• 3 years ago
#11thHour #ChairmanPTI #ToshakhanaCase #HumayunDilawar #AttockJail #LahoreHighCourt

ARY News is a leading Pakistani news channel that promises to bring you factual and timely international stories and stories about Pakistan, sports, entertainment, and business, amid others.

Official Facebook: https://www.fb.com/arynewsasia

Official Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/arynewsofficial

Official Instagram: https://instagram.com/arynewstv

Website: https://arynews.tv

Watch ARY NEWS LIVE: http://live.arynews.tv

Listen Live: http://live.arynews.tv/audio

Listen Top of the hour Headlines, Bulletins & Programs: https://soundcloud.com/arynewsofficial
#ARYNews

ARY News Official YouTube Channel.
For more videos, subscribe to our channel and for suggestions please use the comment section.

ChairmanPTI #ToshakhanaCase #AttockJail

Category

🗞
News
Transcript
00:00 I am not laughing. You tell me, and of course Mr. Naeem is here,
00:03 so Mr. Naeem if you want you can give your opinion.
00:06 First tell us what was the allegation and what is written in the verdict that you are guilty of this crime and that is why you are going to jail for 3 years.
00:15 What is that?
00:16 Thank you very much.
00:17 Mr. Wasim, on this fundamental issue,
00:20 I would like to say that the defense lawyers present,
00:25 that is, there is a team of Chairman Tariq Khan's lawyers, like they themselves have brought in Khawaja Harith, Salman Akbaria, Minister Gohar, Mr. Naeem themselves.
00:33 My question is that what defense have they taken in the trial court?
00:37 They had to defend themselves, right?
00:38 First, the prosecution has charged them with incuplation,
00:42 the election commission has written a statement for the procedure of the investigation,
00:47 the case has been sent to the trial court.
00:49 What defense have they taken?
00:50 I will ask them, I would like to ask them why they did not go that day.
00:54 Salman Akbar had said that the case was closed, I will ask them.
00:56 No, you tell us about the case.
00:59 In this case, Chairman Tariq Khan had a lot of defense.
01:04 He could have produced expert witnesses.
01:07 On the first day, he could have given a list of 400 witnesses.
01:11 Then when you have to give defense witnesses, then you have to produce them, the court does not notice them.
01:17 Whatever mistakes they have made, it is a very long list.
01:20 And that list is that they did not fight this case legally, they fought it politically.
01:26 When you fight a case politically, when you have no defense,
01:29 then you are abusing the judge, you are putting on him, then the result is the same.
01:36 Even now, the legal team of Chairman Tariq Khan has gone inside, they are in jail.
01:41 So, they should fight this case legally in the appeal,
01:45 not that they go to the Supreme Court, High Court, then to the Trial Court,
01:50 then you go against every order,
01:52 you challenged everything, it was your right, you did the right thing.
01:56 But whatever trial I was going to, I should have given my defense in the trial, which I did not.
02:01 120,000 people...
02:03 We will solve this, we will tell you.
02:05 You just understand this decision, what is it?
02:07 Like Nawaz Sharif's decision, that this happened,
02:09 there was a problem in DC, acid was there, did not show, this happened, this happened.
02:12 In form B, their assets and their wealth statement,
02:18 they have hidden many things in it,
02:20 the jewelry item which was in form B,
02:22 they left it empty for 2 years, 3 years.
02:26 And in the third year, they are saying that we have other valuable things,
02:30 we have shown it in that.
02:32 So, in this way, in form B, you have to tell that this is form B, this is jewelry, I have this jewelry.
02:39 In that, you have done it, sometimes you say that we have acquired it,
02:43 and from 30th June, we have to show that thing.
02:48 Then you say that we took it and we have floated it.
02:51 So, this is a technical game, this is a through-out technical game,
02:54 and the form that Chairman Tariq Khan has filled,
