Skip to playerSkip to main content
The Barisan Nasional and Perikatan Nasional electoral alliance, led by UMNO and PAS respectively, secured a commanding victory in the Melaka state election, capturing 24 out of the 28 seats in the state legislative assembly. The remaining four seats were won by DAP for Pakatan Harapan. So what really drove voters in Melaka? What can this election tell us about where Malaysian politics is heading next? On this episode of #ConsiderThis Melisa Idris speaks with Dr Syaza Shukri, Associate Professor of Political Science at IIUM, and Aira Azhari, CEO of IDEAS Malaysia.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:10Hello and good evening. I'm Melissa Idris. Welcome to Consider This. This is the show
00:15where we want you to consider and reconsider what you know of the news of the day. The Barisan
00:20National and Perikatan National Electoral Alliance, led by UMNO and PAS respectively,
00:25have secured a commanding victory in the Melaka state election, capturing 24 out of the 28 seats
00:32in the State Legislative Assembly. The remaining four seats were won by DAP for Pakatan Harapan.
00:39So let's take a look at the results of this election. What really drove voters in Melaka
00:43and what can this election tell us about where Malaysian politics is headed next?
00:49Joining me on the show now is Dr Shaza Shukri. He's an Associate Professor of Political Science
00:54at IIUM. Shaza, thank you so much for being on the show with me today. I appreciate your time.
00:59The Melaka elections, I think, really has shown that this strategic cooperation between PAS and UMNO
01:05seems to be working in their favour. And I'm quite curious to know what you think. Do you think that
01:10this third-time win for this alliance, has that cemented the cooperation heading into GE16? I know
01:18Zaid Hamini has come out to say that, well, no formal plans yet for an electoral pact for GE16, but
01:25is that just wayang? What do you think?
01:28Thank you, Mel. Firstly, yeah, I don't know, unfortunately, but I've used the word wayang quite a bit
01:35here and there as well because I do see as that because, you know, what would stop, but again,
01:43we say Barisan Perikatan, but it's really UMNO passport, right? What would stop them from really
01:48cementing this relationship? Because we have seen the results starting from Johor to Negeri Sembilan
01:55to Melaka. So, and they want big, right? So, if they don't turn this into a more concrete or
02:03quasi-official cooperation, they're really going back to square one of a three-corner fight.
02:10And when we look at past elections, when we had three-corner fights, meaning BN, BN, and
02:16NPH, the Malay votes would split between BN and PN. So, why would they want to go back to that?
02:23Because we're not just talking about wins here. We're not just talking about seats.
02:28We're talking about mandate. They're winning with a huge mandate. So, that is something that
02:33they can carry forward and present to Malaysians that this is the cooperation or the parties that
02:45Malaysians, majority of Malaysians want. So, on one hand, we understand why Dr. Su Zahid would say
02:52something of that sort that is not concrete yet. Because there are still a lot of things to talk
02:58about, especially on seat negotiations. We know about that in the southern states, PAS have, in a
03:05way, kind of given way to BN. What would happen up north in the SG4 states, in Selangor, Perak, Pahang.
03:12So, there's still a lot of rentals for them to work over. And because of that, I think they're
03:19trying to present it as, you know, it's still a work in progress so that they have leverage to
03:24negotiate.
03:24Right. So, definitely you're right. I guess in the PAS three electoral outings, PAS has taken a backseat
03:32and given a more, I guess, a more driving role to UMNO because they have been historically strong in
03:40those states. But in the states where PAS is dominant, the dominant party, do you think that
03:48this cooperation might fall apart? Professor Wong Chin Huat, political scientist, Professor Wong Chin Huat
03:54said that this is, he likened it to two brothers fighting over the same girl. And it might not be
03:59a
03:59lasting arrangement. Is that, what do you think? Do you think that they can overcome this, you
04:06know, rivalry, this historical competition for the same girl, for the same voter in GE16?
04:13What do you think, Dr. Shaza?
