Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 14 minutes ago
A political showdown continues in the Karnataka Assembly over the rendition of the national song, Vande Mataram. The ruling Congress government maintains that only the first two stanzas should be sung to uphold secular values and historical practice, while the BJP insists on singing all eleven stanzas. Amid this impasse, Karnataka Governor Thawar Chand Gehlot has written to Chief Minister DK Shivakumar, advising the state government to reconsider its decision restricting the rendition. Gehlot cited central government guidelines and a recent parliamentary Amendment Act granting statutory authority to the national song on par with the national anthem, calling on the state to revoke its order.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00There appears to still be a showdown over Vande Mataram in Karnataka.
00:04Remember the assembly session is presently on.
00:07The latest visuals also showed that when the BJP said they only want to sing all stanzas very clear,
00:14while the Congress, the MLA's maintained that they need to have only the two stanzas because that stands significant.
00:22That according to them has been followed historically.
00:26That's been their belief and that will be secular.
00:29But now it appears that Karnataka Governor Thavarchand Gehloth has advised Chief Minister D.K. Shiv Kumar
00:34to reconsider state government's decision to restrict rendition of Vande Mataram to the first two stanzas.
00:40Gehloth has said that September 8th government order should be examined in light of the central government's instructions
00:45on the official version and rendition of the national song
00:48and referring to the recent amendment act that has given it that kind of authority.
00:57So that is the big news.
00:58Because remember on day one when the Karnataka Assembly convened,
01:01the Congress government played only the two stanzas and then the audio stopped.
01:06So what did the BJP MLAs do?
01:08Some of them knew it by heart.
01:09Others had a paper with them and they were reading and singing the national song, Vande Mataram.
01:14All the 11 stanzas, even though the Speaker started to then ask what is the next procedure,
01:22the next protocol, which MLA has to speak, which Minister has to give answers.
01:26So while Vande Mataram was being sung by the BJP MLAs,
01:29the Congress ministers and the Congress leaders of the government started to talk about the issue at hand
01:37and what needs to be discussed in the Assembly.
01:39And that is what was happening.
01:41So in the latest now, we know that the governor has written to the chief minister,
01:45seeking to reconsider the stand that the Congress has maintained.
01:49But this, remember, is not really DK Shiv Kumar to really decide upon,
01:52because it's the Congress leadership in Delhi that's already taken that stand,
01:56that they'll follow what they believe is secular,
01:58only two stanzas of the Vande Mataram.
02:00But the governor is quoting that when the Amendment Act, cleared by the Parliament,
02:05clearly states the priority and the significance that needs to be granted to Vande Mataram as the national song,
02:11at par with national anthem, how can Karnataka act otherwise?
02:16But like we have been telling you, that the state government does have the authority to decide on this,
02:22compared to how the Parliament decided, especially for union government or central events,
02:28but for state events, the state government can take a call on its own.
02:33But for now, with the governor also interjecting on this, writing to the chief minister,
02:39it remains to be seen how they'll proceed with it, but definitely big on this.
02:46Sagai Raj is joining me for the latest on that.
02:49Sagai, go ahead, tell me what the governor has written and how the governor has got involved in this,
02:54because DK Shiv Kumar believes that they're doing nothing wrong.
03:00Absolutely, and DK Shiv Kumar maintained that ever since we got the independence,
03:04we are following this, and we are singing only two stanzas of Vande Mataram,
03:09but the order which was being passed on 21st of September,
03:13sorry, 21st of September, which, I mean, 21st of September,
03:17the letter which has been written by the governor, Tavachand Kyaloth,
03:19has said that whatever the government is trying to do,
03:22it is trying to insult the pride of national song,
03:26and as well as the national pride of the country,
03:28because it is an order which has been passed by the central government,
03:31and the state government have to go ahead and follow,
03:34and it is against the federal system,
03:37as the state government is not following on Vande Mataram song,
03:41and he has asked the government to reconsider their decision and revoke that.
03:49I will be tracking the latest on that.
03:53Sagai, thank you very much for now,
03:54but this is going to be perhaps clearly a confrontation
03:57that will continue in the Assembly.
Comments

Recommended