• 3 years ago
PILDAT head speaks up on contradictions within PML-N over election date

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00 Ahmed Bilal, we can see a distinction here.
00:03 The Noon League is not only defending the decision to move forward in the elections,
00:08 it is also justifying it legally and legally,
00:11 endorsing it and even saying on television shows that everyone is on board,
00:15 even the establishment is on board.
00:17 So, the Noon League on one side, the rest of the political parties on the other.
00:20 This is a strange mess.
00:22 Wasn't there a consensus?
00:25 When the Pakistan People's Party voted for a Council of Common Interest,
00:29 now they say that we didn't talk about delimitation.
00:32 Is it even possible?
00:34 Thank you very much.
00:36 Look, this has to do with the question,
00:39 do you think that after the introduction of a new system,
00:45 in which the allocation of seats to the National Assembly has not changed,
00:50 is there a need for delimitation from a political point of view?
00:55 This is the fundamental question.
00:57 If the People's Party thinks that after this,
01:01 delimitation is not necessary legally,
01:04 then the decision they made to approve the Council of Common Interest was not wrong.
01:11 But if they knew that as a result, delimitation would be necessary,
01:18 and made this decision, then it was wrong.
01:21 My personal opinion is that nowhere in our constitution is it written
01:25 that after the introduction of a new system,
01:28 it is necessary to go from the province to the lower level and make a new delimitation.
01:34 This is only written in the law.
01:37 Section 17 of the Elections Act 2017,
01:42 that after every Council of Common Interest,
01:44 you have to make new amendments.
01:48 But because it is the law,
01:50 and the level of the law is below the constitution,
01:53 Article 224 of the Constitution is very clear,
01:56 that you have to have elections on the 90th day.
01:59 Therefore, I think that the intention of the Constitution is
02:03 to have elections on the 90th day,
02:06 and to postpone the work of the lower level.
02:09 Now it is the Supreme Court's job to give its authoritative opinion on this,
02:13 and to give a decision on this.
02:15 Sir, I would like to know your political aspect on this.
02:19 PMLN is the only party that says that delimitation is to be done.
02:24 Most probably, MQM would also like that
02:28 there should be delimitation as a result of this whole process.
02:32 But it is the People's Party, Pakistan Tariq-e-Insaf,
02:35 and in its very essence, it is the Islamic Jamaat.
02:37 All these are the parties.
02:40 So why is PMLN insisting on this, sir?
02:42 Because this is clearly a violation of the constitution.
02:44 First, you did not have elections in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Punjab on time,
02:47 and then you violated the constitution.
02:49 Now, even in the case of the vifak, are you moving towards a violation?
02:52 It is yet to be decided whether this is a violation or not.
02:57 In my opinion, this is a violation.
02:59 But since the Supreme Court has the final interpretation of any legal and constitutional matter,
03:07 then they will decide.
03:08 But I think that this is not right.
03:12 This is a very clear requirement of the constitution.
03:15 And politically, I don't think any political party has sat down and discussed this matter
03:25 and has taken a unified position of the party.
03:27 That is why you see Khurram Dastgir-sahib advocating for 90 days,
03:32 and Rana Salaullah-sahib saying that elections will be held in February.
03:36 Similarly, this division is also seen in the People's Party.
03:39 So it would be right that the political parties should be kind
03:43 and not make a joke of it.
03:45 They should sit in their parties and think about their legal experts
03:50 and then take a unified position.
03:52 It is possible that after that PMLN will also be ready to change its position.
03:56 Who has to give this date?
03:59 Because yesterday, the People's Party took a very shocking U-turn on this.
04:05 Before that, they used to hold the Election Commission responsible for this.
04:08 That this is their mistake.
04:09 Yesterday, Nair Bukhari-sahib, because he understands the law,
04:13 and he is the former chairman of the Senate, so I will give him the weight in his opinion.
04:17 He says that the President has to give this date.
04:20 Obviously, this will happen with the advice of the PM.
04:23 So who has to give the date of the general election in your opinion?
04:27 Because Article 48 of the Constitution is the responsibility of the President.
04:34 And you are right that the advice of the President will come from the PM.
04:41 So I think that despite the change in the law,
04:46 because it is written in the Constitution,
04:48 this is the work of the President.
04:50 And he will work on the advice of the Prime Minister.
04:54 And certainly, when the Prime Minister gives this advice,
04:57 he will certainly consult the Election Commission.
05:00 This has happened in the past.
05:02 But it is written in Article 48 of the Constitution.
05:05 So, until that change does not happen, this is the right of the President.
05:09 So, sir, the Election Commission has released a schedule yesterday,
05:12 in which they have told how training will be done by December,
05:15 then delimitation will be done, then people will complain about this.
05:19 There is another threat from this issue,
05:21 that when there will be complaints, then the matter will be taken to the higher court.
05:26 Yesterday, Mr. Hassan Pasha raised this point.
05:29 He thinks that this matter will go beyond February,
05:33 because the more legal complications, the more it will come.
05:35 Is there any threat of this?
05:37 No, I think there is no threat on this basis.
05:40 But if someone comes up with another excuse to find a move,
05:44 then that is a different matter.
05:45 Because when this final report of delimitation will come on December 14,
05:51 then if some people go to the courts,
05:54 then it does not make a difference on the schedule.
05:57 The final delimitation as provided for in the law will be completed.
06:01 People go to the courts after the elections,
06:04 and they issue election reports.
06:06 This does not stop the formation of the government.
06:08 Similarly, after the report of delimitation comes,
06:11 if some people go to the courts,
06:13 then the rest of the election schedule will not be affected.
06:16 After December 14, it will be necessary to announce the election schedule.
06:20 Sir, one more thing, the Election Commission has given a schedule for December,
06:24 so is this a loyal government?
06:27 Because we are in a very unique stage,
06:29 the transition is also taking place,
06:31 the caretakers are also coming,
06:32 during that time there is a legal, legal and political crisis,
06:36 the previous government is giving a gift,
06:38 the next legislation is also there.
06:41 So, where is this December schedule coming from?
06:44 Because if the President has to give the date of the election on the advice of the Prime Minister,
06:48 then can the Election Commission do this on its own?
06:51 The Election Commission, you must have noticed,
06:55 did not say anything about the election.
06:57 They have issued a schedule for the election delimitation.
07:05 And their interpretation is that now,
07:08 after the approval of the Council of Common Interest,
07:11 and after the census is published,
07:13 now it has become necessary in their opinion,
07:15 that this delimitation should be done.
07:18 That is why they have issued a schedule.
07:20 If the President of the country issues a different schedule for the election on my advice,
07:25 then that will be binding on the election schedule.

Recommended