00:00I would like to ask that I will not be able to get it.
00:06What are the reasons for your side?
00:09I would like to ask you to ask the letter to the contents of that letter.
00:13I would like to ask the confidentiality to maintain it.
00:15All the representatives of the parliament have already been there.
00:18How are you talking about it?
00:20Are you talking about the CJPB two days?
00:23The Supreme Court is open to everyone.
00:27I am talking about the current Supreme Court.
00:32For all that, they will be responsible for their personal attention.
00:36We will have to rely on the Laurenti, which with pleasure,
00:43and we will try to attract further citizens.
00:44For the new Especiallyerns,
00:46we will be able to give our rights.
00:47The last question, what are the conditions?
00:49What are the conditions of the UN?
00:51It is the definition of the UN.
00:54I have seen the JPC and One Nation, One Nation, One Pole was also denied appointment.
01:03Chief Jatum Tan, there was an informal meeting.
01:05So all the grounds are safe.
01:07No, there are more grounds.
01:10There are more grounds.
01:11I have seen the one from one.
01:12There is more grounds.
01:13You will see that I have said that there is a conflict of interest.
01:16It can come to the court.
01:22I and my senior judge-saheba and all of them had a view that we should avoid conflict of interest.
01:33I will not comment on that.
01:47Speaking about the request by opposition leaders, the India Bloc meeting request, the Chief Justice very clearly saying that the
01:57doors of the court are open to anyone who wants to file a petition but it will not be appropriate
02:03to meet political leaders on the administrative side because this is a matter that is before a judicial bench.
02:11He cannot meet the India Bloc leaders in this manner but he is not making any remarks whatsoever about what
02:19was actually in the letter.
02:20He is refusing to make any remarks about the protest itself saying that everything has to be handled on the
02:28judicial side, that the Supreme Court as a whole, all the judges together decided that it would not be appropriate.
02:35There would be a conflict of interest if there was any kind of meeting on these issues, especially when the
02:44matter is subjudice, when the matter is going to be before the court.
02:55Shambhavi is live with me on this story.
02:58Shambhavi, we saw this happening over the last several controversies that everyone wants to come to the court, everyone wants
03:06the Supreme Court to respond on things.
03:08When we saw the letter being sent to the Chief Justice's office by the India Bloc, the Congress leadership saying
03:16that they have an appointment to meet the Chief Justice.
03:20Now the Chief Justice making it very, very clear on camera that the court's doors are open to any and
03:27all petitioners but it is not appropriate to meet somebody, to meet a political leader,
03:33that there may be a conflict of interest if there is a meeting on the administrative side for an issue
03:39which is before the court.
03:41Shambhavi, what more can you tell us about what's been happening about this meeting and about the protest on the
03:47streets?
03:52Sinesha, there are two parts to this entire matter.
03:54First is when the leader of opposition is asking for an appointment for a meeting with CGI, especially on a
04:03matter with the subjudice, as you say,
04:05that will, the moment it was actually expressed in the media, it was, it can be understood that this was
04:12not going to be possible.
04:13Again, given the matter is subjudice and to seek an appointment with the CGI, that will come under conflict of
04:20interest.
04:20Of course, CGI has sent his response via email and extensive reason about why this is not an appropriate time
04:27for them to meet.
04:29Another part being what Supreme Court has been reiterating again and again, even in the Sunday special sitting,
04:35they said that we are going to hear everybody, all of you will get a chance to speak.
04:39Stay on with me for a moment, let's listen in once more to what the Chief Justice has actually said
04:46to the cameras as he attended the NHRC event.
04:50Is there any questions?
04:51Can you please tell us, how people will they meet the students in these conversations?
04:55I have asked him the letter to the minister to the government,
04:57I have the letter to them.
04:59I am out of the room, so I have the letter to the minister to the minister.
05:04So I have the letter to the minister in the evening, so I have the answer to that at night.
05:06So there are a few reasons I have provided them on the basis of what's the basis?
