact with her.
04:04We took it seriously right from the word go. We entered her, and her computer is missing, along with her
04:08car.
04:09By the time they reported it, we were at least 48 hours behind. So we were kind of playing catch
04:14-up at that point.
04:17Police canvassed Nancy's neighborhood.
04:19Moffitt's president, the Indian Harbor Beach Police Department.
04:22We're here wondering to see if you have heard from your neighbor, Nancy.
04:25No, I don't.
04:25Lives over at Unit 2?
04:27Yeah, no. No, I have not heard from her.
04:29And they checked out Nancy's home.
04:32He did, right?
04:33I'd still do it.
04:35Police Department.
04:38Maligan, announce yourself, Police Department.
04:40Indian Harbor Beach Police Department.
04:42If you're in here, announce yourself.
04:44Police!
04:47Her car wasn't there. Her phone. There was no evidence of any foul play at the house.
04:52But then, the next day, the 19th, a big break. Nancy's vehicle was discovered abandoned a few miles away.
05:00The way that it was parked, it didn't look like it was parked carefully.
05:05It was halfway on the roadway, halfway in the grass.
05:08Looking in the window, I saw her driver's license, her debit card, her purse was in the back seat.
05:15And there was a layer of pollen over the vehicle, so it looked like it had been sitting there for
05:19at least a few days.
05:20And then detectives came to learn that Nancy and her ex-husband were still fighting over issues in their divorce.
05:27We did learn that there was a contentious case between the ex-husband Todd and Nancy that was progressing through
05:35the courts that was getting ready to come up here within the next couple weeks.
05:39So there were plenty of questions for Todd Howery.
05:43You always, you know, you start close and kind of work yourself out.
05:46So that was something that we definitely had to look into.
05:49This is Agent Peterson from Working Exercise.
05:51We're going to be speaking with Mr. Todd Howery.
05:55I ask this as a general question.
05:59I'm not accusing you. I'm not saying you've done anything.
06:01Right, I understand.
06:02But have you done anything that would have made her disappear?
06:07No, I haven't.
06:08Have you hurt her in any way and have her gone?
06:15No, I wouldn't do that.
06:17I'm not a violent person.
06:19You know, I was a wild man in my 20s, but we all are.
06:23Okay.
06:24Nancy's mother had told detectives she thought Todd was somehow involved.
06:30Why would anyone say that you were involved in her disappearance?
06:37Why would anyone say that?
06:38No one should be saying that.
06:44I wouldn't know that.
06:50I don't know why anybody would say that.
06:54Except for her mom.
06:55Her mom's a wacko, though.
06:56Her mom's going to say s*** like that.
06:58Okay? FYI.
06:59Are we going to come across anybody that maybe had a suspicion that you were involved in her?
07:03So why would they say that?
07:05You're not going to come across anybody.
07:07Okay.
07:08You're not going to come across anybody.
07:09And generally, if you get to know me, I'm a pretty easygoing, too nice a person.
07:15Okay.
07:16So?
07:17No one's going to say that.
07:18I have to ask you those questions because, you know, this is...
07:35Todd Howrey said he expected he would be accused by Nancy's mother.
07:40She blurts out to my 12-year-old that I killed their mom with no facts, no nothing.
07:45You know, how did I feel about that?
07:49Well, I was looking at Brevard County sheriffs as help.
07:57We needed help to find Nancy.
08:00And I understand that it's part of their procedure.
08:04Cool.
08:05Cool.
08:05Thank you so much.
08:06Thank you.
08:06Thank you.
08:07After about 10 or 15 minutes, they kind of figured out that it wasn't me.
08:13This is a wedding picture, the day we got married.
08:17The wonderful thing about the truth is it doesn't change.
08:21He was helpful with his information.
08:24He was, I mean, anything we asked for, he was willing to give.
08:27We wound up clearing him as a suspect at that time.
08:30So now the focus shifted to Nancy's boyfriend, Daniel Stearns,
08:34who she met online and had dated on and off for the last three years.
08:40I asked her to break up with him because he will end to kill her.
08:47She said, she left me and she said,
08:52amiga, like friend, that never happening.
08:56He is sweet.
08:58Stearns was an army veteran who had served a tour in Afghanistan.
09:01I saw his Facebook page.
09:04He take a picture with two guns and somebody took a picture behind him.
09:12And was creepy, creepy, creepy.
09:17He was vain, you know?
09:20He liked to show himself.
09:23He liked to show how strong he was.
09:36He was someone detectives needed to find.
