00:00 Sharmila bhabhi, it seems that you are making numbers and saying that we won't agree but
00:05 you have to work on this salary, you have to put this budget in your vote.
00:08 People's Party will agree.
00:10 Kashi sir, look, the situation is very precarious.
00:14 As you know, when People's Party had an agreement with PMLN regarding the government,
00:23 it was included in the budget that when the budget is made, in the PSDB, which is Public
00:30 Sector Development Projects, the People's Party will be consulted in all four departments.
00:34 They will be taken into consideration.
00:36 And this was a predetermined task that should have been done, that the government should have done.
00:43 There were many other things.
00:45 The government's decision on all these things has not been biased in any way.
00:50 In fact, it has not been worked on.
00:53 Look, People's Party has its own agenda.
00:55 People's Party has to answer the public.
00:58 Sir, but madam, your compulsion is also yours.
01:01 No, our wish was that if we would sit with them in the budget making process,
01:06 then maybe we could tell them some better things, some steps.
01:12 But you are not a part of the government.
01:14 We are not a part of the government.
01:17 We are a part of the parliament.
01:18 Thank you for correcting me.
01:20 Because when we repeatedly say that we are not a part of the government,
01:23 then we are told that you voted for the Prime Minister.
01:26 But the government is because of you.
01:28 Look, we are not a part of the government.
01:31 You try to get the best of both the worlds.
01:34 This is where you will get the worst of both situations.
01:37 That is, you cannot say anything because you are not a part of the government.
01:40 But you cannot do anything because you cannot bring down the government.
01:44 So in both cases, you get the worst end of the bargain.
01:47 So we will have to vote for this budget.
01:49 We can say, we can protest because this was our predetermined agreement.
01:54 This was an agreement between the People's Party and PMLN.
01:58 This was done before the government was formed.
02:01 Now if one party does not keep its share of the agreement,
02:05 or does not complete the agreement, then what should the other party do?
02:09 We can protest.
02:10 And look, the budget is still in the process of being passed.
02:13 The budget will be passed on 28th, 29th.
02:15 Before that, a lot of things can change.
02:18 Some improvements can come.
02:19 Some matters can be improved.
02:21 They can take input from us.
02:23 They can consult us.
02:24 We also have a finance team.
02:26 Someone said today, Samila Bibi, I am listening to everything you say.
02:29 Someone said, you are becoming MKM 2.
02:31 No, we are not becoming MKM 2.
02:33 We want to do this and that.
02:34 You want to improve your public perception, but it will not happen.
02:38 Because when you will vote in the end,
02:40 and whatever the budget will be, you will sell it, that our words will be accepted.
02:43 But eventually people will know what it is.
02:45 We want the betterment of the public.
02:47 We want the betterment of the public.
02:49 Look, if we wanted our own betterment,
02:51 or if we had any such desire, then we would have taken the ministries and sat.
02:54 Every week they come and offer us to take the ministries.
02:57 Whatever is the will, take the ministries.
02:58 We would have taken the ministries and sat in the cabinet.
03:00 What do we care?
03:01 When we have to listen to such things, then we should take the ministries.
03:04 Sit.
03:05 Sit in Punjab.
03:06 And sit in the federal government.
03:08 We are not taking those ministries.
03:09 Because that is not the end all and be all for us.
03:11 This is not our purpose and intention.
03:13 Our purpose is that we should give advice to the government.
03:17 Madam, I told you that there is a situation where the People's Party
03:20 votes against this budget.
03:22 Or does not vote in its favor.
03:24 This will make the government fall.
03:25 This is a very extreme case.
03:27 Because if the People's Party does not vote, then the budget will not pass.
03:31 And if the budget does not pass, then the government will fall.
03:34 We do not even want the system to be derailed.
03:36 Now elections have been held, three to four months ago.
03:38 And I think this situation is very extreme.
03:42 These are very extreme circumstances.
03:44 I think that the way the government has started the conversation and it has come.
03:49 And I think that a situation is developing where they have also realized that
03:54 the integrity of the People's Party should not be taken advantage of.
03:58 And not keeping the agreement of your share is included in the bad intention.
04:01 So if the government does its own correction, takes some of our inputs
04:05 in relation to the budget, then the people will get better.
04:08 But what will you do if you don't take it?
04:10 This is the real question.
04:12 Look, a lot of things can happen.
04:14 If we take input from it.
04:16 Look, you said once that the government will fall.
04:18 Because of this, you have shown your weakness to the government.
04:23 They also know what you have shown.
04:25 You cannot leave this government.
04:27 The reason is not that the government will fall.
04:29 You are also your own helplessness.
04:31 You are tied to your helplessness.
04:33 You both have to walk together.
04:35 Until you get permission, the problem is that you have to walk with them.
04:39 The government should understand that the People's Party needs them.
04:44 Our Prime Minister is not there.
04:46 We have elected the Prime Minister.
04:48 If we had not given our numbers, then the Prime Minister would not have been elected.
04:53 They know that we are a very strategic partner of theirs.
04:57 And treating us right and totally ignoring us.
05:01 If you are talking about blackmailing, then you have given reference to MQM.
05:06 I am very much impressed by this.
05:08 Because MQM talks about itself.
05:10 MQM wants its funds.
05:12 MQM wants its markets.
05:14 The truth is that you also want development funding.
05:16 In PSDP, the fight for shares.
05:18 We do not want markets, nor do we want committees.
05:20 Madam, it is a fight for development fund.
05:22 Development fund is of all four provinces.
05:25 We said take our input, our advice.
05:27 We are not taking it in our pocket.
