00:00How would you characterize po yung strength po, yung lakas ng allegation kapag gawin ni Drono po?
00:05Well, I leave it to the sound wisdom, sound discretion of the Honorable Impeachment Court.
00:10How would they assess the strength or the weakness or the fact that it was withdrawn?
00:16So I leave it to the wisdom po.
00:18All right. Thank you.
00:18Now, let me show you a video and then ask you thereafter.
00:22Your Honor, this video is unmarked, but we reserve the right to mark it at the proper time.
00:27This is around seven minutes, Your Honor, so we beg the court's indulgence.
00:32If we may be allowed to play, Your Honor.
00:35Before the video is played, Honorable Chell?
00:37Yes, I see from the caption that the video pertains to statements made by the late Senator Miriam, Defensor Sanchago.
00:45I believe that would pertain to the Corona Impeachment Trial.
00:50That's correct.
00:50Yes, then I would have to object, Your Honor, because the circumstances pertaining to that trial are different in terms
00:57of the withdrawal to this trial and the situation here.
01:01I have no question yet.
01:02We are aware of that, counsel.
01:06Again, subject to cross, insofar as pointing that out is concerned, is there a shorter version of this, Attorney Mark?
01:14I distinctly remember, actually, what Senator Miriam said in this.
01:18Well, we will ask a certain portion of that material, Your Honor, if you may be allowed to.
01:24Yes, when you get to that point, you can pause it already.
01:29All right, thank you, Your Honor.
01:31Tech is instructed to play the video.
01:33There is no further meaning factor that prevents you from presenting your evidence that you already said to us in
01:44January you are going to present.
01:45Letter C is merely corroborative or cumulative.
01:49This does not apply because when you file an impeachment complaint, you have different articles of impeachment which are separate
01:56from and independent of each other.
01:57So, none of these articles of impeachment, just like causes of action in a civil case, are said to be
02:03cumulative or corroborative.
02:04Cumulative means you already produced evidence in the form of one witness, and you just want to add, let's say,
02:0910 more witnesses to completely repeat what that other witness said.
02:13That is corroborative.
02:14Kaya, kung corroborative lang witness mo, pwedeng hindi mo na ipresenta.
02:18Ito naman, hindi corroborative eh.
02:20Because they are separate and distinct articles of impeachment.
02:26And, letter D, the suppression is an exercise of a privilege.
02:29Kanyang defendant sa bank accounts niya, ayaw niyang magbigay ng consent niya.
02:35But we cannot apply this presumption to him because the suppression is the exercise of his privilege.
02:43That is a privilege given to any person who opens a dollar bank account.
02:46The law provides confidentiality is absolute except only when the depositor is...
02:55giving his consent.
02:57Ngayon ito, kaiba itong inyong kaso na ito.
03:00Wala kayong privilege eh.
03:02When you file an article of impeachment or a cause of action, it is not only your right to present
03:10evidence, it is also your duty.
03:13It's not a privilege that you can just waive at will.
03:15That is not what the law means by the suppression is the exercise of a privilege.
03:21You have no such privilege to bother the court.
03:24Cases.
03:25People v. Melo Santos, 1995.
03:28The prosecution evidence must at all times be competent and admissible to sustain its stand.
03:36The prosecution cannot rely on an imaginary person charging a serious offense without extending to the accused the benefit of
03:46confronting his accuser.
03:48In default of a satisfactory premise for the non-presentation of crucial witness, it ineluctably follows that disputable presumption that
03:58evidence deliberately withheld would be adverse if reduced remains undisturbed.
04:13What are you conducting trial by publicity? Is that what you're trying to do?
04:19We will not be swayed.
04:22The entire capacity for tsunami waves by Manila Bay can fall over this impeachment court and will not be affected
04:32by what you say in the public or what your chosen public brings back to you, particularly if they've been
04:39paid to do so.
04:41Please, do not try these little dirty tricks on us.
04:44We're all old people here.
04:47Tumanda na tayo lahat sa politikawang nyo kaming ginaganyan, ha?
04:53Kamukha ng survey, just as I predicted.
04:56Aba, may balita kanina, sa isang dyaryo, ng survey daw sa UP, 500 ang respondents, at like 75% of
05:04them said,
05:05no, we no longer trust the chief justice.
05:07Kayo nga, UP kayo, dapat kayo i-kick out immediately.
05:12If you are true, actual person, you should be kicked out immediately.
05:18Because you do not deserve to be in UP, and the people who machinated the publication of that press release,
05:25should likewise be kicked out of UP.
05:28If they're enrolled in the roles of the university as alumni, they should be permanently erased from the roles as
05:38a perpetual shame on the university.
05:40Pero mo, may survey daw sila, na 500 katao sa UP, nagsabi, ng chief justice so far because of the
05:48prosecution evidence, can no longer be trusted.
05:53Eh, ang tasa pa naman ng pagtingin ng tao sa UP, pakatapos limang daan lang, out of let us say
06:0050 million all over the Philippines,
06:01and it's not even conducted on scientific basis, it's not conducted by any of those reliable survey firms
06:07that have already been proven in their forecast for election results.
06:13Kanya-kanya lang sila.
06:14Grabe!
06:15My goodness me!
06:18If I were,
06:21the symbol of UP is standing there, naked,
06:24called the ablation,
06:26I would immediately throw away my fig leaf.
06:31I cannot imagine a survey where 500 high IQ people will say,
06:40we have already lost trust in the chief justice because we have already heard the evidence from the prosecution,
06:46although we admit that the defense has not yet presented its case.
06:50Grabe naman.
06:51Sino namang PR firm nag-isip nito?
06:53Sabihin lang ninyo, tanapin ko yun.
06:57You are playing games!
06:59I was not born yesterday.
07:02I was born a long time ago and I'm about to die.
07:05I want to leave a legacy
07:07that at least, when presented with this anomaly,
07:11in trial technique, I rose to condemn it.
07:14Kindly pause the video.
07:16Mr. President, kindly pause.
07:25For more nations,
07:30to give us your notice among people right now,
07:30including verse yunshake.
07:30I love everybody.
07:30For more nations,
07:31we are a 모�dera.
07:31we are a אבל adult jeunes community,
07:32We are figuring out,