• il y a 1 heure
Watch Murder on Trial, Season 2 Episode 1 on Dailymotion (2026).

Catégorie

📺
TV
Transcription
00:00C'est parti.
00:30Her boyfriend said Stephanie had threatened suicide.
00:32She texted me saying that I feel so helpless.
00:35My family's...
00:38Nobody in my family gives a f*** about me.
00:41But then the boyfriend leaves the country for the Philippines and some new women.
00:47He had met them through some type of dating website.
00:50Oftentimes the nature of the conversation was sexual.
00:54A way to deal with his grief or a motive for murder.
00:59He didn't do anything.
01:00How do you know that?
01:01I would feel safer if you never saw this gentleman again.
01:249-1-1. What's the address of the emergency?
01:26It's the Orthopedic Hospital of Wisconsin on Gulf Road.
01:30Tell me exactly what happened.
01:31We found a dead body in the woods when we were putting up stakes for no trespassing signs.
01:37It was a Friday.
01:39Our captain called.
01:40They have what appears to be the mummified remains of a human probably 20 or so feet into the tree
01:48line.
01:49My name is Brian Fredericks.
01:50I'm a detective with the Waukesha County Sheriff's Department.
01:53This individual had been out there for an unknown amount of time.
01:56She had no identification, no purse.
02:00Unusual for ladies to leave or go anywhere without their purse.
02:04At the scene, detectives only had a ring and a pair of shoes to go on.
02:08And there were no outstanding missing persons reports on file.
02:13I'm Detective Nathan Plentis with the Waukesha County Sheriff's Department.
02:16We didn't know if necessarily it could be someone that maybe was homeless, who had passed there.
02:21Maybe they had been staying there.
02:22The following day, there was an autopsy done.
02:24The body was in such bad shape that the medical examiner could not even determine if the death was accidental,
02:31a suicide, or a homicide.
02:34We didn't really know what we had.
02:36And to identify the body, detectives had to rely on several tattoos.
02:41There was like a rose on the arm.
02:45And a tattoo of the letter J on one of her ankles.
02:49Anyone who's been incarcerated in the past, there's a database that maintains, you know, scars, marks, tattoos, identifying information.
02:57And there was a match with the tattoos of a Stephanie Pavlons, a 44-year-old woman who had been
03:04in prison on drug charges.
03:07And then we went out and met with Stephanie's parents.
03:12I was just in total shock.
03:41Stephanie's parents had not seen or heard from their daughter for at least a year.
03:45At least three weeks.
03:48Always wanted us to know that she was a private person, that she didn't really want to, want to talk.
03:55She didn't want to share anything.
03:58But detectives did find that Stephanie shared everything with a journal she kept.
04:03And that became a key part of the investigation.
04:06She had talked of suicide or made statements.
04:13We've seen that in her diary and her journals.
04:17Making statements like, I hate my life.
04:19I wish I wasn't alive anymore.
04:22My name is Sue Opper.
04:23I was the elected district attorney here for Waukesha County.
04:28She was extremely isolated.
04:31She had no best friend.
04:32She had no sister.
04:33She had a relationship with her mother, but they were not close.
04:38Very sad.
04:38But Stephanie did have a longtime boyfriend, Matthew Paul.
04:43She was in her 20, early 20s when she met Matt.
04:47They had a child together in 2003, a daughter named Layla.
04:52He was 12 years her senior.
04:54She worked with him, lived with him, and he was kind of a stabling influence.
04:59But Stephanie wrote in her journal that her relationship with Paul had turned ugly and violent.
05:06How degraded she felt, how humiliated she felt.
05:11She's basically a prisoner.
05:14Even though she's, you know, walking, talking, breathing, she felt so lonely, so afraid at times.
05:24And they later found photos Stephanie had taken on her phone.
05:28With bruising to her face, to her chest, on the day of where she stayed she was being attacked by
05:34Matthew.
05:35So, detectives brought in Stephanie's boyfriend, Matthew Paul.
05:38Well, we definitely wanted to talk to Mr. Paul because, according to the parents, he, in fact, was the last
05:44person that the parents had said she was alive with.
05:50The detectives did not tell him they had found Stephanie's body.
05:53You don't want to give him any information.
05:55You want him to think that you don't necessarily know.
05:57All we told Matthew is that, hey, she's missing.
06:00What do you know about her?
06:01When was the last time you saw her?
06:03Let's talk about Stephanie.
