Skip to playerSkip to main content
  • 3 years ago
PTI electoral symbol case hearing - Hamid Khan ne dalail ka aghaz kardiya

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00 Why we held the elections in Peshawar?
00:04 Because the administration in Islamabad and Punjab harass our workers.
00:11 And they are not a center.
00:13 If they listen to you, why are you writing to the government?
00:21 You are asking them to give you security.
00:24 But you did not tell them.
00:27 You are telling them, but there is a contradiction.
00:31 We understood you, but you have to answer our question.
00:36 You said that they do not let us hold the elections.
00:40 But you do not write to them.
00:44 They wrote back, where are you doing?
00:46 We will give you security there.
00:48 They do not provide security here.
00:50 I said, when you said this, I will ask you a question.
00:54 We still have a duty to bring notice to them.
00:59 Secondly, we cannot provide every remedy in the world, but we can attend to the case.
01:06 Why did we choose the Peshawar High Court?
01:09 This was the second question.
01:11 I will answer it myself.
01:13 Because of our experience, so many hundreds of our workers, thousands of our workers, ladies have been picked up during the day.
01:21 Mr. Khan, you do not need a worker for this case.
01:25 You need a lawyer for the case.
01:27 Mr. Ali Zafar stood in the court yesterday and spoke.
01:31 Hundreds of workers are being picked up or not.
01:34 But the case has been filed, so no one needs to come to the court.
01:37 You said that you did not let the lawyer go.
01:39 That is a different matter.
01:41 No one needs to come.
01:43 You are standing in front of us today.
01:45 You have brought a thousand workers, it is your choice.
01:47 But they do not need to come.
01:49 Only you need to come.
01:51 I am explaining the perception of why we preferred.
01:53 Because the most independent of the High Court we feel is still the Peshawar High Court.
01:59 Because their orders are being carried out.
02:03 The orders of Islamabad High Court and Lahore High Court have not been carried out.
02:09 The bail is received from here, they are released and they are put back in the detention order.
02:15 In the jurisdiction of Peshawar High Court.
02:17 But you are not answering the fundamental question.
02:21 You have made a list of five bench members.
02:25 Five members is a very big bench for a High Court.
02:27 Lahore, which usually is a one member, single member bench.
02:31 You could have taken back that case.
02:33 But that case is pending there.
02:35 Then you went to Lahore, then to Peshawar.
02:37 This is what I am not understanding.
02:39 Sir, that case was done by an individual, not by a party.
02:43 No, no, leave that case too.
02:45 Let's accept that too.
02:47 But the WP, what is the number of that?
02:49 81171.
02:51 It was made for this.
02:53 2023.
02:55 It was made for this, five member bench.
02:57 The second decision, you are talking about Mr. Jawad Hassan.
03:01 He was a single member and he was upheld in the Inter-Court Appeal.
03:05 We leave that too.
03:07 We are talking about this case, the five member bench judgment, in which the issue was election.
03:13 But it has not been pressed.
03:15 No, the case is still alive.
03:17 It is pending.
03:19 Yesterday, Mr. Ali Zafar himself said that I had appeared, but the bench was not determined.
03:23 He did not say that I moved an application withdrawing the petition or anything.
03:31 But anyways, even if he does so now, the relevant date will be at the date of filing of the petition in the Peshawar High Court.
03:41 Otherwise, we knew, we used to do law, we used to think that sometimes more cases will be filed here or whatever.
03:49 Whenever there was an approach of judges, we all passed through this stage.
03:53 We used to try to withdraw the jurisdiction and take it somewhere else.
03:57 We have all played this game.
03:59 But once you have chosen the jurisdiction, sometimes you have done it in Islamabad, it is being imported from Karachi.
04:05 No, no, because ZFBR is based in Islamabad, we made the jurisdiction like this.
04:09 So, when you have chosen, then I do not understand to go.
04:13 This is the thing.
04:15 We have our experiences.
04:17 I should not take up more time in detail.
04:19 No, no, it is fine.
04:21 I just wanted to inform you.
04:23 I am coming to the propositions, few propositions in addition to what has been very ably, comprehensively argued by Mr. Ali Zafar.
04:31 I am just adding a few propositions to that.
04:35 And most courteously, if we may add.
04:39 You are also very kind.
04:45 I try my best not to be discourteous.
04:47 First proposition, first and foremost submission is that Election Commission of Pakistan, ECP,
04:55 ECP being a constitutional and statutory body performing regulatory and quasi-judicial functions.
05:05 That ECP being a constitutional, public, statutory body performing regulatory and quasi-judicial functions cannot legally be an aggrieved person.
05:33 And therefore, has no locus to file the present petition before this honorable court.
05:41 Therefore, the petition of ECP is not maintainable and liable to be dismissed on this preliminary ground.
05:59 I am relying on two recent judgments of the Supreme Court.
06:05 Can you use the word aggrieved person?
06:09 Does Article 185 require that?
06:13 If the judgment is wrong, I may not be aggrieved by it.
06:17 Can I not still challenge it under, they have come under 185.
06:21 They have not come under Article 199, which of course starts with the word any aggrieved person, except Habeas Corpus.
06:27 So, let us see, 185, does the word aggrieved mention or no?
06:31 It is not mentioned, no doubt about it.
06:35 But generally, suppose someone challenges the judgment of the higher court, and he may not be aggrieved, but he may say the judgment is wrong.
06:41 So, if he was a party in the lower court, will we say, oh, you are not aggrieved by it, but does it really matter?
06:49 We agree with you, but it is not a requirement of the Constitution that they have to be aggrieved, or is it?
06:57 It may not be in Article 185, but may submit that generally, the principle that is applied for any kind of jurisdiction and separate jurisdiction is under Article 199.
