00:00 the CCI. Article 153, Article 54. If the present set up, the present government, the Prime Minister,
00:07 Shabaz Sharif saab says there is no problem, we should take it to the CCI. The problems
00:14 that the constitution is telling, you also guide us in that regard. Are I and Chaudhary
00:19 saab reading the constitution wrong? See, Khawar saab, I was listening and learning
00:24 from you, especially from Chaudhary saab, he was telling us the things of the constitution,
00:29 which are very good. Let me clear a little bit on this. See, there are two articles,
00:34 which cater to the council of common interest. One is your article 153, which tells you the
00:41 composition, who will be there. There are Prime Minister, Prime Minister and three Federal
00:47 Ministers. So, there will be a total of 8 people. And after this, now it is not written
00:52 that he will be elected, that interim CM can also be there, but I will come to this. Before
00:58 that, I will come to its functions. The article 154, which is our relevant article, it says
01:05 that the part 2 of the federal legislative list, related to that, it will have the role
01:12 of supervision of the council of common interest. Now, entry 9 in the list talks about your
01:17 census. So, it has the power of supervision. Now, how will its decisions be? It is written
01:24 clearly in the article 154 that the decision will be by majority. If there are 8 people,
01:30 then if 5 people decide on something, then it will prevail. Now, you were discussing
01:36 a question, if a province has an issue with it, if it has an objection to such decisions,
01:42 then what will happen? You have read its method, it is written in article 154 sub article 7.
01:48 If someone has an objection, someone has a problem with that decision, there is a grievance,
01:54 then it will go to the joint sitting of the parliament and then it can be overruled from
01:59 there. If the decision of the council of common interest has been made, it is binding on everyone.
02:03 The Supreme Court has also come to the judgment on this. Lahore High Court has also come to
02:06 the judgment. If we unpack it again for the general understanding, that if Sindh objects
02:12 to it, Punjab does it, the decision of the council of common interest is made with the
02:17 consent of the people, then it will have to be taken to the joint sitting. Without that,
02:20 you cannot take it forward.
02:22 >> There is only one way to set it aside, that is, your joint sitting will be held.
02:27 Either the Supreme Court or the High Court sets it aside, it is very difficult that this
02:32 is against fundamental rights. That is a separate debate. But the method in article 154 is that
02:38 the province that has an objection, grievance, will go to the joint sitting, the hearing
02:44 will be held, and then it can be set aside. But if the majority has taken a decision,
02:48 then it is binding on the federal government, until it is set aside from the joint sitting.
02:53 >> Let's come back to article 153. It is very clear that when a new Prime Minister takes
03:01 an oath, he should constitute it within 30 days. So the spirit of the constitution is
03:09 that the elected representative should be on the federal level or the provincial level.
03:16 He has to make the decision. You told us, the lawyers, that article 224, the government
03:24 is not in the position to give its opinion on long-term policymaking decisions. So can
03:29 a chief minister take part in such policymaking decisions? People have different opinions
03:36 on this. What do you say? >> Yes, absolutely. Mr. Khawar, I was coming
03:41 to this issue. You yourself asked the question. See, what is written in 153 is that the word
03:47 "chief minister" is written. But if we look at the spirit of the constitution, the
03:51 caretaker CM's point is there, where there are two articles in the whole constitution.
03:56 Everywhere where the word "chief minister" is used, or "federal minister" is used,
04:00 or "prime minister" is used, its interpretation, which we call "purposive interpretation",
04:05 is that you are an elected chief minister. Because what is the purpose of the Council
04:09 of Common Trust? That the representatives of the people of different provinces should
04:13 have a presence there, and there should be a cooperative federalism. So is a caretaker
04:18 CM a representative of the people? No. So the spirit of the constitution is negated.
04:25 >> You are absolutely right. Mr. Choye also wants to talk to you. Mr. Choye.
04:29 >> Yes. Yes.
04:30 >> [Hindi]
04:32 >> [Hindi]
04:34 >> [Hindi]
04:36 >> [Hindi]
04:38 >> [Hindi]
04:40 >> [Hindi]
04:42 >> [Hindi]
04:44 >> [Hindi]
04:46 >> [Hindi]
04:48 >> [Hindi]
04:50 >> [Hindi]
04:52 >> [Hindi]
04:54 >> [Hindi]
04:56 >> [Hindi]
04:58 >> [Hindi]
05:00 >> [Hindi]
05:02 >> [Hindi]
05:04 >> [Hindi]
05:06 >> [Hindi]
05:08 >> [Hindi]
05:10 >> [Hindi]
05:12 >> [Hindi]
05:13 >> [Hindi]
05:15 >> [Hindi]
05:17 >> [Hindi]
05:19 >> [Hindi]
05:21 >> [Hindi]
05:23 >> [Hindi]
05:25 >> [Hindi]
05:26 >> [Hindi]
05:28 >> [Hindi]
05:30 >> [Hindi]
05:32 >> [Hindi]
05:34 >> [Hindi]
05:36 >> [Hindi]
05:38 >> [Hindi]
05:40 >> [Hindi]
05:42 >> [Hindi]
05:44 >> [Hindi]
05:46 >> [Hindi]
05:48 >> [Hindi]
05:50 >> [Hindi]
05:53 >> [Hindi]
05:54 >> [Hindi]
05:56 >> [Hindi]
05:59 >> [Hindi]
06:02 >> [Hindi]
06:04 >> [Hindi]
06:06 >> [Hindi]
06:08 >> [Hindi]
06:10 >> [Hindi]
06:12 >> [Hindi]
06:14 >> [Hindi]
06:16 >> [Hindi]
06:18 >> [Hindi]
06:22 >> [Hindi]
06:23 >> [Hindi]
06:25 >> [Hindi]
06:28 >> [Hindi]
06:30 >> [Hindi]
06:32 >> [Hindi]
06:34 >> [Hindi]
06:36 >> [Hindi]
06:38 >> [Hindi]
06:40 >> [Hindi]
06:42 >> [Hindi]
06:44 >> [Hindi]