- 3 years ago
Category
🥇
SportsTranscript
00:00 Hello everybody, Adam Cleary from 442 here and football, that continues to be mad doesn't
00:09 it?
00:10 Chelsea have finally, finally announced the signing of Moyes' Caicedo and within the
00:13 next possibly even few hours they could announce the signing of Romeo Lavia from Southampton
00:18 as well.
00:19 And this has led to a whole host of people on the internet saying hang on, why would
00:22 you want to sign Lavia if you've just signed Caicedo?
00:25 And I can just, I can clear this up really quickly for everybody, right?
00:28 The reason you still want Lavia, even if you've just signed Caicedo, is because Lavia is great.
00:34 He's really great, he's really, really great.
00:38 So, oh sorry you wanted more than that did you?
00:42 Okay, right, well I'll see what I can do, your majesty.
00:48 Okay so first off to the people asking why you'd want Lavia and Caicedo, very simple
00:53 question for you, have you never had a Sunday dinner?
00:56 Like you could if you really wanted to try and make the argument that roast potatoes
01:00 and mashed potatoes are just, they're the same thing aren't they?
01:03 I mean they're both just potatoes aren't they?
01:04 They kind of taste the same, they're just a delivery method for the gravy after all.
01:08 But if you get offered roasties and mash, you'd take roasties and mash.
01:12 Like I know they're in the same position of like the food group chart or whatever you
01:16 call it, but they're different enough and both delicious that you don't deny yourself
01:20 that.
01:21 And just to stretch this metaphor to its absolute breaking point, if over a 38 Sunday dinner
01:26 dinner season you were for whatever reason without either roasties or mash, you'd still
01:30 be pretty content if you had the other one.
01:33 And crucially going into this season as anybody who watched Chelsea vs Liverpool will tell
01:37 you, Chelsea did not have either roasties or mash and that particular dinner was crying
01:43 out for some kind of potato accoutrement.
01:45 Think that's the right word.
01:46 So by extension potatoes are obviously very important to what Maurizio Pochettino was
01:50 cooking every single week for the next 8 months so it would be stupid to only buy enough to
01:56 make one version of them.
01:57 And if you are now sat there thinking just hang on a second wait a minute, doesn't this
02:01 channel normally talk about like stats and data and actual verifiable facts rather than
02:07 just going on unhinged rants about potatoes then yeah, yeah that's right we do do that
02:14 so let's do that.
02:16 Right so here are Romeo Lavia's FB ref stats as kind of a number 6 compared to Moises Caicedo
02:22 who is going to be his team mate, to Paulinho who was probably the standout player in that
02:26 role last season and to Fabinho who has probably been the standout player in this role for
02:31 the last few seasons.
02:32 Now there are some very obvious takeaways from looking at all these next to each other.
02:36 The first one is that you can see why Caicedo was valued at over 100 million, you can see
02:41 why Paulinho was just so important at Fulham last season and you can see why people started
02:46 to think that Fabinho was on the wane, those aren't the kind of numbers he's been posting
02:50 recently but they're still pretty good.
02:51 But as far as Lavia goes the takeaway from looking at his numbers is that he's just pretty
02:56 good, they're not particularly remarkable numbers, he clearly does a little bit of everything
03:00 reasonably well, he's a solid, solid player in that position so why you could be forgiven
03:06 for asking all this hype, why all this money?
03:09 Well and it's funny you're gonna kick yourself on this one right, when you compare his numbers
03:13 to Caicedo, arguably the best player in the league at this and Paulinho, arguably the
03:17 player in the league who had the best season at this and Fabinho, arguably the player in
03:21 the league over the last few seasons who is the best at this, he's pretty good compared
03:27 to those three at f***ing 19.
03:30 Lavia should not be posting comparable numbers to players like Paulinho or Fabinho for at
03:34 least another three or four years, if you start going "wait a second, Caicedo's there"
03:39 he's still 21, he's two years further down the development line than Lavia is and he's
03:45 still comparable to him.
03:47 So the very, very short version of this video is the reason you'd go and get Lavia regardless
03:52 of who else you've got in your squad is because he is not a guaranteed starter for a Champions
03:57 League level side right now, but he will be in a year or two, cast iron guarantee.