09:48On day two of the search for Nancy Howery,
09:51officers in the neighboring town of Palm Bay
09:54were asked to approach Daniel Stearns,
09:56told to use caution.
09:58We're going to go see if Nancy is 10-12 with Daniel.
10:02He's a veteran.
10:03According to Indian Harbor, he's aggressive.
10:07And Indian Harbor is concerned that she might be in there
10:11and he's not saying anything.
10:13He wants to try to get him out there.
10:27Hello.
10:27Hello.
10:28Are you Daniel?
10:29No.
10:30Does Daniel live here?
10:31Yes.
10:32You need to see him?
10:33If you can, please.
10:34What's going on?
10:36My son.
10:37Yeah, I just need to speak to him.
10:38He's not in any trouble.
10:40Okay.
10:42Is Nancy here?
10:44She's in the bathroom.
10:45I told him you're here.
10:46Is there a female named Nancy?
10:48Nancy?
10:48Yeah.
10:49Is there a female that's in here that's...
10:50Her name is Nancy?
10:52No.
10:52Okay.
10:53But please, when you talk to my son,
10:55it's easy.
10:55He's an army, but he has a PTSD problem.
10:58That's fine.
11:02Okay.
11:02He's not in any trouble.
11:03Yeah.
11:04Just have to ask him if he knows where Nancy's at.
11:07That's it.
11:08Nancy?
11:09Yeah.
11:09I don't know.
11:10You've never heard of Nancy?
11:11Okay.
11:12Yeah.
11:12He's coming.
11:13Hey, Daniel.
11:14How you doing?
11:15How are you?
11:16I have a question.
11:17Are you familiar with Nancy?
11:19I've fallen out.
11:21You haven't spoken to her.
11:22When was the last time you spoke to her?
11:26I can say.
11:28Okay.
11:29Was it like...
11:29Has it been days, months?
11:37weeks?
11:37All right.
11:38Um...
11:39Weeks.
11:40It's been weeks?
11:41Okay.
11:42Do you know where she might be hanging out at?
11:44Because as far as I know, she was with you,
11:46so that's why we're here asking you.
11:49How would you know if she was with me?
11:51With just some information that we got from the AT&T?
11:53We got a call from Indian Harbor.
11:54If you hear from her or if she shows up,
11:56would you let us know?
11:56Because obviously Indian Harbor Beach is working, so...
11:59Okay.
11:59So, yeah, I'm probably guessing a lot of people
12:02have contacted her if she's missing.
12:04So, I mean, I don't know if I hear from her.
12:08If she shows up or you hear anything,
12:11just let us know, man.
12:12All right.
12:12Thank you.
12:17The officers thought something was off about Stearns.
12:21They kind of walked by his truck,
12:23and inside his truck was a firearm,
12:26an unsecured firearm.
12:27They asked him about it, and he said,
12:28oh, I must have just left it there.
12:30Something tells you that he's hiding something.
12:32Yeah, he's kind of...
12:33So he couldn't figure out how long it's been,
12:35and then he finally came up with six, six years ago.
12:39Yeah.
12:40Hmm.
12:41We all met here to review that Palm Bay body cam,
12:46and watching it all together,
12:48we kind of looked at each other and said,
12:49something bad happened.
12:51It was just his demeanor, his body language mainly.
12:55And detectives learned from one of Nancy's friends
12:57that Nancy had talked with Stearns on the phone
13:00just the day before she went missing on the 15th.
13:03And then Nancy said, hey, I'm going to meet him,
13:06and left, and had not heard from her since.
13:13Nancy was still missing,
13:15so Sheriff's Office detectives decided to go at Stearns again.
13:18Good morning, Daniel.
13:20Good morning.
13:20I tried calling.
13:21I don't know if you got my voicemail or not.
13:23Who now admitted he had talked with Nancy
13:26much more recently than he had first claimed.
13:29It sounds like you at least spoke on the 15th,
13:32which you were saying before that you only spoke to her a week prior from when the officers met.
13:37Yeah, yeah, it's kind of like that, but I did not really see her.
13:40What do you mean then?
13:41We never really saw her.
13:43Physically saw each other?
13:44It's not like that.
13:47What do you mean it's not like that?
13:48I'm not really physically seeing her.
13:53Every time we spoke with Daniel during the investigation,
13:57every time we met with him at his house,
13:59the story would change a little bit more and more.
14:01And the local police license plate readers revealed a surprising pattern by Stearns.
14:07Anytime law enforcement speaks with Daniel,
14:09we see that he goes out to the compound area.
14:14The compound is a 2,700-acre abandoned subdivision project.