04:15In a way, I agree. So, here's the thing. If PAS did give way to PAS did give way to
04:23PAS
04:23in the southern states, if it's a reciprocal relationship, we expect that, okay, maybe
04:29BN would give way, let PAS lead the states up north, the SG4 states basically. But the
04:37question is, would Barisan really allow that? And we saw in during the UMNO Assembly, Tok Mat
04:43challenging PAS to dissolve Terengganu. So, we see that that this relationship is still a
04:49bit rocky. But more than that, my reading of it is that we've always talked about PAS, how,
04:54you know, they play the long game. It's okay for them to take a back seat, give AMNO the
05:00front seat, because they are thinking is that it's not this election, but maybe in the next
05:05one or two cycles, then they'll become the main dominant major force in Malaysian politics.
05:09But it's not the same with Barisan. Barisan, they're not looking forward, I believe. They're
05:14looking backwards in the sense that they would claim that they had 60 years of governing the country,
05:20you know, trust us, we can do the same. They want to keep to the, I'm sorry to say, to
05:25the
05:25little power that they have right now. So, I'm not sure how much Barisan would allow PAS to really
05:33lead again in the northern states. So, for that reason, yes, it may crumble before GE16 or it may even
05:43crumble after GE16, maybe they can work up something before the election. But again, a lot of questions
05:50would come in later, once and if they form government about other things, especially on leadership
05:56matters. For the reasons that I mentioned earlier, Barisan would want to have the front seat.
06:01Can we come back to Melaka specifically? And I want to look back at the Johor state election where the
06:07the Barisan national landslide win was actually, I would say, largely driven by the Menteri Basah,
06:13the on Hafiz effect. I'm wondering whether that was the case in Melaka. Do you think that the
06:18leadership of Abdul Rahul played a part in the commanding victory of Barisan national in Melaka?
06:26I would say so. It's just that different levels of, how should I say, in Johor, on Hafiz was really
06:36front facing. Everyone was talking about it. It's not just in Johor, like nationally, everyone knows
06:41he's the poster boy. In Melaka, we don't really talk about that idea of a poster boy, right? Datuk
06:46Abdul Rahul was not really, quote unquote, a poster boy. But when you talk to people on the ground,
06:50in Melaka, everyone has good things to say about him, how he's a good chief minister. He comes to see
06:56the people. He comes to the ground. So, in a way, I would say, yes, part of the big success
07:02of
07:02Parisan national was Datuk Abdul Rahul. That people have a lot of faith, a lot of trust in his
07:08administration. And, you know, people want kind of a longevity when it comes to policy matters. So,
07:14people want to see what else he can do in the next five years. So, definitely, he's a major role,
07:19but not in the way that on Hafiz was this poster boy that everyone was so excited to talk about
07:24and
07:25to see him coming back as Menteri Versa in Johor. So, that was the UMNO past the BN side. Can
07:33we take
07:33a look at the PH side and particularly Pakatan Harapan and Malay support? PKR and Amanah in particular,
07:42are these parties still electorally competitive, Dr Shaza?
07:48The difficult thing is that PKR and especially Amanah, their job within Pakatan is to get the
07:55Malay votes. And since we are seeing this huge swing towards BN and PN among Malay voters,
08:04it becomes difficult to imagine or to think of a situation in the upcoming election where Amanah and
08:13PKR could really challenge BN and PN. But within, so that's a national kind of view, right? An overall
08:22view. But within Pakatan Harapan, I would say yes, they still have a role to play. DAP can't really
08:30penetrate into Malay majority seats. So, they still need that relationship with Amanah, with PKR and PKR
08:39having its own problems. But they still can work together, the three of them within Pakatan Harapan.
08:45But to really be a challenge to Barisan and Perikatan, yeah, they may need lots more work to do on
08:56that in order to remove their votes. But the idea was in Melaka was to have this sort of informal
09:02cooperation with Bersatu. So, Pakatan Harapan and Bersatu, Bersatu was supposed to help draw
09:08Malay votes. Was that not enough to help PH attract Malay votes? Yeah, that tells you already, right,
09:17how they, the lack of confidence in their own parties, component parties to get Malay votes that
09:23they feel that they need Bersatu. I put it this way, if you look at Melaka, Bersatu perform quite okay,
09:28I would say actually, they get a good percentage of votes in certain seats, 30%. So, maybe Bersatu
09:36can be that that party to add on in a way to to PKR and Amanah. But taking everything together,
09:43I would say the calculation would still be about 20 to 30% of Malay. And even then, I would
09:50say 30%
09:51is something that would be difficult actually for PH to reach, even with Bersatu. But I think
09:58that's the thing that Pakatan is doing right now. They're trying to get all the partnership they can
10:04get to cover all the loopholes that they have, especially when it comes to winning Malay votes.
