• 58 minutes ago
Meera Shankar analyses the Quad meeting and shifting geopolitics among the US, China, and India, highlighting key developments and trade tensions.

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00Joining us on this special broadcast is Ambassador Meera Shankar, India's former ambassador to the United States of America.
00:07Ambassador Shankar, welcome.
00:09Ma'am, what are key takeaways for you from the readout of the Quad summit, of the Quad leaders meeting?
00:18Is that impression going out that President Trump is either losing interest or has lost interest in Quad?
00:24The fact that this meeting happened after a gap of two years and was barely about 55-watt minutes?
00:31Well, I think this has been a question that President Trump is not invested personally in the Quad
00:43and that his priority has been to try to work out a constructive relationship of strategic stability, as it has
00:52been called, with China.
00:55So I think it's significant that he did attend this summit.
01:01So that is political signaling of some sort that he is, he remains invested in Quad.
01:09And the fact that it is happening on the eve of the trilateral summit with President Xi and with President
01:20Putin in Shenzhen, I think sends its own message.
01:25This has also happened in the wake of the NVIDIA scandal, where, you know, through espionage or fraud, China is
01:36believed to have procured high-technology NVIDIA chips.
01:41And this, again, coming on the eve of the trilateral summit, shows that there are differences about how conciliatory approach
01:56the U.S. should follow with regard to China.
02:00And this will, in effect, mean that export restrictions on sending such chips abroad will be tightened,
02:15both for China as well as for third countries from which it may have procured, for instance, data centers in
02:24Malaysia or other countries.
02:26And then we have to see if China retaliates in kind by imposing restrictions on critical minerals.
02:34So we really don't know where this will go.
02:38As regards the outcome of the Quad leaders meeting itself, you have their reiterating their commitment to a free and
02:52open Indo-Pacific.
02:54They commit to ensuring...
02:58So let's take this step by step, ma'am.
02:59Let's take this step by step.
03:01Let's talk about the key takeaway.
03:03Is a key takeaway, you know, the long-range maritime reconnaissance aircraft exercise for anti-submarine warfare.
03:11President Trump himself spoke of, you know, 30 rounds of the Malabar series of exercises that have already taken place.
03:17But then now they're bringing in, you know, the P-8s and India operates the P-8i, as you well
03:22know, ma'am.
03:23The P-3C Orions, which India doesn't operate, but then those are, you know, the P-3Cs also being brought
03:29in.
03:30Is that a step forward?
03:31Is that again a signal?
03:33Because if you're doing anti-submarine warfare or anti-ship warfare, who's the signal being sent out to, if not
03:39China?
03:40Well, I think that it's a step up from what the Quad countries were doing earlier with regard to maritime
03:48surveillance.
03:50And they, last year, they agreed on a maritime surveillance framework.
03:56And under that framework, they are now proposing to actually have exercises of their surveillance aircraft, the P-3 and
04:06P-8, as you have said, which will take place in 2027.
04:11So that's certainly a step up in their efforts to work together on generating greater maritime domain awareness and ensuring
04:23the safety and security of sea lanes.
04:27Secondly, I think they have agreed on a business leader summit again next year, which would be an effort to
04:37step up economic cooperation amongst the Quad countries.
04:41The third element is the effort to welcome increased connectivity, particularly cable connectivity, both in telecom as well as communication
04:56links, as well as energy in the Indo-Pacific.
05:00Then there is cooperation with regard to cyber security and the AI accelerator, which would mean deploying, you know, access
05:14and deployment of trusted AI.
05:18So these are the specifics that they have agreed to while continuing their efforts on critical minerals and resilient supply
05:27chains.
05:31So when President Trump says that in the next 10 months, India, the United States and Japan will catch up
05:39with them, do you see real effort happening in India, US and Japan trying to catch up with China on
05:47rare earth minerals?
05:48And whether it's manufacturing of chip or harnessing technology, is that trust there?
05:53Because when it comes to President Trump, the impression is he says something on Monday, he may say something completely
05:59different on Tuesday, and things would be very different the third day.
06:03And look at the manner in which, you know, India started engaging so well with the United States of America
06:08when he was sworn in and after his inauguration.
06:12And suddenly those Trump tariffs came and hit us.
