• il y a 2 semaines
Critical Chain is now widely used in aeronautical maintenance (MRO or Maintenance, Repair and Overhaul / Operations).

We start by presenting the list of the over 30 aeronautical MRO cases worldwide from the USA to Australia and from Brazil to France.

We discuss why the fact that it is quite easy to calculate the cost of winning or losing a day in the hangar has meant that this industry is leading the world in the adoption of Critical Chain Project Management (CCPM). In this business they know that gaining an extra day in their Turn Around Time is worth often of the order of $100K. They know better than anyone that time is money (or mission critical for military aircraft). CCPM and its proven results is therefore the obvious solution.

We share the lessons learnt by Marris Consulting these past 20 years:

- How the starting point is often that there are too many aircraft being worked on simultaneously (not enough focus),
- Why the planning and scheduling competencies must often be reinforced,
- How CCPM brings (as usual) exceptional visibility on the progress of each aircraft. Why the availability of the spare parts is (of course) a necessary condition for success,
- Why using “Work Packages” and 2-tier scheduling facilitates the management of the execution and avoids falling into the trap of micro-management,
- How the identification of “findings” (unplanned extra work due unexpected deteriorations) become even more critical (because everything else is going much more smoothly),
- How, as a result, visits are often cut into 2 stages; a first stage where you do whatever disassembly and tests are required to identify any “findings” and a second stage where you do the work,
- The differences when dealing with recent aircraft versus old aircraft,
- The limits of CCPM in aeronautical MRO (when the visits are too short and simple to require fully fledged project management). Etc.

We also mention several “common sense” solutions that become even more important when traveling at CCPM speeds such as ensuring that the mechanics always have a “full kit” to do their job (the parts, the tools and the documentation).

A 30-minute dive into Critical Chain in aeronautical maintenance (MRO). The world of projects when every minute counts.

This presentation was part of the Critical Chain 2022 Conference organized by TOCICO.

Have a look at our website: https://www.marris-consulting.com/en/
Have a look at our online courses: https://e-learning.marris-consulting.com/
Check out our LinkedIn company page: https://www.linkedin.com/company/marris-consulting
Subscribe to our newsletter: https://marrisconsulting.substack.com/

Marris Consulting is a management consulting firm.
Our motto: Factories, People & Results.