14:19So detectives ordered up a full surveillance on Stearns,
14:23including a helicopter tracking his movements.
14:26He makes the left.
14:27That's going to go ahead out to the compound, I think.
14:29Our aviation is up in the sky at this time,
14:32and they're video recording him.
14:34I see him.
14:35I got his headlights.
14:36Okay.
14:36We'll tell you he's the only guy out here.
14:38Following his truck,
14:40the Stearns moved around the compound's empty streets.
14:45Looks like he just grabbed something out of the backseat.
14:48It might have been a shovel,
14:49and he's walking into the Northwood line currently.
14:52Aviation team is able to see that Daniel exited his vehicle with a shovel
14:55and was in the woods with a shovel at that time.
14:58The agents on the ground were,
15:00I mean, they were able to hear the shovel being used.
15:04You could see where Daniel looks up at the sky,
15:08almost like he can hear the helicopter,
15:10but he's not sure if that's what he's looking at or not.
15:12We can hear you big time.
15:14We need to try to get elevation if you can.
15:18Yeah, 10-4.
15:20But he continues digging,
15:21and he continues doing whatever he was doing there in the woods.
15:24Why would he be digging at 3 a.m. in the woods?
15:27We're not going to be able to stay here much longer.
15:30We're running pretty low on fuel.
15:32From there, our aviation actually had to get gas.
15:37They were up in the air so long.
15:39All right, so we're 10-4.
15:41We're going to have to head back to the fuel.
15:44But when the helicopter returned,
15:46as the sun began to rise,
15:48Stearns was still at it.
15:50And they were able to see that Daniel has since then
15:52moved all the way down south several miles to a canal.
15:55It looks like he might be putting something in the water.
15:58It's really hard to tell because we're about three miles out.
16:03Where he is then captured by our aviation unit
16:06using a bucket in the water
16:07and dumping whatever was in the bucket into the water.
16:10We're going to get a team put together
16:12to go in and stop him right now.
16:1710-4.
16:18He's down, like, in the water line right now.
16:21Star, he's definitely rinsing something off right now.
16:24Try not to spook him, guys.
16:27I know we're coming in hard,
16:28but try not to spook him.
16:30All right, Star.
16:31It looks like he's walking back to the vehicle
16:32and trying to get the truck back in focus here as well.
16:38Yeah, he's pretty close to his vehicle here, so
16:42he's about the edge of the wood line.
16:46Agents on the ground feared Stearns was about to leave
16:49and they moved in.
16:50I'm with you guys.
16:54Our undercover agents, they did a takedown.
16:58He complied.
16:59He immediately put the bucket down,
17:01put his hands straight up in the air,
17:02and our takedown team placed him in handcuffs with no issues.
17:07Trying to find a spot.
17:08Uh-huh.
17:08I got him right here.
17:12Uh-oh.
17:14He's in custody.
17:15He's in custody.
17:16Great job.
17:17Detectives were convinced they had caught
17:19Stearns' red-handed disposing of Nancy's body,
17:23but he told detectives he could explain everything.
17:32We're going to meet you a snack, get you some water,
17:34and then we'll be right back in here shortly,
17:35but we'll get that for you in a moment, okay?
17:41Honestly, most individuals don't want to talk,
17:45so I didn't expect him to want to talk at all.
17:49Detective Peterson started by applauding Stearns' military service.
17:54You're a decorated war veteran, okay?
17:58We know that.
17:59You're not a criminal, okay?
18:02We want to hear what you have from your side,
18:05if that makes sense, okay?
18:09Unfortunately, these are not the conditions.
18:13We're going to ask the questions.
18:15But the detective kept at it,
18:17making sure Stearns was read his rights.
18:20Anything you say can be used against you in court.
18:22If you decide to answer questions now
18:23without a lawyer present,
18:24you will still have the right to start answering at any time.
18:26You understand anything he's trying to explain to you?
18:29I got it.
18:31Is that a guess?
18:32Okay.
18:33And with these rights in mind,
18:34do you still wish to continue talking to us?
18:38I don't know.
18:39He, at that time, started questioning me on if we had evidence.
18:43This is supposed to be over a homicide, right?
18:46Well, we're trying to figure it out, Daniel.
18:49That's what we're trying to see, so.
18:52You're saying you have everything together?
18:55We wouldn't be sitting right here if we didn't.
18:56I think he wanted to know exactly what we had,
19:00so the strategy was to let him talk,
19:03give us as much as he wants to.
19:06And then, just five minutes into the interview,
19:09Stearns opened up.
19:22I was taking her to the compound to teach her how to shoot.