06:05What is she to you?
06:09Oh, my God.
06:13Stephanie is the mother of my daughter.
06:16And you guys already know that.
06:19It was a largely let him talk.
06:21Almost from the get-go, he wanted to talk about Stephanie's mental health problems and addiction problems.
06:27When I've been with her, this is well-documented with her doctors.
06:34It's well-documented with the suicide attempts that she's made in numerous places.
06:46But that was basically his story, that she was addicted to many medications, many prescription medications, depressed and suicidal, erratic,
06:56and that type of behavior.
06:58I also have documentation.
07:02I call the suicide line.
07:04She attempted to slash her wrist.
07:08When was that?
07:10She started this stuff three or four years ago.
07:16I would say the last year, she was just, since the beginning of the year, she was just out of
07:24control.
07:25With what?
07:25Like as far as what?
07:26It's just threatening, threatening suicide all the time.
07:31Threatening suicide all the time.
07:33Slashing her wrist.
07:39And it really, it really got to me.
07:46It was really a serious situation.
07:50Well, it sounds like it.
07:51I mean, taking a bunch of pills like that and slashing her wrist.
07:54What was she being like?
07:55Why was she depressed?
07:56What was she feeling that way from?
07:59She just wanted to be a mother.
08:01And Paul revealed that the couple's daughter, Layla, now an adult, had been taken away from them by the state
08:08when she was only nine years old.
08:11There was alleged drug activity by both Stephanie and Matt and allegations of abuse or neglect for their daughter to
08:19the point where the courts became involved and Layla was actually placed to live with Stephanie's parents.
08:26And they basically raised Layla, I believe, from about the age nine on up.
08:32Paul said Stephanie never got over losing custody of her daughter.
08:36She texted me saying that I feel so helpless.
08:39My family's, nobody in my family gives a s*** about me.
08:45Now, at about 50 minutes into the interview, Matthew Paul asked for a bathroom break.
08:51When the interview resumes, Paul now has a question for the detectives.
08:57Guys, what's the deal?
09:07Am I walking out of here tonight, or am I going to tell you that I'm going to be an
09:11attorney?
09:13I don't know.
09:14Are you asking for an attorney, man?
09:16Again, we're trying to figure out what we can find out about Stephanie.
09:21That's our focus.
09:22Are you charging me with something?
09:24Am I charging you with nothing?
09:25No.
09:26Are you charging me with something?
09:27No.
09:29We haven't accused you of anything.
09:31You guys are a lot of, a lot of lies.
09:33I mean, I'm not, we're not charging you with anything.
09:38We're here asking you questions about Stephanie, and that's it.
09:44It's, I know there's, I didn't do anything.
09:47There's nothing.
09:48We're not accusing you of that.
09:49There's nothing to do.
09:51The friendly interview was about to become a deadly serious interrogation.
10:03That interview went for about three hours.
10:07We tried to pin him down on timeline with regards to when he last saw her.
10:11It's been over, over a couple of weeks.
10:15I don't remember exactly.
10:19Why, where is she?
10:20Any time he would be pressed, he would change the subject.
10:24He would, you know, blow his nose and cover his mouth.
10:33You don't know where she is?
10:35Do you remember the last time you saw her?
10:40No, weeks ago, weeks ago.
10:42And I'm sick to my stomach.
10:45Why is that?
10:48Because I have a bad feeling.
10:50And Paul said he never reported Stephanie missing because, as someone with a criminal record, he thought he would be
10:57blamed.
10:58And I was also thinking about coming in and making some tender report, but with all the things that have
11:04happened to me in the past, I started thinking, you know, right away, you know.
11:10This isn't, this isn't right away, they're going to, oh, this isn't about, this isn't so much about you, it's
11:16about Stephanie.
11:17Matthew Paul lived at this apartment complex in Waukesha, and what he did not know was that the detectives had
11:24put together a video timeline.
11:26The last day, they believe, Stephanie was alive, August 23rd.
11:31About 8.30 in the morning, Stephanie exited through one door of the apartment building, seen on camera, recorded on
11:39camera.
11:39She's wearing the exact same clothing that she was found in on September 9th.
11:44The purse she was carrying, and then a very distinctive pink water bottle.
11:50Matthew leaves through another door.
11:55Mr. Paul did not want to be seen leaving the apartment with Stephanie because he was not allowed to have
12:03a rooming.