Catégorie

📚
Éducation
Transcription
00:05I'm going to talk about applying the critical chain approach to aeronautical MRO or maintenance.
00:13And this is one industry that has been using critical chain for a long time ever since it
00:20was invented. So for over 20 years, some of the very first organisations to use the critical
00:26chain were in the maintenance of aircraft, both commercial aircraft and military. And
00:33that started in fact with the US Marines, I believe, right back in the first days of the
00:38development of critical chain. Another one of the pioneers was Delta Airlines maintenance.
00:43Today it's called Delta Tech Ops. And more recently organisations such as Lufthansa or Air France
00:53have been using it, and many others as you can see, right. So it is now significantly
00:58used throughout the world. And I'm going to, in this presentation, discuss the lessons learned
01:05with regards to this, this vast experience over 20 years, what are the lessons to be learned
01:09about all these. And so what was specific about aeronautical MRO? Well, I think the reason
01:17why critical chain has been used widely in this business is because it's much easier to calculate
01:25how much money you're making or losing with an extra day of time spent in the hangar where
01:32the airplane is not being used to sell tickets and make money, right. Or in the military arena,
01:39airplanes are often mission critical. There's a lot of pressure to gain an extra minute, hence the subtitle of
01:44this presentation, or an extra hour or an extra day. You can quite easily work out what that is worth
01:52to the organisation, which is less evident when you're doing things like new product development.
01:56Anyway, that's my explanation for why there are so many people in the aeronautical MRO business
02:03using critical chain, because it's proven now that it can gain days and hours in your turnaround times,
02:10and you see how much money that is worth to you. Okay, so let's let's go through the various main
02:17problems of the MRO business. Okay, there's a whole bunch of stuff to do with planning and scheduling,
02:24which is difficult because of a number of reasons, the uncertainties and the constraints involved in
02:30this kind of work. Okay, there's a real problem of lack of visibility during execution. That's to say,
02:37there's a big stress when you're doing this kind of work about when that aircraft is actually going
02:42to be finished, right. You hope and you have intuition that it's going to be finished in 48 hours'
02:47time, but you're far from certain, and it's not based on good reliable data, right.
02:55Another thing that you suffer from probably is a problem of full kitting for your mechanics. If you
03:00look at a mechanic today, he will spend a lot of time hunting down new tooling, new parts, whatever,
03:08and will therefore have reduced efficiency because of that, right. So how do you make sure that a
03:13mechanic has everything he needs to work efficiently? Then there's a whole package of stuff that comes
03:18from what is usually called in the business findings. That's to say, an aircraft comes in,
03:22especially if it's a few years old. There's some regular mandatory maintenance, you have to do,
03:27you have to check that, do this, whatever, right. There's a long list of checklists that you have to
03:31run. But also, you might find findings that the aircraft is damaged or corroded in unexpectedly,
03:43or that point in the aircraft, right. And you're going to have to fix that, okay. So these findings have
03:51to be
03:53you have to find the word to be done, you have to fix it, and that is unexpected. You can't
03:57plan it
03:57beforehand. By the nature of things, you don't know it exists, and you must make sure that that
04:03does not become problematic with regards to finishing the work, okay. And finally, there's probably a
04:09problem of having lack of focus because of too many planes at the same time. As a prescriptive on those
04:16remarks, people often think that one of the problems that they have in MRO is that they don't have enough
04:20people or tooling or slots or whatever to do the work. As you'll see, as we get through this,
04:27that probably is not the problem, right, since applying the critical chain approach allows you
04:31to increase efficiency, productivity significantly, with a given amount of slots, given amount of
04:37people, given amount of tools. So, schedules, right. As soon as you're a fairly large organization,
04:46you have the software that will manage your maintenance activity, if only to be able to
04:54confirm that you've done all the various legal obligations of the job, right, and all these points
05:00have been checked and it's done. And those same pieces of software will
05:06offer to help you with scheduling. In fact, they don't because they don't have critical chain. And
05:13so people tend to rely on sort of simple PowerPoint or visual Excel based plans to discuss
05:22future activity and do the planning. And of course, those sorts of tools abandon you when you start on
05:30an aircraft and you know it's here for five weeks, you're two weeks into it, when is it going to
05:35finish?
05:35You don't really know, right? And neither your Excel nor your planning system, even though it was
05:40very expensive, allow you to answer that question. One of the reasons why it's so difficult to work out
05:48what's going on is that people usually get bogged down in details, they get into micromanagement.
05:52It's true that a significant check on a big aircraft will have several thousand tasks that you have to