07:15 So, though the appeals or the petitions are filed under Article 185 clause 3, but that does not mean that the principle applicable to Article 199, because it is initiated through Article 199.
07:33 But there, they were the respondent, not the petitioner.
07:37 So, the requirement of aggrieved will be on the petitioner, not on the respondent.
07:41 No doubt. But sir, the result is that it is continuation of that.
07:47 Why was the petitioner here? They are the petitioners.
07:51 But the question is...
07:52 Suppose, as a farruze, in some other case, the higher court says, I hereby abolish the Election Commission of Pakistan.
08:01 Judgment is passed.
08:03 So, another party, aggrieved, can come out.
08:07 ECB can't come.
08:09 It is not a strange thing.
08:12 Or they can remove a member.
08:14 I don't like this member's face. I remove him.
08:17 I am giving you absurd example, so the point can be appreciated.
08:23 So, ECB can't come.
08:25 They can remove my member.
08:26 Unless it is a co-oronto-ratio, it is a different matter.
08:28 Okay, change all the members and appoint new ones.
08:31 In Javed Hashmi case, there was ECB in the petitioner's court.
08:34 Javed Hashmi case was cited yesterday.
08:37 I am relying on judgments subsequent to Javed Hashmi case.
08:43 Let me show these judgments.
08:45 Javed Hashmi case was five members.
08:47 Sir, very recent judgments.
08:49 One is 2023 judgment.
08:52 You have given us two. Don't repeat that.
08:54 I will tell you the note.
08:56 One was of Ombudsman and one was of Commission.
09:00 Yes, sir.
09:02 We have noted those. If you want to tell anything else, you have told on the first day.
09:06 One judgment is of 2020 Supreme Court 5.1.
09:13 There is also one more judgment.
09:15 2020 Supreme Court?
09:17 2020 Supreme Court 5.86.
09:21 This is the same one.
09:23 Yes, two judgments.
09:24 I have noted that.
09:25 One case was of Competition Commission.
09:28 Statutory body.
09:30 Second case was of Ombudsman.
09:33 Do you have a direct case of Election Commission?
09:37 In which election commission party was held.
09:41 You cannot have a party from your side.
09:44 I will tell you the reason.
09:49 What is the parallel between the two?
09:51 There is a third judgment which has not been reported yet.
09:54 Give me a copy.
09:56 Did you give the copy to him?
09:58 No, sir.
10:00 A recent judgment authored by your lordship.
10:05 Civil petition number 3532 of 2023.
10:10 Are you giving the copy?
10:14 Yes, sir.
10:15 I am giving the copy.
10:17 I am giving the copy.
10:19 This is the right to information judgment.
10:23 This is the judgment where the Supreme Court filed a petition.
10:29 And you have held that it cannot be a right to information case.
10:34 Right to information case?
10:36 Yes, we have given the information.
10:40 What is the connection with this case?
10:44 Supreme Court as a constitutional body cannot be a petitioner.
10:52 This is what has been held in this judgment.
10:56 In paragraph 9 of the judgment.
10:59 May I read out this paragraph 9?
11:02 If you give it to us, it will be easier.
11:04 I will provide you the five minutes.
11:08 Read it.
11:10 Yes, sir.
11:11 I will read it.
11:12 Read it.
11:13 The question of maintainability of the writ petition filed by the registrar of the Supreme Court
11:18 before the High Court was raised before the Leonard single judge who held the petition to be maintainable
11:25 by referring the cases of registrar of the Supreme Court of Pakistan versus Hassan Akbar
11:30 and registrar of the Supreme Court of Pakistan versus Qazi Wali Muhammad.
11:35 The Hassan Akbar case, this Hassan Akbar case is 1987 Pakistan criminal law general
11:42 and the other Qazi Wali Muhammad case is 1997 SCMR 141.
11:48 The Hassan Akbar case was with regard to complain against assistant advocate general
11:52 who had appeared before the Supreme Court when he was not enrolled.
11:57 It was out of the recommendation of the disciplinary committee.
12:00 Therefore, it cannot be cited as a precedent entitled to Supreme Court to initiate litigation.
12:06 In the other case, Qazi Wali Muhammad was terminated from the service of the Supreme Court
12:11 and filed an appeal before the Federal Service Tribunal,
12:14 whose order reinstating him was challenged by the registrar before the Supreme Court
12:19 under Article 212(3) of the Constitution.
12:22 This court held that Qazi Wali Muhammad was not a civil servant as defined the Civil Servants Act 1973.
12:29 Therefore, the tribunal did not have jurisdiction.
12:32 The registrar had not initiated litigation Qazi Wali Muhammad case.
12:36 He had not filed the appeal before the tribunal.
12:39 The particular facts and the very limited scope of these two cases cannot be treated as precedence
12:45 for registrar to initiate litigation on behalf of the Supreme Court,
12:50 particularly when the general is neither case had discussed this aspect.
12:54 So, meaning thereby, the institution of the Supreme Court through registrar cannot be a prediction.
13:02 This is as I read this judgment about.
13:06 There is another thing. The other thing is the Superior Court.
13:11 Registrar means the Superior Court is before the High Court.
13:14 So, here it's not an hierarchy of Election Commission of Pakistan.
13:19 I mean, it's a separate constitutional body.
13:21 So, they get a judgment. They cannot appeal it. It's very strange.
13:26 Either then you say that they can't be sued either.
13:29 If they can sue, they can also defend. No, you can sue, but you can't defend.
13:33 Defend before the court, but you cannot be a plan because
13:38 because it is an institution making decision, judicial or quasi-judicial.
13:46 It is not for the parties in the dispute.
13:48 [Audio not clear]
14:03 [NON-ENGLISH SPEECH]

Recommended