00:00 Next week, the legal cases in the courts will have a direct impact on politics.
00:11 And because of that, in case the special sessions are taken back from the government, and we are not trying to pre-empt any decision of the court, we are hypothetically saying that in case the sessions are taken back, then what will happen in your opinion, legally?
00:32 Bismillahir Rahmanir Rahim. Thank you very much. The special sessions have a legal and constitutional interpretation issue.
00:42 And definitely, the functioning of the government of the day, the parliament, has a big impact on that. Because there are a lot of seats.
00:50 And mainly, the sections according to the election act, if they don't submit the list, normally if a party has submitted a list, the list is exhausted.
01:04 That means they have more seats, their nomination is filled, so they submit the list again.
01:10 Now their situation is a little different, that they have not submitted any list of Sunni faith. And they didn't fight in the elections on the Sunni faith.
01:17 But the first impression that is going to the Supreme Court is, how will the proportional representation be?
01:23 Let's assume that in this whole house, all the people are free.
01:29 So what will happen is that there will be no reserve seats. The reserve seats that are written in the constitution, the concept of proportional representation will be finished.
01:38 So the interpretation of this is to be done by the Supreme Court, that if a party has not submitted its list at that time, and later its nominees, MPAs, MNAs, come in an assembly in a quantity,
01:53 so what will be the impact of that? If the Supreme Court of this case decides that their seats are not formed, because they have not submitted the list at that time, according to the election act, those seats are not formed.
02:05 Now the second question is that if their seats are not formed, then how can their seats be given to other parties? What is that law? Under what law can they be given to other parties?
02:17 Now, because this is a subject matter, we can give our opinion.
02:21 My opinion is, a hypothetical situation is, let's say a party, any party, a PML party, PMLN, JUI, they have taken two seats directly, and how can they get five or seven seats as reserves for the other party?
02:36 If the seats are formed according to the proportional representation of Sunni Taat or PTI, then they have 15-20 seats in one assembly or 30-40 seats in one assembly.
02:54 This is a very important question to determine for the Supreme Court. If we assume that the whole house is free, then what will happen to the seats?
03:04 Then how will you distribute the seats? Will you distribute them freely? Or if there is no concept of a party, or if 100 members, MNAs, MPs are free, then how will they get these seats?
03:14 This is a very technical, constitutional interpretation and first impression case.
03:19 In my opinion, if Sunni Taat does not get seats from any BJP, then other parties should not get seats or will not get.
03:28 This is my personal opinion. It is possible that someone disagrees with this.
03:33 Let's see the Supreme Court's decision.
04:01 Having said that, you know that Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf has a complete and consistent complaint that the Chief Justice of Pakistan should be separated and not to close the cases.
04:17 But the question of Mr. Hamid Khan in the ARY program is that a few days ago he said that full bench is full bench.
04:25 There is a mindset of a full bench and a full bench decision.
04:31 And in a full bench decision, not a single person can dominate.
04:35 So, this demand that the Chief Justice of Pakistan should be separated and all other judges should be closed, has it been a full bench or not?
04:47 What would have happened if that was accepted?
04:51 The Supreme Court is sitting in the full court.
05:02 The Chief Justice of Pakistan has said that he has full confidence and trust in the Supreme Court.
05:22 So, if a full court is formed instead of a larger bench, then the wisdom of the Constitution is different.
05:36 The Supreme Court has said that the Chief Justice of Pakistan should be separated and not to close the cases.
06:04 In the ARY program, some people say that the Chief Justice should not listen to our case.
06:07 But at the same time, they give a statement that they have full confidence.
06:12 So, this is one way or another way.
06:15 They play on both sides.
06:17 Some people say that there is no confidence.
06:19 You see, the Chief Justice of Islamabad has said that he is listening to the decision.
06:24 If he gets the right, he will accept the decision.
06:26 He will not say that we do not have confidence.
06:28 Mr. Jadun, the attitude of the political parties is already in the World Justice Project's ranking.
06:43 Don't you think that the attitude of any political party, such as PMLN, PTI, PPP, etc., does not give any more impression?
07:06 Definitely, this is a very important question.
07:13 I am a believer that if a political party is against a decision, then they criticize so much that they use contemptuous language.
07:17 And the courts have shown a lot of restraint.
07:20 I am saying this across the board.
07:22 Every political party does this.
07:23 There is no exception.
07:25 Absolutely, there is no exception.
07:26 If any political party is against a decision, then they do not accept it with a happy heart.
07:31 They do not accept it with a happy heart.
07:36 They criticize so much that they use contemptuous language.
07:40 People who talk about the rule of law, they do not like to talk about any political party.
07:47 I have a relationship with a political party.
07:50 But I say that if any political party condemns it, then it should not be done.
07:55 Our institution is a constitutional institution.
07:58 If it works for the rule of law, then it should be done.
08:02 I am a lawyer.
08:04 I present my case daily.
08:06 How many times do they come against us?
08:08 If we do not make the judge a target of personal criticism,
08:10 and lawyers take money from people,
08:13 when the case comes against them, it affects their practice.
08:16 They feel embarrassed.
08:17 But this has to be taken with certainty.
08:21 Mr. Jadun, I will come to you.