05:58do, mandatory, you have to check this, check that, check that, you have to open that hatch, check this
06:03part, then close the hatch, and all that has to be confirmed. And if you manage things at that level,
06:10right, several thousand different work orders or job cards, you're going to get lost in details.
06:15And it's not going to help you really know what's going on, because it's not because you've done
06:1995% of the jobs that need to be done, that you're 95% finished, right? You don't actually know
06:25what
06:26is still remaining to do and how long it's going to take to do it, okay? And also aircraft have
06:33a number
06:33of technical constraints and physical space constraints. A cockpit, for instance, is a fairly
06:40reduced locale, and therefore you can't have 10, 20 people working simultaneously in the cockpit, right?
06:45So you're going to have to schedule that space constraint and ensure that people can work correctly.
06:52And you're going to have various stages in the work, and you have to take into account electrical
06:58constraints, hydraulic constraints, and many others to make sure you don't have any safety issues or
07:05whatever, okay? And finally, of course, the number of mechanics you have is limited. Now, the mechanics,
07:13as I said, if you follow a mechanic around during a given day, you'll find that they spend a lot
07:20of time
07:22trying to constitute a full kit, everything that they need to actually do the work, right? So they need
07:28a job card, this is what I have to do, with all the descriptions of the work to be done,
07:33okay?
07:34In some cases, they'll need the spare parts, this part here has to be replaced by another.
07:41Quite a lot of specific tooling is required to check out this or that technical aspect of the airplane to
07:47measure the pressure here, the tension here, or whatever, the communication system here.
07:53And of course, there are various skills required, right? Depending on whether it's apionics,
07:59whether it's something dealing with corrosion or whatever, okay? So you're likely to find that in
08:06fact there's a lot of interruptions and not enough, not much value added time spent by these mechanics in
08:12the hand, right? Another thing that happens is that the inspections are done too late,
08:19and these often become critical. As I say, you get findings, as I say, work that is not expected,
08:26right? Especially in an old plane, old I'm talking, of course, as soon as you're about five years old,
08:31you're going to start having significant levels of findings. And as the planes get older, in fact,
08:37it's the findings that will determine your turnaround times, right? The corrosion in particular will
08:44become such a significant issue that that will be the longest sequence of tasks, okay?
08:51Now, to avoid getting caught out by that, what is absolutely fundamental is to make sure that you
08:56inspect your aircraft as much as possible, as early as possible, and identify all the areas which might
09:04have findings, are there findings, how much work is involved and whatever, okay? And it's not that
09:09difficult because these planes, by their nature, if they're old, you know them quite well, right?
09:14And so you just have to look through or ask around where are the places where you're likely to have
09:18problems and ensure that you pounce on the aircraft and really look into all the areas where there might
09:25be a problem and identify those as early as possible. Otherwise, if you identify them too late,
09:32you're probably going to find you don't have enough time to repair them. And that's going to be the
09:35critical chain, the critical path that determines when the aircraft can be put back into service, okay?
09:43And finally, having too many aircraft is a classic problem in MRO hangars, right? And when you do that,
09:51well, then you have to spread your resources among several airplanes by spreading them out. Work is less focused and
09:56less intense, and everything slows down, and you get into a vicious spiral. You have more and more planes,
10:02things moving around slower and slower, right? That's little law, the curing law, whatever, okay?
10:09So, if we apply the critical chain approach to the MRO, right, maintenance, repair, overhaul of aircraft,
10:18there are a number of elements. One of them is that you plan things differently, you plan things the
10:24critical chain way, right? This usually, well, always requires using critical chain software. There are
10:31at least half a dozen suppliers of critical chain software that are compatible with this kind of
10:36business, okay? And that will then enable you to start planning the critical chain way, okay?
10:47One of the phenomena is to estimate focus durations, optimistic durations for the different tasks,
10:56and compensate for that with buffers. And the other is to plan focused work rather than distribution work.
11:03Let's have a look at an example here. This is the example of a check C on a business jet,
11:11okay?
11:12Before using critical chain, it used to take at least 10 weeks to do the work. And after applying
11:18critical chain, it took less than five weeks, okay? The plan above shows exactly what was going on,
11:23okay? And what is noteworthy is that between the third week and the sixth week, right,
11:30you're planning, you're expecting to work on all the different bits of the aircraft all the time,
11:35right? You're spreading yourself all over the aircraft. In this particular example, there are
11:40about 20 mechanics working on the plane, right? But there'd be two of them working here, one of