04:04 And the beauty of Chelsea, the beauty of this transfer, is that they are not a Champions
04:08 League team at the minute, they hope to be again in a year or two's time.
04:12 So ta-da!
04:13 See the levels where Chelsea will be wanting to throw him in, he's already perfectly comfortable
04:19 playing at and by the time they're at the levels he's not, he will be.
04:23 Thing is though, and I know I did just say cast iron guarantee, that was probably a little
04:27 bit strong, anyway we're talking about things in the future right, these are all hypotheticals,
04:30 they haven't happened yet and the only way they are going to happen is if his development
04:33 continues on this upward trajectory and the only way that will happen is with game time.
04:39 And so by extension the other question everyone's asking is, well is he going to get enough
04:43 game time?
04:44 Chelsea haven't got the burden of European competition to provide them with all these
04:48 extra minutes for players, will he play enough?
04:51 And well yes, I genuinely think he will.
04:53 Like the reason I use that whole Sunday dinner analogy is not because I'm losing my mind,
04:57 although obviously that probably did help a bit, but because they are different players.
05:01 Like so think about Caicedo's best attributes, he's an incredible tackler of the ball which
05:05 we saw at Brighton, he's incredible at progressing up the field and evading presses and being
05:10 a central part of the build up.
05:11 Lavia has all these attributes, admittedly not to the same level, but he does have them
05:15 all, but what he does have over Caicedo is he is, if not necessarily a better passer,
05:21 a more dangerous passer.
05:22 Caicedo is fantastic at progressing the ball up the pitch with his running and bringing
05:26 others into play and going around people, but what Lavia did, and this was a great weapon
05:29 for Southampton last season, was play these line-breaking killer, really incisive passes.
05:36 It's annoyingly not something that's backed up by any data, but the eye test will tell
05:39 you that when Lavia gets his head up and he has the ball at his feet, he can find players
05:43 in better positions than Caicedo can.
05:46 And that's a pretty valuable thing for Chelsea to have if, as expected, Fernandes is playing
05:50 considerably further up the pitch.
05:51 It means for whatever reason, if they are required to go more direct, he hasn't got
05:55 to drop all the way back to be the player to do that, he can leave that to someone like
05:58 Lavia and continue to do all his good work in the final third, which as we discussed
06:02 yesterday, video's right there if you didn't see it, he's very good at.
06:06 And also while Caicedo is a much better tackler of the ball, he reads the game and he makes
06:10 these brilliant interceptions and he just goes through players and he wins it that way,
06:13 Lavia has something he doesn't, and that is just one of the best bail you out recovery
06:19 runs in the Premier League.
06:21 Like if we look at the difference in their numbers here between tackles and interceptions,
06:24 yep, Caicedo is miles ahead of him, but blocks, blocked passes and blocked shots, that is
06:29 something Lavia had to be good at at Southampton given how open they were, but it is also conveniently
06:34 something he just was really good at.
06:36 And that means in any sort of game state where the play is stretched, where Chelsea are really
06:40 committing, he's a slightly more valuable defensive midfielder to have than Caicedo
06:45 is because if you bypass Caicedo with a pass, that's probably him out of the game, whereas
06:49 Lavia is no bypassing him, he will just hunt you down.
06:53 And just so I've got myself on record as saying this, while I do think Caicedo is better in
06:57 all of these regards, I don't mean that Lavia isn't also at a top, top, top level for them,
07:02 like he does win the ball back brilliantly, he has a great tackling technique.
07:07 And then there's all the other various things that can just happen across the start of the
07:09 season, I don't think in a straight shot between him and Caicedo he's ever going to start ahead
07:13 of him, but there's no reason that doesn't mean that Chelsea can't play with three at
07:17 the back and use all of them, and because they're all really good at six, you can have
07:21 this kind of system where they all constantly move around, and imagine trying to defend
07:25 against that.
07:26 And there's also like Rhys James, like Chelsea is so much better as a team when he is on
07:31 the right side of defence and he can bob up from that position, but he still hasn't put
07:35 his injury stuff behind him, he went off against Liverpool, and yeah, Gusto came on, but I
07:40 would probably rather in that situation, purely for his ball carrying ability, have Caicedo
07:45 over there, and if you do that, well, you haven't got to worry about what you're losing
07:48 in the middle, because you've got mashed potato, Romeo Lavia.