19:29We got there.
19:33In the middle of me showing her how to aim,
19:38she goes for my gun.
19:43She nearly gets a hold of it.
19:49She fails the first time,
19:51and she goes absolutely berserk,
19:54not wanting to take a loss for an answer.
20:00Get into a grapple.
20:02She even spits on my hand.
20:07After multiple times,
20:08I couldn't take the chance again.
20:12When you're saying she, who is she?
20:15Why do I have to say the name?
20:17Because I don't know who you're referring to.
20:19You're saying she.
20:20I mean, that could be anybody.
20:23You're referring to Nancy.
20:26I was not expecting him to just give up the information.
20:31The fact that he came out with it with self-defense
20:34kind of shows that he thought about it ahead of time.
20:37What led to her acting the way she did?
20:40What happened?
20:42It was as good as an ambush.
20:45What do you mean by that?
20:47She was close.
20:49She was next to me.
20:50Okay.
20:51So she tried to take your firearm,
20:52and what happened from there?
20:56She fought ruthlessly to take it from me.
20:59She was unresponsive to the words,
21:01stop.
21:03So as you guys were fighting,
21:04was she saying anything?
21:06She hated me.
21:10What would have led her to hate you?
21:17I feel like it was denying her
21:20power over me.
21:22Mm-hmm.
21:24She took
21:28deflections as an insult.
21:31She would
21:32continue to insult me
21:36unprovoked.
21:37Okay.
21:38So,
21:39she tried to take her gun,
21:41what went there?
21:43Yeah, okay.
21:45So, first move,
21:49grabs it.
21:51She's using her body weight.
21:57Looks like she might have been
21:58maintaining a stance.
22:01It's not working.
22:02It's in my hand.
22:05Goes for a bite.
22:07Doesn't work.
22:11So what happened from there?
22:17She advanced the end,
22:19and then I shot her.
22:22Where did you shoot her?
22:27It's in the head.
22:29How many times was that?
22:31Once.
22:34Stern said that he and Nancy
22:35had argued,
22:36and the detectives pressed him
22:38on why,
22:39looking for a motive.
22:41Her seeing other men.
22:44Is that,
22:45is that what was
22:46your concern?
22:48That she was with other men,
22:49or what was it?
22:50that she was with other men?
22:55And how do you know
22:56she was with other men?
22:57She would show me.
22:59And how would she show you?
23:02Sexually split your text messages
23:04and pictures.
23:06Okay.
23:06And what would it be of?
23:10sexual dialogue.
23:13Maybe photos.
23:15Showing me another man
23:16in the same bed.
23:17You know,
23:19I get it.
23:21Nobody would be happy about that,
23:23I wouldn't think.
23:24You know?
23:26And,
23:27correct me if I'm wrong,
23:28but over time
23:29that builds up anger.
23:32It just builds up inside me.
23:34The more she sends,
23:35the more she sends.
23:36And at what point
23:37did you decide,
23:38okay,
23:38you know what?
23:39I'm,
23:39I'm done.
23:40What,
23:40what made you feel like that?
23:46It seriously felt like
23:48my last resort.
23:50You shot her.
23:53Did you call 911?
23:56I didn't trust the law
23:58with that situation.
24:03Detectives on the scene
24:04reported back
24:05that all they found
24:05of Nancy's remains
24:07were hundreds
24:08of tiny bone fragments.
24:10And Stearns described
24:11in detail
24:12why that was.
24:14It's because I burned her.
24:19And then I buried
24:21the remains.
24:23Was she
24:25in full body form
24:27or did you
24:28do anything to
24:31her body from there?
24:32Okay.
24:34Okay.
24:35Vultures came.
24:36Okay.
24:39And once you burned her,
24:41what,
24:41what,
24:42what followed
24:43behind that?
24:44Take the ashes
24:45and bury her.
24:47Take the
24:48ash and bone
24:49and bury it.
24:50where you found me.
24:54I was cleaning
24:55the buckets
24:56that held her ashes.
24:57It was,
24:58it was very surprising.
25:01Not only because
25:02he,
25:03he
25:05admitted
25:06to,
25:06to being there,
25:07not only did
25:08he admit to shooting,
25:09but he also
25:10actually pointed out
25:11different areas
25:12in the compound
25:13where he
25:14did stuff.
25:15And the most surprising
25:16thing about that
25:16was how accurate
25:17he was.
25:18now the detectives
25:19were ready to
25:20close out
25:21the interrogation.
25:22I don't know
25:23if I believe that,
25:23Daniel.
25:26You know
25:26that's not what
25:27happened.