11:44them working here, whatever, and one over in this place, okay? And to speed things up,
11:51what you do decide is to focus the work very much on and start something and then finish it,
11:58right? So the engines that used to take from week three to week six in the critical chain plan,
12:03you say, we're going to focus on it, we're going to get rid of this engine problem. And in one
12:06week's
12:07time on the second week, we're going to make sure that we have no problems with the engine. And by
12:12the way, there were two reasons for doing it that way. In this particular example, it's because of
12:15course, if there was a problem with the engine, it wasn't something you would repair, you'd have to
12:20get a new engine in and the lead times of getting a new engine in were long. And so you
12:25really need to get
12:25the engine issue behind you early on with this particular aircraft, right? The other thing you do
12:34is to, as I said, use optimistic durations. That's to say that if you have an estimate, this task here
12:43is
12:43going to take me 50 hours or whatever work, okay? You try and discuss with ideally the mechanics, how long
12:52would be your
12:52optimistic estimate, okay? Optimistic being if I have all the tools, all the parts, no problems,
12:59on average, what time would it take? And they might think we should give you a significantly reduced
13:04duration, right? It's not a commitment, it's optimistic duration, and half the time you're going to take
13:10longer than that, okay? If you do that throughout the visit, all the tasks, all the 1000 tasks, right,
13:17you're going to get something that's obviously going a lot faster because all the times have been reduced,
13:21okay? But it's unrealistic because it's optimistic, right? You're going to have problems, and so you
13:25compensate for that by adding the buffer. I don't have time today to go through all the logic of how
13:32you calculate sizes of buffers and so forth, but this is critical chain. You have a buffer at the end,
13:37which is significant, 20% maybe of the duration of the overall work, okay? And it's there to absorb
13:45what problems you're going to have, and when you're too optimistic with your task durations, okay?
13:52So, that's the before and after using the critical chain approach, okay? And there are other little
14:02tricks that you put into your plan. As I pointed out with the example of the engine, you want to
14:07do things
14:08as early as possible when there is a risk that will uncover findings. The other thing you do is, by
14:14the
14:14way, is to put findings capacity buffers in there. That's to say that since you know that that type of
14:21airplane is old, has significant corrosion problems because it's in a tropical and salty atmosphere or
14:29whatever, you know that looking at the past, it's going to have several hundred hours of repairs on corrosion,
14:37okay? But you don't know exactly where it's going to be, what part and so forth. Well, you expect,
14:43you plan for a certain number of the right kind of people working at the right time
14:49on the aircraft, right? And then you confirm it as the aircraft comes in and you have a look and
14:53say,
14:54okay, we've expected 200, ah, it's got 260 and you adapt it and do the work, okay? But at least
15:00you
15:00try to minimize the uncertainty by having an estimate of how many hours you're going to need,
15:06what kind of speciality and where, right? You don't know exactly what's going to be wrong with the
15:11airplane, but often you have an idea of what the proportion of the problem is going to be, right?
15:16In older airplanes, for those who don't know the business well, about 30% of the work to be done
15:22will be findings, right? So you have to get a handle on the findings issues and as early as possible
15:28to minimize the uncertainty and ensure that you can execute correctly and without too much stress
15:37what needs to be done, okay? The other thing you do when you're applying critical chain is
15:44to improve the work to be done by various improvement actions, whether you want to call them lean,
15:52kaizen, kaiteku, just common sense, whatever, right? You look at the critical chain sequence on a job,
16:01right? That's the sequence that will determine the duration of the visit, right? It will determine the
16:09turnaround times. It's a particular sequence. Let's keep it very simple. It's similar to
16:18the critical path, but it's called the critical chain because it takes into account the availability
16:22of resources. So you look at that particular sequence and then you discuss with the various
16:28people doing it, how can we improve it with different tooling, having more people, this sort of
16:32thing, right? And typically the sort of thing we do is we have to change or check the undercarriage,
16:39right? It was planned with one person. Well, okay, let's try and do it faster. Let's have two people.
16:44We put two people in, it goes twice as fast, right? That's a good list. From now on, the standard
16:49is
16:49we do it with two people. We try with three people and in fact, they get in each other's way.
16:53It's
16:53hardly faster than doing it with two people. So that's the ideal is two people, okay? You do that
17:00sort of thing and you manage to improve immediately and also in the future in terms of process of
17:05ongoing improvement and the turnaround times. This is all theory constraints. So of course,
17:10you have the five focusing steps, you need to find the capacity constraint, the bottleneck of your
17:17organisation, of your hangar, okay? It could be one of the specialities. Is it the Aegeonics people?
