• 3 years ago
Why was Bani Gala declared a sub-jail? Maria Memon's important question to Barrister Ali Zafar

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00 This is my question because this was happening and you kept the election despite that.
00:05 You don't know all this?
00:07 I think we were mistaken.
00:09 We thought that no one should have any issue in the intraparty election and there will be no interference.
00:17 Because they are putting restrictions on the general election campaign.
00:21 They may not have any issue in the intraparty election but such a thing did not come out.
00:25 Mr. Ali Zafar, tell us, the talks about the deal that you are seeing,
00:30 Mr. Murad Syed tweeted that three options have been given.
00:34 Then, Ms. Bushra herself said while talking to her journalists,
00:39 what are the consequences of this?
00:42 What is happening?
00:43 When people are going to Benigala, there is a discussion.
00:46 Is there any official version of PTI regarding this?
00:48 As far as I know, the trial that is going on in the jail, I don't call it a trial.
00:56 It is a witch hunt.
00:58 I went to witness it and to meet Mr. Khan.
01:05 I stayed there for two days.
01:07 I stayed with him from morning to 10 pm.
01:14 In both the three cases.
01:16 He did not mention this at all.
01:20 In fact, he said that you go and talk about this.
01:25 There is no such thing as the situation that is going on.
01:29 There is no deal.
01:31 There have been cases against us.
01:34 Punishments have been given against us.
01:36 Sir, but has the deal been offered or not?
01:38 Because there was a discussion with Ms. Bushra,
01:41 where she said that you go and talk to Mr. Khan.
01:43 Give confirmation in this regard.
01:46 No, there is no such thing.
01:49 In fact, Mr. Khan has denied this.
01:53 So I don't think it is right.
01:57 So why is there a difference between Benigala and other places?
02:01 Did you give any written request?
02:03 Did the lawyers of the Paktarikin say that this should be declared a sub-jail?
02:07 Is this happening because of this?
02:08 What is the reason behind this?
02:10 What is the reason behind this?
02:13 I have my own theory.
02:15 I will share it with you.
02:17 Originally, this was the plan.
02:20 Actually, the punishment for the case of Ms. Bushra
02:24 was only one reason that Mr. Iman Khan should be humiliated.
02:29 Obviously, he did not care about his cases.
02:33 But it was a suspicion that if his wife,
02:36 any family member, is involved in a criminal case,
02:42 then obviously there is a problem.
02:44 So maybe she was punished to humiliate and trouble him.
02:48 But when it did not affect him,
02:50 and Ms. Bushra herself went to jail,
02:54 then the drama that was going on
02:57 that she was brought home from home,
02:59 and she was caught,
03:01 and then she was taken to the public,
03:04 and then she was taken to jail,
03:07 this was not possible.
03:10 When it was not possible,
03:12 then maybe the administration thought
03:14 that it was not good to arrest her and keep her in jail.
03:17 It was a loss.
03:18 Impression will be worse for people.
03:20 So for now, you should...
03:22 So was there no written request for her to be taken to jail?
03:25 No written request.
03:27 In fact, she was waiting since 7 am
03:33 for the judgment to come.
03:35 And maybe she reached the jail at 9.30 am.
03:38 When the judgment was announced.
03:41 There is one more problem that has come up today.
03:43 We will not call it a problem, but a challenge.
03:45 The case of Salman Akhram Raja
03:47 was sent to the Election Commissioner of Pakistan.
03:49 He said that since this is happening in the Supreme Court,
03:52 so there will be a proceeding there.
03:56 The decision will be made there.
03:58 Do you think that if this decision was not made after the election,
04:05 it would be difficult for you?
04:08 Today, the Chief Election Commissioner of Pakistan has stated,
04:10 if we can show it on Express,
04:12 he has quoted him,
04:13 that Azad Arqan can make his PM.
04:16 Now, this statement from the Chief Election Commissioner of Pakistan
04:19 means that technically he is giving a legal opinion.
04:22 So, it has a lot to do with this.
04:25 So, can Azad Arqan really make his PM?
04:28 My point of view is different.
04:32 I think that this case should not have been filed.
04:36 In my opinion, it is very clear that
04:39 the candidates are of three types.
04:45 One is purely independent,
04:47 who have no connection with any party.
04:49 One is purely party candidates,
04:52 who fight for the party's symbol.
04:54 And the third category is those candidates who have said,
04:57 who have given an affidavit,
04:58 that we are connected with a party,
05:00 but they fight for the symbol of their party.
05:03 They fight for the symbol of their party,
05:05 but they are of the party,
05:06 and they cannot be separated from the party.
05:09 They will remain of the party, the parliamentarians.
05:11 And that parliamentary party will be,
05:14 every political party has a parliamentary party.
05:19 The parliamentary party is the one,
05:21 who has the parliamentarians in the parliament.
05:24 The leadership of the party,
05:27 and the leadership of the party outside the party,
05:31 are according to that.
05:32 And this is the principle.
05:34 I remember, I had filed a case in the Supreme Court of Pakistan.
05:38 So, this question was asked there,
05:40 and finally, the Supreme Court itself gave its answer,
05:44 that the political party,
05:46 is registered till now,
05:49 and the parliamentarians are in the parliament,
05:52 and they are under the parliamentary party,
05:55 but outside the parliament, they are under the party.
05:59 This is the procedure of our parliamentary democracy.
06:02 So, these suggestions...
06:03 People are talking about different things,
06:05 but the parliamentary democracy...
06:07 A little clarity,
06:08 because the political strategy of PTI,
06:11 was also under consideration,
06:12 that after the election,
06:13 the party of Mr. Shirani,
06:16 or any other party,
06:17 all these people should join there,
06:19 and then make their separate positions.
06:22 So, why was this suggestion under consideration,
06:24 if according to your assessment,
06:25 it is not needed,
06:26 the parliamentary party is there,
06:27 the party is intact?
06:28 You keep making two or three or four strategies,
06:32 and you should make them.
06:33 You should not stop at one strategy.
06:35 Now, you mentioned,
06:37 Maria mentioned very intelligently,
06:40 that the election commission of Pakistan has given its statement,
06:43 and you said that it may have a legal status.
06:47 So, these things also need to be taken care of,
06:50 that what is the election commission of Pakistan thinking,
06:55 whether it is thinking against the law,
06:58 but do you want to go into that legal war,
07:01 or do you want to find a peaceful way?
07:03 These are the strategies,
07:05 and that is why I think some people are talking about this,
07:09 and this debate is going on from a very far distance.
07:12 And this is going on in every political party,
07:14 because every political party is thinking,
07:16 that how can we claim this so-called independent PTIK,
07:22 that we should fall in their lap,
07:23 they are expecting it.
07:25 So, all of them are depending on them,
07:27 which is a strange policy.
07:29 It is unfortunate that politicians are thinking like this,
07:33 and this is the reason,
07:34 that the dignity of the politicians in this country is being mocked.
07:39 So, I suggest that you play your own game,
07:43 in your own votes,
07:45 elect your own candidates,
07:48 and then if people elect you,
07:51 then form a government,
07:53 and from there PTI will come into opposition.

Recommended