00:00 I have terminated him under party discipline in 2018.
00:06 Can you show me? I have repeatedly asked this question.
00:09 I have sent you the document.
00:13 Show me. I have been asking this since yesterday.
00:17 He is giving you the termination letter.
00:20 Then why have I kept it with me?
00:23 Show me. Which page is it on?
00:30 Termination letter.
00:32 Where is it?
00:33 It is not with me.
00:35 Show me the page.
00:37 Let me finish this first.
00:39 It is not termination.
00:41 Then I will send it home.
00:43 It is not in this. He is giving you the copy of the termination letter.
00:46 It is not like that.
00:48 You told me that you have the paper book.
00:53 Let me see.
00:55 Let me finish this first.
00:58 Then your case will be strong.
01:01 Correct.
01:02 You are coming without a reason.
01:04 Correct.
01:05 Show me the termination letter.
01:07 No, no. Finish this point.
01:09 Why are you ignoring our question?
01:11 It is not termination.
01:13 I have sent you the document.
01:15 I will tell you how to become a member of the RAPTA app.
01:19 This is how members have to be followed.
01:22 Sir, according to my instructions, there is a RAPTA app which can be viewed on the website also.
01:30 Before the Supreme Court.
01:32 All the members of the RAPTA app, if you click on it, you will see the membership list.
01:38 The membership cards and fees are also there.
01:46 All the members are voted.
01:50 If you are not giving me a clear answer, I will presume that Mr. Akbar S. Ahmed and the 13 others are members of PTI.
02:01 Sir, I have not given you the copy of the website.
02:03 The website is not evidence.
02:05 No, I am telling you clearly.
02:08 I will tell him.
02:10 You will tell him now.
02:12 You are sitting on Saturday.
02:14 Yesterday, I asked you a question again and again.
02:16 I agree, sir.
02:18 I am not taking you by surprise.
02:20 I agree, sir.
02:22 If I cannot take the document, you can presume.
02:24 I am coming to 209.
02:26 From 209, read 205.
02:30 Is it 215?
02:32 No, read 205.
02:34 It is not that you can remove a member from the membership.
02:36 A member of a political party may be suspended or expelled from the political party's membership in accordance with the procedure provided in the Constitution of the political party.
02:46 So, this is an internal matter.
02:48 Continue reading.
02:50 Before making an order for suspension or expulsion of a member from the political party, such members shall be provided with a reasonable opportunity of being heard and of showing cause against the action proposed.
02:58 This is a right that the member has.
03:01 Any member of a political party…
03:04 You have to show.
03:06 If he is not a member, show us from the record that you followed the protocol.
03:09 If I cannot show, you can presume that he is a member.
03:12 I have no issue with that.
03:14 I will continue to argue my case on the basis…
03:17 It changes the frame.
03:19 If you are conceding that these 14 complainants or whatever you want to call them are members of PTI, then we ask the next question.
03:30 Why were they not allowed to contest?
03:32 My statement may be recorded that they are not members.
03:34 We will not record any statement.
03:36 On what basis will we record such a statement?
03:38 That is all I can say.
03:40 My statement may be recorded that the world is…
03:42 That is all I can say at the present moment till I get the documents.
03:45 I cannot go any further.
03:47 Look, Ali Zafar sahib, my way of conducting a court, maybe it's a better way, is whatever is agitating my mind, I will put it forward.
03:57 It is very good.
03:58 I appreciate that.
04:00 Some people get very upset.
04:02 But it's better than a surprise judgment.
04:04 Yes.
04:05 So, I am repeatedly asking the whole world, we don't care with these minor irregularities.
04:10 We even agree with you, there are no irregularities.
04:15 But the fundamental thing is that the election is over.
04:17 These people came, either the election commission would have come, or they would have said that this is the election commission,
04:23 or you could have made them the front men, that this and that Mr. has come.
04:27 So, he is an old worker, whatever founding he is claiming, yesterday Mr. Hamid Khan categorically said that he is one of the founding members.
04:36 So, 14 people, 14 people, if they come, then it's a small thing, you have brought democracy in the house.
04:46 Right.
04:47 Coming back to your line.
04:49 You just said that these are not your members.
04:53 They are saying that they have agreed.
04:55 So, if they have agreed, then 11 in front of the Peshawar High Court, under oath you have said that they are not our members.
05:02 I am still saying this.
05:04 Both the things are recorded.
05:06 I am saying that they are not members, my statement may be recorded.
05:08 You are saying that you are not taking it seriously.