17:23Is it something else? It could be in quality control and inspections. It could be the paint shop. It could
17:29be anywhere, right? So you need to find it. Once you find it, you make sure you're using it properly
17:35and
17:35you exploit it better. And if it is pertinent, you can elevate it, increase its capacity by
17:42investing time and money, okay? Just a classic theory of constraints process of ongoing improvement there.
17:49Another thing that is specific to MRO, but you do find in other kinds of project management
17:58industries is two level scheduling or two tier scheduling, okay? As I mentioned, you have several
18:03thousand things to be done on an aircraft, but that is not the units that you measure, right? You don't
18:11work at a work card or job card level. You group them together in work packages, as we call them,
18:17and those are the entities that you manage and the sequence of these work packages that determine
18:24the work to be done. And that's the level at which you manage the activity, okay? Within each work
18:31package, you just use a simple checklist principle to see how you're doing on that particular work
18:38package, okay? And to keep the whole thing moving simple, what you do is if you find that in a
18:43given
18:43work package, you have 25 things to do, right? But one of them you can do because, I don't know,
18:48somebody made a mistake and you don't have the right nuts and bolts for that bit. You take that
18:54job card that could not be done in that work package and you put it in a little job package,
19:00work package, so it can be done later, okay? Then you close that initial work package and it gives you
19:06good idea, you know, how you're progressing, okay? It's a classic of MRO. It avoids micromanagement,
19:14keeps you a good helicopter view, if I may, view of the progress of a visit.
19:23The control tower, you get the people together around the same table or in an open space where
19:29they can talk to each other. The job will be to make sure they have the full kitting of the
19:32mechanics,
19:33that they have the tooling, they have the documentation, they have whatever it needs to work.
19:36Mechanics, if they have a problem, then come and ask for help. And obviously, it breaks all the
19:44silos between the various procurement, execution, human resources departments to ensure quick
19:51decision-making, okay? This control tower, our war room, is quite
20:01a classic thing that you find even without critical chain. The main difference between a control tower,
20:08a war room, with and without critical chain, is without it, you're basically running things
20:15on an hour-by-hour real-time basis, reacting to problems as they emerge, okay? If you've implied
20:21critical chain properly, that control tower will in fact be working on issues that determine what's
20:27going to happen tomorrow, in five days' time, in two weeks' time, whatever, right? You're not going
20:31to be scrambling around panicking, you're going to be making sure that everything's going to run
20:37smoothly over the next days and weeks, okay? So the concept is well understood, it's rather different
20:46and a lot more powerful when you're using the critical chain approach, okay? Let me just repeat
20:51something that, from our experience, always needs repeating. You must make sure that people close
20:57their job cards promptly, as quickly as possible, and not leave a job finished, but not declared
21:04finished in your computer system. Otherwise, you're going to have a big scramble at the end,
21:09when the aircraft is nearly finished, and you say, ah, I know that's done, I looked at the hatch,
21:13it's closed, the work's done, but where is the job card? It has to be stamped to say, this is
21:18done,
21:18right? Because there are a number of regulations. So to avoid that last-minute panic, you have to
21:24impose and insist to repeat that jobs have to be declared shut and closed as soon as they're finished,
21:31otherwise it's going to get a big mess. The other important thing about running things at the Twillam
21:39trainway is you're going to have these iconic fever charts. Each aircraft will have its fever chart,
21:45which shows you how things are progressing, gives you a good idea when the end date is going to be,
21:51and then you have a concatenation of these individual fever charts, one per aircraft, and it gives you
21:59what we have here on the slide, a portfolio fever chart with all the various aircraft in the hangar,
22:05showing you which ones are okay and which ones have got more problems, and that allows everyone to
22:11reallocate priorities and people accordingly and ensure that everything runs smoothly, right?
22:17And the fascinating thing, as always with critical chain, by the way, is that management attention
22:21gets brought upstream, way right up to the beginning, and people spend a lot more time looking at a new
22:27aircraft coming in rather than panicking and screaming at each other about the aircraft that's just
22:32about really the hangar, right? It changes the management focus to the source of problems early
22:37on. It's a different kind of situation. Focus, focus, focus, focus. Theory of constraints. You want to
22:44reduce the number of airplanes you're working on at twice as many people working on half as many airplanes,
22:49if I can keep it very simple, okay? So to do that, you make sure that you don't start on
22:57an airplane too
22:58early, and it's often people like the idea of start finishing, stop starting, ensure that you finish