02:57 which is basically a kind of declaration,
03:00 what he did, it came in a mis-declaration.
03:02 Concealment capacity...
03:04 Hassan sir, this is based on technical basis,
03:07 and if the same technical formula is applied,
03:11 sitting in the public of Pakistan,
03:13 today, there are 200 Bhatt, or 342 MNAS,
03:15 today's number is not 342, but for example,
03:17 how many will be blown up?
03:19 Or is it such a big mistake that these are the ones who have been killed?
03:21 Or is it such a scale that if it is applied to everyone,
03:23 then half of them will be blown up?
03:25 Wasim bhai, this is a very good question.
03:28 And the question is that the question you have asked,
03:31 why did the legal team of Pakistan Tariq Khan take this defense as a comparative analysis?
03:37 Why did they not take this defense?
03:39 All the people of their party, who were 10, 15 years old,
03:42 their form B's declaration,
03:44 they produced it in the court.
03:46 They say, this is our form B's declaration,
03:48 this is 50 MNAS more,
03:50 who have nil-ed the jewellery.
03:52 They did not do this.
03:54 This is what they did.
03:56 This is a big mistake.
03:58 I have said all the MNAS as an example.
04:00 Otherwise, it is obvious that only the people of the opposition
04:02 are aware of the gift given by the President of Tushar Khan.
04:04 But here,
04:06 everyone fills their form B.
04:08 So, the mistake of the Chairman of the Tariq Khan
04:10 was not punished for taking the gift from Tushar Khan.
04:12 The form B that he filled,
04:14 was whistle-blown on it.
04:16 And on that whistle-blowing,
04:18 the matter started again,
04:20 despite 120 days.
04:22 Let him tell, Naeem sahab.
04:24 If it is so simple, then why didn't you do it?
04:26 You want that he should not be behind bars.
04:28 Why didn't you do it?
04:30 The request is that
04:32 from the first day,
04:34 we are doing the legal proceedings.
04:36 Mr. Khan
04:38 somehow escaped from the NIS case.
04:40 Since the start,
04:42 when Mr. Khan was attacked in Wazirabad,
04:44 from that time,
04:46 Mr. Khan was medically
04:48 under arrest.
04:50 And he was compensated.
04:52 If I am not wrong,
04:54 you have repeatedly challenged
04:56 his maintainability.
04:58 You have said that you don't want to go to the QS,
05:00 you don't want to go to the ABC.
05:02 Although, the political narrative of PTI was that
05:04 if you didn't steal, then search.
05:06 Why do you challenge the request
05:08 that the QS should be searched?
05:10 End the matter.
05:12 Absolutely.
05:14 My answer to what you are saying is that
05:16 first, Mr. Khan was arrested
05:18 on 9th May.
05:20 And on 10th May,
05:22 without any legal procedure,
05:24 he was told that
05:26 the death of an individual
05:28 is a form of reprimand.
05:30 He was not told that.
05:32 After that, we were
05:34 pleading that Mr. Jai should not be charged.
05:36 We have been pleading for three days.
05:38 But from the start,
05:40 you have been challenging
05:42 his maintainability
05:44 and the QS.
05:46 Yes.
05:48 Your political narrative was that
05:50 the QS should not be searched.
05:52 End the matter.
05:54 The matter of jurisdiction
05:56 was not a matter of the QS.
05:58 We raised the question of maintainability
06:00 because it was not there.
06:02 A person is deseated from Mianwali.
06:04 Instead of
06:06 having an additional session
06:08 with the judge of Mianwali,
06:10 you have him in Islamabad.
06:12 It was not there.
06:14 You have to see it legally.
06:16 Then you have to see
06:18 whether the complaint is legal.
06:20 You have to doubt the first procedure.
06:22 If a complaint has been filed,
06:24 is it legally maintainable?
06:26 Is it legal?
06:28 We have never done this.
06:30 We have been to the Election Commission.
06:32 Mr. Khan has given his answer.
06:34 We have decided.
06:36 We have given him a chance to give an answer
06:38 within a month.
06:40 This is not a question of
06:42 what defence you have taken.
06:44 You have taken the defence that
06:46 we have made a mistake.
