00:00In the coming weeks, the Constitutional Court will issue a new ruling on a conflict
00:05regarding carbon credits. What's striking this time is that the company being sued
00:11It is Más Bosques, the same one that prompted the first ruling on this issue in 2024.
00:17Wait, if you write news in the comments, the full story will arrive in your inbox.
00:21First of all. But before we continue, a brief explanation of what carbon credits are.
00:26In the RedMás projects, as they are also known, communities commit to conservation
00:32the forests in which they live. In return, for every ton of CO2 that is avoided being emitted into the
00:37Maintaining forests standing generates a carbon credit. By covering large areas
00:43of land, the reserves hold hundreds of thousands of carbon credits that are acquired
00:48by national and international companies that use them to offset emissions
00:54of CO2 they generate. These projects can generate hundreds or billions of CO2.
00:59of pesos.
01:00Let's return to the project in Guainía. Since 2018, Más Bosques has been developing the
01:05RedMás Aguacadá-Matsiadali project, which covers 13 indigenous reserves and more than 500,000
01:11hectares. To give you an idea, this is an area larger than the entire
01:16department of Risaralda. The case that prompted the proceedings before the Court originated in the
01:21The Carrizal reserve has an interesting feature: it is inhabited by indigenous people.
01:26Sikwani and Puinave. Two Puinave leaders denounce that Más Bosques negotiated the entry of the reserve.
01:32the Aguacadá-Matsiadali project only with the governing council of the time, which was from
01:37Sikwani people. That was in 2022. In 2025, when the Puinave leaders came to occupy
01:44The position of council governor, they sent a petition to Más Bosques asking
01:48He asked her to answer three questions. To whom had they sold the carbon credits?
01:53Their safekeeping? What was the financial scheme for managing the resources? And what had they been used for?
01:58Did those resources get spent? Más Bosques refused to hand over the information. The company told them
02:04He asked the two leaders to prove their authority in order to hand it over to them.
02:08information. Despite having it verified, the company refused again. In that second instance
02:14Más Bosques said that other communities involved in the project had not authorized it.
02:20the delivery of that information. The Puinave leaders filed a legal action requesting
02:25that Más Bosques would provide them with the requested information. They won; the company delivered the
02:30information, but appealed the ruling. On appeal, the court upheld the first ruling
02:35and sent the case file to the Constitutional Court. Julián Trujillo, director of the Legal Clinic
02:41Javeriana University, which has been involved in the process, explains that the case is novel, as it raises
02:46an unprecedented issue in the Colombian legal system. To determine whether the information on
02:52Carbon credit projects can be treated as private information by
02:56the project developers or, conversely, if it is public environmental information
03:02Subject to the principle of maximum publicity. Furthermore, the case has several aggravating factors, as
03:09This is the second project by Más Bosques to reach a process before the Constitutional Court.
03:14Furthermore, it is possible that the company sold the loans before having the necessary guarantee to do so.
03:20and there are even indications that the project overlaps with another company's project.
03:26If you want to know more details about this dispute between indigenous people of Guainía and the company
03:31who was involved in the first ruling on carbon credits issued by the Constitutional Court,
03:37in addition to understanding what they are asking for and what the high court can order in
03:43In this case,
03:44Don't miss the full article we published in the Environment section of El Espectador.
03:48And if you don't want to miss more stories like these, be sure to follow us on all our social media channels.
04:07Thank you.
04:08Thank you.
04:08Thank you.
04:09Thank you.
04:09Thank you.
04:09Thank you.
04:09Thank you.
04:10Thank you.
04:10Thank you.
04:10Thank you.
04:10Thank you.
04:10Thank you.
04:11Thank you.
04:11Thank you.
04:11Thank you.
04:11Thank you.