23:05the the planes you already have before you start on a new one, because otherwise you can spread yourself
23:09thin and you can start slowing down everything and the situation is just going to get worse and worse
23:14and worse, okay? More specifically in MRO, as I've mentioned before, one of the challenges is to work
23:19out if there are any findings, if there are any problems in an aircraft that's just arrived, so you have
23:23as much time as possible to solve any nasty findings that's going to require a difficult procurement
23:30from Seattle Boeing, a rare part which you've never seen before. So you might want to do it in two
23:39stages. First, when the aircraft arrives, you pounce on it and inspect it in the right places to find all
23:45the issues it might have, any findings it might have. Then, if necessary, you pause it and you only start
23:51doing the work when there is sufficient available mechanics and other resources to do the thing
23:58quickly and efficiently. So, to conclude just a few case studies. The US Air Force has been using it
24:08for over 20 years, right? One of the first to start and still doing it. These are some very recent
24:15articles from a few weeks ago about how it's now being rolled out in one of the US Air Forces
24:21bases
24:22in Japan and in other places. I don't know exactly how many bases are now using field constraints and
24:28critical chain. Well over 20 is my guess and it's increasing regularly. It's often in the news if you
24:35look out for it. Okay, so they de facto are probably the largest users of this approach because of the
24:41number of aircraft they have, the number of people involved. Another example, this one from the Czech
24:47Republic, ABS jets, a reduction of turnaround times of 35%. By the way, that's significant in the sense
24:56that these people were already considered the best in the world in their business, much faster than
25:01everybody else. And yet, they decided to implement critical chain and went even further and faster.
25:07And what they enjoyed was not only the fact that it took them to another step in terms of performance,
25:13but also a significant impact on the quality of life and the visibility that they had, much less
25:20stress, much less panic, a lot greater feeling of control and mastery of what was going on, right?
25:25Have a look at the testimonial videos if you wish. And finally, one last case, this one of Embraer
25:34executive jets in Le Bourget, Paris, the European Middle East and Africa base for Embraer executive jets.
25:45Again, a significant reduction in turnaround times, right, nearly divided by two, but also a significant
25:53increase in productivity, which is something that most people that switch to critical chain also
26:01discover, right, faster, more efficient, more profitable, and much better visibility, much less
26:08stress, all these sorts of things. Okay, again, have a look at the numerous client testimonial videos
26:14that are available about that case of Embraer executive jets.
26:19So, to conclude, let me just point out that there are limits within aeronautical MROs using critical chain.
26:32In the vocabulary of aeronautical MRO, you have base maintenance and line maintenance.
26:37Line maintenance is more the stuff you're going to be doing that is quick, such as fixing a
26:44tire that's worn out, all that sort of stuff, right. It's going to be an hour, a few hours, whatever.
26:52And base maintenance is the longer stuff, the bigger stuff, right, going up to a check seat,
26:56it could take several weeks. The reason I'm describing that is that a critical chain,
27:01the full critical chain, as I've described it, only applies to projects that are longish,
27:08let's say greater than 12 hours, okay. If you get to these very short jobs, then you'll find that
27:16the critical chain can't be used in its entirety. You can use, let's imagine we're talking about a
27:22check A of an Airbus 320, a couple of hundred hours of work to be done overnight, between midnight and
27:31four o'clock in the morning, that sort of stuff, right. So you've only got four or six hours,
27:35which we have the airplane available, and you have to do these very small checks,
27:40which is okay for the morning, okay. You won't be able to use critical chain, as I've described it,
27:45with the fever chart updated and stuff, because that's usually done with updates of every eight
27:51hours, or days, or every day, or every week, depending on your business, right. So what you
27:57can do is use the critical chain to design the work, say, okay, I'm going to have these people do
28:01that, then those people do that, then that people do that, whatever, right. So you design an optimal
28:06sequence of tasks to do that check A, okay. But you won't use the fever chart with a regular update
28:13to monitor progress, okay. Okay, so to conclude, I guess my question to all those listening who are
28:21in the aeronautical business, but who are not using critical chain yet, is why not?
28:27It's been around now for 20 years, it's proven how efficient it is at solving these problems,
28:32and the results are frankly, they will exceed your expectations, right, the turnaround times will
28:38drop by 20 to 60 percent, the productivity of your expensive mechanics will increase by 20 to 60 percent,
28:45there's rare mechanics, right, that are getting harder and harder to find. And you can, if you
28:52organise yourself correctly, you can finish nearly all your work on time, which will please everybody,
28:57and make the organisation a lot more stable and robust, okay. Thank you very much for your time, bye-bye.

Recommandations