06:15Are, is the relationship returning on an even keel?
06:18Will the next two years be better or will it be more of the same in your view, ma'am?
06:24Right now, I, you know, on the tariff issue, I don't see much change.
06:30You know, we are still at a stage where we are, the agreement we are supposed to sign with the
06:38US, the interim one,
06:40is still awaiting, you know, clarity about the US tariff structure, and the degree of preference that India will get
06:50vis-a-vis other countries.
06:52So that's something we are waiting for.
06:55Then, you know, on many other issues, the Trump administration has not been very forward looking in its relationship with
07:07India,
07:07whether it's sharing technology or, you know, giving, treating India as being of strategic consequence.
07:16I think on all these issues, there have been doubts about where India stands vis-a-vis the US.
07:24Whether this will all clear, we don't know.
07:27But the fact that Trump has now attended the Quad Leaders Summit, which he was loath to do earlier, is
07:37sending a signal.
07:38If that signal will be sustained going forward, is a question.
07:44But clearly, the rest of the establishment in Washington wants a more conventional foreign policy,
07:55where they work with partners, strategic partners, and with alliances, which they have,
08:05to improve stability and balance in the Indo-Pacific region.
08:15So, you know, we've seen this, we've seen this meander so much that it changed, it changed Ambassador Shankar,
08:22it changed from Indo-Pacific to Asia-Pacific, today again he said Indo-Pacific.
08:27It just seems that either the US administration or the White House, they don't care about what's happening here,
08:34they don't know what's happening here, or do you see a method to their madness that they want this region
08:39to remain in turmoil?
08:40And if he wants to stabilize relationship with China, that is seen as a competitor, if not a rival, in
08:47decades to come,
08:48but he wants to upset countries like India that are seen as strategic partners,
08:52somewhere down the line, the Trump administration functioning doesn't seem to add up into what they want to do,
08:59either internally or externally.
09:02Well, I think there is a degree of strategic incoherence about the policy,
09:08and some of it flows from Trump's tactics, which involve blowing hot and cold at the same time on most
09:19issues,
09:20and with most countries, including alliances, allies and strategic partners.
09:26So it, you know, it introduces a degree of confusion about the way, about the US perspective on this region.
09:39But again, as I said, there's some political significance in the fact that President Trump did come for the Trump
09:47summit,
09:48for the Quad summit on the eve of his meeting, and that the, you know, scandal with NVIDIA and the
09:59espionage allegations against China in this regard
10:04will perhaps lead to a hardening of, or could, I won't say will, could perhaps lead to a hardening of
10:14perspective in the US.
10:16Again, we have to wait and see, because with President Trump, things are always fluid.
10:26So right now, is Quad a footnote and the trilateral at Shenzhen the major headline?
10:33And do you see a new architecture, some kind of a G3 emerge, or it's too soon to look at
10:39it as an architecture for G3?
10:41I mean, this is grabbing big headlines, but for the three of them to find areas of convergence is easier
10:47said than done.
10:49Yes, I think it's the fact that they are meeting, which is grabbing eyeballs, but there's no agreed agenda for
10:59the meeting as yet.
11:01President Xi has said that they will discuss world peace and what the three countries can do to help stabilize
11:08the world.
11:10And then I think President Trump has said he wants to discuss nuclear disarmament or nuclear arms limitation.
11:21And that's because all the arrangements between Russia and the Soviet Union, on the one hand, and the US for
11:31arms limitation and strategic stability in Europe have broken down or come to an end and have not been extended.
11:39And President Trump says he would like to begin fresh negotiations, but he wants to draw China into the fold
11:48of those negotiations, because he says China's arsenal has grown and is growing.
11:58So they cannot leave it out of the strategic calculus while working out limits on the deployment of US and
12:09Russian nuclear arsenals.
12:11Okay.
12:11They feel China needs to be brought in, but China opposes this fiercely.
12:17So where all this is going to go, we don't know.
12:21It's too early to say.
12:25So there are several balls, yeah, there are several balls up in the air and we're tracking that story very
12:29closely here in Shenzhen.
12:31Ambassador Meera Shankar, as always, for joining me here on this India First special broadcast.
12:36Many thanks.

Recommended