10:10All right. Can I ask you, Dr Shaza, in terms of the issues that resonated with voters?
10:15One of the, I guess, later developments within the campaign period was Najib's house arrest. How much
10:21do you think that factored into this election, either in the lead up in the campaigning or on voter
10:28sentiment? I think it did play a major role. Okay, let's discuss the easy one, which is for the
10:36Pakatan Harapan supporters. They're really unhappy with the outcome. I think they made it very clear.
10:43There might be protest votes. We saw that, right? Bandar Hile, the lowest turnout among the 28 seats
10:50in Melaka, which is a traditional DAP seat. So, yeah, definitely it impacted PH supporters. Now,
10:57on the BN side, I would say the same thing, even though I know some might disagree with me, but
11:02I feel that with the release of Datuk Seri Najib to home arrest a few days before the election, what
11:12it did was
11:13that it gave this sense of euphoria in a way for Bahraes and supporters that, hey, we got this one
11:19win,
11:20this thing that we've been fighting for more or less since 2022 and we got it. So, psychologically,
11:29it leads them to believe that they can keep this quote-unquote momentum, not just when it comes to
11:34electoral victory, but, you know, politically, we still have influence, we still have power. And if we,
11:41as in Parisan, come together, work together with Perikatan, maybe we can do more because we've had this
11:47one win. So, yes, I think it, psychologically, their voters feel this sense of, we need to come
11:52out, we need to vote and support Barisan. Okay. So, riding on that feeling of euphoria, I want to ask
11:58you,
11:59are we, so we have Sarawak elections coming up in the next month or so, but do you think we
12:07are,
12:08given that feeling of euphoria that you say Barisan National and UMNO might have, are we done for
12:15state elections in Peninsula Malaysia until GE 16 or do you think there could be more ahead?
12:24I think maybe we are done. I just can't think of any good reasons for any of the coalitions to
12:31push for any more state elections. Firstly, it's not very popular with the people anymore since GE is
12:37coming up in one year, I would say. So, I think this is it for Peninsula Malaysia. We'll just see
12:45what
12:46Sarawak would have to offer us. But I think the next thing we're looking at is really GE 16.
12:51Wow. Okay. All right. Dr. Shaza, thank you so much for your time. I appreciate you sharing your
12:55insights with us. Dr. Shaza Shukri from IIUM. I'm going to take a quick break here and consider this.
13:00I'll be back with more on the Melaka State elections. Stay tuned. We'll be right back.
13:25Hi, welcome back to Consider This. I'm Melissa Idris. Let's continue our discussion about the
13:30results of the Melaka election where the Barisan National and Perikatan National Electoral
13:37Alliance has continued to prove successful, winning some 24 seats for a super majority in the State
13:45Legislative Assembly. Joining me on the show now, I have Aira Azhari, who's the CEO of Ideas Malaysia.
13:53Aira, thank you so much for joining me on the show today. How did you interpret the decisive win
13:58in Melaka? I'm quite curious to know what you thought was some of the reasons or the driving
14:04factors behind Barisan National or UMNO's success? Yeah. Hi Mel. So for Melaka, well, you know, it seems like
14:15it is a big, huge win for Barisan National. Well, it is a big win, but I wouldn't say that
14:22it's totally
14:23surprising. You know, because they were the incumbent state government and Melaka apart from the maybe two
14:33years under the first PH administration has always been quite a strong bastion state for UMNO. Of course, this time,
14:46the BN-PN
14:48electoral pact strengthened their machinery prevented the clash between the Malay parties in BN in many of the seats.
15:00So that clearly gave an advantage in terms of increasing the majorities that was won by BN in many seats.
15:10So I think, you know, it's a combination of both, but we also shouldn't discount the fact that BN does
15:19have a track record in the state, you know, and
15:23you know, after Johor and also Negeri Milan, of course, we also can't deny that BN came into the election
15:33with a momentum that was already set from their victories in the last two state elections.
15:40So I think all these factors combined really made the win quite expected, I would say.