05:29 The national PSDP has already increased by 1.5 trillion.
05:34 In this difficult situation, where you have to cut expenditures.
05:39 There is a PSDP of 3.7 trillion.
05:42 The provinces have also received money.
05:44 But we said this.
05:46 And the Taish-e-Udabati, we have not put any demand ahead.
05:50 This is before the government of Taish-e-Udabati.
05:52 Madam, they say that you have received briefings twice.
05:56 Once in China, the finance minister was briefed through a video link.
06:02 Pakistan came back, then the briefing was given.
06:04 They say that we have done everything.
06:06 People's Party does not listen.
06:08 People's Party is doing point scoring.
06:10 We were not given any briefing.
06:12 We were not given any briefing.
06:14 No consultation was given to the people's party.
06:16 I will tell you, I was sitting there myself.
06:20 No, it is wrong.
06:22 Navid Kamar was there and others.
06:26 You check.
06:28 I have checked with two people.
06:30 I have checked.
06:32 So you are saying that you were not given any briefing.
06:34 No briefing of any kind has been given.
06:36 No consultation of any kind has been given.
06:38 They had to work during the budget making process.
06:42 This is not a matter of today or tomorrow.
06:46 They had to work within the last 15-20 days, within a month.
06:50 This was a very well-defined agreement.
06:52 But the bottom line is one thing.
06:54 We have not done it.
06:56 Sharmila Bibi, this budget will get the vote of the People's Party.
06:58 You see, many issues, in two years, the politics of the People's Party,
07:02 has put many things on its head.
07:04 In which you say that we did not govern.
07:06 But you were a part of that system, that government,
07:10 which violated human rights,
07:12 steamrolled the media,
07:14 and you were a part of all that.
07:16 We were in the cabinet,
07:18 so we had to take the responsibility.
07:20 Absolutely, you were in the cabinet at that time.
07:22 You are not in the cabinet now, but the government is standing because of you.
07:24 Thank you very much, Sharmila Farooqui.
07:26 Talib Rizvi is present with us. He is a banker.
07:28 Talib sir, my friend is also here.
07:30 Yesterday, he was giving me a breakdown.
07:32 What will be the impact of this budget on the salary-seeking class?
07:34 Talib Rizvi sir,
07:36 the salary-seeking class,
07:38 who already pays all the taxes,
07:40 how will this budget affect them?
07:42 Thank you very much, Kashif Abbasi sir.
07:44 Thank you very much, Kashif Abbasi sir.
07:46 Thank you very much for giving me this opportunity.
07:48 I just want to tell you that there is a principle,
07:50 and that principle is that "Hissa Bakadre Jutsa".
07:52 The contribution in GDP,
07:54 has to be contributed in the same way
07:56 to the greater financial cause of the country.
07:58 So, the salary-seeking class is the only class
08:00 which at source, not only cuts its share,
08:02 but also cuts the share of the trustworthiness of the country.
08:04 So, the salary-seeking class is the only class
08:06 which at source, not only cuts its share,
08:08 but also cuts the share of the trustworthiness of the country.
08:10 So, the salary-seeking class is the only class
08:12 which at source, not only cuts the share of the trustworthiness of the country.
08:14 But, it has to contribute more than its own worth.
08:16 But, it has to contribute more than its own worth.
08:18 I would like to share with you the numbers of the 11-month FDR.
08:20 I would like to share with you the numbers of the 11-month FDR.
08:22 In the 11 months,
08:24 the salary-seeking class has paid a tax of Rs. 330 billion.
08:26 the salary-seeking class has paid a tax of Rs. 330 billion.
08:28 the salary-seeking class has paid a tax of Rs. 330 billion.
08:30 And if I take this over the entire year,
08:32 then this year,
08:34 this salary-seeking class will pay a tax of Rs. 360 billion.
08:36 this salary-seeking class will pay a tax of Rs. 360 billion.
08:38 Unfortunately,
08:40 despite the fact that the Honourable Prime Minister
08:42 declared this time,
08:44 and repeatedly,
08:46 the Honourable Finance Minister and Ali Pravesh Malik
08:48 and repeatedly,
08:50 the Honourable Finance Minister and Ali Pravesh Malik
08:52 have said that the red line has been defined
08:54 that the salary-seeking class should not be affected.
08:56 But, that red line has been crossed.
08:58 And, as per the record of 75 billion rupees,
09:00 And, as per the record of 75 billion rupees,
09:02 if you see this document,
09:04 an additional burden of Rs. 75 billion
09:06 has been placed on the salary-seeking class.
09:08 And, the most ridiculous thing in this is that
09:10 the lowest slab
09:12 the lowest slab
09:14 has an increase of 100%.
09:16 has an increase of 100%.
09:18 And, the problem is that
09:20 And, the problem is that
09:22 Ali Pravesh Malik has said
09:24 Ali Pravesh Malik has said
09:26 that do not look at the percentage of this,
09:28 look at the absolute number.
09:30 But, I think that the government of the time
09:32 needs to consider
09:34 that the society in which
09:36 the shopkeepers cannot take Rs. 3000 as tax
09:38 the shopkeepers cannot take Rs. 3000 as tax
09:40 they should not make a joke of Rs. 2500 contribution
09:42 they should not make a joke of Rs. 2500 contribution
09:44 where it already belongs to one of the highest tax-payer segments.
09:46 where it already belongs to one of the highest tax-payer segments.
09:48 So, my only request is that the salary-seeking class should not...
09:50 But, you are saying that the crunch
09:52 the real crunch will be felt by
09:54 the real crunch will be felt by
09:56 the highest class.