06:48 We have given a list of witnesses.
06:50 We have given four witnesses.
06:52 We have given a list of witnesses.
06:54 If the judge had to decide
06:56 that these four witnesses are not relevant,
06:58 would he have said
07:00 that we should make final arguments?
07:02 No.
07:04 You have not made an on-oath statement
07:06 of Chairman Tarik Khan.
07:08 You have made him state 342.
07:10 But you have not made
07:12 an on-oath statement.
07:14 If you had made an on-oath statement,
07:16 you would have been disqualified from the trial.
07:18 You are a lawyer.
07:20 You know what happens in the trial court.
07:22 You know the situation.
07:24 You should have given an answer.
07:26 You should have given an answer.
07:28 You should have given an answer.
07:30 You should have given an answer.
07:32 You should have given an answer.
07:34 You should have given an answer.
07:36 I am saying that 342
07:38 is not an on-oath statement.
07:40 I will not let the court of Humayun Dinawar
07:42 take a statement on 342.
07:44 You can see that
07:46 the case of Arjun Nohiyat is only seen in the holidays.
07:48 The way the trial was conducted with Ujjwaid
07:50 is in front of you.
07:52 Even after the Friday,
07:54 this trial continued.
07:56 And for a moment,
07:58 there was no break.
08:00 What was the special case
08:02 that you had to decide
08:04 in five minutes or one day?
08:06 The statement that Mr. Khan made
08:08 of 342,
08:10 you can see that Mr. Khan said
08:12 that he wanted to read the evidence.
08:14 He wanted to see the cross-examination.
08:16 He wanted to see all the documents
08:18 that were used against him.
08:20 Then I can give a satisfactory answer.
08:22 There are 35 questions.
08:24 You can take it today.
08:26 But you know that the time was not given.
08:28 It was given at 1 o'clock,
08:30 then at 2 o'clock.
08:32 Then the list of earnings was given.
08:34 The High Court has said itself
08:36 that the case will be fixed next week.
08:38 Where is he standing?
08:40 And the proceedings that are being done here,
08:42 the immediate decision that has been given,
08:44 then there is no point in noticing it.
08:46 Okay, no, sir, I have to tell you another question.
08:48 When the Islamic High Court gave a decision
08:50 and it was over the next day
08:52 and it was written in the decision
08:54 that when the final arguments are being made,
08:56 then make sure that the arguments are based.
08:58 And you did not present.
09:00 The court started at 8.30, then at 10.30,
09:02 then at 12.30, then the decision was started.
09:04 At that time, you did not present.
09:06 You were busy somewhere in some accountability court.
09:08 So that was also a part of the strategy or what was it?
09:10 The cases are so many that
09:12 they have to be presented in different cases.
09:14 But the case was not presented.
09:16 It goes without saying that the most important case was the same.
09:18 Because the Islamic High Court had written
09:20 that you have to be presented in the final arguments.
09:22 And Mr. Dilawar had said that if it was not presented,
09:24 then I will go to the court to hear the decision.
09:26 So then you should have left all the cases there.
09:28 The associates who are present,
09:30 they said that they are coming.
09:32 They did not say that we refuse that we will not argue today.
09:34 They said that they are in the new court.
09:36 You take time.
09:38 That time was not given.
09:40 And immediately, at 12.15, we were standing in the court.
09:42 At 12.30, Mr. Jai comes and starts writing the decision.
09:44 Mr. Khai starts the argument.
09:46 He does not listen to Mr. Khai's arguments.
09:48 But on his own, he started writing the order.
09:50 When he came at 12.30,
09:52 did Mr. Jai say that as a lawyer,
09:54 I am present and I want to give arguments?
09:56 Yes, absolutely. I was standing with him.
09:58 Was this initiative rejected by Mr. Humayun Dilawar?
10:00 He did not listen.
10:02 He started writing the order.
10:04 And at 4 o'clock,
10:06 if you had listened to him,
10:08 you would have been able to argue.