15:48Aira, can we talk about that momentum? So I think there's been a lot of commentary out there about this
15:55so-called blue wave. I don't know what people are calling it. Blue Nami? Biru Nami? So Biru Nami, yes.
16:02So what do you think about this? Is it an accurate representation of this trend that we're seeing in the
16:10last three electoral outings?
16:12Will that likely continue going into GE 16?
16:16Yeah, so this Biru Nami terminology, we like to come up with different ones for every election.
16:23The last one, the last PRU was green wave, right? So, yeah, well, I think it's different from, say,
16:31the so-called green wave from the last GE because, well, Marisa National being dominant was kind of the
16:40status quo before 2018, at least. So I think, you know, it's not that Malaysia has not seen a Biru
16:48Nami
16:48before. It's just that now I think the dynamics have changed a bit because UMNO-BN as a party,
16:56as a coalition has also changed the composition of, you know, there were, after 2018, the fragmentation just
17:04changed the nature of political parties in Malaysia. I think maybe what makes it a bit different now,
17:14or maybe why people are so kind of anxious or like surprised is because the federal government is
17:23being led by UNRNPH, right? So I think there is an expectation that when the federal government is
17:31dominated by a certain party, then it would be a no-brainer that the states would also be
17:39governed by the same party. But we're not seeing that in this case. And of course, many people
17:46associate the results of the state elections with what's happening at the federal level. Some
17:51people are calling it like there's a dissatisfaction with ANWAR and PH at the federal level that's being
17:58reflected. I mean, I think that those, all those factors could be true. State issues and also federal
18:06issues are, of course, different, right? And you can't really transplant federal issues into the
18:14states, of course. But I mean, you know, nothing we live in a world where we have a 24-hour
18:21news cycle
18:21and you can't really separate issues per se. So whatever unhappiness that people have with the federal
18:29government, you know, perhaps without even realizing it or subconsciously is being reflected at the ballot box.
18:36at the state level. So one discussion we had when I was on Awani during election night was when the,
18:43you know, the state elections, the succession of state elections can be seen like similar to the
18:50midterm elections in the US where it's always a referendum against the president. I thought that
18:56was an interesting point. And yeah, I think we could be seeing that some of that dissatisfaction perhaps
19:02being translated at the state level. Aira, then how do you think or do you think Najib's house
19:10arrests factored into this election? Did it play a part? If you're saying that maybe this was a
19:16referendum and this development happened quite late in the campaign period for Melaka, what do you think
19:23in terms of Najib's house arrest? Did that factor into it? Yeah, well, you know, it's hard to tell
19:30because if it did, then it benefited UMNO, right? Which is, of course, Najib's party.
19:39Perhaps there are core Pakatan Harapan supporters who feel that, you know, Anwar's zeal or rhetoric
19:50against corruption or fighting corruption, you know, is not, is seen as false when Najib's house arrest
20:00was granted by the court. So, you know, and this could have been reflected in how the voting trends
20:08were. I think, you know, PH does have a crisis where their core supporters, I think, are increasingly
20:17feeling disappointed, I would say, in the coalition. DAP used to be, or no, I shouldn't say used to be,
20:27DAP is, has always been a linchpin of the Pakatan Harapan coalition. And, you know, the four seats that
20:36PH won in Melaka are all, of course, DAP seats as well. But, you know, even DAP, with their strong
20:42performance and the strong machinery of the ground, also has been facing some trust deficit issues.
20:49We know that Anthony Loh had to resign from his ministership because of the house arrest. And,
20:57you know, in Johor and Gris Milan as well, there were losses for DAP, which I think were pretty unexpected,
21:03including in the Gris Milan fight Anthony Loh. So, you know, definitely there is that trust deficit
21:11within their core supporters. And, of course, now we have Parti Bersama, which is a splinter party from
21:18KR. And it'll be interesting to see how many votes from PH that they managed to steal away, right?
