Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 3 years ago
You say that the establishment is under pressure on the EC, so prove it, CJP
Transcript
00:00 You can say, yes, it continues today, you may say so.
00:05 But today, your opponents are not in government.
00:11 They're not.
00:12 We use the word casually, establishment, establishment.
00:18 Why don't we use the word honestly, army?
00:22 There does not apparently appear to be any interference.
00:26 You may allege there is.
00:29 But you know the overt kind of stuff, unless you point out,
00:32 matters are coming, elections are not being held.
00:34 It was your own petition we argued,
00:36 which we pressed it in 12 days.
00:38 We got the date.
00:40 You were happy.
00:41 Everybody was happy when it--
00:42 so access to courts is there.
00:45 It's not that nobody allowed you to file.
00:47 Making allegations on the media or outside
00:52 undermines, unnecessarily undermines
00:54 constitution, institution, which does not
00:56 mean you should not make these allegations if they
00:59 are true.
00:59 Now, the very same election commission
01:01 has issued you the notice to hold elections as far back
01:05 when you were in government.
01:06 Can you start from there?
01:08 What was the malefide then?
01:10 Please read that notice, the first one.
01:12 Because from a timeline point of view,
01:14 that will be very important.
01:15 Because if we have to gauge whether suddenly
01:21 the euphemism that is used, establishment,
01:24 is weighing heavy on the election commission
01:28 and doing something.
01:30 You will certainly hear this.
01:32 But then how did they know then when
01:36 the very same establishment--
01:39 surely it was not your allegation
01:41 then that they were siding with the election
01:43 commission of Pakistan.
01:44 So if you're going to make it dramatic and political,
01:47 then give the whole context or keep it legal.
01:52 So if you're going to use--
01:54 I mean, I respect every constitutional body.
01:57 You said malefide in fact and law.
02:00 Did we appoint them?
02:01 You all appoint these people.
02:02 We don't appoint them.
02:04 So when you just throw an allegation,
02:06 it's not acceptable because you don't serve Pakistan then.
02:10 We need these institutions.
02:12 We can make them better.
02:13 If they're not doing their job, force them to do their job.
02:17 That's our job.
02:18 But we cannot take on their responsibilities.
02:20 Because you'll be the first to complain.
02:22 We will not take on the responsibilities of parliament
02:25 as I have repeatedly stated.
02:27 You will be the first to complain.
02:29 Who is he?
02:30 I'm the parliamentarian.
02:31 I'll make the law.
02:32 I want to.
02:33 We judge the law, whether it's constitutional or not.
02:36 And that's it.
02:37 [SPEAKING HINDI]
02:39 [SPEAKING HINDI]
02:39 It changes the prism completely.
02:47 If they're malefide, then we look at them
02:49 at very suspect eyes.
02:51 Or you take away this allegation.
02:53 I'm not saying take it away.
02:55 It's your call.
02:57 I'll be totally non-political in my arguments in Lordship
03:00 as always.
03:02 There's no point in bringing-- although it's
03:05 relevant to a political party, this case.
03:08 But I will keep it very legal.
03:09 And on the malefide in fact, I will
03:12 be more relying on procedural malefide than anything else.
03:15 I'm not going to--
03:16 Are you withdrawing the allegation of malefide in fact?
03:19 Because it's very important.
03:21 You have to answer this.
03:23 I'm-- when I use the word malefide in fact,
03:26 maybe I was wrong in saying in terms of--
03:29 See, you can withdraw it if you want to.
03:31 You can't withdraw it if you don't want to.
03:33 I'm not even going into that arena.
03:37 I'm basically going to argue that there's
03:38 a procedural clear cut on the--
03:41 I'm noting that you are withdrawing your--
03:43 you're not saying malefide in fact.
03:44 I'm not saying malefide in fact.
03:46 Please proceed.
03:48 You are always fair.
03:49 Please proceed.
03:52 Now, your Lordship, so I was starting
03:56 by saying that symbol is a fundamental right
03:59 of a political party under Article 17, subarticle 2.
04:06 And I'm not saying that your Lordship said back it up.
04:11 I will back it up with a judgment which is known
04:14 as the famous symbols case.
04:16 Benazir Bhutto case?
04:17 Yes.
04:18 I think both parties are relying on the same judgment.
04:21 They are not.
04:22 They are relying on the other Benazir Bhutto judgment of '88.
04:25 I am relying on the '89 judgment.
04:28 Citation, please.
04:29 It is PLD '89 Supreme Court--
04:32 1989 Supreme Court.
04:34 '66.
04:36 '66.
04:38 12 judges sat on this case.
04:39 And it's basically all about symbol.
04:44 Relevant page?
04:45 I will just read that relevant page.
04:47 But before that, your Lordship, let
04:49 us look at the effect of no symbol.
04:51 No, wait a second.
04:51 [INAUDIBLE]
04:52 Maybe I at least--
04:59 the fundamental question is, if elections are proper,
05:04 I for one don't think that you should
05:06 be deprived of the symbol.
05:08 So can this, when you're citing Benazir Bhutto,
05:11 was it a question of inter-party elections or no?
05:13 No.
05:14 It was a question that a symbol was--
05:17 the symbol was being taken away.
05:18 You can't just deprive someone of their symbols.
05:21 But here it is connected with the party elections.
05:24 My point is--
05:26 Certification.
05:27 Suppose there is a particular time within which you
05:29 have to file a certificate.
05:30 You don't comply with the time.
05:31 I don't think it's such a relevant thing
05:35 that a person should be deprived of their fundamental rights
05:39 or even normal rights.
05:41 So let's-- I mean, when we read this judgment,
05:45 we have to consider the fact that it was not
05:47 a question where the political party had not held elections.
05:52 Yes, who can deny the importance of a symbol?
05:55 But my reason for reading this judgment
05:58 will be something different.
06:00 My reason for reading the judgment
06:01 would be to show to this honorable court
06:04 that a symbol is not just the right of a political party.
06:09 Symbol is the right of the illiterate millions
06:13 of people of Pakistan who rely on the symbol for the purposes
06:19 of exercising their right of vote.
06:21 They rely on a political party symbol for the purposes of--
06:25 Mr. Ali Zafar, I think maybe it's too final point of what--
06:29 I don't disagree with you at all.
06:31 Yes.
06:33 OK.
06:33 But--
06:34 So I--
06:34 No, no, no.
06:35 No, but listen to the whole thing.
06:37 But I'm saying something else.
06:38 Yes.
06:41 "There is a name for it, right? Political party."

Recommended