12:04The dash cam on Paul's truck showed what happened next.
12:09You see Stephanie standing there, and you see him pull up to her.
12:15Cell phone data showed they were both in the truck together, stopping at a gas station convenience store.
12:23Stephanie goes into the store, and you can see her in the store.
12:27She does not seem distraught, upset.
12:30More importantly, she does not seem impaired or under the influence of any drugs.
12:34Makes a minor purchase, I think, of some breakfast food, and goes back out to the truck and sits in
12:41the truck.
12:42You can see her in the truck.
12:44You can see somebody in the driver's seat, presumably Matthew Paul.
12:49And then she gets out and makes a deposit into the trash can.
12:59Gets back into the truck, and they leave together in the truck from the gas station.
13:13That is the last time she is known to be alive that we can document.
13:17Their next stop was the orthopedic hospital, where Paul had an appointment for a broken foot.
13:23He goes in alone.
13:26She stayed in the truck?
13:28Yeah, she stayed in the truck.
13:30You finished your appointments?
13:32Yeah.
13:32Come out of your truck, and then what?
13:35She's gone.
13:36She's not in the truck anymore?
13:37She's gone, yeah.
13:39Stephanie's body would be found about 400 feet from the clinic parking lot.
13:44When you got back out to your truck, ma'am, and she wasn't there, did you go in the building?
13:49Did you check her out?
13:50What, ma'am? What's going on, ma'am?
13:51That's what we're trying to find out, ma'am.
13:54Okay?
13:54Like you said, when you came out here...
13:56What happened?
13:57That's what we're trying to figure out, ma'am.
13:58The surveillance video at Paul's apartment building shows him returning alone about three hours later.
14:07He walks in cool as a cucumber, and he's carrying the pink water bottle.
14:20He goes into the apartment, changes his shirt, and about 10 or 15 minutes later goes back out to his
14:25truck,
14:26and now he comes in, and he's carrying a plastic grocery bag.
14:30Her purse, we believe, was in the plastic grocery bag.
14:40He's now bringing back into the apartment.
14:43I see you coming back the same day at 11.14, okay?
14:48Hold on, listen, man.
14:50You're holding her water bottle.
14:52This is the same day.
14:55At 12.29, so less than an hour later, you walk in,
15:00and that's her purse in the bag.
15:03So you carried in her water bottle and her purse that same day?
15:07It's not her purse in the bag.
15:09It is her purse in the bag.
15:10No, it's clothes.
15:11It's clothes, ma'am?
15:12It's clothes.
15:13Whose clothes?
15:14Yeah.
15:15That's clothes that I had in the bag.
15:16That's not a purse.
15:17It is her purse, ma'am.
15:18No, it's not.
15:19It's not.
15:22It's not her purse.
15:23How do you figure, ma'am?
15:25Because it's not.
15:26That's a bag.
15:26Can I show you something?
15:27It's a bag of clothes.
15:28I'm going to show you something, ma'am.
15:29Okay?
15:30See, I knew you guys were going to do this.
15:32But what the problem is is...
15:34I knew you guys were going to do this.
15:34That's why I should...
15:35Nobody's doing anything.
15:37You're the one.
15:37Just showing you a purse.
15:38Can I show you something?
15:39That's her purse right there, right?
15:41You see that?
15:43Yeah.
15:43You see that?
15:44Yeah.
15:45What is this?
15:46Matt, Matt, Matt.
15:47Matt, Matt.
15:47Matt, Matt.
15:48Paul was shown a photo of her purse found during the search of his apartment,
15:52carried out while he was being interviewed.
15:55That's her purse, okay?
15:58So we're not going to play games about it's not her purse.
16:00It is her purse, okay?
16:01We know it's her purse.
16:03Regardless, I have nothing to do with what happened to her.
16:08What happened to her?
16:08So that purse...
16:10What happened to her?
16:10That purse and water bottle ain't...
16:12Matt, what happened to her?
16:14That purse and water bottle ain't...
16:17Yeah?
16:17Okay?
16:18Yeah?
16:18That's not going to prove anything.
16:19We're not...
16:20That's not going to prove or disprove anything.
16:22Agreed.
16:23Matt, what happened to her?
16:26Only you can tell us.
16:28I don't know what happened to her.
16:31If you're going to charge me, charge me.
16:34I didn't do anything.
16:36You're the only one who can give us info about her.
16:38I can't be honest.
16:38So we can get an answer to her family.