25:28There's not a
25:28mother of two,
25:31not physically fit
25:32lady that
25:33caught you off guard
25:34when you have
25:34military training
25:35on know how to
25:36keep your firearm
25:37and keep it.
25:37But I feel like
25:39it wasn't a
25:40self-defense
25:41like you're saying.
25:44there's something
25:45you're not,
25:46you're holding back
25:47and,
25:47and I understand
25:48that.
25:49I understand
25:50that she
25:51has made you
25:52mad.
25:52Tinder messages,
25:54you receiving
25:54these nude pics
25:55from her
25:57and other guys
25:58made you mad.
26:01I refuse to
26:01answer questions
26:02at this time.
26:05So you no longer
26:06want to speak
26:07anymore?
26:08Trying to put
26:09words in my mouth.
26:11That's not what
26:12I'm doing.
26:12I'm trying to
26:12figure this out.
26:13Well, I'm done.
26:14Okay.
26:17We'll be back
26:18here shortly.
26:20Detectives left
26:21the room confident
26:22they had the
26:23confession they
26:23needed to charge
26:25Daniel Stearns
26:26with Nancy's
26:27murder.
26:28First of all,
26:29this case took
26:30a sad turn
26:30from missing
26:31person to
26:32homicide.
26:33Late last
26:34night,
26:34our team
26:34arrested
26:35Daniel Stearn
26:36on second
26:37degree murder
26:38with a firearm
26:38tampering with
26:39evidence.
26:39and mutilation
26:41of a dead
26:41body.
26:42But a few
26:43months before
26:44trial,
26:44the case
26:45started to
26:46fall apart.
26:53Then we're
26:54going to start
26:54Daniel Stearns.
26:55A routine
26:56pretrial hearing
26:57for Daniel
26:58Stearns
26:58turned into
26:59a disaster
27:00for the
27:01prosecution.
27:03First issue
27:03is whether
27:04or not
27:05it was right
27:06for being
27:06silent.
27:07Stearns's
27:08lawyer
27:08claimed that
27:09his confession
27:10video should
27:11be thrown
27:11out.
27:12He invoked
27:13his right
27:14to remain
27:14silent at
27:15the very
27:15beginning
27:16before they
27:16even read
27:17him
27:17Miranda.
27:19Fortunately,
27:20these are not
27:21the conditions
27:22for me to ask
27:23the questions.
27:25Then this
27:26will not be
27:26the time
27:29that I would
27:30ask the questions.
27:36The court
27:37determined that
27:38anytime somebody
27:40says they
27:41don't want
27:41to talk,
27:42that that's
27:43pretty much
27:44an unequivocal
27:45invocation of
27:47your right to
27:47remain silent.
27:48I believe the
27:49defendant's
27:49statement should
27:50be suppressed.
27:52Once that
27:53statement was
27:54out completely,
27:55we had to
27:56determine,
27:58can we prove
27:59that he killed
28:00her?
28:01All that
28:01they had
28:02recovered from
28:02the scene
28:03for evidence
28:03were hundreds
28:04of tiny bone
28:05fragments.
28:07They were
28:08as small
28:09as, you
28:11know, an
28:11inch or so
28:14up to the
28:15largest piece
28:16was maybe
28:18the size of
28:19my hand.
28:20And a few
28:21of the larger
28:22pieces would
28:22be crucial.
28:24The skull
28:25pieces that
28:26were recovered
28:26by the crime
28:27scene, one of
28:28them was her
28:28frontal lobe,
28:29and the
28:30forensic
28:31anthropologist
28:31would determine
28:33that the
28:34bullet hole
28:34was an exit.
28:35So that's not
28:37particularly
28:37self-defense-y,
28:39it's more
28:40execution-style
28:41murder.
28:45We're in
28:46Florida this
28:46hour for our
28:47latest live
28:48trial called
28:49the Scattered
28:49Remains Murder
28:50Trial for
28:51Daniel Stearns.
28:52Without
28:53Stearns'
28:54confession and
28:55no body or
28:56murder weapon,
28:57the evidence
28:57did not support
28:58a charge of
28:59first-degree murder.
29:00He was charged
29:01with second-degree
29:02murder, which
29:03in Florida is
29:03punishable by
29:04life in prison.
29:06Nancy Howery,
29:07a 44-year-old
29:09divorced mother
29:10of two children,
29:11was last seen
29:12alive on
29:13February 15,
29:142023.
29:16That was the
29:17day that this
29:18defendant, Daniel
29:20Stearns, murdered
29:21her.