10:10 Mr. Dilawar did not listen.
10:12 He did not listen.
10:14 He had got a check from the NAB court
10:16 regarding Mr. Khawaja.
10:18 He was not present in the NAB court.
10:20 And he wrote in the decision.
10:22 He was somewhere else.
10:24 And the second thing is that Naeem Bhai is talking about four witnesses.
10:26 So if Naeem Bhai had given four witnesses,
10:28 he would have presented them in the court.
10:30 He should not have given an empty list.
10:32 Because the witnesses of the defense
10:34 are responsible for the defense.
10:36 But the judge did not make the judge smile
10:38 when he presented the witness.
10:40 He made the judge smile later.
10:42 He should have been there in the morning.
10:44 Sir, the one who has to fight the case,
10:46 he sits on the bench of the court
10:48 at dawn.
10:50 This is the same in Pakistan.
10:52 The one who has to fight the election,
10:54 he reads the prayer of dawn on the day of the election
10:56 and goes out and assembles his team.
10:58 You know that this is the ground reality.
11:00 He was not coming here.
11:02 So this is how ...
11:04 I am telling you as an observer
11:06 that according to me,
11:08 the defense that was in his hand,
11:10 and still in the High Court and Supreme Court,
11:12 he can take his defense.
11:14 But he has to fight his case legally.
11:16 He has to leave the political and technicalities.
11:18 And do you think legally
11:20 they have a strong case, Mr. Hassan Naeem?
11:22 Sir, he has not taken his defense yet.
11:24 Mr. Wasim, I am talking about this.
11:26 He has not taken his defense yet.
11:28 He will take his defense now.
11:30 And he has taken his defense
11:32 without getting his case registered.
11:34 This is what I am saying.
11:36 I think he was not a wise man.
11:38 What defense has he taken yet?
11:40 I am asking this question.
11:42 Sir, if you answer this question,
11:44 what defense have you taken?
11:46 I am still wondering.
11:48 The prosecution had to prove the case.
11:50 And the prosecution could not prove the case.
11:52 The documents that are being filed,
11:54 the documents were not supported.
11:56 But you are not challenging
11:58 the fact that we have not taken our defense.
12:00 Here, you are saying that we were not bound to give our defense.
12:02 The prosecution had to prove it.
12:04 We have taken our defense.
12:06 We have made arguments.
12:08 We have taken our witness in the defense.
12:10 What did you say in the defense?
12:12 If this is what they have to do in the High Court,
12:14 then I say, Mr. Naeem,
12:16 you do not bother about the appeal.
12:18 If you are behaving like this in the High Court,
12:20 then I am telling you seriously,
12:22 you have to go to the High Court.
12:24 We have given the list of witnesses.
12:26 One day around 12 o'clock,
12:28 they have said that you should come by 1.30
12:30 otherwise I will close the hearing.
12:32 They have decided.
12:34 We have not given the witnesses to hear.
12:36 We were saying that we will give them one or two days.
12:38 The case is pending in the Supreme Court.
12:40 The transfer application is pending in the High Court.
12:42 Sir, you are right in saying that.
12:44 But the list of witnesses that were not there,
12:46 what is your defense on that?
12:48 Tell us.
12:50 Why were not there in the case?
12:52 The case says that in 2018,
12:54 Khan sir took 21 million gifts
12:56 and sold 58 million.
12:58 He did not show that in the account.
13:00 We say that Khan sir collected 30 million
13:02 and said that why did you use that money
13:04 or if you have made a profit,
13:06 then why did you do that?
13:08 This is the first question.
13:10 The second question is
13:12 that the two years remaining,
13:14 they say that you have used
13:16 30 million in the last two years
13:18 and you gave the asset on June 30
13:20 in the election commission.
13:22 You did not mention that
13:24 in the gift that you sold.
13:26 We say that we did not have the gift at that time.
13:28 The gift was sold.
13:30 Sorry, I will talk to you later.

Recommended