16:40I can't be honest.
16:41What?
16:42What do you mean you can't be honest?
16:43You've been honest?
16:44I can't be honest.
16:45You haven't been honest.
16:46Because you keep everything that I say...
16:49We're not twisting anything you say.
16:49You keep twisting anything.
16:50All we're doing is pointing out the inconsistencies on what you say.
16:53I can't remember everything.
16:55I didn't do nothing to this girl, regardless of the purse, regardless of the purses, regardless
16:59of the stupid water bottle.
17:01Okay, I have to get an attorney.
17:04Hey, Matthew.
17:09I'm trying.
17:11I don't think you are.
17:12No.
17:12You're not.
17:13You're lying.
17:15We gave you an opportunity to be truthful with us.
17:17Yeah, and I was.
17:19You asked for an attorney, man.
17:20We're done, right?
17:21We'll be in touch with you in the next couple weeks.
17:22That's what I can promise you.
17:25Okay?
17:27That's fine, you know.
17:28I can promise you.
17:29I didn't do anything.
17:30So you say.
17:31So I know.
17:32Okay.
17:33So I know.
17:34Okay.
17:34We had no physical evidence.
17:36We had no confession.
17:38We had no eyewitnesses.
17:39And so we weren't in a position to be able to charge him with anything.
17:42And so we let him walk out the door.
17:45But detectives continued to track Paul and thought they would be notified by Homeland Security
17:51if he tried to leave the country.
17:53Unfortunately, we weren't notified.
17:55I don't know what happened.
17:56It wasn't the best feeling in the world.
17:58And he was soon heading to the Philippines, where Paul planned to start a new life with a new woman.
18:12Matthew Paul went to a small town out of Manila in the Philippines, looking for love, to meet women he
18:18had met online.
18:20He had met them through some type of dating website.
18:23Oftentimes, the nature of the conversation was sexual.
18:31Hi, good morning.
18:32Good morning, Sherrilyn.
18:33How are you all?
18:35I'm good.
18:37One of the women Paul spent time with was Sherrilyn Valente, who Philippines police brought in for a Zoom interview
18:44with the Waukesha detectives.
18:46Chi-Lynn, what do you expect from this?
18:49What do you and Matthew got a life plan?
18:52Is that the goal?
18:56Of course.
18:57That's the goal?
19:01We live in Cornwall.
19:03What's that?
19:04In our relationship, yes.
19:06Okay.
19:07In our relationship, yes.
19:09To live over there?
19:11Was he going to move in by you or are you going to come to America?
19:14Um, when he moved here, he was just enjoying the place.
19:21So we're not, um, no, no particular plan yet.
19:27But so he was just, you know, trying to enjoy the place.
19:32And Sherrilyn said she met Paul well before Stephanie's death.
19:36And he talked about the investigation.
19:38He was just telling me he was having, he was just telling me he was having anxiety because, you know,
19:44But he might be, um, blamed for anything that he didn't do, you know?
19:52He told you that he might be blamed for something he didn't do?
19:55Yeah.
19:57He didn't say he might be blamed.
20:00He said he was blamed.
20:02Actually, he was blamed.
20:04He didn't do anything.
20:05How do you know that?
20:06I was with him.
20:08How do you know that?
20:09Because I know the person deeply.
20:13I know the person.
20:14You know him on some fantasy website.
20:18I'm not trying to be rude, but you don't know the gentleman.
20:22And I use that term loosely.
20:25No, we, we met here.
20:29Yep.
20:30After Stephanie.
20:30You know, we met here, so.
20:32And the detectives told Sherrilyn about Matt's treatment of Stephanie.
20:36You would hit her.
20:37You would throw things at her.
20:39I remember Stephanie, um, had a problem with her ears.
20:44Yeah, because Matt hit her with a bottle.
20:47And then the detectives sent a crime scene photo of Stephanie's body.
20:51This is how we found Stephanie, your friend.
20:54Stephanie.
20:59If you still think that she committed suicide, that's how she was found.
21:05I would feel safer if you never saw this gentleman again for your own well-being, to be honest with
21:13you.
21:14To the surprise and great relief of detectives, Paul returned to the United States some 10 months after Stephanie had
21:22disappeared.
21:22His visa was, was up and he had to return to the United States.
21:26And upon his arrival back to the Los Angeles airport, uh, I believe it was Detective Plentis got a call
21:32in the middle of the night from Homeland saying he's back.