29:22Ms. Howery had
29:23been dating
29:24the defendant
29:24on and
29:25off for
29:25several months.
29:26They had
29:27a volatile
29:27relationship that
29:29he wanted to
29:30be exclusive,
29:31but that was
29:32not.
29:33And the
29:34prosecutor
29:34described the
29:35helicopter
29:36surveillance video
29:37of Stearns
29:37seemingly disposing
29:39of Nancy's
29:40burnt remains.
29:41I told
29:42them that
29:43the defendant
29:44tried to
29:45erase her
29:47from this
29:47earth, but
29:48she wasn't
29:50going to go
29:50away that
29:51easily.
29:52So I ask
29:53simply that
29:54you listen
29:55carefully to
29:56all of the
29:56evidence and
29:57you will find
29:58this defendant,
29:59Daniel Stearns,
30:00guilty as
30:01charged of
30:02the second
30:03degree murder
30:03of Nancy
30:04Howery, of
30:05the abuse of
30:06her dead
30:07human body,
30:08and tampering
30:09with physical
30:09evidence.
30:10Thank you.
30:12He was
30:14eerily calm
30:15throughout the
30:16trial.
30:16He maintained
30:17his military
30:18bearing.
30:19He was just
30:19sitting there
30:20like he was
30:21at attention,
30:21just looking
30:22forward,
30:24and hardly
30:25moving, hardly
30:26saying anything.
30:28Defense.
30:30Defense would
30:31reserve their
30:31opening to the
30:32beginning of the
30:32defense's case.
30:34Thank you.
30:35They don't want
30:36to put all their
30:37cards on the
30:38table at that
30:39point, and
30:40they don't have
30:40to.
30:41State, may
30:41call your
30:41first witness?
30:43State.
30:45Nancy's
30:46ex-husband,
30:47Todd Howery,
30:47was the
30:48state's lead-off
30:49witness.
30:49It was the
30:50first time he
30:51had come face
30:52to face with
30:53her alleged
30:53killer.
30:54He avoided
30:54eye contact
30:55with me.
30:56I'm not going
30:58to avoid eye
30:59contact with him
31:00whatsoever.
31:01Somebody who
31:02would do that
31:02to another
31:03human being
31:03is not
31:05normal.
31:06Howery described
31:07the panic their
31:08two children
31:09felt when their
31:10mother twice
31:11failed to pick
31:12them up at
31:12school.
31:13Uh, I
31:14text messaged
31:16Nancy, basically
31:18saying, you're
31:19scaring us, please
31:21reach out.
31:24Um, and then we
31:26went to the police
31:27department when she
31:28did not respond.
31:29Okay, so there
31:29was no response
31:30from as of
31:32February 15th,
31:332023 onward.
31:35I believe it was
31:37the morning of
31:38the 15th that my
31:40daughter last heard
31:41from her.
31:43I don't have any
31:44additional questions.
31:45Thank you, Your
31:45Honor.
31:47Howery says he has
31:48worked hard to help
31:49his children deal with
31:50their mother's murder.
31:51I myself was in
31:54shock how someone
31:56who I was married
31:57to, somebody who
31:58I loved, it's
31:59without a doubt
32:00that if my children
32:01were with her that
32:02day, he would
32:03have done the same
32:03thing with them.
32:05And that is, is
32:09something that even
32:09today, um, I
32:12become very guarded
32:13of my children.
32:14But the state's
32:15most important
32:16witness was still
32:17to come, the
32:18forensic anthropologist
32:19who had reassembled
32:21what was left of
32:22Nancy's skull to
32:23prove she had been
32:24murdered.
32:32All right, you
32:33may have a seat.
32:34We're back on the
32:34record in the state
32:35of Florida versus
32:35Daniel Stearns,
32:362023 CF 18918.
32:39Please introduce
32:40yourself to the jury.
32:41Uh, my name's
32:42Neal Lee.
32:42I'm an agent for
32:43the Brevard County
32:44Sheriff's Office.
32:46Prosecutors called
32:46Agent Lee to
32:47introduce the body
32:48cam videos of
32:49Stearns changing
32:50his story again and
32:52again about when he
32:53last saw Nancy
32:54Howery.
32:56Did he tell you
32:57anything new or
32:58anything inconsistent
32:59with what he had
33:00previously told you
33:01two days before on
33:02March 6th?
33:03Yes, he did.
33:05And what was that?
33:06Um, initially he
33:08had, uh, mentioned
33:09during the previous
33:10interview that he had
33:11not, uh, spoken to
33:13Miss Howery for about
33:15a week.