05:10I would like to ask that I will not be able to get it.
05:16I would like to ask that I will ask that I will be able to get it.
05:23The representatives of the parliament have been in which way.
05:28The CCP has two days to protest.
05:31The Supreme Court has been open for any petition.
05:34foreign
06:05Shambhavi is continuing to be with me on this story.
06:08Shambhavi, the Chief Justice, saying that he has made his reasoning clear that the court,
06:12the senior judges of the court and the Chief Justice together decided that it would be a conflict of interest
06:18if they spoke to a political leadership, a gathering of political leaders.
06:23What more can you tell us about what's happening in the court and outside the court?
06:31See Nisha, as I was saying before that the Supreme Court has been very clear and has reiterated time and
06:38again
06:38that the doors of Supreme Court is open.
06:40That is why we saw multiple, not one, not two, but multiple PILs being filed for the special bench hearing
06:49on Sunday
06:50where people, more or less the contents of all the PIL were same, citing the inconvenience that was caused
06:56to the common public or the illegal detention or the blanket closing of 45 metro stations
07:02or the troubles that was caused to the common public because of it.
07:06But that is what the CGI has again come forward and said that if Rahul Gandhi wants to meet him
07:13or wants his contentions to be heard, he is more than welcome to file a PIL.
07:18And there is a proper process in matters which is subjudice to actually get a hearing before the court.
07:24So, this was definitely expected in Nisha given again and again SIR has been going on for months.
07:30The hearing on it, for months, extensive hearing has been going on.
07:34And now that writing a letter and then also saying out publicly that they have got an appointment
07:41between 4 to 5 p.m. today which the CGI office clearly declined.
07:45And now you also heard CGI on the camera.
07:47Talking about the protests, of course the scenes here, outside you can see of course
07:51there is mostly media persons, there was some security outside, no barricading,
07:55you can see after the order of the Supreme Court on either side.
07:59Now that barricading that is mostly there most of the time, the barricading that you see on the other end
08:05of the street.
08:05And the traffic is usual, of course there were some concerns that given the security arrangements are heightened outside the
08:15Supreme Court
08:16and that a lot of private vehicles are parked in the parking space which is allotted to the lawyers here
08:22practicing,
08:23that caused a little bit of trouble but then it was quickly sorted out.
08:26So you can see pretty normal Monday for the Supreme Court.
08:32Anisha.
08:33Alright, so Shambhavi, let's also take a look at what's been happening when it comes to, you know, as you
08:38said,
08:38the court is already judicially taking note of all these matters.
08:43Just last week we had PILs seeking suspension of CEC Gyanesh Kumar.
08:48We had these petitions which had raised concerns about, you know, decision making in this election commission which is not
08:57being done properly.
08:59And that hearing of course is at the end of this month.
09:03But let's listen in once more to what the Chief Justice has said this morning.
09:08The Direction of CEC Gyanesh Kumar
09:08The Direction of CEC Gyanesh Paranay
09:14I had the chance to ask him to ask him at night.
09:19I was given a letter on the floor of the floor of the house,
09:20I was outside, so I got the letter on the floor of the house,
09:24so I got the answer on the night.
09:26I have given him for some reasons for which I have given myself a good attitude
09:30that I will not get into the floor.
09:34What other reasons are the two sides?
09:38foreign
09:42foreign
09:44foreign
09:44foreign
09:45foreign
09:50foreign
09:51foreign
09:54foreign
09:54foreign
09:54Katsiks� بھی कोई बी चाहे वो आम नागरी कहे है या कोई माननीस दिश्याय किसी इलेक्रिड बोडि का कोई भी
10:00है बारत का हर नागरी का।
10:02उसका अधिकार है वो हमारे पास आये हम कानून की विवस्ता और कानून के अनूरूप जो उनकी समस्य है उसका
10:10हम अपनी
10:10We will be able to support those who are going to be made and who is going to be made,
10:13we will be able to support those who are going to be.