21:37And, uh, uh, Detective Plentis was very surprised because we didn't know he had left.
21:42And Paul went right back to Waukesha, still living in the same apartment building.
21:49He might have thought, hey, they're not after me anymore, uh, I'm home free, it's, you know, it's been this
21:56long.
21:57I truly don't know what he was thinking, but we got very, very lucky.
22:00And once he was back in the country, we tried to really speed up the process and make sure that
22:05we were going to be able to issue charges before he tried to leave again.
22:09But there was a major legal hurdle.
22:12We had the final reports from the medical examiner saying, you know, we can't determine cause or manner of death.
22:19Stephanie's remains were just too deteriorated.
22:22So without that evidence, we had to really take a look at the evidence that we did have, the circumstantial
22:28evidence in his phone, in his computer, the surveillance video.
22:32The forensics team found a search in Paul's Internet history for Stephanie's obituary.
22:38Long before Stephanie's body was found.
22:42And detectives discovered a video from the dash cam in Paul's truck, showing that he had driven by the crime
22:48scene the day Stephanie's body was discovered.
22:51Undercutting his claim, he knew nothing about it.
22:55I don't know what happened to her.
22:58Paul claimed he was only on his way to the hospital for his broken foot.
23:02Why were you at the place on the 9th? You didn't have an appointment at the end?
23:15And Paul told detectives that when he went to wash his truck, he found a note from Stephanie under the
23:21floor mat, implying it was maybe a suicide note.
23:25She said that I'm tired of everybody, I hate everybody, I hate you, I hate my parents, I'm f***ing everybody,
23:40you know, that type of language.
23:44That note's in your truck now?
23:47Yeah.
23:51Detectives later retrieved the note in a search of the truck.
23:54We did not conclude it was a suicide note.
23:56We declared it as a Dear John letter.
23:59She was telling him off.
24:00She was saying, I'm done with you.
24:01I'm tired of the abuse.
24:02I'm tired of the way you treat me.
24:04In other words, I'm moving on.
24:06I think in a fit of rage, he could not control himself, and he either strangled her or caused some
24:14type of injury to her that he killed her.
24:19Almost a year to the day since her body was found, Matthew Paul was charged with the murder of Stephanie.
24:26Prosecutors charged Matthew Paul with killing his longtime girlfriend, Stephanie Pavlons, and hiding her body.
24:32The defendant at one point saying in court, this is all a fabrication.
24:36If convicted, he faces up to life in prison.
24:40But it would be very much a circumstantial evidence case.
24:44Without a murder weapon, without a medical examiner coming in and saying she was strangled, she was shot, is a
24:53jury going to accept this?
25:02Welcome to our first hour of Court TV Live.
25:04I'm Julie Grant.
25:05We're in Wisconsin for the bad boyfriend murder trial.
25:08Defendant Matthew Paul is accused of murdering his on-again, off-again girlfriend of 20 years, Stephanie Pavlons.
25:15Court's expected to start up at 9 a.m. Eastern time.
25:18I've seen a lot of people who are supposedly killers, but he looked normal, you know.
25:23He looks like somebody you would meet on the street and think nothing of it.
25:28Stephanie's father, Richard Pavlons, was in court every day and says he had to restrain himself when he saw Paul.
25:35I thought about just going over and strangling him.
25:38To put him in, to give him the same kind of treatment that he gave my daughter.
25:44So, ladies and gentlemen, this is Stephanie Pavlons.
25:48She is the person who was the subject of this homicide trial.
25:52You see, Stephanie did have a hard life.
25:55There's no getting around it.
25:57There were times she felt hopeless.
26:00There were times she felt sad, depressed, lonely.
26:03Unfortunately, she kept a journal.
26:05And it will also be very clear from her journal entries that the cause of her despair and her hopelessness
26:11was the abuse that had been inflicted upon her by the defendant, Matthew Paul.
26:16And District Attorney Sue Oppert knew she had to deal with the case's biggest hurdle.
26:22The first question is, how did she die?
26:24And I can't answer that question.
26:27There's one thing we won't be able to present to you.
26:31And that's the cause of death.
26:33And you may say, how in the world are you going to prove a murder case when you don't know
26:38how she died?
26:38The burden of proof on the state of Wisconsin is not to prove how she died.
26:43You will not be asked that at the end of the case.
26:46Not one witness is going to tell you the whole story.
26:48But everybody has one little thing.