33:15His whole demeanor and
33:17speech pattern is
33:18very unusual and
33:19strange.
33:20Um, they're trying to
33:21get information out of
33:22him, asking him simple
33:24questions that if he's
33:25telling the truth
33:25wouldn't be difficult
33:26to answer.
33:27So where are you?
33:29That should be it.
33:29So I was like around
33:31there.
33:31So you're around
33:32here and what,
33:34where did you see
33:35her?
33:36She turned in.
33:37And his story is not
33:39consistent with what he
33:40said originally.
33:46So ultimately he puts
33:48himself with her on the
33:51day of her disappearance,
33:51the last day she was
33:52seen alive by anyone
33:53else.
33:54He was angered at how
33:56their relationship was
33:57going and how she wasn't
33:59being exclusive with him
34:00the way he wanted her
34:01to.
34:04And the prosecutor
34:05showed the jury the
34:06helicopter surveillance
34:08video of Stearns at the
34:09compound.
34:15Driving to the four
34:17different parts in the
34:18compound where we found
34:18the body parts and showing
34:20him trying to dispose of
34:22her body in the river.
34:24That was a strong piece of
34:26evidence that tied him to
34:27the scene, tied him to all
34:29the body parts and would
34:30have been indisputable.
34:37my name is Dr.
34:38Heather Walsh Haney.
34:41And to prove that there was
34:43indeed a murder, the state
34:44would rely on its forensic
34:46anthropologist who had
34:47sorted through some 800 human
34:50skeletal remains.
34:51On the frontal bone above the
34:54right orbit, a little to the
34:56right of it, I noticed a
34:58wound.
34:58It was a semi-circular defect
35:00with external beveling.
35:02So an exit?
35:05It's consistent with an exit.
35:07Okay.
35:07She was able to find entry
35:09wound and an exit wound.
35:10She was able to take those two
35:12different pieces and place
35:13those on a model of a skull,
35:15which was the evidence we
35:17needed to present to the jury
35:18that not only was Ms.
35:20Howie murdered, but the cause
35:22of death was a gunshot wound
35:23to the head.
35:26Based upon my training,
35:28education, and experience,
35:29this was consistent with a
35:33gunshot exit wound.
35:35All right.
35:36Any further questions?
35:37Thank you very much.
35:39On cross-examination, the
35:41defense sought to raise
35:42reasonable doubt.
35:43Is it possible that this
35:45injury is actually something
35:46other than a gunshot wound?
35:47Based on my training,
35:50education, and experience,
35:51this is consistent with a
35:53gunshot wound.
35:54I agree it's consistent
35:55with a gunshot wound.
35:56It's possible that it's
35:57consistent with, is it
35:58consistent with something
35:59else?
36:02So, is it probable it's
36:04something else, Mr. Fisher?
36:05Um, I don't think so.
36:07Is it possible?
36:08Yes.
36:09She was the final witness
36:11for the prosecution.
36:13All right.
36:14Mr. Stearns, will you
36:15please raise your right
36:15hand?
36:15I need to ask you some
36:16questions.
36:18Now, the defense had to
36:19decide if Stearns would
36:20take the stand.
36:21The only way he could
36:23claim he killed Nancy in
36:24self-defense, as he had in
36:26the now suppressed
36:27interrogation tape.
36:29It was self-defense.
36:31What ironically ended up
36:32happening by the defense
36:34moving to suppress that
36:35statement, they suppressed
36:37their own defense.
36:38Unless Stearns would
36:39testify.
36:40The jury would need to
36:42somehow understand why the
36:44defendant believed his life
36:45was in danger or why he
36:47believed he would have been
36:48justified or needed to use
36:50that deadly force.
36:51Your attorney has just
36:52advised me that you intend
36:54not to testify.
36:56Is the decision not to
36:57testify your own decision?
36:58Yes.
37:00How does the defense wish to
37:02proceed?
37:03Depends for us.
37:05So, no witnesses at all
37:07for the defense, and
37:09prosecutors wondered, what
37:10would his lawyer say to the
37:12jury in their closing
37:13arguments?
37:14It would be hard to deny
37:15that he was there disposing
37:18of the body when he was
37:19caught red-handed by the
37:20police, and then say, but
37:23that doesn't prove that he
37:24killed her.
37:24We don't know who the real
37:25killer is.
37:26So I was concerned that that
37:27was going to be sort of their
37:29angle.
37:41The attorneys now will
37:43present their final arguments.
37:44State, you may proceed.
37:47Not every case has an
37:49eyewitness.
37:50Not every case is on video
37:53when the crime is being
37:55committed.