21:25We've seen in Melaka, in Bemban, where PH did not contest, the Bersama candidate finished second,
21:34although a very distant second from the winner. But you can see that when PH is not around and they
21:42don't contest, then Bersama seems to do better. Right. Aira, so having said that,
21:47I think opinions are split at the moment about Bersama. And until we have, at this point,
21:53it's still quite an initial reaction, but until we have further polling data, we'll see how the vote
21:58transferability, as you mentioned a bit earlier. But what do you think? Do you think, what do you think
22:04about Bersama's future and looking ahead, what their biggest challenges are for such a small and new
22:11party like Bersama? Yeah, so because of our electoral system, because of our coalition system,
22:19you know, we know that it's always difficult for new parties, small parties to go edit on their own
22:27and win elections. So historically, at least in the recent history, for smaller parties,
22:34they've managed to win, but only when there is some sort of electoral pact, right? So we could see
22:40that with Muda, Saeed Sadiq, and also YB Amira, who won their seats, either when they were in different
22:48parties, or there was an electoral pact. Same with PSM, also in recent history. So with Bersama,
22:57I don't see that changing. I think unless they get into some sort of, I wouldn't say join a coalition,
23:04I think that would jeopardize their brand too much. But unless they can come up with some kind of
23:10electoral pact, it will also be similar for them. However, I think the difference with Bersama is that
23:17they seem to be a lot bolder than other new parties. They're putting it, they put up like what,
23:2216 candidates in Melaka. And yeah, so I think their boldness is quite interesting. The way they
23:30recruit candidates as well is also unconventional. I think they called out and there was an open call
23:35for candidates, which is very different from how parties in Malaysia generally put up candidates
23:43during the elections. So the test for Bersama, I believe, would be how would they brand themselves
23:48as a party that is ideologically distinct and has their own worldview, their own vision for Malaysia,
23:57and you know, not be stuck with the label of a party of Rafizi or a party of people who
24:05were
24:05dissatisfied with ANOA, so they left, right? So I think trying to move away from that stigma,
24:11from that label is really important because I think that's only when people can take them
24:18more seriously and what they can offer to the electorate. I do believe that there are sections
24:24of the electorate that do want something refreshing and something new in Malaysian politics. But again,
24:31people usually vote pragmatically. So if a party like Bersama, they know that they can't get into
24:36government, people just might go for the alternative, which is PH at the moment.
24:43All right. Well, okay. So in the time that we have left, I do want to ask you, you said
24:46earlier about
24:47the momentum of this win, the third win, the hat trick, so to speak, of this electoral pact
24:53between BN and PN. Do you think this might, and some commentators are saying this, that Barisan
24:59National might be emboldened by this third successive win, that there might be more pressure on Anwar
25:05Ibrahim to dissolve parliament earlier than expected? And do you think Anwar might either cave or resist
25:13that pressure? Yeah, definitely there is a momentum that is on BN side. You know, they clearly,
25:24after three successive victories would feel emboldened coming into an election.
25:32Yes, I think the pressure from them to dissolve parliament would continue. Ultimately, Anwar does
25:41have the, he holds that card, and I'm sure he's holding it close to his chest. And yeah, I mean,
25:50I think there are many moving parts as well. It's very close to the end of the year, of course.
25:56And
25:57in Malaysia, it's not that hard to find out actually when elections are, you know, with all the festive
26:01seasons. And then we know that next year, we're hosting the Sea Games. So all of this will definitely
26:07come into play. The Prime Minister, any Prime Minister would want to call elections only when either he's
26:15confident that he can win or a time when there's like least damage for himself and his party. So I
26:22don't think Anwar is at that point yet, despite the three victories. You know, I mean, I think if you
26:31at the last Malacca State election, Richard, which was in 2021, I think PH performed badly as well. But
26:39you know, in the 2022 January elections, they lost all the parliamentary seats in the state. So
26:46anything can happen, of course. And I think at the federal level, there is definitely different
26:55issues and different sentiments at play. So yeah, I think the pressure will continue. But I'm not so sure
27:02if Anwar will cave into it just yet.
27:06Aira, thank you so much for being on the show. Aira Azhari from Ideas Malaysia wrapping up this episode
27:11of Consider This. I'm Melissa Idris, signing off for the evening. Thank you so much for watching and good night.
27:25So
27:25aira Azhari
27:25has it?
27:27Aira Azhari
27:27that
27:27has it?
27:28die
27:28as
27:28we
27:29we
27:29who
27:29we
27:30who
27:30anything
27:30You
Comments

Recommended