26:50The only reasonable conclusion you can reach is that he's guilty of killing Stephanie Pavlons in an intentional act.
27:01Thank you.
27:02Thank you.
27:04Mr. Wolfe?
27:05Yes, your husband.
27:06Okay, go ahead.
27:07Good morning.
27:08No witnesses will be able to testify with any certainty how Stephanie Pavlons' life came to an end.
27:15In this case, the Waukesha County Medical Examiner will testify that despite exhaustive testing and investigation,
27:23they can sum up the conclusion about the manner and cause of Stephanie's death in one word, undetermined.
27:31Ask, if Matt carried Stephanie into that wooded area, when would he have done that?
27:36Keep in mind, the government has hundreds of hours of camera footage and cell phone mapping.
27:42Keep in mind, Matt was still dealing with a broken foot.
27:45Finally ask, what proof does the government have that Stephanie was even killed by another person?
27:51It could have been suicide.
27:52It could have been medical issues.
27:54It could have been anything.
27:55Listen for what can be proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
28:06Stephanie's mother, Georgie Ann, testified on the first day of the trial about Matthew Paul's treatment of her daughter.
28:13After she met Matt, did you know if Stephanie had any friends?
28:17Not really.
28:18She didn't, no, she didn't really have any friends.
28:21Okay.
28:21Was Matthew welcome in your home?
28:23No.
28:24Why not?
28:26Because of the way he treated her.
28:27And she stared straight at Paul.
28:30I wanted him to know, you know, exactly how I felt.
28:34And I'm sure that through my testimony and through me being up on the stand that he got the message.
28:42But on cross-examination, the defense used the mother's testimony to show that there might be other causes than murder
28:49for Stephanie's death.
28:51And you were aware she was also taking oxycodone and other medicines for her epilepsy, true?
28:57Yeah.
28:59In fact, one time when she was driving, she had a seizure and she crashed her vehicle, true?
29:04True.
29:06And then when the police came over to your house September 12, one of the first words that came out
29:11of your mouth was suicide.
29:13True?
29:14Don't remember.
29:16You also told the detective that Stephanie, your daughter, I don't mean to be disrespectful, she was a cutter.
29:24Is that true?
29:26I don't recall.
29:28I don't remember.
29:28You don't recall telling the detective that Stephanie would cut herself?
29:31No, I don't.
29:32If it's in the report, I must have.
29:34I think the defense was doing a very good job of painting Stephanie as mentally ill.
29:40Maybe Stephanie was going to commit suicide.
29:45Prosecutors arranged to take the jury to the crime scene, hoping it might help answer the question of how she
29:51died,
29:51showing how the body was hidden from view in the woods with no evidence of the means of a suicide,
29:57like a knife or a lickature.
30:00Our ultimate reasonable conclusion was he either killed her in the woods or dragged her a short distance into the
30:06woods.
30:07But the problem was the medical examiner was about to testify she did not know the cause of death.
30:13A lot of people still had that question of how did Stephanie die?
30:17It was the question that never went away.
30:29Good morning, ma'am.
30:30Good morning.
30:31How are you employed?
30:33I'm an associate medical examiner for Waukesha County.
30:35Prosecutors had no choice but to let the medical examiner testify she could not rule Stephanie's death a homicide.
30:43I observed no external trauma to the body or internal trauma.
30:49The caveat is that because she was missing portions of soft tissue, such as the neck,
30:57there were limitations to whether there were injuries there that I simply could not evaluate
31:02because she was missing those portions of tissue.
31:05Ultimately, were you able to reach a conclusion on cause of death?
31:11The cause of death was undetermined, so no, I was not able to reach a conclusion as to why Stephanie
31:18was dying, was dead.
31:20Okay.
31:21Were you able to reach a conclusion as to manner of death?
31:24If cause of death is undetermined, then manner of death must be undetermined.
31:30Was this a challenging case for you, Dr. Scheel?
31:33Very.
31:34One of your hardest cases ever?
31:36Yes.
31:36Is there a way that Ms. Pavlons could have died that you just couldn't see from the autopsy?
31:48Specific to a homicide?
31:50Specific to a homicide?
31:51Yes, ma'am.
31:52Yes, based on the autopsy findings.
31:55I could not rule out strangulation.
31:57I could not rule out a smothering.
32:00I could not rule out head trauma.
32:02I could not rule out sharp force injuries to the neck.