07:51 So I do think genuinely across the course of a season, you will see games where they
07:54 start Lavia, Caicedo and Fernandes all at the same time, whether that's a tweak to the
07:59 system, whether they decide to play Fernandes in the 10, again, not the best, but you'd
08:02 have a really solid base to build from.
08:04 I think there's enough flexibility and enough game IQ in these players, and in Pochettino,
08:09 that he's a great, great, great option for them to have.
08:13 And just one final point in all of this, about money.
08:17 If you think the reason why Chelsea and Liverpool and also Arsenal are pushing so hard to get
08:22 Lavia in this window is because he got relegated with Southampton, so he's probably a little
08:26 bit cheaper than he would have been, then that is not the entire reason.
08:31 Southampton bought Lavia from Manchester City just 12 months ago for a measly, let's face
08:37 it, £10 million, but City did not let him go because they did not rate him.
08:42 They let him go because they did not have a viable path into the first team for him.
08:46 They could not give him anywhere near the game time they knew his development required.
08:50 If you remember, they had a plan for Foden, they've got a plan for Parma, they've got
08:53 a plan for Rico Luis.
08:55 They do not have one for Lavia because, well, they play one single number six and Rodri
09:01 is playing there, and you've also got Calvin Phillips.
09:03 He's not getting a look in.
09:04 Now that was 12 months ago, and City are very aware that things can change.
09:08 It hasn't really worked out for Phillips.
09:09 Maybe Rodri wants a move, maybe he leaves, maybe he gets a bad injury.
09:12 Maybe they play a crazy new system with loads of number sixes in it.
09:16 Things can change, and City really did rate the player that Lavia could become, and thus
09:22 they inserted deep into the bowels of his contract a buyback clause.
09:29 Now I would argue if there wasn't a path into the first team for him a year ago, there almost
09:32 certainly will be in 12 months time.
09:35 So the reason all these teams are trying to get him right now is because it's either right
09:41 now or it's probably never.
09:43 So as a result, it looks like he's going to Chelsea and he's going there right now, and
09:46 I personally, personally think that is a brilliant bit of transfer business.
09:51 Unless you're Liverpool, in which case, terrible.
09:53 Sucks.
09:54 And before I go, just genuinely want to say a little thank you to everybody who commented
09:58 on yesterday's video saying like, "Oh, can you do one for Lavia, please?
10:02 I'd like to watch that."
10:03 Made me feel like a somebody.
10:05 That did, because I just sit here and do these to a room with no people in them.
10:08 So that was nice.
10:10 People wanted to know what I thought about this.
10:12 So there you go.
10:13 Hope you liked it.
10:14 And if you're now sitting there thinking, "Well, hang on, I've got a really good idea
10:15 for a video with players you want to see, tactics you want to discuss, game systems,
10:19 anything you think I'd be remotely good at," please get that in the comments and I'll have
10:23 a look.
10:24 And of course, as all other feedback, criticism, comments, someone said I look like Tom York
10:27 yesterday.
10:28 That gave me a little bit of a laugh.
10:29 All in the box below.
10:30 And of course, please, please do, if you enjoyed the video, subscribe to 442.
10:34 Hitting that subscribe button is the one thing that really helps us out.
10:38 It shows the progress of the channel and lets us do more stuff.
10:41 That and sending it to all your friends very publicly on social media going, "Have you
10:46 seen this?
10:47 It's great."
10:48 In the meantime, though, Twitter, Instagram, threads, everything, @adamcleary, C-L-E-R-Y.
10:51 The 442 socials are in the corner for the entire video.
10:54 I don't know why I read them out, but you should still buy the latest issue of the world's
10:58 greatest football magazine, the season preview issue.
11:01 The best one we do.
11:02 Here's a preview.
11:03 Oh, in stores now.
11:04 Go and treat yourself to that.
11:05 And until next time, sub a name, said what you could do.
11:09 That's everything.
11:10 Bye.
11:10 (laughs)