37:56But that's why the standard in
37:57a criminal case is beyond
37:59all reasonable doubt.
38:02Not all possible doubt.
38:05Okay?
38:06With this trial, we had a
38:08whole bunch of smaller
38:09puzzle pieces.
38:10So when we wrapped up our
38:12case and finally were able
38:14to present it to the jury,
38:15we were just hoping that the
38:18jury was able to absorb
38:19everything.
38:20The surveillance video, the
38:22shifting stories to police,
38:24and the forensic showing a
38:25bullet exit wound.
38:26The defendant wants you to
38:29imagine a scenario where she
38:31somehow accidentally got shot
38:33and the exit wound is out her
38:36frontal bone of her skull.
38:38And he wants you to force
38:39yourself to believe that this
38:42defendant lied to the police
38:43all those times because he was
38:45innocent.
38:47You're allowed to use your
38:49common sense and find this
38:52defendant, Daniel Stearns,
38:54guilty of second-degree murder
38:56with a firearm, the abuse of the
38:59human body, and the tampering
39:01with evidence.
39:02Thank you.
39:03For the defense, the lack of
39:05evidence was the evidence of
39:07innocence.
39:07The core issue of this case is
39:10what happened?
39:13What happened in this case?
39:16And the answer is, you don't know
39:19because the state hasn't given you
39:22evidence as to what happened.
39:23Not a single witness has ever said
39:25that he shot her in the head
39:27because it's consistent with her
39:30shooting herself.
39:32It's consistent with an accident.
39:35It's consistent with any number of
39:38other events.
39:39and the core problem here is that
39:43the state must prove what
39:46happened.
39:48And they haven't done it.
39:51Therefore, he must return a verdict
39:53of not guilty.
39:54All right.
39:55Members of the jury, you are now
39:57released to deliberate.
40:00I have received an alarm.
40:02I have been told we have a verdict.
40:04The jury was out for two and a half
40:06hours.
40:07State of Florida versus Daniel
40:09Lawrence Stearns.
40:10We the jury find those calls as
40:12account one of the charge.
40:19The defendant, Daniel Lawrence
40:21Stearns, is guilty of second-degree
40:23murder when they filed.
40:26Stone-faced, stoic, eerily calm.
40:31No reaction.
40:32The same way he was throughout the
40:34entire trial.
40:39We are here today for sentencing.
40:44All of his family was there.
40:50Good afternoon, ma'am.
40:51My name is Gloria Stearns.
40:53Ms. Stearns, how do you know my
40:56client, Daniel Stearns?
40:57It's my son.
40:59What did you want to put together
41:00today in 77?
41:02Something to say.
41:04I just want to tell him.
41:06I love him.
41:07I miss him.
41:09And I was going to be there for him
41:11when he needs me.
41:12And I want to say sorry for the other
41:16party.
41:18I felt, I did feel really bad for his
41:21mom because she was clearly heartbroken.
41:25No one thinks they're going to end up being
41:28the mother of a murderer.
41:29I feel bad for them, but not as bad as I
41:32feel for Nancy Howery's children.
41:37Mr. Howery is going to present a victim
41:40impact statement on behalf of his children
41:42that he shared with Ms. Howery.
41:46Now my children don't have a mom.
41:50They don't have a mom to share birthdays
41:51with.
41:52My daughter doesn't have a mom to share
41:55prom with.
41:57Wedding day.
41:58Same with my son.
42:00We would love to have the death penalty.
42:02We would love that.
42:03But we realize this is not a capital case.
42:06With a second degree murder conviction,
42:08the judge had the discretion to impose a
42:10sentence between 22 years to life in
42:13prison.
42:15Mr. Stearns, if you please rise.
42:19As to count one second degree murder
42:22reclassified, I'm going to send it to
42:25you for a term of imprisonment of your
42:27natural life.
42:28In Florida, there is no parole.
42:31It was the maximum possible sentence.
42:34This was a, this was a mother who,
42:37who disappeared and now there's two young
42:40children who will no longer have a
42:42mother in their lives.
42:46There's a hole in that family that can
42:48never be replaced.
42:50Someone who does that to another human
42:51being is demented, is defective.
42:56He's going to spend a lot of time in a
42:59small box.
43:00for you.
43:02Don't you see what it is?
43:03Don't you see that man?
43:03I'm not.
43:04Don't you see what it is.
43:04See you then.
43:04I'm going to be a man.
43:04You're missing this.
43:06I'm going to be a woman.
43:10I'm going to be a man.
43:10Sous-titrage FR ?