32:06I mean, there are a lot of things I can rule out, which is one of the reasons her cause
32:10of death is undetermined.
32:12Okay.
32:13All right.
32:13Those are all my questions.
32:14Thank you, doctor.
32:15Great.
32:15Thank you.
32:15Cross-examination.
32:16Thank you.
32:17You're aware that the government is prosecuting or trying to prosecute Mr. Pavl for a homicide, correct?
32:24Correct.
32:24Okay.
32:25And you can't rule out a car accident in this case, can you?
32:29Correct.
32:29Okay.
32:31And you can't rule out an overdose?
32:33Correct.
32:34And you can't rule out some kind of medical or natural death, correct?
32:38Correct.
32:38Nothing further than that.
32:40Throughout the trial, Matthew Paul had drawn the attention of the judge as he loudly whispered to his lawyers, making
32:47comments about witnesses and prosecutors.
32:49He did eventually tone that down after being told many, many times by the judge and even his own defense
32:57attorneys, you know, that this was being captured by the microphones in the courtroom.
33:02And the jury's sitting right here.
33:05They will call Detective Fredericks.
33:06One of the strongest witnesses against Paul was lead detective Brian Fredericks.
33:12Fredericks took the jury through the video surveillance, showing Paul returning home without Stephanie, carrying her pink water bottle, and
33:21the plastic bag with what he believed was her black purse, a key piece of evidence.
33:27What was significant about the purse and what you saw in the video that made you believe they were the
33:33same item?
33:35These metal chains connecting the strap to the purse itself.
33:40And then the detective read some of the heartbreaking entries from Stephanie's journal.
33:45Gave me a good hard slap to my face, which stung and gave me a migraine.
33:50Good day, bad night, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde.
33:54This is why I want to die sometimes.
33:56Again, blame for something I didn't do.
33:58I feel worthless, unloved, used, and miserable.
34:01Why am I here?
34:03How can I escape?
34:05Got punched in the nose, hit two times in head.
34:09I will either wind up in a mental home or six feet under.
34:13I feel so helpless, worthless, and most of all, hurt.
34:18And if there wasn't a journal, we wouldn't understand the level of domestic violence.
34:24That what maybe looked like depression and mental illness was somebody being abused every day.
34:32Watching it all was Stephanie and Matt's daughter, Layla, who wanted to show her support for her mother and the
34:39prosecution.
34:40Obviously, what a terrible position for that young woman to be put in when her father is accused of murdering
34:46her mother.
34:47It's a lot of a burden to carry.
34:48I think she also, like Stephanie's parents, had no idea the level of the abuse and the control that Stephanie
34:56was suffering.
34:57And then the detective read Stephanie's final Facebook post.
35:01I feel incredibly alone, sad, and hopeless, but I will never feel the love or joy that I see so
35:08many people slash family members have.
35:10I have been made to feel that the air I breathe isn't even worth breathing.
35:15So sick of life and waking up in pain slash agony.
35:20Just want some real friends and can't even have that out of 7 billion people in the world.
35:26And you said that was Stephanie's last Facebook post that was made on her account?
35:31Correct.
35:31I don't have any other questions for you.
35:33Now the question was, would Matthew Paul take the stand and explain?
35:38He thought he was smarter than the judge, certainly smarter than the two female prosecutors.
35:44And we thought for sure he would testify because he was smarter than everybody in the room and he could
35:50explain all this away.
36:00Have you discussed your decision whether or not to testify with your attorneys?
36:06Yes.
36:06Have you made a decision?
36:08Yes.
36:09What is your decision, sir?
36:11Well, I think Opper's too good at fabrication, so I don't think it would be a good idea for me
36:17to testify.
36:18Okay.
36:19Blame me at all on District Attorney Sue Opper.
36:22And that's 100% consistent with his narcissism and his inability to take responsibility for his own conduct.
36:31The attorneys will now give closing statements.
36:33The state, because they have the burden of proof, goes first.
36:38Ladies and gentlemen, this is a classic story of escalating domestic violence.
36:44We know that there was a history of domestic violence incidents between Mr. Paul and Ms. Stephanie Patlons.
36:51She writes,
36:52I feel trapped.
36:53September 2nd of 2020, scared to death of him.
36:58Have no one.
37:00This was not a seizure.
37:02You can rule that out.
37:03This was not a suicide.
37:06So what is this?
37:09This was a homicide.
37:10This is a circumstantial case, ladies and gentlemen.