05:11 There must be some evidence.
05:12 You are saying that you are giving evidence.
05:13 There must be some expensive data.
05:15 You are saying that there is evidence, you are saying that there is compliance, show compliance with section 205.
05:19 So, I am going ahead on that, sir.
05:21 If it is coming, if it does not come, then you will have to make your presumption.
05:25 My statement is that I have been given information that they are not members.
05:28 Who is giving you information?
05:30 The party head.
05:31 Who joined the party two years ago?
05:33 They are looking at it from the app.
05:35 Shall we give him more credibility or shall we give Mr. Ahmed more credibility?
05:39 So, I will continue with my argument, sir, on that basis.
05:43 I will also come back to section 209 based on my factual position.
05:47 Section 209(1)
05:49 A political party shall
05:51 The certificate which contains these two
05:54 And three is important, sir.
05:56 Subsection (3) cannot be ignored.
05:59 A commission shall
06:01 Three of?
06:02 Of this section 209.
06:04 Subsection (3)
06:07 A commission shall, within seven days from the receipt of the certificate of a political party, under subsection (1) publish the certificate on its website.
06:17 So, in effect,
06:19 In section 209, it is not written anywhere that a commission can start examining the irregularity in an election.
06:26 All it says is that if a certificate comes, then publish it in seven days on the website.
06:31 Read section 215.
06:33 Read section 215.
06:34 Read it and then decide whether the ECP has jurisdiction or not.
06:42 Absolutely.
06:43 It is a core issue.
06:45 215(1)
06:48 Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law,
06:52 A political party enlisted under this Act shall be eligible to obtain an election symbol for contesting elections for Masjid-e-Shura Parliament, Provincial Assemblies, or local government on submission of certificates and statements referred to in sections 202, 206, 209, and 210.
07:17 So, basically, sir,
07:19 Read it and then decide.
07:22 Okay.
07:23 A combination of enlisted political parties shall be entitled to obtain one election symbol for an election only if each party constituting such combination submits the certificates and statements referred to in sections 202, 206, 209, and 210.
07:43 An election symbol already allocated to a political party shall not be allocated to any other political party or combination of political parties.
07:54 4. Where a political party or combination of political parties severally or collectively fails to comply with the provisions of section 209 or 210,
08:07 the Commission shall issue to such political parties a notice to show cause as to why it or they may not be declared ineligible to obtain an election.
08:20 5. If a political party or parties to whom show cause notice has been issued under subsection (4) fails to comply with the provisions of sections 209 and 210,
08:33 the Commission may, after affording it to or them an opportunity of being heard,
08:38 declare it or them ineligible to obtain an election symbol for election to Parliament, Provincial Assembly, or local government,
08:48 and the Commission shall not allocate an election symbol to such political party or combination of political parties in elections.
08:56 6. But this section has been challenged, whether the virulence of this section or this is the main section which confers power to the Election Commission to question your certificate submitted under section 209.
09:12 I agree with this section, I don't agree with the interpretation.
09:22 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
09:50 [END PLAYBACK]
09:51 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
09:52 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
09:54 [END PLAYBACK]
09:55 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
09:57 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
09:58 [END PLAYBACK]
10:00 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:01 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:02 [END PLAYBACK]
10:03 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:04 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:05 [END PLAYBACK]
10:06 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:07 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:08 [END PLAYBACK]
10:09 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:10 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:11 [END PLAYBACK]
10:12 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:13 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:14 [END PLAYBACK]
10:15 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:16 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:17 [END PLAYBACK]
10:18 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:19 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:20 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:21 [END PLAYBACK]
10:22 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:23 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:24 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:25 [END PLAYBACK]
10:26 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:27 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:28 [END PLAYBACK]
10:29 [VIDEO PLAYBACK]
10:31 a symbol to a political party if the political party complies with the provisions of this act?
10:36 If the political party complies with the provisions of this act?
10:41 Even if we ignore 215.5, what do you make of 217.1?
10:48 217.1 is as per the provisions of the act. If the provisions of the act specify something, then I have to comply with it.
10:56 If the provisions of the act specify that I have to comply with 215.5, then I have to comply with it.
11:03 Mr. Ali Zafar, you are talking about the certificate again and again.
11:06 This is not something that can be done with a piece of paper.
11:09 Even we follow the code of law. We don't have a lot of control over it.
11:15 The truth is that one thing has happened.
11:17 On the other hand, Bilawal Bhutto Sardari has reached Multan. He is talking to the media.
11:21 [BLANK_AUDIO]