37:13I ask that you carefully consider each of the pieces of evidence that were presented to you.
37:18Mr. Paul is not only guilty of first-degree intentional homicide, but that he also intentionally concealed Stephanie's body.
37:27Thank you.
37:28Thank you, Ms. Gordon.
37:29Mr. Wolf.
37:31You, as a jury, have heard seven days of testimony.
37:35You've heard from 28 witnesses and seen hundreds of exhibits.
37:38Yes, he is evasive.
37:40Yes, he is paranoid.
37:42And yes, he does not recall some specifics.
37:45However, given the evidence and testimony, the state certainly has not satisfied their burden of proof with respect to the
37:52crimes charged.
37:53I'm confident you will render verdicts that will be consistent with good common sense and logic and find Matthew Paul
38:00not guilty.
38:02Thank you.
38:03And the prosecution saved its rebuttal to finally offer a theory about how Stephanie was actually killed.
38:10Mr. Paul grabs her purse.
38:15And ladies and gentlemen, this is the murder weapon.
38:18He wraps this around her neck.
38:20He strangles her for just a minute or two.
38:23That's all it takes.
38:24She goes unconscious.
38:27And she's dead.
38:30He uses the strap of her own purse to kill her.
38:34When she talked about the fact that Matthew wrapped that purse around her neck and choked the life out of
38:41her, and she died and ended up out in those woods, I think everybody got the same thing.
38:48And everybody's like, oh, my God, yes, he has done that.
38:54The jury was back after only one hour.
38:57It's my understanding that the jury has reached a verdict.
39:01Who's our presiding juror?
39:03Is that correct, ma'am?
39:04Yes.
39:05All right.
39:05If you could hand the materials to Mike, please.
39:08Never had a one-hour verdict on a murder case.
39:10The verdicts read as follows.
39:13We, the jury, find the defendant, Matthew E. Paul, guilty of first-degree intentional homicide as charged in count one
39:28of the information.
39:29The second verdict reads, we, the jury, find the defendant, Matthew E. Paul, guilty of hiding a corpse as charged
39:37in count two of the information.
39:42I don't think he was surprised.
39:43I think he knew it was coming.
39:45Paul would soon tell the world how he felt.
39:53Prosecutor Christy Gordon read a statement from Matthew Paul's daughter, Layla.
39:58She says,
40:05A man that hits and abuses an innocent woman is not a man, but a weak, sick-minded individual.
40:18A woman that had a daughter died because of you.
40:21You took an innocent woman's life and hurt so many people.
40:24I hope you rot in jail.
40:26All right, Mr. Paul, do you wish to make a statement, sir?
40:29Of course I'm going to make a statement.
40:30Okay.
40:31Go ahead, sir.
40:32First, I just want to crack some of the puke coming out of Gordon's mouth.
40:37I don't take it personally.
40:39He really came after both the prosecution team and the investigation team saying that we were fabricating evidence and framing
40:46him.
40:47And, you know, that's certainly not what happened here.
40:50It was definitely a pseudo-sham trial where psychopaths in suits fabricate extreme circumstantial events and turn them into their
40:58wild imagination.
40:59I am the only victim here.
41:01I'm the one being murdered by the new Gestapo.
41:04What I see in this case is domestic violence.
41:13And what I see in this case is an individual, Mr. Paul, who did what he could to exhibit or
41:21to exert power and control over Stephanie Pavlons.
41:26And he couldn't, in his arrogance and his ego, have someone else tell him it's over.
41:37And so he killed her.
41:39He killed her and he left her to rot in the woods as if she was roadkill.
41:47That's what the jury said.
41:51Mr. Paul, everybody's wrong.
41:54You're the only one that's right.
41:57You shake your head in the negative as I say this to you.
42:00And that's okay.
42:01That's your right to do that.
42:03But, sir, what you have exhibited to me demonstrates to me what I consider, and again, I'm not a shrink.
42:14This is what I consider to be narcissistic behavior.
42:19And in light of that, as to count number one, I'll impose a sentence of life imprisonment without any eligibility
42:28for release to extended supervision.
42:31So he will not be eligible for parole.
42:34He will spend the rest of his life in prison.
42:39Ultimately, a finding of guilty is the most justice that Stephanie can get because it shows that she was living
42:48a hard life, and that life was at the hands of Matthew, and he was the one that took her
42:53life and took her life much too soon.

Recommandations